DECEMBER 3, 2009 6:48PM

A Suicide, a Drowning, and a Murder - Part 1

Rate: 21 Flag
rose hills2 
 
Part One - Tom
I was a pretty normal kid in junior high school. I had a couple girlfriends and played sports and did okay in my classes. My best friend Tom, on the other hand, was anything but normal. He was spectacular. He was tall, winningly handsome, lithely athletic of frame, and infectiously funny.

I don’t know how we became best friends. We just did. And the friendship deepened in the last a few months before he ended his young angelic life.

Tom and I loved the roughhouse matches we played with our Coach, Mr. Jackson. Coach Jackson was a grown up version of Tom. He was athletic, charming, and could run like the wind. The trick to the “matches” was to smack Coach on the ass with his clipboard - when he wasn’t paying attention - and then try to outrun him before he could tackle you and grind you into the playing field; leaving the clothes your mom had worked so hard to wash and iron for school in a wrinkled mess of grass stains and dirt.

Tom and I always lost the roughhouse matches, but that never stopped us from trying. And I think losing was the point. It made us feel special and the girls loved cheering and watching us get pummeled by Coach.

About two weeks before Tom took his life he began telling those of us who were his friends what he was planning to do. Because Tom was so gregarious and outgoing none of us took him seriously. He was just messing around. He had to be. Everybody joked about doing it. After all, nobody we knew had ever committed suicide. Kids who committed suicide were older and on drugs or crazy or came from bad homes. Tom’s life was characterized by none of those things. He lived a charmed life, had genuinely caring parents, and was blessed as a boy could be.

On the day before he died Tom and I were walking in a ravine near his house. He told me I was his best friend, the only friend who really understood him, and that he wanted me to have his faux raccoon coat. Tom was the first to wear wild fashions at our school. He loved his weird raccoon coat and his black and white saddle shoes. I continued wearing my “squad cars” for years after he died. I never took the coat.

As a kid of 12 I had very little understanding of the permanence of what Tom said he was going to do. None of his friends did. We all assumed he’d be at school the next day and we’d all be goofing and messing around like we always did. Even when he said “goodbye” to me I could not put it together - despite the strangeness of how it felt.

On Wednesday morning, February 16, 1966 I woke feeling horribly uneasy. I told my parents what Tom said he was going to do and we immediately called his house.

His lovely older sister answered the phone that terrible morning. I will never forget our brief conversation as long as I live. “Hi, this is Dennis. Is Tom there?” I asked, remembering the manners I had drilled into me as a kid. 

His sister softly and quietly replied, “No. He died last night.”

  ∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞∞

Tom’s service was held at the Episcopal Church. His coffin was closed. The Cleric did his best to comfort us young boys about the death of our friend, but honestly he wasn’t too good at that part of his job.

All I can remember of those terrible, nightmarish days was hearing the Mama’s and Papa’s singing, “California Dreaming” on the radio. I can recall standing on a steep grassy knoll at Rose Hills Memorial Park as Tom’s casket was lowered into the ground. The wind was blowing, the sun shining, and I was feeling the strangeness of a world that my best friend was no longer in - though I kept expecting to see him at any moment, walking toward me and shouting at me in his familiar excited voice.

I wrestled for years feeling I was to blame for Tom’s death. I still feel I was. I was his best friend. I failed him. When it mattered most. If I had only taken him seriously and called the night before, the day before, the week before, Tom might still be alive.

Years later, I wanted to ask his parents to forgive me. But my parents counseled me to leave those dear grieving folks alone and not stir the awful memory afresh in their hearts and minds. I fought that advice hard until I realized I would only be trying to make myself feel better. My need to feel exorcized was robbing me of any sort of sensitivity as to what it would be like to remember finding your 13 year old son had taken his own life.

Not long ago I made my peace with my old best friend. I stood at his grave, on a windy sunny day - much like the day he was buried. With my teenage daughter at my side, holding my hand, I told Tom how very, very, sorry I was for having failed him. He’d heard it before. Thousands of times in fact. But this time another teenager heard it too. And I am certain she will never fail her friends.

She will make the call that I did not. She will understand that suicide - no matter how jokingly referred to - is a deadly serious thing.

That doesn’t bring Tom back. Nothing can do that. But I know he’d smile and shove me and tell me it was okay now. And that he is okay too.

Tom and Me

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
This one takes my breath away, really. Especially when I view the photos of those two little boys...I don't think words really can express how I feel. So many people touched for a lifetime. Such a tenderness and loss and so much love. This is beautifully written, and bravely I think with the emotion that must flood you on the re-telling. Thank you. I am glad you have made peace with this. And I am sure you are right...it is what your friend would want. Cheykutuo
Dennis this is a fiercely heartfelt tribute to a dear friend. It echoes a similar event in my life. At 17 one of my closest friends was killed in a car accident. He was the driver and the only 1 of 4 in the car to die.
Our whole community was rocked by the event and even today, some 20 years later I still talk to him and share with him experiences that I know he would have enjoyed.
In doing so I feel like he's still around.
I used to spend time with his parents after his passing, in the hope that I could help ease the loss of their son by telling them stories of our antics. There were a lot of tears and laughter and I know they appreciated it.
Thank you deeply for painfully happy reminders.

Rated with thanks.
Oh, Dennis... you are a careful and kind soul... and I keep typing and erasing responses. Your twelve-year-old self didn't have the measuring tools for what he was given to fathom. Shalom.
Oh, my goodness. What are we supposed to do with this, Dennis? Survivor guilt is an awful, awful bitch.

If I may:

Could Have
by Wislawa Szymborska

It could have happened.
It had to happen.
It happened earlier. Later.
Nearer. Farther off.
It happened, but not to you.
You were saved because you were the first.
You were saved because you were the last.
Alone. With others.
On the right. The left.
Because it was raining. Because of the shade.
Because the day was sunny.

You were in luck -- there was a forest.
You were in luck -- there were no trees.
You were in luck -- a rake, a hook, a beam, a brake,
A jamb, a turn, a quarter-inch, an instant . . .

So you're here? Still dizzy from
another dodge, close shave, reprieve?
One hole in the net and you slipped through?
I couldn't be more shocked or
speechless.
Listen,
how your heart pounds inside me.

Thank you, Dennis. I don't have the words. Szymborska bailed my ass out again.
Beautiful tribute to a troubled soul. It is hard when young people die and even harder when we are close them. There are no words for the sorrow we experience. I think it is a lie that time heals all wounds. They wounds are always there, we just learn to deal with them.
Lorraine,
Being forced to listen to me for 5 minutes let alone a year can be a challenge. Thank you for such a kind and thoughtful comment.

chey,
You know how much I admire you and the way you have faced even greater challenges. Thank you for your encouraging words. I really do appreciate them.

JL,
Tom was one of two best friends I had who left this Earth early. I sincerly thank you for your comments and for sharing a bit of your own moving story of friendship and loss. Thank you very much.

CK,
I look at the class pictures of Tom and myself and realize just how young we were. Your words are deeply appreciated and so true. I wish the kid had known then what the man knows now. Thank you kind lady. Shalom.

Frank,
You have walked some paths yourself. I am sure that’s why you were able to find Szymborska’s piece so consonant to your intent. You’re a good man and I appreciate your kindness.

MAWB,
Thank you very much for your thoughtful comments. I agree. I’m not sure it’s a matter of the wounds healing as much as a case of the scars reminding us of the value of what we passed through.
Beautifully written. I could feel this. I was telling my family about it and found myself unable to speak .
Damn it... you had to go and make me cry didn't you?
This story is so sad. Sad for your best friend....and sad for you. What a burden you've carried for all these years. I just can't imagine what was going through your friend's head to want to end his life. I can't imagine my own 12 year old boy even thinking about suicide. Thank you for sharing this most painful event with us. Thank you for trusting us with your soul's content.
Dennis,
I cry for that boy and cry during the last scene as you talk to him with your daughter. You have a deep soul.
It is so strange that children should have such a loose grip on life. I read a study on fears of mortality, and the two groups who were more fearful of death were women in their fifties and those in their twenties. I was at first surprised but thought that maybe it was a reaction to how lightly they had held life as teens. We can never know why.
My heart goes out to you.
I really don't have adequate words here, Dennis. Beautiful, heartfelt, haunting, sad.

Eek! I'm scared for next part.
Twelve? Twelve. I, too, was twelve in 1966. And I can't even imagine what could have weighed so heavily on Tom at twelve. Tell it.

Really fine writing. Your daughter is a very lucky girl. Thanks.
Gail,
Thank you for your very generous comment. I was really moved that you wanted to tell your family about it.

surly,
Well, that was not my intent but I’m grateful you were willing to tell me. Thank you.

patricia,
Thank you taking the time to read and comment so kindly. His reason was pretty superficial which added to why none of us took him seriously. It was one of the day to day things that we all joked about. Many of us experienced a life long change in that attitude as a result of his death. The lesson came at a terrible price.

Stephanie,
I’m grateful to see you back and posting once again. Thank you for such kind and thoughtful remarks. I’ve made peace about my friend. I’ve also come to believe that some small luggage is beneficial for the life journey as long as it’s designed to share from.

Julie,
Thank you for your comment. I appreciate how closely you read the story to feel as you did.

M.Mckenzie,
Thank you for commenting on the post. I really appreciate your constant encouragement.

JK,
Thank you very much for such a considerate and kind comment. That is actually my hope with this series as well. There is a redemptive sense of peace hoping that past events which cannot be changed might still be used to influence actions in the future.
this is just wonderfl. it drew me in and held me till the very last word. well done.
Dennis, what a brutal and horrible story. And how rare that someone that age would take their own life, especially given everything you said about him. What I also found brutal and horrible is that you still blame yourself in some way. How could an adolescence have the emotional maturity to even fathom that his friend would be serious about this. It would have been virtually impossible at that tender age to have an awareness of this as a reality. You never failed your friend. You loved him and no one can ask for more than that. Highly rated.
I hear you, Dennis.

Thanks. I don't think there is anything else I could say.

Thanks.
lorianne,
Thank you for such a kind comment. It’s hard to gauge a piece like this.

Mary,
Thank you for the encouragement in your kind reply. What you shared affirms much of what I’ve slowly realized. I know I would feel the same about others who had a similar experience. This took more time because it was me and being hard on me is easier. How’s that for being obscure? The comfort as you rightly point out was that I loved him and still do.

Bill,
Thank you kind sir. Being “heard” is part of the greater intent.
Your journey to manhood and soul searching began with Tom's death. The next time you visit his grave, thank him for the beautiful gift he bestowed upon you. You have generously shared it with so many others. Now I understand not only how, but why. Sad and beautiful, beautifully written.
O’Really,
Thank you for such a kind, insightful a comment. You are probably right on the money about certain aspects of the journey. A few others began earlier and some much later.

I look back and marvel how much sooner we begin to warn kids of things in these days which back then were seldom if ever discussed.
Sometimes it's very difficult to remain as skeptical as I am of fate or meaning: Earlier tonight, before reading this powerful piece, I posted a blog which seems to me to be its antithesis. I must have felt guilty about my snarkiness because I went online and instead of promoting my blog I answered a young man's query about whether he should take his suicidal ideations as signs of depression. I emphatically answered in the affirmative, urged him to seek help and found a few organizations that might be helpful. Then I came back and read this. I can't help but feel I've made a tiny journey myself this evening.
Thank you Dennis,

This post moved me to tears.

Do we ever really understand another's interior life? Does any teen know what's going through a friends mind?

What a difficult memory to live with!

Rated and appreciated.
Rachel,
Thank you so much for all you shared. One of the reasons I wanted to put this narrative up was in hope it might give pause to others regarding kids, friends, or people of any age who have mentioned thoughts of suicide. I really appreciate your encouragement.

Dr. Ayala,
Thank you for such a kind comment. I don’t know if we ever understand as we wish we would. Coming to grips with the tangle of our own thoughts/feelings is challenging enough - but fully understanding the inner workings of another may not be possible. But I don’t think that should keep us from trying. :) Your thoughtfulness is appreciated.
All these years you have carried that. Did you cry when you wrote it?
This tragic tale is so lovingly told and you have passed on such a valuable lesson to your daughter...
Dennis,

Jesus. This is stunning, wrenching. Comments and criticism are utterly beside the point.
Damn. I just read this blog post yesterday, then today this news out of Gary, IN.

http://www.suntimes.com/news/metro/1943112,gary-missing-boy-121909.article

This young boy, 12 years old, came home from school, took a weapon from the house and went out an shot himself. They don't know why, but he may have gotten into trouble at school that day. This was not a kid with any sort of a record of behavioral, discipline or learning problems. Stable family, etc, etc. It can happen anywhere.

Not to get up on a soapbox, and start any sort of thread, but WHY, oh why, did these parents have an unlocked handgun in the house to which this child had access?