Existential Angst.

AND OTHER FUN THINGS.

Deborah Young

Deborah Young
Location
Honolulu, Hawaii, U.S.A.
Birthday
July 30
Title
C.E.O.
Company
Existential Angst, L.L.C.
Bio
I'm a political analyst and cultural voyeur & usually write about when those two things merge. I'm an amateur mother, a professional reader and excel in generalized anxiety, although sadly there is very little reimbursement for that particular skill. And of course, I love books & dogs.

Deborah Young's Links

Haiku Nation
My Blog Entry Index
Articles of Interest
Great Posts to read!
MAY 18, 2009 1:02PM

Camille Paglia: A Rorschach Test

Rate: 7 Flag

She's a democrat lesbian feminist, called liberal by conservatives and called conservative by liberals. She doesn't believe in a gay "gene", she and her partner are raising their 7 year old son together. She leans toward libertarian-ism but like Tammy Bruce, she won't leave the democrat party behind, attempting to influence it instead of abandoning it. She's an atheist who respects religion. She is skeptical about global warming. She criticized Bill Clinton for not resigning after the Monica Lewinsky scandal, which she says led to America being "blindsided by 9/11". She voted for Barak Obama.

She's always been an academic achiever, whether at Nottingham High school or Binghamton University where she graduated as class valedictorian. She's an intellectual. She has said, "To me, comedy is a symptom of a balanced perspective on life, and people who are going around, like gloomy gusses, in that Sontag style of intellectual, these people are suffering from something coming from their childhood, it has nothing to do with the proper intellectual response to life..."

She did her graduate studies at Yale, noting she was the only open lesbian there from 1968-1972. She has had mammoth fights with feminists, lesbians, chauvinists, homophobes and academics her whole life. She outraged Susan Sontag & Gloria Steinem & Patricia Ireland & Molly Ivins. She criticized the American feminist movement, accusing it of, among other things, "harming young women by teaching them to see themselves as victims."

She wrote the highly acclaimed book "Sexual Personae: Art and Decadence from Nefertiti to Emily Dickinson" (1990). She published "Sex, Art and American Culture" in 1992. In 1994 she published "Vamps and Tramps" a collection of her writings since 1992. Her most recent book is,"Break, Blow, Burn: Camille Paglia reads forty-three of the World's Best Poems"

"Is gay identity so fragile that it cannot bear the thought that some people may not wish to be gay?" Vamps and Tramps.

In an interview with Reason Magazine in 1995 she was quoted as saying, "In the first chapter of Sexual Personae, I made a defense of capitalism. I feel that capitalism has a very bad press with the pseudo-leftists who clog our best college campuses and that in point of fact capitalism has produced modern individualism and feminism. Modern capitalism has allowed the birth of the independent woman who is no longer economically dependent on her husband. I despise the sneering that our liberal humanists do about capitalism even while they enjoy all of it's pleasures and conveniences. I just despise it." She adds that she does believe there should be some kind of safety net, "that we should not tolerate, in an affluent society, extreme levels of poverty or deprivation."

camillepaglia

When compared to Ayn Rand, she discusses how she see's some similarities and also differences between them. "She and I say to people, "Think for yourself! Don't be such a toadie! Stop going along with the group! Don't be such a sheep, just going along passively with other people!"

Her latest examination of the state of liberalism in the U.S.:..."It has been reduced to an elitist set of rhetorical formulas which posit the working class as passive, mindless victims in desperate need of salvation by the state. Individual rights and free expression, which used to be liberal values, are being gradually subsumed to worship of government power."'

Camille is a lapsed Catholic. She's a former girlscout. She was born and raised in New York. She's obsessed with Amelai Earhart. She writes for Salon.com. She a professor at the University of the Arts in Philadelphia, PA. Three gay men have had a lifelong influence on her thinking: Bruce Benderson who she went to highschool with; Stephen Jarratt and Stephen Feld. She is as comfortable with the working class man as the world of academia. "I'm also aware why very masculine men are not represented in academe. Very masculine men cannot sit still long enough. And so all the idealogy of feminism is coming out of these women who are married to wordsmith men, who are not that combative or confrontational to begin with, because the really masculine men, the high-testosterone men, are so restless they can hardly sit still in class.

"I'm very worried about this new kind of bourgeois imperialism which predicates the ultimate human type as someone who is good at sitting still at a desk." This statement in itself succinctly describes the anti-ritalin, anti- ADD movement.

Paglia defies a label. These things are true: she is smart. She is an individual, marching in lock-step with no one. She walks the walk. And this is also true: how we respond to Paglia says more about who we are than who she is. She is the ultimate rorschach test.

 

 

 

drupal counter

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I like certain things about her..for instance, she never worried about being uber-PC....and sometimes feminism does make victims (as does extreme liberalism), but she is sometimes a bit wacky. Sometimes very smart people lose sight of common sense.
Deborah,
I am delighted that you have put a spotlight on a woman who has long been a favorite of mine. I skimmed "sexual personae" a few years ago, and was blown away. The first chapter is a masterful rendering of a sort of....nietzscian feminism...she is from Italy, as she never tires of jabbering at us....that is the FUN of Camille, her jibber jabber....

From the last page: "dickison & whitman=Late Romantic confederates of the american Union....self-ruling hermaphrodites who will not and cannot mate..."

then the paragraph gets interesting!!! "voyeurism, vampirism, necrophilia, lesbianism, sadomasochism sexual surrealism:"

In Amherst no less! The soul of the union is pulled out for inspection by our lovely quirky italian sister...

I would have to agree with 99.9% of what she writes in "s. personae".....the stuff i dont like is on pg 45.....ha.....movies, tv, low culture so called

brought to the Olympian Pagan heights , with the maidens ready & eager to be sacrificed to the Moloch of self-identity-seeking....pagan paglia, with her swampy Feminine trap, her plea to young women to break FREE from the maddeningly cyclical enslavements of nature....to rise & meet the Male head on, not

through a veil of abstractions and petty semantic quarrels....she is brilliant in "sex & american culture" where she praises BOTH...refreshing as hell...but still a hotblooded fully eroticized gal....one of a kind? i hope not...

The Dr, Dr. Strangelove, gave me Paglia as a rorshark test, how'd you know? I told him, "Dr., this is a sweet lady, very high-spirited...." The dr. says, "yeah, but what about all the controversial shit she sez?"/....i said, "hm? where is that, pray tell?"

maybe page 45....she says "spiritual enlightenment produces feminization of the male." Then laot of stuff....ritual androgny, etc. The tv, in other words. Well, my dad said, "i never been to a ritual androgny , but i gotta say, i dont feel terribly girlish aymore, after the ostomy bag was put on me, and i lost my ass. They sewed it up..."

The ideal human? It is a sit at home dad on the computer with his wife and 3.75 kids, with a mortgage and a prediliction for watching adam sandler films for inspiration....that's bourgeois Nietzschian Last Man,

becoming more banal every day....say hi to camille...is she in the vatican for the opening of "angels & demons"?


Jim, being a literary criticism buff
Great post. Rated.

As much as I admire Paglia, she's no Ayn Rand, the latter being an oracle in her present and a prophet in her future.

Paglia is an immaculate writer; therefore, I have difficulty imagining she would have confused it's and its in the passage you quote:

"even while they enjoy all of it's pleasures and conveniences."

Thanks for your wonderful summary of a very important social commentator.
I was recently given a list of books by a young woman about to graduate from college as her "wish list" from which friends, family, etc. could choose. The usual suspects. I considered giving her some Paglia but regrettably couldn't find any in the biggest bookstore in Boston, which says something about her outcast/iconoclast status among feminist writers.
Con, she is definitely an outcast from the feminist movement, at least a part of it. Which is pure irony in that Paglia lives the feminist ideal but they reject her because she tells the truth and doesn't subscribe to political correctness or purposeful stupidity. I've seen this in other settings as well, older feminists literally heckle younger women living their dream such as air force pilots or lawyers but there is always something they are doing *wrong*. The feminist movement lost its credibility during the Clinton years when they sided with Bill over the women who came forward on his serial adultery/harrassment/lying.
A great post and very interesting post.

Paglia though ... yuck. I think she's intellectually dishonest, frankly.
I KNOW!

I love what she has to say about the very masculine men.

And I'm not smart enough to say anything more about her!
"I despise the sneering that our liberal humanists do about capitalism even while they enjoy all of it's pleasures and conveniences. I just despise it." Yep. As an development economics student at a very, VERY liberal university with a very affluent student population, I'm becoming more and more sick of people dissing capitalism. Sure, it's got it's problems. Yes, we could probably use a little more regulation in some areas of the market, and ideally people would be paid the actual marginal value of their labor (translation: farmers and garment manufacturers may make a bit more, and execs may make a bit less). But what exactly do these people have in mind? Planned markets? Been there, done that, major clusterfuck, ESPECIALLY for the poor. Feudalism? Oppressive. Sucks. Oligarchy? Ditto.

I want to steal from Winston Churchill: "Capitalism is the worst system we have, except for all the others." I disagree with Paglia about a lot, but capitalism sure ain't one of them. Interesting post.
errr....a lot OF THINGS. Is how that last sentence is supposed to read. It's been a long day...
Jessabelle, I absolutely agree with Paglia and with you on Capitalism. Every other form of government conveniently thrives on the back (literally) of women. Show me something better!