Five years ago I began a new career. Last night I ended it. The result of my five-year career is three published fiction novels (a fourth is half complete,) a short crime story, a short science fiction story, no profit whatsoever, and a tremendous amount of money down the drain. When I received yet another invoice from the printing company last night that I had sold over two-hundred-fifty-dollars in books yet my compensation was twenty-one dollars and some change, I threw in the towel and cancelled my contract. My suspense fiction novel, The Devil’s Valet, is no longer available in hard copy online or in books stores.
Along with countless other authors, with each of my three novels, I emailed and snail-mailed literally hundreds of literary agents with queries, synopsis and bios. Take The Devil’s Valet for example: I got probably a one percent hit. The majority of agents wanted exclusive rights to simply review either the first three chapters or the manuscript. This translates into having your manuscript put into limbo for six months to a year (all agents moan about the massive amount of submissions they get on a weekly basis). One San Diego agent held onto The Devil’s Valet for NINE MONTHS before rejecting it. That was it for me at the time. Being your typical Aries, I had my manuscript published within a month. I published it. I created my own publishing company, Philia Publishing. At the May 2009 launch at Borders, I sold all but three of forty copies of The Devil’s Valet.
Nora Roberts once told me personally never to write to trend. I had certain agents along the way who admired my work but had their own advice. I was guaranteed to be on the bestseller list within a year with my first novel, A Port of No Return, if I would make my protagonist, Quinn Carrigan, a lesbian. 2006 was a hot year for gay and lesbian rights and outings. The problem is, Quinn simply is not a lesbian. She’s survived shark-infested waters, taboo love, hurricanes, the black arts, and drug smuggling. She is what she was from the beginning and there is no way I or anyone else is going to change her.
The critics hailed my debut novel as “a sexy, thrilling ride.” The second novel in the series, The Shadows of the Sea, received an equally as favorable review. By dint of perserverance I side-stepped the "casting call" process and got myself booked on three Princess cruise ships (eastern Caribbean, the Panama Canal, and Australia New Zealand) one year as a featured author/lecturer. It was beyond rewarding to see passengers relaxing on the Lido deck reading my novels. One night I spied a couple from Texas heading into the dining room with both my novels, A Port of No Return and The Shadows of the Sea, tucked under their arms. They told me they simply couldn't put them down.
Timing has a lot to do with everything, and two years ago when I finished The Devil’s Valet, vampires and werewolves became the rage. Even armed with this Kirkus review, “McKellar has created a strong, empathetic heroine, and she renders the world she moves in in convincing detail. Worthy of a Lifetime movie," The Devil’s Valet was doomed it appears from the get go. I wrote press releases. I scheduled book events, printed hundred-dollar posters, book marks, business cards and other collateral material. I invested in a website and blog. I literally went into debt with my novels. I refinanced my house to support my “craft.” The bottom line is I have made a tidy sum for two publishing houses and one print house.
I must concur with a fellow author who wrote, “Unless I was a brand name, 99% of publishers/agents would never give me the time of day.” Case in point, my former-niece-by-marriage, Danica McKellar, starred as Winnie along with Fred Savage in the fabulously popular 1988 sitcom, Wonder Years. She’s published several books on math for young readers. Not to detract from Danica, who I know personally to be a talented, brilliant and creative woman, I have no doubt publishers saw how marketable her film resume made her. I haven’t read the books, but I believe the critics and I commend the niche she chose to express even more of her talent.
Writing, to me, isn’t at all about “the money." I could care less about fame—I treasure what privacy I have. It’s about “the look” in readers’ eyes. I’ve been blessed countless times since publishing my first book with seeing that look. And equally with hearing, “I was up so late last night because I couldn’t put your book down!” I’ve had moments at my PC keyboard where the hair on my arms and even my head stood up as a plot took off. I’ve paced my back patio in a total frenzy, talking to myself or scolding my characters. I’ve cried real tears over a plot twist in The Shadows of the Sea. The imagination is a living thing and it cannot be stifled. Like a shark, if I don’t write, then the imagination and I, too, shall die.
Yet, authors must eat and pay mortgages. And, there is something diminishing about working your ass off seven days a week, day in and day out, and not receiving any compensation. No one in their right mind would put in the magnitude of hours of solitude, of research, of proofreading, of editing that a writer does without any expectation of return. One can’t eat accolades. One can’t survive on less than a five percent return. Therefore, I’ve turned my eyes, my mind and my talent to non-fiction writing. To a world where at least I can get paid by the word: those words that so command me, and that I love so much.


Salon.com
Comments
I don't write, so I apologize that I cannot firsthand understand exactly how you feel, but I do sing and I also never cared about the money. There was something about seeing that joy in someone's eyes. NOT adoration - that's far to egocentric for me and was never my intention - but that you made them FEEL. That's electricity.
Anything trite I can say about some day finding a lesson in all of this would only aggravate both of us, so I will offer a gentle hug through the computer.
Still--I gotta write. I can't do anything else... ;)
I have no doubt that you will ultimately succeed.
Raven West - author Red Wine For Breakfast, First Class Male and work in progress; Cry U.N.C.L.E.
Oh, and if you still see Winnie, uh, I mean Danica please tell her that I've had a crush on her since I was 12 :-D
Sometimes we just know its time. Good luck!
Why not offer your novels FREE as downloads on the internet? You have zip to lose at this point. And what you might gain is a readership.
It's a brave new world publishing-wise out there, for everyone—even Alfred Knopf.
Create a fab website dedicated to each novel, like movies do these days. Optimize the hell out of them. Start with free and then once you've got a following charge $5 -$10 for downloads. That's way more profit than even the big publishers see. Or free first half and if the reader likes it the second half is $5. Set up e-book or pdf download files.
Create your own audience, CL. Your very adventurous heroine would do such things—why not you? You really want that other drudgery: schlepping all over God's green acre doing book-signings that flop? That's the old dying way and only works for mega-stars—as if they need it.
Outside the box, CL. Outside the box.
sheeeeez
I hope you don't mind, but I'm going to be referring to the URL of this blog post whenever people say that POD is the answer to everything. You put a ton more into selling your books than most people who go the self-publishing route (including not using POD but actually setting up your own co), and you got some excellent buzz, so the result is a true reality check.
Like others here, I'm glad you're going to keep writing. Look forward to seeing it!
Look for "Eyeballs, Crocodiles and Whores" for free on OS in the months to come I suppose.......
crap.
You've already made the investment so I would agree with Joy Mars and encourage you to continue the promotions. Good luck in whatever path you choose.
I'm saying that I can see the "box" (miserable hole that it is for most of us) and that there is something moving out there, but I can't quite make it out. Anyone else thinking along these lines?
K
You could use an editor as well. Your home page features the phrase "fiction novel" several times, and it shows up twice in this post. How many kinds of a novel are there? How many other simple writing mistakes did you make that turned agents and/or potential publishers off?
I once encountered these words in a Usenet writers' group: "Odd, how these people seem to think that writing is some kind of miraculous gift endowed by a kindly god just on themselves because they deserve it so."
Let's just see how I do as a fiction writer, because that is what I always wanted to do. I was accused by artists friends of being a sell-out, but, guess what? I wasn't an actor/waitor, or a writer/housekeeper. I was a writer/writer and I learned to work with editors and I learned how to writer when I didn't "feel like it" and I learned how to make deadlines. I learned how to really and honestly make a living as a writer.
BUT, we'll see if any of those years of learning will serve me as I try to transition into making a living writing fiction.
I'll keep everyone posted.
gr
P.S. I posted a sample chapter of my novel here titles, "American Assholes Need Mexican Buttplugs." Let me know what you think....
I totally agree with Bob that carelessness and lack of editing skills are total buzz kills.......
I'd like to share with you the advice I gave to a middle-aged white actress friend of mine who was bemoaning being passed over for acting jobs in favor of "young blonds with big boobs." With the greatest of compassion, I suggested to her that she might not feel so despondent if she started think of herself as a "n-----."
Truth be told, unless you're an A-list star like Meryl Streep or Sandra Bullock, middle-aged actresses are pretty low on the Hollywood food chain. And even those two had their share of career challenges once they hit 40. Fortunately, middle-aged female movie-goers made their voices ($) heard loud and clear at the box- office, last year, so they should be fine. (http://popwatch.ew.com/2009/12/10/sandra-bullock/).
But I digress. Unknown, unpublished writers are also "n-----s". Yes, it's unfair and it sucks and my saying it's not politically correct. But it's the truth, and being armed with this new insight can be empowering.
Having grown up in the South during the era of Jim Crow, my daddy (who would have been 103 this year, had he lived...but who did manage to make it to 95) instilled in me that because I was "a little colored girl," I was going to have to work ten times as hard as a white person to get the same things.
He said it with no malice or bitterness, but just as a statement of fact...and that's how I took it.
I never felt the sense of entitlement or world-view of meritocracy that my white friend had. As a result, I was better prepared for the rejections and financial challenges that creative-types often must endure.
My daddy's advice not only prepared me for facing tough times in my chosen career path as an actress and writer, it's also bolstered me against the new ignominy that comes with getting older in a youth-oriented culture.
Taken to heart, the wisdom of "if it doesn't kill you, it can make you stronger" may not take away the pain you're feeling right in this moment, but once you're up to the task again, it'll motivate you to get back on track with new resolve...which you MUST do, because turning away from your passion and talent is a slower and, I think, ultimately more painful death.
Wishing you much success,
Mariann Aalda
P.S. -- Here are links to how I "walk my talk..." :-)
www.mariannaalda.com / www.moistonstage.com
I'd always heard that self-publishing made more money for the writer than the traditional route. But it sounds like you wound up on the short end, there. The advice I take from your story (if I understand it correctly) is avoid vanity presses, whatever they call themselves. Stick to your work and don't worry about the publishing end of it. The writing is the only fun part. We're all hobbyists, here.
Barnes and Noble is not the problem. Amazon is not the problem. Neither publishers, nor agents nor some pernicious force within the system is to blame.
People (sometimes referred to as "consumers") are to blame.
People buy what they want and they buy a lot of it. You can get a digital camera for $19 at the drugstore. You can buy four plastic lawn chairs, a matching table and an umbrella for $49. You can spend $30 for teeth whitening strips at the supermarket or $300 for a more personal teeth whitening procedure at the dentist. You can buy a used Porsche for $4,000 on Ebay, fake tits for $5,000 anywhere and a double cheeseburger for $0.99 at McDonald's. Netflix starts at $15 per month, cable starts at $25 per month and a lot of people choose the complete NFL package in Direct TV for $350.
In short, people can buy pretty much anything and everything they want, at every price, and they buy it all the livelong fucking day. They buy MORE than they can afford.
Writers seem to be unique in the impression that somehow people are being prevented from buying something (namely, their work). Additionally, so many writers persist in asserting they are not in it for the money while simultaneously cursing some injustice/corruption for their lack of remuneration.
If you want to write, write.
If you want to get paid, write about your:
a) stupid fucking dog
b) harrowing recovery from addiction
c) autistic kid
d) autistic dog's harrowing recovery from addiction.
But the market is WIDE open.
"If you want to write, write.
If you want to get paid, write about your:
a) stupid fucking dog
b) harrowing recovery from addiction
c) autistic kid
d) autistic dog's harrowing recovery from addiction."
HA!!! Now that d novel... that would be a best seller !! :)
I'm just a lurker here, not a writer, so what the heck do I know? I do believe, though, that if you are meant to do something like writing, then you'll do it in any form... either part time or full time non-fiction stuff, as you're planning. But don't give up totally on your dream of fiction writing... maybe the timing is just wrong now. You've already reached readers with your previous work, and if your post here is any indication, you are touching many here as well. Hold onto that during the dark times and know that eventually you will prevail.
Sorry you went through this experience. I did, too. Nonfiction is a tough market these days, too. Not many people want to pay when they can get the information for free.
What an amazing, multi-talented, and extended group of people on OS!
You are preaching to the choir.
Thank you for inspiring me...
Regards
επιπλα
my last post on my blog Toronto Airport Taxi