David A. Love's Blog

David A. Love

David A. Love
Location
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, U.S.
Birthday
June 18
Bio
David A. Love is the Executive Editor of BlackCommentator.com, where his Color of Law column appears weekly. He is a contributor to the Huffington Post, the Progressive Media Project, McClatchy-Tribune News Service, theGrio, News One, In These Times and Philadelphia Independent Media Center. He contributed to the book, States of Confinement: Policing, Detention and Prisons (St. Martin's Press, 2000). Love is a graduate of Harvard College and the University of Pennsylvania Law School. He also completed the Joint Programme in International Human Rights Law at the University of Oxford.

Editor’s Pick
AUGUST 13, 2010 9:29AM

The Professional Left Wants Its F.D.R. Now

Rate: 29 Flag

Although inadvertently perhaps, White House press secretary Robert Gibbs performed a great public service when he complained about the "professional left" that will not give this administration proper credit for its legislative accomplishments. And he insulted a wide swath of the Democratic base in the process. He apologized and later stood by his statement, but it's the type of thing you just can't take back. Not unlike that proverbial tube of toothpaste, you just can't put it back in.

This was a showdown in the making, and should be welcomed. On the one hand there's the base that worked hard to get Obama into office, and now pushes this president to do more. On the other hand, there's a White House that is simply dumbfounded. The Obama administration apparently cannot understand why its supporters are not in awe over its ability to politick, compromise, and water down great legislation into mediocre laws, without getting anything for it in return. There seems to be a sense of arrogance emanating from the White House, this attitude that the base should just be happy and stop complaining. After all, Obama is much better than Bush, and look at what he has achieved in only a little over a year and a half -- health care reform, student loan reform, a recovery act that prevented the nation from sliding into a depression, and so on.

To be sure, the accomplishments to date are considerable, and we should not ignore them. But at the same time, the base always expected, even demanded great things from this president who campaigned as a change agent. And the dire problems America is facing require some urgent, forceful, audacious leadership.

But far too often this administration appears to want to play it safe, hedge its bets. For example, the economic stimulus, however well intentioned, should have been much larger. Other times the Obama White House negotiates with itself and gives away far too much, as was the case with the public option. Or the White House will try to bargain with rabid conservatives who have no intention of working together, and would like nothing more than to bring down this presidency. And one gets the impression some of these Republicans would bring down the entire nation just to win an election.

This leads us to the issue of jobs. Part of the problem is the White House is entertaining the foolish proposition of cutting the deficit during a time of recession. At this rate, we might as well put another nail in the coffin that contains what is left of the U.S. middle class.

You know how bad it's getting here in Third World America because the mobs are coming out with the pitchforks. Now, don't get me wrong, people right now have every right to be angry. This recession is unlike any other in recent memory, certainly since the Great Depression. There is no rebound this time, no jobs magically coming back with an upturn of the business cycle, much as the tides faithfully ebb and flow each day. There is no relationship between the fortunes of Wall Street and the plight of the common folk, so it seems. And those who are at the top don't need the rest of us, except when it comes to gaining at our expense.

The handiwork of Democrats and Republicans alike, years of regressive policies have amounted to highway robbery of working people. Deregulation wrecked and plundered the economy, and eviscerated Americans' life savings and home equity. Unemployment is the highest it has been in years, and long-term employment is at disturbing levels, with nearly half of the unemployed out of work for at least six months. College graduates begin their careers in a mountain of debt but with no jobs. Moreover, a trickle-down policy has resulted in the greatest gap between rich and poor in modern history, and a nation that ranks among the least upwardly mobile of the advanced nations.

So now, what is supposedly the world's greatest nation cannot afford to keep its schools open. State and local governments are out of cash, and some localities are grounding up the streets into gravel because they can no longer afford to maintain the roads. State austerity measures--including layoffs of government workers and cutting of important programs--will only exacerbate this economic death spiral.

These are the times when hate groups and unscrupulous politicians suit up for the ugly days ahead, preying on the fears of low information Americans. Bereft of solutions, the ultra-right is doing what the ultra-right does, which is to tear apart the country with an "M-G-M." strategy: blame the Mexicans, Gays and Muslims for all your problems, with the actual or perceived threat of violence thrown in. Of course, blaming that poor undocumented worker for your plight will not help you, but isn't that what scapegoats are for? And the Fourteenth Amendment be damned, they say.

Surely, we can and should assign much blame for our woes on George W. Bush, who bankrupted the nation with two wars and a massive tax cut for the wealthy. However, Bush is no longer running for office. President Obama must realize that he will be judged if he cannot deliver on jobs, and rightly so. Progressives are trying to do him a favor by ensuring that he is not a one-term president, but he refuses to take the hint. A fighting spirit is lacking. At this rate, President Obama is well on his way down that road, despite the phalanx of incompetent empty suits found in abundance on the other side. To this extent, the base is doing what a good base should do.

President Franklin D. Roosevelt came into power after a failing Herbert Hoover who meant well, but either had the wrong ideas, or his good ideas were too little, too late. Roosevelt enacted a massive New Deal program based on relief to the unemployed, economic reform, and recovery through federal spending. The measures were sweeping, and helped cement a Democratic coalition for decades.

But as F.D.R. once told labor and civil rights leader A. Phillip Randolph during a discussion on the future of the country and the plight of African-Americans,

"You know, Mr. Randolph, I've heard everything you've said tonight, and I couldn't agree with you more. I agree with everything that you've said, including my capacity to be able to right many of these wrongs and to use my power and the bully pulpit. ... But I would ask one thing of you, Mr. Randolph, and that is go out and make me do it." 

Once again, the base is making a president "do it," so to speak, for his own good and ours. The party faithful did not vote for good speeches alone, or milquetoast policies and lukewarm, half-hearted solutions to a crisis situation. Nor did they vote for "drill baby drill," or the escalation of a senseless war in Afghanistan, or Wall Street lackeys controlling the till. Certainly, they did not vote for a U.S. that spends as much on military as the rest of the world combined, as other nations beat us in expenditures for science, technology and infrastructure. But they did vote for the active role of government in making things right, as only government can do.

The "professional left" simply wants its F.D.R. in the form of Barack Obama, because that's what 2008 was all about, after all.

Author tags:

news, politics

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Well put. Although, I continue to think that the "left" (myself included) and the nation would benefit more from "Truman" than FDR.
It's been a while since I've read a post on OS. This one reminds me why I come here: to read intelligent, well-written opinion that's not in colusion with the MSM. This is excellent and needs to be widely read. Thank you for stating this so well. Now, when are you running for office and where? I'll move there and vote for you! Rated
President Obama is more like Bill Clinton than FDR.

Clinton was a centrist, so is Obama.
Rated for dead-on-right and clarity.
FDR scolded the banksters and embraced the workers. Obama embraces the banksters and scolds the workers.

In that, Obama is FDR -- Franklin Delano Reverse.
Excellent point! I was full of hope when Obama took office, just to have to realize that the real, meaningful change IS being watered-down and compromised-and the progressives have done all of the compromising! R
Just to add something-much of the country needs to get over the idol worship of Ronald Reagan. He has been the architect of the demise of the middle class, and fools still will buy into the whole 'bad government' stuff! I would only hope people would vote in their own interests instead of corporate interests!
"M-G-M" strategy. Hmm...I can see that motion picture company's logo now...Glen Beck's ugly mug, spewing invective, in place of the roaring lion...

But seriously, in my darker moments, I see President Obama (who I volunteered for in '08) as the new Neville Chamberlain. And anyone who knows English history knows what happened when Mr. Chamberlain tried to negotiate peace with Machiavellians.
Superb. This is the best essay on the Obama administration I've encountered. Thoughtful and well reasoned. Well done!
Very well said, David! Thank you.

For those of us who have lived in the gothic vestiges of the feudal South, we long ago saw the things you speak of, the dangers of upper classes dividing and preying on those below. As the nation became more and more like Dixie, we feared what lay ahead.

That poisonous fruit is now growing. The blooms began to fall during the last regime and many of us saw the need for an FDR type to tend the garden. That's what we thought we were getting with Obama but it appears he was indeed more like his predecessors than we wanted to believe.

Looks like we may all pay the price for his ambition and the partisan politics of Democrats who care more about chalking up tally marks than accomplishing anything substantive.

Rated.
A lot of interesting stuff has been written about the Robert Gibbs comments. But this is probably the best I've seen. Puts things in perspective and very well stated.
With writing this good, you may speak on my behalf any day of the week, David! Well done.

My disappointment in President Obama has caused an apathy in me that I used to despise in others. Now that I know I can't count on him to change things, I don't believe any of them.
Lezlie
David, I love your posts. You just cut right to the meat of it and express my thoughts so well.

There is a brain drain in progress. I have friends in other countries who are beckoning us with the promise of jobs.

My daughter moved to Europe to teach English when W was re-elected (and earned an advanced degree in Germany). She's currently teaching English in Kosovo.

My friend Rebecca, a PhD in Medieval Literature, teaches English in South Korea. I could teach English in Korea or a host of other countries, or there are opportunities available for substance abuse counseling. Jobs are plentiful, but I imagine that's only true for a short time. Both Rebecca and Lynne have complete medical care.

We have nothing left here. No family in this state (CA), one part time minimum wage job for the two of us and our pets, no health care, and bleak prospects for finding better. I'd join you with my pitchfork, but I had to sell it on eBay (along with everything else of any value) to pay for food and gas.

I can't drive the car because I have outstanding tickets and my license is expired. If I get caught, they will impound the car, which is okay because my tires are so bald as to be dangerous. NO TREAD at all.

My credit has gone to hell. With tickets on my record and very bad credit, I'm not sure I can get a job even if I get an interview. Twenty-seven beautiful resumes went out three weeks ago that would have ordinarily gotten me many calls, and I have had NONE.

You can read it all here: http://www.open.salon.com/blog/leslieca/2010/08/12/should_i_be_uneasy, but you get the idea.
Or it could be that there is something fundamentally wrong with consumer capitalism after all.

Nice piece though.
"... health care reform, student loan reform, a recovery act that prevented the nation from sliding into a depression, and so on."

Also the decision to sue Arizona over this SB1070 nonsense is on Obama's 'plus column.'

I agree with your assessment. The WH is getting arrogant and needs to remember the progressive base put them there.
Exceptional analysis!
pelosi recently echoed the "make me do it" line. its curiously passive and submissive. not what the americans want out of a president.
gotta give him some credit. obama showed strong spine and cojones except in one occasion. when he got elected into office.
What you call "the base" is only part of the constituency that put Obama in office. More significant support came from romantic intellectuals and unthinking independents. This support has, as the polls indicate, awakened to the reality that routine Chicago community organizers simply don't have the goods to be the leader of a country with the power, traditions, and philosophical grounding of the United States.

Fortunately for the future of the country, what you call the "base" is simply not numerous or resourceful enough to call the shots. May it always be thus.
I, too, like Frogtown Diva, have been absent for awhile; a long while, for the reasons she mentioned. Yours is the first OS post I've read in ages, and expresses exactly what I've been feeling since last year when I worked hard on behalf of single payer health care and was astonished to discover not only that none of my work mattered, not even as far, at least, as getting a public option into a bill that is clearly designed to favor insurance companies over citizens is concerned, but that many of my comrades, once the bill was passed, changed their tune and began congratulating this administration on a job well done. The same has been happening with financial reform...stimulus efforts...foreign relations...war policy...the list goes on. I've been studying politics ever since my in-the-trenches work on health care reform to try to understand what happened and what is continuing to happen, and, maybe, contribute to a change in direction. I'm still befuddled, too befuddled to write, yet, so I thank you for expressing much of exactly what I've been thinking, and expressing it so cogently.
Do many of us who lean to the left understand that when we lionize minimal administrative accomplishment we are also settling for a "better than nothing" (the phrase I've heard numerous left leaning pundits use to rationalize their expressed appreciation for the little this administration has managed to do) nation? I think, unfortunately, not. Your post reminds me that I am not alone.
Again, thank you.
fdr enacted nothing, as he was merely president. congress saved america. people who expect action from the president should read the constitution, and marvel if anything gets done at all.

it was the intent of the writers of the constitution that nothing get done. they were already on top of society and did their best to freeze the nation at that point, with great success.
President Obama appeared and sang a song like the Siren in Sinbad and the Seven Seas. His wild spending along with bills that people are just now figuring out what's in them is leading us into a watery grave.

The reason President Obama's poll numbers are dropping, along with Congress, is people are waking up and hearing the song like Marina. Hopefully those you now berate for jumping from President Obama's ship can steer it away from the rocks of ruin we are heading for.

When people voted for the ship to go a new direction, they didn't vote for it to head for the rocks.
Excellent post. You hit the nail on the head.

The Obama administration seems to have forgotton this old adage at their peril, "You should dance with the one that brung you." And if you're smart, you don't stomp on their feet.
I think you've written about it elsewhere, but it's worth repeating . . . Right before FDR died he gave a wonderful speech about how he saw human rights as the cornerstone of any viable future. Amongst these rights, he numbered the right to economic security---a job---as paramount. Of course this would be considered heresy today, even for most of the so called professional left, who have instead enshrined human rights as a set of abstract principles attached to the individual alone that are supposed to give each of us all the tools we need to make it on our own.

With so much of the progressive community having completely accepted the basic "pull-yourself-up-by-your-own-bootstraps" principles of capital, it's no wonder we ended up with a disappointment like Obama rather than a new FDR to provide counter-values to the age of global neoliberalism and neoconservatism. And this IS about the values of the system we want, as you point out. FDR was speaking of social rights, and the social values that underpin them, when he spoke of human rights. The individual has become an insidious concept, shilled by the weirdos who keep recommending further privatization and "liberalization" of trade as the preferred fixes to the present crisis. Obviously the only rights they're interested in are those of the corporation, the only individual that matters to them, and then only as an tool for financial speculation and not as an agency to employ real people.
rated.
A friend and I lost out onn a great economical scheme a while back.
The planconsisted of a lovely blue tablet, when placed into an eight=ounce glass of water produced a wonderful, thirst quenching glass og H20. When we cut production
rated.
BOKO
August 15, 2010 09:40 PMA friend and I lost out onn a great economical scheme a while back.
The planconsisted of a lovely blue tablet, when placed into an eight=ounce glass of water produced a wonderful, thirst quenching glass og H20. When we cut production, people complained they had nothing.

Sorry for the double-post. My tired hands hit the wrong button, and I stubbed my tou kicking the pulbic option out the window.
thoroughly well written, but it's a bunch of stuff I already know. You just need to read things here and there on the internet, or listen to NPR for a little while, or read a little Barbara Ehrenreich to know that the workers and voters in this country have little if any power. Paul J. O. makes a good point too. Gibson is beneath contempt. The question is WHAT DO WE DO? Keep doing what we have been doing, I guess, stay informed (though that's so depressing), vote, but now that we know what contempt the administration has for the left (why shouldn't we be professional?), it's just so disheartening. But let's admit, when FDR was president, things were somewhat different, to put it very mildly. This president needs more fight under the circumstances, and he seems to be saving his fight for his base. Like Jon Stewart, I give up.
"The Obama administration apparently cannot understand why its supporters are not in awe over its ability to politick, compromise, and water down great legislation into mediocre laws, without getting anything for it in return. "

In this retiree-intensive community, I know quite a few Greatest Generation Democrats who were hoping for Obama to be FDR in 2008. What they discovered after the election is that the hippie flat-earth wing of the party still rules. You can look this up under "Sunrise Powerlink".