DebFeb's Blog

Everyday Observations and Existential Musings

Deborah Sosin

Deborah Sosin
Location
Boston, Massachusetts,
Birthday
February 27
Bio
I'm a writer, editor, psychotherapist, and graduate student in the MFA in Creative Writing program at Lesley University. I facilitate Write It Like It Is workshops and groups in the Boston area and teach at Grub Street. ("DebFeb" is a nickname related to my birth month.)

MY RECENT POSTS

JUNE 9, 2011 10:19AM

It's the Impulse Control, Stupid!

Rate: 7 Flag

“I take full responsibility and I deeply regret any hurt or pain I might have caused anyone by my actions and indiscretions.”

How manly. How mature. Yes, I’m talking about Anthony Weiner, and the long punch line of men (I really can’t think of an equivalent errant woman) who have eloquently apologized for their misdeeds—after the fact.

Man biting fist, raising eyebrows, portrait photo

Let’s back it up, shall we? The pundits ask, How could you be so foolish as to tweet, cheat, stray, deceive, and so on? Or they wonder, Why would you risk power, position, family? Were you so deluded that you thought you’d be the one not to get caught? Theories abound about narcissism and power, which help us understand the confounding behavior. Think Bill Clinton or Arnold Schwarzenegger or . . . well, you know the list.

But before the sneaking and the secrets and the lies and the cover-ups comes the impulse to “act out” in the first place.

“Oh, but it feels good. I want it,” they think. Or,  “Because I can.”

True responsibility, Weiners of the world, is not acting on the urge in the first place.

What they’re missing is good old-fashioned impulse control. You know, the kind we’re supposed to learn as kids. The kind that keeps us from eating every cookie in the cookie jar just because we want to. The kind that keeps us from beating up our little brother whenever we feel like it.

And that’s not so easy in a culture that celebrates instant gratification and pleasure over mindfulness and maturity.

I’m a therapist working with drug addicts and alcoholics. Most of them are in treatment because they’ve gotten into some kind of trouble— physical, legal, financial, marital, academic, professional—as a result of their substance abuse. Some are in treatment because they want to be, some because other people want them to be.

In my recovery groups, we talk about relapse prevention. One strategy is to identify triggers—people, places, things—and learn to manage them. Another strategy is called “playing the tape all the way through.” If I act on this impulse—this desire to feel good or powerful or numb—what will it lead to? What has it led to in the past? Stop. Think. Project into the future. How will I feel about myself? Is it worth it? What will I gain? What will I lose?

I have a kid in one of my early recovery groups, let’s call him Mack. Mack is nineteen and drank beer and smoked marijuana all through middle school and high school before getting into painkillers like Percocet, Vicodin, and Oxycontin. He became addicted and, because of the expense, picked up a heroin habit. Not an uncommon path.

So Mack hasn’t used anything in a few weeks. He comes to my group late, chomping on a big, thick chocolate bar, high-fiving all the other guys upon his entrance.

“Mack,” I say. “You’re late. Please sit down and put away the candy bar.”

“Whaddya mean?” he says, flashing an angry look.

“You know the rule. No food in group.”

“When did you ever say that?” he says.

The other boys jump in, “Yeah, you never said that. Why shouldn’t he be able to eat? He’s hungry! He’s probably had a hard day! He deserves it.”

“Mack,” I say. “You can choose to leave the room and finish your candy bar and come back next week, or you can put it away and eat it later.”

He continues chewing. He tries to stare me down. Then he jumps up with a dramatic flourish, walks past me, and throws the candy bar in the garbage can. Later, he apologizes profusely and promises it won’t happen again, after I threaten him with a few weeks’ timeout from the group.

Bottom line: We don’t get to do whatever we want whenever we want to. We don’t get to express our every thought and act on our every whim. It causes problems. And apologizing after the fact doesn’t cut it.

But how do we learn to control our urges and impulses? Practice, man, practice. Counting to ten. Taking deep breaths. Redirecting action. Identifying triggers. Asking for help. Putting as much time and space as possible between the thought and the action. Then we’re at least empowered to make a better choice. 

So back it up, boys. Grow up. Think before you act.

And if that’s too much to ask, at least keep your candy bar in your pocket.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
"And if that’s too much to ask, at least keep your candy bar in your pocket." I love that punch line! How clever and true! This piece deserves an EP! Fantastic. You've said it all! Now, the hard part for some of us......putting it into practice. Some times my will power or self control gets the best of me. I can be extremely weak.
"And if that’s too much to ask, at least keep your candy bar in your pocket." I love that punch line! How clever and true! This piece deserves an EP! Fantastic. You've said it all! Now, the hard part for some of us......putting it into practice. Some times my will power or self control gets the best of me. I can be extremely weak.
So well said - and I started reading this thinking, "David freaking Vitter et al.," and "Stop talking about that jerk!" But you went to the very core of it.

My family is full of Macks. Mack is the ideal. My 87 year old mother is a Mack. I am so deathly tired of Mack.

... a culture that celebrates instant gratification and pleasure over mindfulness and maturity.

I once was in group therapy with a 30-something man who had a mega-crush on a woman he spent time with around their children's activities. Both were in otherwise good marriages. He was agonizingly working through what would happen if he pursued a relationship with this woman.

After weeks of his fruitless talk I said something like, "You don't have to act on every feeling you have." It seemed to take him - and everyone else in the group including, I think, the therapist, by surprise. Which took me by surprise. Is lack of impulse control generally expected?
Thanks, Patricia. I think it's something we all have to practice! I kicked Gummi Bears but it was hard. I finally realized that the negative consequences far outweighed the positive gains.

Nerd: You're right! I love your comment to that guy. Check out this article from 2009 on a study with little kids testing the ability to delay gratification. If the link doesn't work, Google Jonah Lehrer, the New Yorker, delayed gratification. http://www.newyorker.com/reporting/2009/05/18/090518fa_fact_lehrer?currentPage=all
I say it all the time: "You have a brain. Use it."
Sterling advice, Deb which I wish more people would take. And a great truth. We all have impulses. Mature people manage to control them, most of the time. (I've messed up on that one before, so I'm in no position to sit too hard in judgement on others who also slip up.) If one acts on poor impulse control though, the best damage control is to admit it up front the first time one is asked, and not deny it and insist that somebody else hacked into your pants.

The best and the worst I can say of Weiner is "Tawdry." I'm on the fence about whether he should suck it up and resign, or lay low, and behave better in the future. He needs to work things out with his wife, yes, definitely. Has he offended all of America to the point where we can't possibly suck it up and concentrate on more important things? I think not. The strongest emotions I can summon on this topic are distaste and irritation.

Far worse damage is being done to the country and the people who live here by a great many of his Congressional colleagues, these days than was done by his moment of Grande Stupidezza. I wish Michele Bachman would resign on the grounds of pop-eyed hysterical stupidity alone.

rated!
So wise, and so well-written. I hope Weiner gets a therapist as good as you seem to be. There is hope for him I do believe, if he follows what you say.
Melissa: Thanks for your comments...this really does stir up a lot of feelings. I agree w/ you re: Michele Bachmann. Eek.

Lea: You're very kind. I love working with people who are aware of the negative consequences that have accrued as a result of their behavior and are ready to make changes. Having genuine remorse and some degree of humility helps too. Not easy, but gratifying when it works. Behavior change is a challenge for all of us!
"But how do we learn to control our urges and impulses? Practice, man, practice . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . . Putting as much time and space as possible between the thought and the action."

I think this is the answer, but we miss it because our society is one that values (as you said) instant gratification more and more and makes it look as the desirable norm. Very good piece, I hope it gets more coverage.