Dave Cullen's Blog

Conclusive Evidence of My Existence

Dave Cullen

Dave Cullen
Location
New York, New York, USA
Birthday
June 03
Title
Author/Journalist
Company
Written for NY Times, W Post, Slate, Salon, Daily Beast. Publisher Twelve (Hachette)
Bio
An expanded paperback edition of my book COLUMBINE came out March 1, 2010. Links to the book and my bio below: http://www.davecullen.com/columbine.htm

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
FEBRUARY 13, 2010 2:58PM

A Rare Breed of Killer

Rate: 32 Flag

Something unusual happened in Alabama Friday afternoon. A woman committed mass murder.

That's the opening of a piece I wrote late last night for The Daily Beast. It's their lead story right now.

I am really tired now, because I spent a good chunk of the night writing it. I heard about it at the 24 Hour Fitness around 7:30 p.m., whenKari Rene Hall, a photojournalist with the Orange County Register called my iPhone in the middle of my seated reverse-grip military presses on the smith machine. (I use the phone as an iPod while I work out.)

Kari is a colleague from The Dart Center for Journalism & Trauma, so I figured her team would write em pathetically, and I was eager to help.

She wanted to know if a woman had ever perpetrated a school shooting before. Yes, I said, but rarely.

I called my wonderful volunteer researcher in Kentucky to find the long list we'd compiled and email it to  my phone. The reporter said the woman had killed only faculty, which immediately made me guess it might actually be more of a workplace shooting. Maybe, maybe not. Was she a grad student, I asked. The reporter didn't know. She turned out to be a professor herself.

I was intrigued. Lots of interesting aspects to this case. Lots of ways to address all the myths most of us have about the "profile" of the typical shooter. (Which is nearly all complete nonsense: except that they are nearly always male, which is nearly always true, but not this time.)

I kept lifting, and thinking. Between sets, I'd scramble over to the front desk, reach over the counter to where I know they store the stack of pink message pads which have blank backsides, grabbed one of those and a pen and scribbled down thoughts.

They tend to look surprised when I rush up and do that, but they are also kind of used to me. They start to say, "Can I help y. . ." and then they appear to think, Oh, their wierd guy who frantically needs to scribble things again.

I do my bestcomposing on walks, bike rides and lat pulldown machines.

My gym pants had no pockets, so I fold them twice the long way and then tuck them into my waistband, half inside, half out, with my shirt hanging down to cover them, except when I stretch. Then it might look odd, I'm not sure.

I got home with a stack, and a lot of data to go digging for. It was after 10 on the east coast, so I emailed a couple editors I've worked for. One was still up and wanted it.

A bit past midnight I had the piece, sent it off tried to go to sleep and thought about all the stuff I left out. I sent an update, got five hours of sleep, and by the time I got up for my nightly pee-break, there was an edit waiting for me, with questions. 

It took and hour and a half to satisfy myself with the rewrites, and then my body didn't want to go back to sleep.

So the story is up, and I'm happy with it, but I would really appreciate it if my body would turn itself off for awhile. Not going to happen. My brain does not believe in naps. It's hard enough to make it shut up at night. 

I hope you like the piece.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Interesting story. Looks like you are starting something with this? It seems real-life based. My first daily newspaper job was as a night's cops reporter in Huntington, W.Va. Thanks for the post.
Interesting that you are the "expert" on this bizarre type of story. Then again, that's how leads are follwed and ledes are made. R
The professor who is the alleged shooter, was recently denied tenure. This denial of tenure appears to be the motive.
Thanks, everyone. More soon--in a rush.

Willie, I address the tenure in the piece. Be careful to assume too much about that (see the piece for why).
I just heard that she killed her own brother when she was 18. My source is my mother -so not sure, but either way this is one tasty story. Sure, it's very tragic to the victims and the family, but as a story.... tayysteee.
I did like the piece. And I appreciated your behind the scene peek. _r
Chilling. There seems to be a growing segment of the population who thinks they are owed things, deserve things. We have all worked hard. We all have talents. We are all owed things, and deserve things -- even if the thing we are owed or deserve is a life without cancer rather than something like tenure. I know the people who do these things are mentally imbalanced, but I do wonder how much consumer culture has to do with it. It isn't that far of a leap from "You deserve a car like this!" to "You deserve everything you desire and have worked for."
Good piece, Dave.

I was thinking of the exception while reading it...I remember Brenda Spencer in San Diego very well -- and of course her reason for killing her school mates was immortalized in the Boomtown Rats song, "I Don't Like Mondays."

Having worked in HR for many years, I tend to see these as workplace shootings, not school shootings, too. It was always our greatest fear to have an employee come after us in the HR dept due to something like this, especially as we went thru many rounds of layoffs. And then there were always those odd employees who got fired for cause who really scared you.
fernsy, i can't share your opinion of it as tasty, but you were right about the previous shooting.

This is getting stranger:

http://www.boston.com/news/local/breaking_news/2010/02/professor_accus.html

I would not jump to conclusions, but man.
This is a well written story Dave. I think people rush to profile murderers and motivations to ward of fears of this happening to them-- but that's what you made so clear in Columbine, isn't it--we can't rush in to explain away things like this. It's so good to know a reporter I can trust. Otherwise, I just don't read this kind of story at all.
http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/us_and_americas/article7026844.ece

She has a look in her eyes that is very unsettling.
It gets weirder:

Alleged Ala. killer was suspect in attempted bombing of Harvard professor

http://www.boston.com/news/local/breaking_news/2010/02/ala_slay_suspec.html?s_campaign=8315
thanks for all the comments.

i'm glad the bits on my process were interesting to some people. i wasn't sure what i was even going to write when i sat down here, and that just spilled out.

in terms of the writing life, the web is an interesting place for a freelancer these days. it's almost impossible to make a living that way anymore, and the web has destroyed a staggering number of writing/journo jobs, so that it's almost impossible to make it as a freelance writer on any platform now. but . . .

the upside is that there are a lot of different kinds of sites, that look for things of different length. i only had about 600-800 words of material last night, which in the old days would have been too little to contribute anywhere professionally. now it's not.
Nice piece on The Beast. I'll have to look this up, but why is the Secret Service doing reports on school shootings? Seems odd.
Interesting stuff . . . unfortunate, but interesting.
Your admonitions not to judge this case on first blush are extremely precient as the "weird" elements unfold here. Good reporting. It was also fascintaing to read your reporting of yourself behind the scenes on this piece here.
Bishop's killing spree seems clearly related to her outrage over tenure, which is an institutionalization of the concept of entitlement to the unearned--a concept which is flourishing in our current political climate. I can see tenure for justices who must be protected against political influence and pressure. But teachers? Why?
I'd say the Boston Herald has done the best job so far. There's a lot of local color. She killed her brother with a shotgun, but charges weren't pressed because her mother was a member of the police personnel board in town. The file on the case is missing from the local police department. She stormed into an auto dealership with a shotgun demanding a getaway car after the killing, threatening an auto-body worker. She's a far-left political extremist who's "obsessed" with President Obama to the extent of being "off-putting" to those who disagree with her. She was implicated in an attempted pipe-bombing of a Harvard medical school faculty member who critiqued her work for her tenure review.

Just saying she's unique because she's a woman doesn't begin to describe her. The Boston Globe, as usual, glosses over details that don't agree with its world view.

http://bostonherald.com/news/regional/view.bg?articleid=1232943
This is an utterly bizarre case, this women, bizarre. What is not bizarre is the way you write. I take a tiny notebook to the gym. sleep is at times impossible. Thanks for your post and back scenes peek-a-boo.
The fact that she shot her 18 year old brother and the Braintree, MA police, instead of actually investigating, believed her story of "accidental" is very troubling.

Police have become like the media: transcribers instead of researchers.
When I heard she killed her brother with a shotgun "OMG, I just accidentally shot my brother in the chest 3 times!!" I knew this was a mentally unbalanced person. That her mother (apparently) and others chose to protect her rather than get her some serious help (while locking her up) is frightening. And I'm guessing that "workplace shootings" (somehow linked to some stress-inducing denial/loss at work) aren't nearly as common as family murder-suicides which often take more lives than these shooting sprees, including infants and small children (somehow linked to some stress-inducing denial/loss at home).

Okay, the old canard: why are these fools able to so easily obtain firearms?

And WTF is going on? As Moore showed us, there are more guns per capita in Canada yet we far outpace Canadians in these wacko shoot-em-up scenarios, as well as "everyday" type murders (if there is such a thing). So the (a) solution is not just as easy as gun control.

BTW, that 16-year old in 1979 said she shot up the school "because I don't like Mondays".

Maybe we need to look at ourselves as a culture. It's not tv or books or movies. Those are available all over the world. I don't know what it is but there is something in our mindset that, for the most emotionally unstable of us seems to lead to mass carnage.
(about earlier investigation of attempted pipe bombing): "During a search of Bishop's computer, authorities found a draft of a novel that Bishop was writing about a female scientist who had killed her brother and was hoping to make amends by becoming a great scientist"

yikes. There's the motive for why denying her tenure would trigger such incredible violence.
I wonder if it's useful to distinguish between different kinds of "sprees." It seems to me that there are at least two kinds. First, there is the "spree" in which the person targets specific individuals who have caused some offense. Second, there is the "spree" in which the individual mostly targets people at random, perhaps also including one or more specific individuals.

In other words, I think the pathology behind the two kinds of shootings may be very different. The first may be more of a typical criminal mentality, in which the shootings are done for revenge, the second more of a sociopathic mentality, with the shootings done for deeper psychological or delusional reasons.
Very compelling take on another shocking story...I look forward to following your investigation on this...I hope it continues...xox
I enjoyed your piece and it reminds me of how I collect ideas and stick them wherever I can for writing poetry.. My take on this shooting thing is no one can take critisism these days. Everyone feels insulted before they even get the entire feedback of a situation. People seem to be so quick to want to "kick someone's ass" and it's sad we have all gotten so soft and ultra- sensitive..as I heard a comedian (Dennis Leary) say once, "Life's hard, get a helmet!"
I really liked your piece. The glimpse into the writer’s life and the art and craft of getting an article together was a real treat.

As shocked as everyone seems whenever there’s a mass shooting I rarely hear anything that suggests any possibility for this unfortunate American recurring theme ever changing.

There are crazy people in every country. No one knows who they are until they strike. Yes, they can even be middle aged women and mothers to children. But we in the US have so many more casualties because guns are available—everywhere. A crazy person without a gun can only do so much with household objects.

Yet no matter what happens, the shock lasts for a day and no one dares speak the obvious truth. No other western country has our rates of gunshot casualties because no other country allows guns to be sold as if they’re toys.

Rated and appreciated
You're a reporter, Dave, a very good one. Unfortunately, these kinds of stories seem to be morphing into head-shakers rather than rage-inducers. I hate all this violence.

Nice job on the Daily Beast piece, too.
Great story, but I enjoyed the background you posted here better. It is interesting to see how a journalist puts together a story. R
Damn, you guys are nice. Thanks.

I needed the support right now. I think I just started getting panicky about my paperback release. It kept seeming like forever away--annoyingly long to wait--and then today I heard myself tell someone it comes out in two weeks and my pulse doubled in the next 30 seconds. Haha. I'm more or less serious.

Suddenly I feel like there were a million things I should have done and this puppy is about to launch without me. The other thing is that with the hardcover release, I expected anxiety but this time it didn't occur to me that it would repeat. Dumbass. How hard was that to foresee?

Anyway, I'm nervous as hell suddenly, and I came home and read these and it makes me feel like I have a safety net. Thanks.
Excellent article, and you're right - as this story unfolds it becomes more and more a case of truth being stranger than fiction. I'm proud of my hometown paper (The Boston Herald) even though I haven't lived there for many years.
Really liked your description of the creative process - you made me feel less like a crazy person for all the weird stuff I do when the moments when fleeting inspiration strikes!
Killed brother, pipe-bomb-threatened Harvard colleague, trips to the firing range--one might fairly conclude that the hiring committee of the U of A received its training at the Obama terrorist team school.
Really interesting--both pieces.
And now they are reopening the death of her brother....that seems to be another story but leads you to wonder how she functioned so effectively (?) for so many years.