
My body is not my own.
Neither does yours belong to you. Our bodies are civic bodies, subject to the changing whims of temporal convention and the larger body politick. The very notion of a woman’s right to control her own body is mere comforting illusion for our sakes, no more. We argue around the edges of a reality that exerts daily control over all our bodies.
Our bodies are civic bodies, each belonging to us all and to the government. Skeptical? Consider then, the following.
We rail in outrage against the Taliban forcing women to wear burkas. But do you think you have it substantively different? No. You have it different only in degree. If you doubt it, try walking into the police station naked, or sunbathing on the beach in your altogether. And it doesn’t take the police to enforce this civic rule. Try riding the bus or subway naked and see how far you get.
Your body belongs to us. We not only tell you what you can show us of it, we tell you what you can and cannot do with it, too.
Abortion on demand may be a right, but try getting a mastectomy because your mother and three aunts died of breast cancer, and if you haven’t already got cancer you are going to have a very difficult time protecting yourself in the manner you wish.
If you think you are free to do with your body what you want, try getting a sex change operation. You won’t be allowed to unless you jump through years of expensive tests, first. Just ask our own brave and eternally sunny Elena Kelly.
And speaking of sex, try charging money for it and we will put you in jail. We let you give your body away, but we won’t let you rent it out. How's that for body ownership? And we’ll put you in jail for trying to rent someone else’s body, too. And even if you don't charge money for sex, we will put you in jail if you don't do it where we want you to. Disneyworld is a very stupid place to give your body sex if you want it to stay out of prison.
If a woman in Saudi Arabia walks with her head uncovered, government officials can hit them with sticks, and if I go to court in cutoffs and a tank top I am subject to arrest and a fine.
In America, if your body likes to have sex with the same kind of body, you are not free to marry or serve in the military or have other rights afforded to those whose bodies like different kinds of bodies.
If your body has an outie, you are a role model if you have sex with lots of people. If your body has an innie and you have sex with lots of people, we will give you names like tramp and slut and whore. And those are bad names.
Certain doors in life will be closed to you if you put too much ink on your body. And while we have no problem at all with you putting a hole in each of your ears and inserting jewelry into those holes, if you put holes elsewhere in your body we label you with other bad words and we limit what careers you can have. And if you put the holes in certain places that we call “private” -- and we get to determine which of your body parts you should keep private -- we will give you those tramp and whore names again.
We control where you can take your body. For instance, if you have to go to the bathroom, we tell you which rooms you can and cannot take it into. It used to be that we would tell you what kind of job your body type could have, but that doesn’t happen so much anymore, except at Hooters. We make clubs and gyms that you may or may not be allowed into, depending on your body.
Women are allowed to put pants on their bodies, but we weren't always. If you are man, we won’t arrest you for putting a dress on your body, but life will certainly be made very difficult for you. Likewise, if your body has a penis and you want to put makeup or nail polish on your body, we will limit what jobs you can have and where you can go. And we will generally make your life miserable. Oh, and good luck getting a date.
Women are allowed more leeway in what they can put on their bodies, but we are not completely free. People will occasionally be mean to me when I do not put a bra on my body. Boobs are bad. Nipples are worse. Other people get to control my boobs and my nipples. Yours, too. And tops that are considered fine for bodies with smaller breasts are often considered inappropriate for my body with my size breasts.
Plus, women bodies have more clothing requirements than men bodies. It is the rare woman who can get away with one pair of dress shoes and one pair of casual shoes, yet lots of men do just fine with exactly two pairs of shoes.
If you have a vagina, we charge you more to get your hair cut. Don't ask us why. No one knows.
We also tell you what you can and cannot put inside your body. If you’re under 21, you cannot put alcohol in your body. You can put tobacco smoke in your body if you’re 18, but you cannot put just any kind of smoke in it. For instance, you cannot put marijuana smoke in your body, ever.
We have lists of other things, sorted by the conditions in which we will let you put them in your body. A few years ago, you could not put Claritin in your body unless a doctor prescribed it for you, but today you can. That same few years ago you could put all the Sudafed in your body that you wanted, but not anymore. Today we limit how much you can have and make you identify yourself so the government can track you. Cocaine used to be an over-the-counter weight loss treatment and an ingredient in the nation’s best selling soft drink. Today we will put you in prison if you put cocaine in your body. And depending on which kind of cocaine you put in, we can incarcerate you for longer and longer periods of time.
If your body has ever been sick, we may not let you have medical insurance.
We won't let you take your body in an automobile unless you first buy insurance and wear a seatbelt. And while cowboys are not required to wear their hats, there are special hats we force you to wear if you ride a bike or a motorcycle.
Your body is not your own. It belongs to the rest of us. Today, I would like to ride my naked body to the beach on my bike, and plop it on the sand in the buff while putting marijuana smoke in it. If my body were my own, I could do that. But my body is a civic body. It belongs to you, not me.
And that kinda pisses me off.


Salon.com
Comments
But I know that much of it is an illusion.
The rest I'll send in a PM.
as long as i can join.
rated for mental images. (ok, and for the truth)
Good points, all.
Sending virtual chocolate - I know, it doesn't taste like real chocolate but it has way less calories.
You and me both, sistah!
rated (and not just for the chocolate cake tag) :-)
But, this:
"We rail in outrage against the Taliban forcing women to wear burkas. But do you think you have it substantively different? No. You have it different only in degree."
I really take exception to. The forced wearing of a burka and laws against public nudity are not at all equivalent. For one thing, the intent is completely different - subjugation versus public standards of decency (even though those public standards may feel more burdensome to some than to others). For another thing, the punishment for trangressing these norms is the difference between a fine and court appearance and the possibility of being executed.
That doesn't change my mind very much on this particular issue.
Liberty is largely an illusion. WTF these days they give you a drug test if apply for a job as a maid at the Days Inn! I can understand pilots and train and bus drivers, but can't the maid smoke a spleef, how can anyone even do that job unless they're high??
Because we can't be trusted to control ourselves. We need to be warned that drinking can lead to fetal discomfort! In a fucking bar!
It also gives an excuse for zealots who DO want to control womens bodies to go to extremes - all of a sudden, you're not allowed to have a margarita because you are carrying a child. According to the waiter or the bartender.
The assumption that women are so incapable of making "correct" choices and need to be monitored makes me sputter and rant and rage.
Yes, cigarettes are nasty and dangerous to all who consume them - is it really neccesary to put a huge thing about pregnant women on there?
It's a subtle way of forcing women to accept control over their bodies.
You see, I don't really care what you do with your pregnant body. I hope it's all good. Crack, gin, sherry , pot - it's yours, not mine.
Yoga, pilates, pot, wine, chiropractor - I'm still nonplussed.
I don't care what you do with your non pregnant bodies, unless you show me pictures.
I still hate walking into a bar and seeing the warning - that drinking alcoholic beverages could lead to birth defects. Where's the fucking warning about caution and respect and how NOT to get pregnant in the first place - which seems to me to be the more timely message in a frigging bar. To EVERYONE involved with any pregnancy.
OK - that's my rant. Thanks, Dana.
Given a vote...I'd probably vote to keep some of the restrictions you mentioned.
But just some.
This is a very good point.
SavageDaughter painted SavageHusband's toenails while he was napping (that's what he gets for being lazy) then he heard that girl scouts were selling cookies down the street. He grabbed his wallet, but not his shoes and ran to buy some cookies. When it was his turn he, along with everyone else noticed his toenails were pink.
Helmets are for pussies! (kidding)
we live in groups, very large groups now, and we need rules of behavior so your right to move your fist doesn't collide with my right to put my nose where i'd like.
we are social animals, can't help it.
what we can do, is shape the rules to allow maximum freedom within the fist-nose limits. the process of shaping those rules is where humans can add to their happiness.
i think democracy is the best process, but americans in general do not. they prefer to be ruled by politicians and priests, by managers and foremen, beyond the control of the ordinary person.
amazing, innit?
I wish I could ride my bicycle naked and smoke anything I wanted to at the beach with you. And eat cake.
A+++++++++
Seriously, that thing about the women in burkhas? I just told that to my fifth grade class last winter when they wanted to talk about how not free those "weird" Middle Eastern women are. I was feeling oppositional, I think, because I launched into the idea that they weren't really free to wear whatever they wanted, either, come to think of it. That wearing nothing at all or similar variations would get them into trouble. And then I brought up the business attire, church clothes, etc., reminding them that we have all kinds of cultural tyranny around what we wear. They were sort of dumbfounded, I must say.
"Women have no rights, Don, except what men allow us. Men are more aggressive and powerful and they run the world. When the next real crisis upsets them, our so-called rights will vanish like - like... smoke. We'll be back where we always were: property. And whatever has gone wrong will be blamed on our freedom, like the fall of Rome was."
The Women Men Don't See
James Tiptree Jr. (who was really alice bradley sheldon)
you've written a profound piece here. i wanted to share that quote because i think it's better than it was, but still not there yet. we are still swimming out onto the skin of the civic body. eventually, maybe, we will get out there in the sun, without fear of being flicked off, just for wanting to feel it for a moment.
Interesting. I've seen a Jimmy Hat, but never a Pussy Helmet. It just goes to show that you really do learn something new every day.
Great work here!
BTW I gave up trying to own mine many years ago......I wish they would show up once in a while and mow the grass........
fingerlakeswanderer, I like how you talked about bodies being anarchical. That is so true!
halfof42, if that's how you feel, if my body can't belong to me, then I wish my body did belong to you. Heck, if it keeps feeling like it does today, I'll give it to you. Meetcha on the beach!
Mr E, I thank you 100 times for your single rating. :)
Thanks, Owl. Just lucky!
Bill S., it's "fewer" calories, no matter what the advertising industry tells us. But I virtually accept, and will happily share the chocolate with you. :)
darkside, glad I could help. I think.
More later, as I have to help my nine-year old niece make "backwards dinner." We're having dessert first (chocolate cookies), followed by the main course of shrimp stir fry and veggie fried rice, then the appetizer of pork potstickers, and the first course of sliced oranges and melon.
Back after cookies.
I was merely reflecting that in life one is related to the other.