Balancing Act

JUNE 17, 2009 11:28AM

Speech in a Maine Town Meeting

Rate: 8 Flag

Thank you, Jack.  I'd like to address the notion that we can't afford this school budget.  

While I was waiting to come to this meeting I was reading.  Thucydides wrote a great account of the history of his city as it unfolded in his lifetime.  When I put the book down to get in the car, I was at the place where the citizens of Athens gathered in their assembly to discuss their treaty obligations to Corinth.

People in Athens came to their Assembly 2400 years ago to talk over the problems of the day, just as we are doing today.  Listening to you now, I felt that I was doing something with a tradition thousands of years old.  They didn't let everyone into the assembly in Athens, just people they thought had judgment enough to be counted on to make a good decision.  Long ago in this country, though conservatives fought the notion, it was decided to aim for 100% literacy, mostly for this purpose right here.  The idea was that a citizen had to read and be informed to even be a good citizen.

Somewhat later in this country the idea of publicly funded education took hold, though, again, conservatives fought the notion.  We even made it mandatory.  You can't have a truant child, by law, unless you can show the court that some equivalent to public education is being provided.  Your grandparents and parents lived in a town, paid their taxes, and you folks here now got the advantage of it.  Using that education, you are now informed enough to have decent judgment about whatever might need to be done in town.  

I remind you that you'll get old one day, and if a crop of kids have grown up around you who are ignorant, there's lots of ways they could sit in a meeting like this one and bring to ruin a lot of the things you know are important.  They could perhaps never have picked up properly the idea of the common good, of how responsible citizens have to work together.  They could be swayed, maybe, by someone with a chip on her shoulder and a gift for speeches to make people mad.  Ignorant people can cost everyone, by letting crumble all the things careful citizens have slowly built, just because no one ever told them any better.

And it's your turn.  You're grown up now, the gray is coming into your hair.  It's your turn now to live in a town, pay your property taxes, and fund this school budget.  

Yes, it costs more this year.  Bread costs more, gas costs more, heat costs more.  It isn't a great surprise that the schools are going to cost more.  I'm sure the generation which gave you your education griped and grumbled about how much it cost, too, but they did it.  Now it's up to you to man up and do what needs to be done.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Rated for my 22 years as resident of Maine.
"Ignorant people can cost everyone, by letting crumble all the things careful citizens have slowly built"

By letting crumble, and by tearing down. Thank you for being one of the people who keep working to shore up the foundation.
Based on a true story. Thucydides, all true; and there were several people who had gotten to be on the school board purely and only to kill off everything the town was doing that cost any money. They did it because of taxes, for reasons a greedy dog would use if he wanted money instead of food. It was actually a school board meeting, and the issues a little less simple to state, but I take fictive license here.
Awesome. I hope the ancient history hit home, since most of Maine likes to pretend it's the 1800's.
Your speech would resonate in every school district in the country, I think.
There's a major vote on an override for the town budget happening today. I'll vote for it, but I also think that forcing people to choose between teachers and higher taxes is a mismanagement of funds.
I'll pay higher taxes when I see a lot less of $20,000.00 committees figuring out how to raise funds.
(i'm in a mood today! Rated.)
Well, thank you. I don't elevate this argument, in specific, to the status of a Principle to Live By. Every decision has its own color, and simply voting for a school budget, unexamined, is no universal truth. What I think is a universal truth is that there is such a thing as stewardship.
this is the core of democracy. it needs responsibility in the electorate, and sufficient education to understand the issues. but if you have those things, you have a good chance of getting decisions that deliver the best results for the society.

it works in town hall meetings, and it would work at the national level too, if america were a democracy. but it's not.
If only your neighbors in New Hampshire would adopt a sales tax, perhaps this message would be better heard by the beleaguered property owners would be better able to vote for increased school funding. Well said, Dave.
Town Meeting is one of the things I miss out here in Seattle. Sun in February's another.
We don't stand a chance here in my neck of the woods (North Bergen, Hudson County, New Jersey - Town Motto "We're Corrupt and We Love It!"). Our Mayor is also our assemblyman and our state representative. I don't even think they have meetings, just dinner.

Well said, by the way.