Did I suddenly get old? Or does American pop culture really suck? (And that’s not a vampire joke.)
I didn’t realize my level of disengagement from American culture until I received a renewal notice from Entertainment Weekly this weekend and realized I had no interest in receiving the magazine any more. I’d subscribed almost since its start 20 years ago and I used to devour the contents as I tried to keep up with the latest trends in mass media. Now I skim through it in five minutes, with as much interest as I give the content-free Us while sitting in the doctor’s waiting room.
It seems very little in mainstream American culture piques my interest any more. Among the things I disdain: vampires (sorry, Densie), comic-book heroes, sci-fi, movies with more explosions than intelligent lines of dialogue, movies that are even worse than the stupid TV shows they were based on, movies with Roman numerals in the title, vapid pop stars whose IQs are about the same as their dress size, rock “legends” who are 20 years past their expiration dates, rappers with more tattoos than obscenity-free lyrics, reality-TV morons who, if I saw them crossing the street, I’d run a red light at high speed and figure I’d be doing the world a favor, and books by idiot celebrities who couldn’t spell cat if you spotted them the “c” and the “a.” (Yes, I’ve used that joke before; it’s a classic.) Have I left anything out?
I guess that makes me a snob. I hate being a snob. Snobs are people I disdain. I want to love mainstream entertainment, and there is some I enjoy. I have man-crushes on Paul Rudd, Justin Timberlake and Hugh Laurie, I think Beyonce is a goddess, and I’d gladly adopt Taylor Swift. I’ve read all the Harry Potter books and I’d love to get stoned with Harold & Kumar. I’ve got Stephen King and Janet Evanovich books on my night stand. Unfortunately, that only covers about .0001 % of the crap that’s foisted on the poor American consumer. It’s not that pop culture is providing empty calories; it provides no calories at all. Instead of a bag of Doritos, it’s giving us wilted iceberg lettuce.
I’m embarrassed that the only films I see now are in art cinemas, but would it hurt Hollywood to come up with a story that doesn’t sound as if it was put together by a teenage boy during a game of Mad Libs? The only mainstream movie I’ve seen in the last nine months was James Cameron’s idiotic Avatar – and I was dragged to that - where a gazillion dollars were spent and much electricity consumed to create a message about not wasting our natural resources and acts of violence were committed on screen to spread a message of peace. Thanks a lot, Jim.
There are some modern bands I like – Vampire Weekend and the xx are in heavy rotation on my iPod and I’m really looking forward to the new Arcade Fire CD next week – but many of the “buzzed”-about performers should be approached with a fly swatter. I listening to the “hot” new band Sleigh Bells, but it was just a clattering noise to me; yes, a little of it was catchy, but so are STDs. I’m not anti-hip-hop – I just got the new Roots CD – but if I have to listen to Kanye brag one more time about his legend-in-his-own-mind status, Imma hurl Flavor Flav’s clock at his forehead. I have absolutely no idea what anyone sees in M.I.A. And I’ve already made my feelings known about Lady GagGag.
Don’t get me started on reality-TV. Too late. I know there are people on OS who I deeply respect who watch a few of these abominations, so I’ll bite my tongue a little. But it’s just sad to me that America has come to this – people wishing to become rich and famous without doing anything except letting cameras into their homes (hi, Jon and Kate’s eight, hope you’ve got a nice therapist picked out), and millions of people who are willing to laugh at them every week.
And perhaps the reason I’m contemptuous of these shows is that many of them prompt you to be contemptuous of the participants. There is a meanness to American culture now that often we no longer laugh with, but laugh at. All of this reminds me of Borat, a movie I loathed and thought a mean-spirited piece of crap. It was elitist in its (carefully edited) depiction of the poor, ignorant little people it cleverly stacked the deck against. OK, that’s a rant for another day, but while I may have a “cranky” nature, I still have the ability to feel empathy, and I’m disgusted when other people don’t.
We laugh sneeringly at Lindsay Lohan who, for goodness sake, just turned 24. I don’t know about you, but when I was 24, I was a total dumbass. And unlike her, I didn’t have parents from hell and too much money at too young an age. Whatever happened to “walk a mile in their shoes?”
We've succeeded all too well at reducing everything to the lowest common denominator. We've created an America where intelligence and true wit are no longer considered assets. No wonder so many people can actually picture Sarah Palin in the White House. Can't anybody refudiate that?
My disgust with pop culture today is so deep and total that I can’t even bring myself to start watching a show I assume I would enjoy. Like Mad Men. Parts of it even take place in my actual hometown of Ossining, NY, so you would think I’d be drawn to it. However, I just have no interest in consuming my limited free time with catching up with the three years of episodes I’ve missed, and nothing will make me change my mind. Except maybe a Christina Hendricks nude scene.


Salon.com
Comments
Hollywood COULD find new talent to make better movies, but they choose to turn out the same old schlock time after time, instead. Okay, but I'm damned if I'll pay $10.50 a pop for the dubious honor of watching them. If more people refused to pay to watch the utterly stupid and vapid and vile,hitting those lazy bastards in the pocket book, we might get some decent movies, again. (I make an except for Pixar, as I think they are putting some thought, talent and imagination to work on their movies.)
You're not a snob my dear man--you're intelligent and discerning. I don't see it as a shame, but a mark of honor that you don't want to settle for the lowest common denominator. Why pay for what you don't enjoy, anymore? We need to demand better entertainment if celebrities and movie makers want our scarce dollars.
/jumps off soapbox.
rated
Well!"
And you think you're a snob?
But, I sit here visiting this summer and realize that without HBO, Showtime and other specialty channels that TV sucks.
And that is not a Vampire joke:)
And don't get me started on the movies.
Plus Entertainment Magazine has gotten oh so thin in content..:)
Rated with hugs.
Inspired by Steve Blevins, I think of myself not as a snob but rather as being ignorant and apathetic. Much more appealing, eh?
Nobody ever 'splained Avatar like that to me before. And here I thought I liked it. Bah!
Lezlie
I don't watch TV except for MM now . C'mon, you'd be surprised how quick three seasons of a show you get quickly addicted to can go ... I know, I did it for the great writing in The Sopranos. :)
But listen, it isn't because you are a snob. You're just getting old and cranky.
Congratulations.
I'm not one to crit others who watch trashy showdowns, but you won't find me paying money for that crap either.
I'd rather piddle around in my garden or visit the local library, both of which I find enriching.
I think we have all gotten too scared of being critical of the prevalent culture or whatever we call what it is ... they throw on us all.
All that snottiness aside, your man crush on Justin Timberlike intrigues me very much.
It's not being a snob - it's just being picky about maintaining high standards.
The quantity of suppliers of pop culture have grown exponentially in that time as well. Now, rather than fairly homogenized content from a limited number of sources, we have incredibly diverse content generated constantly. There's no way *anyone* would like most of it any more. We all can find a few entertainment options we like, intermixed with lots of things we think people are just nuts to like. As they would think about our choices.
I think it is kind of cool that so many different pop culture items can coexist and all have enough market to keep them afloat.
And I never listened to them before I read your blog!
Get that pulp off your night stand and read Ian McEwan: The Road and No Country for Old Men. Or find them in movie form at the library. They're manly novels with a real fist on destiny and humanity.
If you're a snob, then all these readers and I are your fan club.
Enjoyed your article immensely--made me register for membership to Open Salon! Thanks for writing it.
I don't think it's only a matter of getting older. American pop culture is more vapid than ever before - and more pervasive. It used to be just one aspect of the culture, now it's everything.
And if you can't relate to it, you feel totally alienated from the rest of society.
I have felt that way for years. You couldn't drag me to "Avatar", and I gave up on pop music eons ago. Does that make me a "snob"?
Fine.
But you also touched on another aspect: the "mean" factor. I think that makes it all even more disturbing. One reason I love to watch old movies is that they are devoid of that mean spirit. Was it a more
"innocent" time? Of course. And it was shallow in its own way.
But it is remarkable to think that the public could watch those films
and accept them at face value without a shred of cynicism. We have lost that "sweetness". And I mourn the loss.
In fact, forget the Unites States and check out what's coming out of other places... :-)
Tell them you´re a snob and they leave you to yourself - for a while - but will come back for details... Don´t gibe them !!
From the GripeVine... & Donah..//
And if this makes me old, then I've been a codger since I was a teenager.
I just wish there was more variety in everything. All the trends are very narrow because everything has to be a hit, the people, clothes, cars are generic wow and I get bored with the constant wow factor. I won't eat a cheap steak but I love hot dogs. Call yourself discerning and then only other people will think you're a snob. Yes, Beyonce is a Goddess.
http://open.salon.com/blog/kikstad/2010/07/27/defending_pop_culture
Well...you certainly started an interesting conversation and we all are seeking to show each other how appalled we are by pop-culture. I am appalled! Completely. I tell you. And then there are all those people who spend time engaged in serious naval gazing and who write about it for the entertainment, amusement and education of others. I think they call them bloggers. Somebody has to blow that &%$@ wide open. You should write about that! For sure! ;-)
But I feel a growing indifference to the flashy pop culture these days too. For me, it seems like incipient old-fogeyism more than snobbery. At some point in everyone's life, one just can't muster the same enthusiasm for "What's New and What's Hot" as the typical 20-something.
Ha, I am teasing! I recently hit the mighty 4-0, and sometimes I'll see something popular in the mainstream and think "Really?" You mention Lady Gaga, and when I think of her today, I think, she's just Madonna with a weirder costume designer. As much as I pay attention to a lot of pop culture, I couldn't give two farts about facebook, twitter, or myspace.
I wouldn't say you're snob, but in a more serious vein, I think you're just more discerning. Maybe too discerning? I also hate the tabloid nature of magazines, some news programs, E!, etc. If anything, pop culture is just shoved in your face. But the thing to think about - there's a lot of good things out in the world today. I'd say in the cyclical nature of pop trends - including music, tv, movies, books, internet - we're in more in the upward part, closer to a high period than a low.
Music? Kind of middling. There is a lot of interesting stuff out there, even though it's weighed down by the derivative nature of the top pop stuff. But with things like itunes, etc. It's at least like we have instant access to a lot.
Movies? Also, a lot of derivative reboots, sequels, adaptations, etc. But there are some great gems out there, not to mention that we're at a level of technical proficiency that makes even mediocre stuff good.
TV? For all that is out there, good and bad, I think we're in the midst of a great period of TV. For the weird mundanity and asshattery of most reality TV, there are a lot of other good things on the tube. Some of the smartest, most creative, and well produced shows in the history of tv are out there today. You are totally missing out on Mad Men, too. That show eschews a lot of the typical fictional pablum. And interestingly enough, it revolves around the pop culture of the early 60s. It's only 13 eps a season!
I think that there's a lot of fun stuff out there to enjoy and be entertained by, and you don't need a subscription to EW to enjoy it!
Bread and circuses, anyone?
i'm right there with ya, Crank.
R for right on
We live at a time when a whole lot of popular culture is unbelievably vacuous. Who was it who said "There's no 'there' there"? Why pretend that things are different? It's not specifically that you're yearning for some golden age; it's just that this one seems so......I don't know, corporate. Too much style, not enough substance, and the style isn't all that hot. Bread and bad circuses.
The last thing you should bitch about is being cranky. As my wife says: "What it is is in the name." You're cranky because you have something legitimate to be cranky about. More power to you.
In a mass culture 90% of everything will be crap. It's just that the 10% that isn't, will be different for each of us.