Deborah Young

Deborah Young
Location
Small Coal-Mining Mountain Town, Colorado, U.S.A.
Birthday
July 30
Title
Sole Proprietor
Company
Western Colorado
Bio
Varied & Sundry

MY RECENT POSTS

Deborah Young's Links

My Blog Entry Index
Great Posts to read!
JANUARY 7, 2010 11:14AM

Flight 253: We Are All Just Collateral Damage

Rate: 24 Flag

Collateral damage is damage that is unintended or incidental to the intended outcome. The term originated in the United States Military, but it has since expanded into broader use.

To the terrorists, I am not collateral damage:  I am the target. But to my Government and foreign Governments, this is what I've been reduced to.

I am racially profiled by terrorists every day: American. Christian. Western Woman. Infidel. If there is a way to blow up my airplane or my mall or my towers, it will be attempted. Sometimes it will succeed.

"The system worked," Napolitano had the nerve to say. Well yes, it worked for the terrorists.

Flight 253 recently taught us multitudinous lessons, not the least of which is that very little has changed since September 11, 2001.  Security is terrible. Nobody is sharing information with anybody in any meaningful way. It takes an Amsterdam film maker who is a passenger to jump the terrorist trying to blow up the airplane, just like it took the brave Americans who brought down United Airlines Flight 93. That flight was headed for the White House or the U.S. Capitol; the passengers chose to die fighting rather than let the terrorists win that day.

You are collateral damage.

By all accounts, and after everything we know, the Nigerian Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab never should have been allowed on that airplane.

  • He had no passport.
  • His own father had warned authorities he was a terrorist and a security risk.
  • He had no money.
  • He had no reason to be flying to Detroit, Michigan.
  • He had received training and instructions from al-Qaida in Yemen.

The hijacking of Flight 93 on September 11th was led by Ziad Jarrah, a member of Al-Qaeda. The only difference between he and Abdulmutallab is that he had a passport and he succeeded in his terrorist act.

Abdulmutallabs' attempt to blow up the airplane [which would have become another 911 under President Obama], which could have killed thousands had it succeeded and blown up as it descended upon Detroit, serves another purpose. It's called a Practice Run. Trial Run. Test Run. Dry Run. Terrorists use the information gleaned from Practice Runs to sharpen their tactics, fix some mistakes, plug any gaps.

Actor James Woods was on a flight from Boston to Los Angeles a month before the 911 hijackings during a dry run. It scared the living crap out of him. He did all the right things. He reported it to authorities and a flight attendant but they seemed unwilling to become involved. A month later, these same men helped kill 2,819 Americans when they slammed into the World Trade Center.

News reports indicate that at least some of the 19 hijackers made "dry runs" several weeks in advance, taking trips on cross-country flights headed for S.F., L.A. and San Diego from east coast departure points such as Boston's Logan Airport.

The Imams out of Michigan in 2006 performed a practice run and managed to scare everybody before the plane ever left the ground. Even before the airplane took off, both passengers and crew members became alarmed at their suspicious behavior so much so that the airport police and Federal Air Marshall asked the men to leave the plane. The suspicious behavior included:

  • The Imams refusing to sit in their assigned seats.
  • Requesting seatbelt extensions, even though according to flight crew they didn't need them and indeed placed them on the cabin floor instead of lengthening their seatbelts with them.
  • 3 traveled without any checked baggage and on one-way tickets.
  • Spoke only in Arabic to each other but were listened to by a passenger who also spoke Arabic who called what they were talking about suspicious.

They filed a lawsuit for being discriminated against and eventually won.

A Northwest flight in 2004 involved 14 Syrian men who were also eventually released even though passengers, Air Marshalls and crew members again became extremely alarmed. Their actions were so obvious that several passengers became distraught, with grown women crying. Pilots for both Northwest Airlines and American say there is "widespread knowledge" among crew members that these probes are taking place. One event documented on the Northwest flight was the rushing of the cockpit and stopping suddenly to try and flush out the Air Marshalls. The Syrians were taken into custody and released after their information and fingerprints were added to a database.

Each time a terrorist makes it onto an airplane, it gives more information to the terrorists on how to sneak somebody on, in plain sight; how to blow it up, how to take down "hero's" before they can stop you.

Every time a terrorist makes it onto an airplane, another one of my conveniences is taken away. Box cutters and plastic knives are now weapons. Taking off shoes at the airport is mandatory. Bottles of water are dumped before I can drink them while going through security. Now they are talking about not allowing passengers to get up during the final hour of an international flight. Make the good citizens cower and grovel, lift shirts and open briefcases and keep allowing the bad guys on board. Don't profile them but keep checking my trunk at the airport. Now will they ask us all to take off our underwear before boarding the plane?

This was a sophisticated enough terrorist attempt that Abdulmutallab got exactly the seat he wanted, which would allow the most damage if he had succeeded in his attempt to blow up Flight 253. He boarded without a passport! When was the last time somebody waived you through when you said you didn't have a passport on an International flight?

I thought so.

Lawyer, passenger on Flight 253 and witness, Kurt Haskell, has this story to tell. He and his wife live in Taylor, Michigan.

While waiting in the holding area in the Amsterdam airport, in a room designated for only the passengers of Flight 253, Haskell saw a well dressed man of apparent Indian descent accompany a young, poorly attired man of African descent to the boarding gate. He said the Indian man appeared to have no accent.

The well dressed man told the ticket agent that the young man had to get on the flight even though he had no passport. She told him he must have a passport in order to board. The man insisted that this happens all of the time, these guys get on flights without passportss all the time, so she sent him off to talk to management. That was the last time Mr. Haskell saw the Indian man and it was the last time he saw the African man, until later in the day when he tried to blow up the plane.

Did the well dressed man bribe Airport management to allow the terrorist onto the airplane? The FBI has twice interviewed Kurt Haskell and his wife. Kurt was one of the passengers who jumped up and ran to row 19 when he saw flames shoot up as their plane descended into Detroit. They have the ticket agent as a witness, they have the film of the man and the terrorist at the desk, but have yet to release it, to help identify the accomplice. Yet as of Tuesday January 5th Dutch investigators are claiming they have found no evidence of accomplices.

Under the category of looks-like-about-12-days-too-late, the State Department has announced it is revoking the U.S. visa for suspected Nigerian underwear bomber Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab. Why did he have one in the first place? It is a privilege to visit the United States, not a right. He was on a terrorist watch list. Are American lives now so under-valued that we must give the benefit of the doubt to any and all who might wish us harm?

Political Islam is not a religion, it's an act of war. I guess security will only get seriously tightened when Paul Pelosi or Malia Obama or Trent Franks are on one of those airplanes that go down. But since our Washington elite do not fly commercial, that may never happen.

We are all collateral damage.

 

 

wordpress stat

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Excellent post, Deborah. Brava.
Very good post. I hadn't heard about this possible bribery/Indian man twist to the story. More to follow I'm sure.
Deborah, add to the list that the British government rejected Abdulmutallab's visa application. That put him on the watch list for the United Kingdom. Apparently, that information is not shared in a meaningful manner.
I've wondered about why Haskell's testimony hasn't had more press. Either he's a nut, or Homeland Security is keeping this information secret in order to investigate. There's also the allegation that someone was videoing Abdulmutallab the whole flight. (But if they videographer thought the plane was going to be blown up, why bother with a video that would be destroyed? If the videographer exists, it points more to another terrorist dry-run or a CIA/FBI "test".) I'd like to hear more about the James Woods story-- can you provide a link?
I still don't know how to do links but you can google the James Woods story. I remember him being interviewed about this after 911. He became active politically after that because of what he saw as gross negligence on the part of U.S. security.

Mr. Haskell is not a nut, he's a respected attorney. I think that his story makes everybody look so bad that that is one reason he is not getting the press he should be. If any poor terrorist without a passport can get on any plane going to the U.S. we're doomed. And Bonnies right, nobody was fired for 911 and nobody is getting fired now. There are no consequences and that's why we've become collateral damage.
There is much here with which I can agree. However, we have ALWAYS been collateral damage to whatever is going on with US policy. That's news to a lot of Americans, perhaps because we've lived for quite awhile in a relatively decent bubble of illusions about what's really going on.

If we compare the "ideals" that our country claims as its moral high ground with our actual foreign policy, our actual actions, is it any wonder that there are those who wish us harm? God knows - and I do mean GOD knows - that our policies have produced some serious collateral damage . . . at home and abroad.

Yep. We're collateral damage. Is that really such a suprise?
Well-done, Deborah. Excellent research that provided some very scary facts.
Rated for excellence.
so you think Haskell is right?
Interesting. Now, there was an example from the Slovack Republic this week, of trying to test security by Slovak police, in which htey messed up and actually put the stuff on the plane, which was really bad, although RDX will not go off.
Now, that was legitimate, right until when they used real explosives to see what was up.
Doing something like that to scare people would be different.
Now, in a gray area, if you are trying to prevent one attack that is really big, then playing games with another operation might seem to make sense, they wouldn't be trying to scare people here, but al Qaida, although that seems really unlikely that our security people would let it go that far. I don't see how that could be smart, even if it was too clever by half. but thanks for the info.
Great post. Rated.

"the State Department has announced it is revoking the U.S. visa for suspected Nigerian underwear bomber Umar Farouk Abdulmutallab."

Wow! How's that for retaliation? Next thing you know, when the Capitol is attacked, Obama will suspend alternate-side-of-the-street parking regulations.
To quote Owl: "God knows - and I do mean GOD knows - that our policies have produced some serious collateral damage . . . at home and abroad."

Jesus said don't try to get the splinter out of someone else's eye when you've got a plank in yours.

As Americans, we need to fix our policies that destory lives, families, children, and communities around the world.

We can't control terrorists from Yemen. But maybe we can try to stop terrorism by the US.
Holy Shit! I had no idea about all the info included in the dry runs! Winning lawsuits etc. Do Americans look like a bunch of pansies or what? Grrrrr
So true, Deborah. But would I ever have thought of it this way? No, it took you to put it together. Collateral Damage is us. Rated. Best Wendy
I have mixed feelings about this post i will go sort them out and come back to comment.
Very interesting sources. I haven't kept up with this story at all. I do have to disagree on one point: Flight 93 shows that the system can work. The terrorists on that plain were missing a man that a customs agent had turned back. The man who turned him back has received relatively little notice, but The Daily Beast did a piece on him a couple months ago. I can't find it at the moment.
Airport "security" is like the tricks magicians use to distract us from what's really going on.

Will we have the guts to switch to teleconferences, trains, and busses and then to fly so seldom the airlines and govt. will have to stop manipulating us to control us with airport "security" that is a grim joke? The problem is not passengers. It's govt. security analysts failing abysmally. We're supposed to be too scared to notice.
Excellent piece, Deborah. I hope you submit this to as many places as possible, including your local press. Your writing just keeps getting sharper, cleaner and more focused.

And I'm in agreement. Worrying about water bottles not passports. Or obviously shifty behavior like traveling internationally without a jacket or any bags. WTF?

I dread flying now. It just seems like a political morass and mess and why bother?
Here's synchronicity. I just got an email from a friend of a friend describing a dry run on his flight November 17, 2009, Flight 297 scheduled to fly from Atlanta to Houston.

He said: "If this wasnt a dry run, I dont know what one is. The terrorists wanted to see how TSA would handle it, how the crew would handle it, and how the passengers would handle it."

The flight was eventually cancelled but it was not reported why [the newspapers just said the flight was cancelled because a passenger wouldn't get off his cellphone] so he is trying to get the information out there. 11 Islamic men boarded the airplane, refused to stop using their cellphones, called the stewardess an Infidel and were watching porn on their laptops. A lot ensued but how it ended was the pilot and crew refused to fly with these men on board and left. A new crew arrived and that's when this man got off the plane. So the dry runs continue to happen frequently here.
What Beth Mann said. What Bonnie Russell said. So much information I didn't know. You are a serious journalist and editorial writer.. somebody should snatch you up.
Yes, it makes little sense that the first people to receive further security after an attempted attack are average Americans.
we are going to have to change our whole lifestyle
if will be impossible to stop all terrorism no matter what steps we take
Honestly what do you expect people to do? Get tattoos if you prescribe to a certain religion in a certain part of the world? How do you know whether someone is Muslim, Hindu, or Buddhist, unless you ASK them? And, considering that FRANCE was considered a "suspicious country" (remember "Freedom Fries") only a few years ago, where does all of this fear mongering lead you? What comfort do you get from being afraid, essentially, of "brown people", when that is the ONLY unique characteristic that all these people so far have held in common.

Oh, wait, except there was Timothy McVeigh. He was white and Christian, there was Ted Bundy, CHarles Manson, all white, presumably CHristian. So the racial profiling idea doesn't exactly hold up under scrutiny.

So what ARE we supposed to do, when a Right Wing Teabagger is just as likely to put down his picket sign and pick up a gun while ON American soil as any of these Muslim (or any other Non-Christian) terrorists are to make it TO American soil
@conspiracy
Do we know why Detroit was targeted?
Bonnie-

My point is that whether it's Timothy Mcveigh, Charles Manson, Ted Bundy, or Kalid Shiek Mohammed, Osama Bin Laden and Saddam Hussien, violence is violence, terrorism is terrorism, and we should not be profiling people who we suspect of being terrorists simply based on the color of their skin, because history has proven that color of skin and religion has no bearing on a person's ability to commit acts of terror, and, yes, mass murder is mass murder, whether it be by knife, gun, or bomb or plane
Just posted your piece on Twitter. Hope you Dug it and Reddited it, etc.
Thank Beth!

Placebosstudman: moral relativism will get you nowhere. None of the 3 killers you mentioned were Christian so we'll start there. And to be in denial that we are targeted and your loved ones and mine or ourselves might be on the next airplane flown into a building is just that: denial. Nobody deserves to be targeted for death like we are being. Israel doesn't have this problem. There is no need to invent the "security" wheel. Just do what they do.
This out of NY Daily News today: "The administration's review leaves no doubt individuals were to blame here: "A series of human errors occurred - delayed dissemination of a finished intelligence report and what appears to be incomplete/faulty database searches on Mr. Abdulmutallab's name and identifying information."

By whom? Who was supposed to train them? Why are they still on the job?

Also still on the job is Homeland Security Secretary Janet Napolitano, who made a fool of herself in the immediate aftermath of the attempted attack. She hasn't been fired or reprimanded."

Read more: http://www.nydailynews.com/opinions/2010/01/08/2010-01-08_ok_bam_you_know_what_went_wrong__now_is_the_time_to_ax_who_went_wrong.html#ixzz0c2ZpfzTJ
I'm inclined to be with you on this one Deb and your writing on this post is particularly sharp. Most stunning to me is the failure of Amsterdam security. When I traveled through that airport in 1999, I was quite impressed with the precautions. Not so now.