Deborah Young

Deborah Young
Location
Small Coal-Mining Mountain Town, Colorado, U.S.A.
Birthday
July 30
Title
Sole Proprietor
Company
Western Colorado
Bio
Varied & Sundry

MY RECENT POSTS

Deborah Young's Links

My Blog Entry Index
Great Posts to read!
JANUARY 25, 2011 8:48AM

When mothers reject their daughters

Rate: 30 Flag

Mothers rejecting their daughters might be offensive and insensitive and hurtful but it's not all that uncommon. I don't know the actual statistics on it but anecdotally I've heard enough of these stories to last a lifetime. 

A lot of mothers reject their daughters at puberty. If they are not strong enough within themselves with good self-esteem and if they are not anchored in something other than their own looks and sexuality, they will feel threatened by their daughters burgeoning sexuality. As their own "looks" are starting to fade, they can become frantic and angry at their daughter's fresh lives. Fables and archetypes abound in this theme: Cinderella for one.

My own mothers rejection of me was complicated by many things. Her own shaky mental health that included depression and a late diagnosis of bipolar disorder. And by the fact she was the second oldest child of ten and never got over her bitterness at not being an only child. That her whole identity was based on her own good looks and the perks and attention they provided her.  And by the fact that she got pregnant with me first, and then had to get married. [This always alternately amused and frustrated me to no end. She was raised a strict Catholic, with a creed that taught her to save sex for marriage. The fact that she was so angry at everyone else because she got pregnant for having sex outside of marriage was typical of her. Nothing was ever her fault. Really Mom? If you had just followed your own religious teachings we wouldn't have had to listen to that particular complaint for 18 years!]

Oh Mom. She tried. She really did, at least when we were young. She was at her best when we kids were younger and she was busy raising 3 daughters while her husband worked and was the sole provider.  She had some really good years there of friendship, travel, getting along with relatives. But as I hit puberty at 14 and she turned 36 she became unglued.

mothers-day 

She walked away from all  religion. She embraced a fanatical brand of feminism where she really did hate men [the repercussions here included her divorce, manic diatribes telling us she wished she never had us and the suspect choice by my youngest sister to become a lesbian.  Suspect because she has slept with more men than I have but unfortunately absorbed the brunt of my mothers MEN ARE HORRIBLE rants for years. But that's between her and her shrink.]

My mothers craziness rubbed onto me of course. How could it not? We only have two parents. I started having anxiety and panic attacks out of the blue, felt unguided, missed having a Mom. I was a ship without a rudder for many years, riding wild waves, stuck in calm harbors, unable to pick up the anchor and go or unable to throw the anchor overboard to commit. I went to therapy, took xanax, travelled the country, worked, went to school, meditated, always feeling that the gentle rocking that was my life could cause me to capsize at any moment.

Teacher and author Caroline Myss writes that there will always be people in our lives whose sole job is to not be who we want them to be. That is part of the human experience. I've come to accept that. 

In the years since, my mother has come in and out of my life. She is unable to stay long, she visits and then finds something to get angry about: my son oversleeping, my choice of a husband, my choice of geography and off she goes and I don't hear from her for years. Then she'll pop up again and I always let her back in albeit less and less enthusiastically as they years go by. She can't seem to get along with most people and has created a narrow world of those who can tolerate her behavior and enjoy her for short bursts.

The last I heard from her was 2 years ago, going on 3. She came to visit, got angry over something inconsequential and I never heard from her again. But although it is hurtful, it is strangely liberating. Because without a mother to guide and caution and scold, my path has also been liberated from her angry need to control. I did take the path less travelled by. And you know what? It has made all the difference. 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
You are doing the right thing with your mom. Probably you are happier when she is out of your life but you are a good daughter to let her back in even though you know. . .
Shew. Some distinct similarities that I'm loathe to admit. Your candor is liberating, in and of itself. Solid, resonant piece.

The best part was feeling the sense that you're talking from the other side of it all - you found your own harbor.

"I was a ship without a rudder for many years, riding wild waves, stuck in calm harbors, unable to pick up the anchor and go or unable to throw the anchor overboard to commit."
This post is so sad and incomprehensible. I just can't imagine a mother not loving or caring about her children. Hopefully, most moms aren't this way. Your mom seems to be an extreme. I'm curious about something....if you are a Mom yourself....how has this affected you with your children?
That's a hard thing to go through, Deb, but I can see how it might be freeing too -- at some point, for someone with a strong sense of self, and maybe having to find your own way made you that strong, independent person. But I still wish you'd had the mom you deserved.
Thank you so much for posting this. My mother and I started having a rocky relationship when I was about 12... old enough to start to have opinions.

I am 45, my mom is in her seventies. I really miss her at Christmas as she always made Christmas wonderful. She has some sort of personality disorder and she lost it around 50. That's when she really got down about her looks. What you say makes much sense and I don't feel so alone in this.
Boy, some of us can identify with this candid post. Sorry for the past but you seem to have figured out the present and adapted as best possible to a bad break.
Going through some unexpectedly weird stuff with my mother right now. I hope I won't be identifying too strongly with this post, but I just don't know.

Sad, but hopeful. Well-written. Rated.
While I didn't go through this with my mom, my sister did and it turned her life into a nightmare that she is still going through. I'm sad for her, and sad for you and everyone who doesn't have that reassurance that their mother loves you and wants the best for you. It's an emotional disability that has to be overcome. It sounds like you are on the other side of that struggle. Good for you.
Deborah, this hits home for me, too. One of the primary tasks of my adulthood has been mourning the fact that I never had a "real" mother. Blessings to you on your path.
Rated with understanding.
Our stories are quite similar, except for the feminism part.
It's hard to have an unstable mother when motherhood is so idealized, isn't it?
Now I have a 12 yr. old daughter with mental health issues, and on it goes...
Love how you brought in the caroline myss snippet.
This should be on the cover.
Love your refreshing honesty on a subject so many of us are loathe to speak about. I think the hardest thing about having a mother who doesn't fit the "good mother" mold is admitting it - first to oneself and then to outsiders. We all want that great mother/daughter bond, but sometimes - for so many different reasons - it's just not meant to be.
Thanks for this, Deborah. Brave of you.
Rated.
I know what you mean. My mother died last year leaving much unresolved and me on the outskirts of it all. I have written of some of it early on in my tenure here as it was right after I started here that I found out she was dying. It was difficult with all the animosity between us. I have had enough therapy to look back on it too. With all six of us, once we couldn't sit still in her lap, we weren't hugged or cuddled. That was something I made a point of doing with my own children. Thank you so much for tackling this.
Well. I bet you know I can relate to this. The circumstances are different, but the ending is the same: motherless daughters.
Terribly painful at first, astonishingly freeing at last. ~r
Wow--such astonishing honesty. I'm so blessed to be close to my own mother, but I still understand a lot of what you say, as something happened at puberty between me and my father. He was always controlling, but when I began to blossom, his rages became constant and cruel, and I deal with it to this day.

It sounds like you're making peace with it all with your understanding and compassion. This is a beautiful piece. Rated.
An excellent post, Deborah. While my own relationship with my mom as an adult isn't fraught with so much drama, I understand feeling rudderless and lost. It sounds like you've come out as a strong person.
Your mother is my daughter. We've both come to the conclusion that it's healthier for all of us to not dwell on the past. We'll always love one another but we won't compromise our own separate and distinct individual core values; this potentially allows each of us an opportunity to accept and forgive ourselves and others.

Some people never change and that's when it's wise to just walk away from what could result in an overwhelming onslaught of unhealthy animosities becoming more than emotional attacks.
My wife was rejected by her mother at an early age for the bottle, and the father was incestuous. She never for a moment took responsibity for her life, and the father never took responsibility for his acts.

Now that my wife is dead I see as never before the impact this has throughout the course of ones life and on those with whom one bonds, or attempts to bond consequently. My wife did not follow in her mother's footsteps at least in the sense that she never capitulated to alcohol, and spent most of her life in treatment of some sort or other until the very end. She did take responsibility.

That was the most impressive thing about her.

This is a good post, honest, revealing, and I like how the "feminism" is implicit.
My mother was nuts, too--that's a clinical term, right? My father always said she was just fine till she read that damned "Feminine Mystique," by Betty Friedan.
I just noticed your tags and had to laugh : "joan h, narcissist personality disorder."
Were we separated at birth?

Zumapick!
wow, this is very enlightening. Your mother sounds a lot like my mother, but I never thought of it as her rejecting me, just hating everything about me, which is the same thing! And she treats everyone like that, always finding a reason to get angry and go. I talk to my mother every now and then but haven't seen her in a few years. We don't miss each other, and I think I'm better off for it. Same circumstances you describe too, almost, Catholic, many children that she wished she hadn't had. Sad.
being a mother would mean being a sister and bestfriend to her daughter. so i don't really see the point of rejection here.

if you disagree with me, visit me at http://ithinkrevolution.com.
This could be me, I hear where you're coming from. It's difficult for others with strong, "normal" relationships to understand not having that close mother/daughter bond. Rejection for me was at a very early age. My mother also fell pregnant out of wedlock and interesting this somehow became my fault..... I remember her constantly telling me that somehow I was the reason her life was a mess. If only she had never had me. Like your mother, having sex and falling pregnant was someone else's "fault"!!
All of this aside, for me not having contact with my mother since I was 21 (I am now 40) has been overall positive. The first few years I grieved for her (well a mother figure, not really her) but now I am reconciled with the fact that she could never be a mother to any of her children and that the pain of the loss of my relationship is less than that of the daily pain she would cause if she was in my life!