SKC new year's breakfast: OMG! Crabby eggs benedict
There’s no better meal than breakfast. I wake-up hungry, and though a simple slice of Arnold’s Oat Bran toast with melted Irish sweet butter sprinkled with organic sugar mixed with Saigon cinnamon will usually suffice, there’s nothing like a real breakfast. Yes, the kind you sit down and linger over, savoring each bite, wishing the egg yolks filling the English muffin crannies would never empty.

I make a killer precision soft boiled egg breakfast. But what I’ll share with you now is even better. (And no, there’s absolutely no fruit in the vicinity so I guess I get no bonus points.) But this recipe is to die-for delicious. A pain in the ass to make, to get all the pieces done at the same time. But divine. And low calorie and inexpensive! Ok, I’m totally lying about that. But really, there’s way too much talk about calories and money after the holidays. Enough already.
Make this dish for a special friend, linger over it and revel in its glorious goodness. Or just make it for yourself; indulge and enjoy. You’ll be full for hours and happy for days. If you hate crab, skip it, and substitute salmon, Canadian bacon, or regular bacon. It’s the hollandaise sauce that will sing to you, the runny egg – so daring, so cavalier – that will make you sigh.
I’ve actually had all versions; I’m an eggs benedict connoisseur, and there aren’t too many of us. People shy away from eggs benedict. It’s too pricey, too fatty, too indulgent, too big, too fancy, and besides, you might get salmonella.
Nonsense. Eggs benedict is the filet mignon of breakfasts. It’s the standard by which all other egg dishes are judged. The fact that it’s hard to make just adds to its awesomeness.
Never would I attempt to make such a dish – just like I don’t make filet mignon – except for my encounter and break-up. I was introduced to crabby eggs benedict at the Princeton Diner by a Princeton boyfriend. It was love at first bite. I ditched the guy, but I could not – would not – break up with my crabby eggs benedict. Princeton was 90 minutes away; I had no choice but get used to long turnpike drives, or learn how to make my beloved dish.

The Ballantine house, Newark Museum, NJ. Guessing she
lost her head over the crabby eggs benedict.
There’s something about the buttery goodness of the hollandaise that perfectly complements crab. It remains the gold standard of breakfasts in my book of breakfast standards. And my book of standards means something since breakfast is the only meal I truly care about. Deny me lunch. Give me a dollar menu item for dinner. But don’t mess with my breakfast.
I’ve since encountered crabby eggs benedict closer to home. In fact, the Renaissance Hotel in Rutherford does a Cajun Crabby Eggs Benedict that’s beyond replication. It’s pricey, and you have to get there before 11 a.m., but you won’t be disappointed.
But make this dish and be happy for days, maybe even weeks. Really! It’s not so hard. Email me if you have questions or something doesn’t work out. Not only do I know this dish, my sister is a professional, and she consulted on the hollandaise. No one cooks better than she does. If she didn’t get all distracted with kids and such, she’d have her own cooking show for sure.
CRABBY EGGS BENEDICT
Total ingredients
2 egg yolks
2 tablespoon freshly squeezed lemon juice
3/4 cup salted butter
Pinch cayenne
Pinch salt
1 Tablespoon white vinegar
4 large eggs
2 English muffins
1 1/2 cups of crab meat (I use uncooked Chris Crab Cake meat from Whole Foods but any will do. But if you can, get Chris’s; it’s amazing.)
Hollandaise sauce
The KEY to this not curdling is very low heat. You don't need a double boiler, but if you have one, by all means …
3/4 c. salted butter, cut up into about 6 pieces
2 egg yolks
2 Tbsp water
1-2 Tbsp lemon juice (or to taste), fresh preferred but concentrate will work too
salt to taste
- In a 2 qt pot whisk together the egg yolks and water (without any heat)
- Turn the heat on low and add the butter pieces.
- Slowly whisk the butter and eggs together until melted; you must babysit the pot, don't leave, don't answer the phone, don't talk to your kids, if you get distracted it will curdle.
- Finally whisk in the lemon juice and salt (easy on the salt as the butter is salted, give it a taste first
- Continue to whisk the sauce until it thickens, you may need to turn it up a bit, but just a little, or it can still curdle.
- When it's at the desired thickness it's ready to serve.
Get the English muffins in the toaster when you’re about half-way through the crab-cooking process below.
Sautee the crab meat in some extra virgin olive oil, cayenne and salt, about 10 minutes, if you’re using uncooked, but prepared, crab cake meat. If you have left over crab, sautee with same ingredients until heated through and season with extra cayenne and salt as desired. If using canned or any other type of crab, follow cooking instructions.
Poach 4 eggs in an egg poacher if you have one. If not, here’s a cheat: Fill a 10-inch nonstick skillet half full of water. Add white vinegar to the cooking water. Bring to a slow boil. Gently break 1 of the eggs into the water taking care not to break it. Repeat with remaining eggs. Reduce the heat to a gentle simmer. Cook 3 1/2 minutes until the egg white is set and the yolk remains soft. Remove with a slotted spoon, allowing the egg to drain.
Butter the English muffins with Irish butter if you have it. Add the crab on top, then the egg, and pour on the hollandaise.
For the totally clueless – and I would be if I’d never eaten this out -- what you basically end up with is four English muffin halves, each topped with an egg, some crab meat and hollandaise sauce. Really fancy people put asparagus on the side, which also goes nicely with hollandaise.
But I’m not fancy, and I have no clue how to buy or cook asparagus. But I’ve eaten it out topped with just so-so hollandaise. So if you have a clue, go for it. You’ll have hollandaise leftover, and it’s so good you’ll eat it alone with a spoon before letting it go to waste.


Salon.com
Comments
haha i know gabby abby. it's an odd display in an amazing part of an even more amazing museum. the dish is great; you won't be disappointed.
it is brian. it what makes english muffins and soft eggs the perfect pair.
thanks pb&J
gee trig and i didn't even make the dish for you! you're sweet.
JK, the secret is low heat and never leaving the stove. distraction is the downfall to hollandaise. good luck if you decide to try it again. the knorr's is ok but doesn't compare really.
You make me assume you can make deviled eggs.
A Place you manage is a forum for kicking farmer.
I feel like a little hungry red rooster's brown eggs.
silly.
Aspergillosis- is called 'farmer lung' that wheezes.
But, the way you write in a OS forum is safety foods.
You cook fancy. You need a big flock of healthy hens.
Eggs in commercial hatcheries are wet as a sewer-leak.
Rotten pork, sulfite bacon, hormone breeds with spurts.
Hen in CEO's barns die young. Chickens can't even stand.
They die every night by the hundreds. No fresh condition.
No clean air, shells are thin film-ill, and antibiotic kill USA.
Keep cooking.
Organic grown
Care about health
a next generation
land that is fertile
and so seriously
be good stewards
healthy pastures
chickens eat leek
pest bugs, bad grub
and need sunshine!
hens eat healthy,
and you will be-
glowing shine-
facial smiles-
countenance.
I'll scramble two
eat 2- geese eggs
eat duck eggs
double yokes
a duck double
4- yoke eggs
fried on
Tuesday
Hollandaise.
BUT K- Street?
Greedy eat French fry, dead rodent road kills, bogus Stat EPA, and USDA,
Monsanto,
baloney goo,
spirited brew?
blood of slain. War profiteers eat dead carrion grizzle, and entrails.
Dead rotting, rot hog
franks, further filthy
It's analogy. Homer
Thanks for breakfast
I email to Sam Kass.
Lawyers are wiles, and deceptive counselors. They corrupt government protection agencies, and Everyone in the US government knows the AMA wants folk to feel ill-sock-o!
If we human's are feeling deathly sick-sick? Call MD doc quack!
Go eat at the K-Street eateries. Greedy eater can pop-purple-pill!
DC politico's will lie and cheat and fight over the behind-shank-quarter. Politicians argue, and kill for a dead mouse hind-quarter- anal-stinky-anal-squirt.
They fight for scraps.
Politico's are TWITS.
The poaching "cheat" is actually the true way to make poached eggs. It is the "poacher" that is the cheat. Though when I do make poached eggs, I never add vinegar. If you use enough vinegar to have an effect on the cooking of the eggs, they will taste like vinegar.
I'm one of you.
I could eat eggs benny a couple days a week.
I need to attempt this here in my lab/kitchen.
BTW-If you think it's a pain in the ass to make, think how the chicken feels.lol
Also an eggs benny connoisseur, I've tried a number of ingredients as replacements for the traditional Canadian bacon: smoked salmon, avocado, polska kielbasa.... (all these were good with the polska kielbasa possibly - and surprisingly - the best). Next time maybe I'll try avocado AND polska kielbasa!
On one of our trips to Australia (my husband's a native) we did an eggs benedict tour from Queensland to just south of Canberra. I was never disappointed but possibly the best was at Cafe Woodworks in a little touristy town called Bungendore, where they used toast points in place of the English muffins, the most lovely smoky, thick-sliced, peppery, bacon and crowned the dish with baby spinach. In case you ever get there: http://www.bungendorewoodworks.com.au/node/59
Adding you to my favorites.........
julie, the key is to not get distracted, not even for a second. you have to babysit the hollandaise.
art james, you always have such a way with putting the words together just right. thank you.
angela, thanks for the additional tip. you're right about the poaching tip -- it is in fact the preferred method. real cooks scoff at the mere mention of a poacher. but i enjoy a short-cut if i don't think it makes much difference ...
xjs -- let me know how it comes out. oh yes -- the poor chicken. boy do i have a post on chickens ...
geebee, dry cooked bacon is the best. but i cant imagine skipping the sauce...
wow, candyfreak, those are some interesting varieties! way cool. even without a whole foods, most fish markets or upscale supermarkets should sell lump crab meat or cakes, uncooked and unbreaded. if i ever go to aussie -- sigh -- will hit Bungendore's spot for sure!! thanks!