Sir Sidney Fudd

Sir Sidney Fudd
Location
California,
Bio
If you push something hard enough, it will fall over.

MY RECENT POSTS

Sir Sidney Fudd's Links

Salon.com
MAY 12, 2010 12:33AM

Is love worth financial suicide?

Rate: 2 Flag

Fellow OpenSaloners,

 I need some advice: 

I have been in a relationship with a woman for almost two years now.  We've been living together for about a year.  We are from different parts of the country.  She lived on the East Coast, and I on the West.  She moved in with me a year ago, leaving her house in "mothballs".  She has her own business which has been in bad shape on account of the economy.  In fact, she has had no work for 2 years.  I've been supporting her for the past year, in hopes that her business would pick up, but it hasn't.

 I have a steady job, a job I've had for over 20 years.  I'm in no danger of losing it.  But I don't make enough money to cover both of our expenses.  A year ago, I had $50,000 in savings.  It's all gone now.  Not all on her, I admit.  I've spend some of it on myself, or on activities for us.  But I'm paying her mortgage, the maintenance on her  house, her credit card bills, her utilities.  She had $90,000 in credit card debt, now she had $70,000.  I paid off the difference.  Our combined expenses exceed my income by $4000 a month.  That's 'bare-bones' expenses, before entertainment, vacations, or anything else. That's just housing, food, credit card payments, taxes, child support, house maintenance, utilities - that sort of thing.

 The fact is: if I didn't have her, I could live the life-style to which i'm accustomed on the salary that I make.  The fact is also that if I abandoned her at this point, she is, as she puts it, under the bridge.  She would lose her house, her belongings, everyting.  But the fact is also that I just had to take a $25000 loan from my retirement to cover my own credit card debt.  Now, I'm running that debt up again keeping up with both of our expenses.  I could realistically cover both of us for another year by raiding my retirement.  But I'm 53 years old.  My retirement is all I have saved.  If I deplete that, I've got nothing.  She's had a year to find work or to make her business work.  Maybe things will pick up and she'll have business again, but maybe not.  The fact is, in a year, I could have nothing, and we could still be in this same predicament.

Now she has decided that she does not want to live with me in California anymore.  She wants to move back to the East Coast, to her house, and have me commute from the east coast to my job in California.  I would get a cheap place to live here, and would come to stay with her on weekends.  This idea was all predicated on her getting a job with an airline, so I could fly for free.  But that didn't happen, though she did apply.  As I write this down, it becomes abundandly clear to me that this is crazy.  We can't afford one place to live, let alone two.  We can't afford the airfares on top of all our other expenses.  If I pay for my own place to live here in order to keep my job, and continue to pay for her to keep her house in the East, I myself am going to go bankrupt in a year.  In addition my retirement will be gone.

I love her, and she loves me.  It seems shameful to me that a love should be lost because of money. She has been really good for me emotionally and as a companion.  But it is beginning to seem like that situation we've all heard about where someone tries to save a drowning person and they both end up drowning.  I don't want her to drown, but I don't want to drown either.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
oh, i'd say it's fairly obvious you should find a new companion. tho at a minimum, cut off all financial assistance. her debt isnt your problem and if she sinks, she sinks. if she truly loves you, she'll understand that you don't have the financial means to support her mortgage and debt. sounds to me like she's taking advantage of you. and really, how much of a companion is she living on the other side of the map?
Perhaps a question you might want to ask yourself is it love that's driving you into debt for this woman or the guilt you might feel if you allowed her to go "under the bridge?"

We all know that love & relationships, at times, require great sacrifice, but in your case, it's more like you have thrown yourself in front of the bus (with an added push from her) to save her.

Despite the fact you have financially provided above & beyond , something sounds rather odd about her wanting to live back on the East coast. Surely somewhere in California, there's a job that would fit her skill set or perhaps a change in careers is in order for her.

In my humble opinion, love may not "conquer all" in your relationship. Here's hoping you find your way through this difficult time...
If she loves you then she would not expect you to committ financial suicide. That being said, even those that do love us can be selfish at times and forget to consider the ones that should be most important to them. My advice for what it is worth, and I am the first to admit that I am no guru on love and what is right and what is wrong, but I think you should pull the rug on the money. She needs to figure out her money matters on her own. If she does love you this is not going to be a deal breaker. But, for me it would be a deal breaker if someone I was with ask me to endanger my own future because they had a low time in their own. Theoretically, this girl could take you to the cleaners and then be alright. Then you would be the one in financial trouble and she would be in the clear. Be careful, and take care. There are many good people out there, and there are many selfish people out there. Maturity comes with age sometimes and others it does not. It sounds like you have it together, the question is, does she?