DANAGRAM

Politics and Culture in the Comic Zone

Daniel Rigney

Daniel Rigney
Location
New Texas, USA
Birthday
August 01
Title
free-range writer
Bio
In this writing workshop and citizen's blog I'm exploring various short forms, often from a satiric angle. My interests include politics, culture and the human comedy; old and new media; social theory and urban ethnography; the commercialization, corporatization and tabloidization of everything; sustainability; Unitarianism (UU); coffee; and writing (sorry, I mean providing content). Turtle stamp is from Tandy Leather. Interested in republishing a piece? Contact drigney3@gmail.com.

Daniel Rigney's Links

MY LINKS
NOVEMBER 10, 2012 12:20AM

GOP Gets Fact-Checked in November

Rate: 1 Flag

By Daniel Rigney

A factoid is a statement that has the look and feel of a fact even when it is demonstrably false. The campaign speeches of Mitt Romney and the spincasts of Fox News have been studded with false or misleading factoids this political season, including false predictions of the outcomes of the November elections. Dick Morris's notorious announcement of an impending "Romney landslide" keeps coming to mind.

Some factoids, however, may in fact be factual. In the wake of the recent  elections, NYT blogger Nate Silver’s election forecasts, for instance, have turned out to be closely in line with actual vote counts. Silver has proven his mettle once again as a member of the reality-based community – a veritable gold standard of analysis and prognostication.

Yet in the weeks preceding the election, many on the right dismissed Silver’s gold in favor of the more Republican-friendly tin forecasts of the Rasmussen poll and the Drudge Report.

No wonder Republicans were surprised by the outcome of the recent election. They failed to fact check their own factoids.

In fairness to the right, those of us on the center-left should be equally scrupulous in our vetting of facts. Here are some examples of factoids about prominent GOP leaders that stand in desperate need of verification.

 

Is it really the case, for example, that Donald Trump belonged to the college fraternity Sigma Phi Nothing? And is it true that his hair was the chapter mascot? We shouldn’t make claims of this sort, however plausible they may seem, without first doing some serious fact-checking.

Is it true that Karl Rove lives in an alternate universe in which Ohio had a Republican majority on election day? If so, how would we fact-check that claim? Not the claim about Ohio. That fact is in. I mean the claim that Karl Rove is not from the planet Earth as we know it.

Have you seen Rove’s Earth certificate? Or Trump’s, for that matter? I certainly haven’t. Someone needs to look into these things.

And while we’re checking facts, can someone please check preliminary reports that the Republican bridge to the 19th century has collapsed under the weight of the coal-fired locomotive of a Tea Party express train? Many careers are feared lost in the unexpected disaster, and massive sums of dark money will be needed to rebuild the party’s infrastructure.

 

If these aren’t true facts, we shouldn’t report them as such. Not every claim or factoid that sounds true passes the Veritas test.

I hope all you journalism majors and Young Republicans out there are taking notes. Your future may depend on the depth and quality of your relationship with reality.

 

Bonus question: Is our relationship with reality relevant to our reporting and understanding of climate change? Is nature itself the final fact checker?

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
It's just not true!! This election was rigged with fraudulent votes from illegal aliens all coordinated by the terrorist neo-colonial, Islamo-fascist, socialist, Black Panther, tree hugging, climate change, Zionist, femi-nazi, secular humanist, atheist conspiracy to poison our minds and "precious bodily fluids" with fluoride, homosexual AIDS and evolution theory!! It's all laid out up on the internets!!
I wonder if you could package that worldview, market it, sell it and make millions. Oh, wait. An entire political industry is already doing that. Thanks, j.