I'm a born and bred Southerner, and although raised in Atlanta, GA. (sometimes referred to as an Island in a Sea of Ignorance), I have a native's knowledge of the Southern condition. I learned to say "No Sir" and "Yes Mam", went to church three times a week, and drank at the "White's Only" water fountain. But I was lucky. I got spanked the one and only time I used the n word. I was taught that people were people no matter their color; most of my neighbors and schoolmates were not.
In my childhood, the South was solidly Democratic. The Republican Party was still the Party of Lincoln, the man that caused the War Between the States and freed the slaves. There wasn't much of an effort to conceal the connection between political choice and race relations. The Democrats played upon the fears of white constituents and promised to keep the "Coloreds" in their place. Local voting officials made voting difficult if not impossible for non-whites, assuring that political power remained in the hands of white Democrats.
But in 1960,the Democrats betrayed the Southern Block. The South had voted Democratic since 1880 (with the exception of Strom Thurmond's States Rights Party in 1948 which only reinforces the race tie-in). Southerners trusted the Democrats to keep things they way they were. Boy, were they wrong.
Kennedy thought that all Americans should have the right to vote and although he did not live to see it, the die was cast. The Civil Rights Act in 1964 and the National Voting Rights Act of 1965 changed the South and changed their political allegiance. Only in 1976 when "home boy" Jimmy Carter was elected, did the South vote for the Democratic ticket; in every other election, the Republican Party took the South.
So, why did this happen? Is it because of the Republican stance on abortion, on "family values", on small government, or fiscal responsibility? (the last eight years cancel out the latter two reasons, don't they?) Or is it the Republican ability to incite fear? Vote for us or the gays will molest your children, abortionists will kill the next Jesus, and perverts will rule the earth. No, just talking points that hide the real reason. Since the 13 colonies, the South has been a class based society with distinct roles for each caste. Simply put, there were the wealthy land owners at the top, the merchants and professionals next, then the mill workers and share croppers, and finally, the slaves.
Southerners don't like change: they fought a war to prevent it. They lost the war, but continue the battle. Deep in the Southerner's psyche is a desire for the past: a romantic, "Gone With The Wind" past, a past where the slaves were happy and knew their place, a past where slave owners were kind and generous - a past that never existed. I was raised in the lower class. We never owned a house and it took ten years to finally pay off our one car. But even I have felt the tug to return to that imagined past.
But ingrained in that false memory is an ugly truth. A return to the way things were means a return to race discrimination. This is the reason not spoken: the fear that people of color will take a position of power. The white Southerners, from plumbers to politicians, are afraid that a black man will take their job, or worse: be their boss. This is the reason that George Wallace stood on the school's steps to block black students from entering the University of Alabama, this is the reason that Lester Maddox chased integrationists from his restaurant with an axe handle and became Governor of Georgia.
The fear remains today. It may be couched in "family values" but it's the same fear. And as long as it remains, and as long as the Republicans can use it to their advantage, the South will bleed Republican red.


Salon.com
Comments
I am passing it on to my child and that's the only way to beat ignorance. Knowledge.
Rated
That scene in "Mississippi Burning" where Gene Hackman's character explains that his father once killed a neighboring black family's mule because he did not have one will always be so pivotal for me. "If you're not better than a black man son, then who are you better than?"
I.e., taking money from hard-working (read: white) people and giving it away to non-deserving (presumably to lazy, welfare-riding, primarily black/hispanic/non-white but certainly non-bourgeois) people
example 2: school vouchers and school choice
I see it less as a fear that one black person might take his job or be his boss and more of a prevalent fear or unease with black people or immigrants as a group taking over society and bringing it down, at least that is the reality of institutionalized racism that I can see even now from New Orleans to Loudoun County, Virginia
Great post!
We have a lot in common. I started as the son of a tenant farmer. We were "poor white trash" in Kansas. PWT were classed right down there with Mexicans and Negros.
I too have medical issues that involve chronic pain and with no cure available, or likely ever available. So you learn to live with it, cuss it now and then, and try to calm down that 20 year old kid and the delusion that he can still go motorcycle touring just like he did just two years ago. Not.
The post is great and cuts through all the excuses to the heart of the issue. So thanks for doing that so well.
Visit my blog sometime and you might find some kinship there.
Monte
May the new times of this financial crisis shake some sense into the old 'family values' that have united the GOP in the Deep South.
Rated
That caveat aside, I knew very early on in my life that the Underground Railway ended here in Canada, and am very proud to now live near Buxton, the first real African-American settlement constituted almost entirely, at its beginning, of escaped or freed slaves.
Ironically, my family's prejudices and racism were aimed at those of a different religious heritage rather than colour. I learned very early on to loathe those who preach and practise intolerance. I wound up marrying someone of that other "suspect" religion. Bigots appall me.
[edit] Civil Rights and Black Power Movements Period: 1955 - 1977
[edit] 1964
Rochester 1964 race riot; Rochester, New York - July
New York City 1964 riot; New York City, New York - July
Philadelphia 1964 race riot; Philadelphia, Pennsylvania - August
[edit] 1965
Watts Riot; Los Angeles, California - August
[edit] 1966
Hough Riots; Cleveland, Ohio - July
Hunter's Point Riot; San Francisco
Chicago Race Riot; Chicago, Illinois -January
[edit] 1967
1967 Newark riots; Newark, New Jersey - July
12th Street riot; Detroit, Michigan - July
1967 Plainfield riots; Plainfield, New Jersey - July
Milwaukee riot; Milwaukee, Wisconsin - July 30-31
Minneapolis North Side Riots; Minneapolis-Saint Paul, Minnesota - August
[edit] 1968
Orangeburg massacre; Orangeburg, South Carolina - February
125 cities in April and May, in response to the murder of Martin Luther King, Jr. including:
Baltimore riot of 1968; Baltimore Maryland
1968 Washington, D.C. riots; Washington, D.C.
1968 New York City riot; New York City, New York
West Side Riots; Chicago, Illinois
Louisville riots of 1968; Louisville, Kentucky
[edit] 1970
Jackson State killings; Jackson, Mississippi - May
[edit] 1972
Escambia High School riots; Pensacola, Florida
[edit] 1977
New York City Blackout riot
This list is incomplete; you can help by expanding it.
[edit] Modern
1980: Miami Riot 1980
1991: Crown Heights Riot
1992: 1992 Los Angeles riots
2001: 2001 Cincinnati Riots
2001: Seattle Mardi Gras Riots
2009: Oakland CA, Oscar Grant Murder Riots
How many of these were NOT in the South? If we are so terribly racist--much more than the rest of the country, then why did these even occur?
I'm another liberal, raised and lived in Florida and Georgia much of my early life, and I too drank from the colored fountain.
As far as I can tell the Civil War and Dixie are still in the DNA of some. Hard to get too far from that for some folks who never left or traveled outside their comfort zone. It' s the newbies who have to affect change.
The South is such a strange place when it comes to race. Before the Civil War, during and after several of the slave revolts, southerners were genuinely surprised that their slave might be unhappy with their conditions. My students never believe this, but those contradictions are still so obvious in the South and yet avoided.
After 4 years at Ole Miss, I had heard so many times the phrase, "I'm not racist...I'm just saying there are blacks and then there are niggers." And yet, when my wife and I drove down through Alabama this past Christmas. My wife commented on the incredible friendliness and familiarity with which we were treated by the black workers at Waffle House. We both recognized that we probably wouldn't have experienced that in Minneapolis.
I really appreciated your historical references and enjoyed how easily you described what is truly beneath it. Would there be racism without competition for resources? I guess we'll never know.
Do you think that Jimmy Carter somehow implied that he was "one of them?" Other Southerners (Clinton, Gore) didn;t do so well in the deep south.
Great post.
The Dixiecrats of Strom Thurmond left the Democratic Party in 1948 largely because Harry Truman insisted on integrating the military, a move Truman was advised would cost him the election in '48. "If that's true," he replied, "then the job isn't worth having. Truman won the election, but Strom Thurmond made a strong showing as a third-party candidate winning 38 electoral votes in South Carolina, Alabama, Mississippi and Lousiana, and 1 electoral vote from a disaffected so-called "faithless" voter in Tennessee.
After Truman came Dwight Eisenhower, the last of what I consider traditional Republican Presidents. The Republican Party was radically altered by the Goldwater Revolution iu 1960, and one of the acolytes was a young man named Karl Rove.
The Sixties saw the formation of the American Independent Party, which I firmly believe was the precursor to today's Republican Party. In was formed as a reaction to civil rights legislation, and my father and a lot of other blue-collar workers in the north voted for George Wallace, the AIP candidate for president. He was one of the most successful third-party candidates ever, garnering nearly 10 million votes (13.5%) and 46 electoral votes from Georgia, Alabama, Mississippi, Arkansas and Louisiana.
Every Republican candidate since Richard Nixon (with the exception of Gerald Ford) has run a companion that depended heavily on a thinly-veiled racist appeal. Reagan had his welfare queens, Bush I had Willie Horton, and the Bush II appeal to racism was all too apparent.
Have things have improved in the South over the last 50 years? Certainly, particularly in big cities, but racism is still very much alive here. In the 2008 election, many Democrats in TN stayed home, and as a result McCain got roughly 56% of the vote. But his victory was even more decisive than that number expresses. In only 6 of 95 counties did Obama win a majority of the vote.
(And yet, I must say, I am amazed that Bobby Jindal, an Asian Indian by ethnicity, was elected Gov. of Louisiana! Perhaps because he's an idiot? In a strange way, it gives me hope! Not the idiot part of course...)
I do think class is a large part of it, but who am I, soaked in my white privilege, to say anything about racism? It's real and undeniable.
More of the homes than I care to count have black lawn jockeys welcoming folks into their driveway. More than a few of the pickup trucks have confederate flags emblazoned on the back windshields or bumper sticks with the flags on it and as a protest for the recent change of our state flag that once enshrined that flag, some drivers never change their old car tags to reflect the new one. Once upon a time, that used to intimidate me, but now I just shake my head and snicker.
In addition to Delia's list there was the Boston school integration riots by whites. That Bernie Whatshisname in the NY subway and just the other day in California the Mayor with the watermelon patch joke. My belief is that it's easier for the rest of the country to point fingers at the South rather than actually deal with the problems in their own backyard. It's always noce to feel superior.
That song still explains race issues in this country to a perfect T.
"Now your northern n-----'s a Negro
You see he's got his dignity
Down here we're too ignorant to realize
That the North has set the n----- free
Yes he's free to be put in a cage
In Harlem in New York City
And he's free to be put in a cage on the South-Side of Chicago
And the West-Side
And he's free to be put in a cage in Hough in Cleveland
And he's free to be put in a cage in East St. Louis
And he's free to be put in a cage in Fillmore in San Francisco
And he's free to be put in a cage in Roxbury in Boston
They're gatherin' 'em up from miles around
Keepin' the n---- down"
We are, I believe, a fear-based society. And from that fear we somehow find solace in creating a feeling of superiority over others: as Amyssss noted so well in the quote from Mississippi Burning above.
Kind of Blue has a new post on teenage suicide. I think that the bullying of which he writes is part in parcel to this fear response. We're afraid and we have to push that outward. Maybe we think we can make someone afraid of us, and maybe that makes us feel less afraid? Is that the base of prejudice? Or do we dislike anyone who doesn't conform to our group, be it race or religion or high school clique and somehow fear them because they are different? And why do we fear in the first place?
I wish I were smart enough to understand.
I wish I could say my parents corrected any utterances of the "n"-word. Not so. I grew up in a racist environment, not so much around my mom but definitely my dad. I myself never used the term. Maybe it had to do with the fact that my mom's negro housekeeper was the person who taught me to read at approximately age 5.
Somehow, I managed to get beyond the ingrown racism and I've been so much happier for having laid that burden down so many years ago. Your explanation resonated completely with my experience.
BTW, glad you mentioned Lester Maddox. He is almost never included whenever recent GA history is discussed, on television or otherwise. He is a disgrace GA seems to want to forget, and rightly so. Even George Wallace redeemed himself - somewhat - before he died.
Lester faded when Jimmy the peanut farmer got his supporters to continue to vote democrat in the guvnah's race. Of course, the good ol boys were duped by Carter.