Dennis Loo

Sometimes asking for the impossible is the only realistic path

Dennis Loo

Dennis Loo
Location
Los Angeles, California,
Title
Professor of Sociology
Company
Cal Poly Pomona
Bio
Co-Editor/Author of Impeach the President: the Case Against Bush and Cheney, World Can't Wait Steering Committee Member, dog and fruit tree lover. Published poet. Winner of the Alfred R. Lindesmith Award, Project Censored Award and the Nation Magazine's Most Valuable Crusade Award. Punahou and Harvard Honor Graduate. Ph.D. in Sociology from UC Santa Cruz. An archive of close to 500 postings of mine can be found at my blogspot blog, Dennis Loo, link below. I publish regularly at worldcantwait.net (link below) and also at OpEd News and sometimes at Counterpunch. Technorati Profile

FEBRUARY 2, 2010 1:11PM

Haiti: A Letter on the Crisis

Rate: 13 Flag
From Elaine Brower, World Can't Wait Steering Committee Member and mother of a US Marine. 
I want to start an open dialogue about what is happening in Haiti.  I am deeply disturbed by the reports I have been hearing.  I thought, maybe naively, that by now things would have gotten better for the people who were injured and starving.  But more and more reports are saying that people are now dying from starvation.  
 
I posted on my blog a few days after the earthquake that my daughter's professor was asking friends to help him with medical supplies into haiti.  He was going down as a reporter for Indymedia, and had an empty duffel bag to be filled.  So we set out to fill it with medical supplies and food.  He got it over into Haiti, and he was overwhelmed with gratitude by the people he handed it out to.  We included feminine hygiene napkins in the supplies, and he said the women were in tears.  They felt like someone really thought about them personally.
 
He will be posting his story soon, and I will forward it. However, this is just not enough.  Over the weeks I have been asking people I meet who either are in the Haitian community, or others who either made trips there or were there when the earthquake struck, and the stories are horrendous.  Just last night I called a group I met at a rally Friday night, Bed Stuy EMS, and spoke to one of the guys who is trying to put another trip together for doctors and nurses who are willing to go.  He went on and on about how they were there 2 days after the quake, and the hospital doors were chained shut.  They broke open the chains and set up an ER, and treated over 1,000 people. then after the military arrived, they were shut down. They had to scavage for medical supplies because they were not on the official "military manifest" to get anything that has been sitting on the tarmac being guarded.  
 
He didn't want to condemn the military, he kept saying they were just doing their job.  I told him so were the Nazis, and he agreed.  These people need help.  Not only because they are extremely vulnerable, they can't speak up for themselves, or if they do they will be squashed one way or another, and my professor friend told me and Tanya that the people in Haiti just feel like giving up.  he said they want to be occupied, taken care of, because they are suffering.  
 
We can't let this happen.  I don't know everything that is happening there, but what I do know it isn't good.  The professor also said that the military was hanging around the tarmac guarding the supplies, on their laptops or cell phones, lounging, while people were standing outside screaming for food and help.  I believe him, because I have had this verified by others.  
 
Haiti represents an opportunity for the US empire like no other opportunity.  It's a representation of everything that is vulnerable, horrible and a complete opportunity for oppression to not only continue, but to deepen and become irreversible.  
 
We must address this issue.  Can we think outside the box on what we can do to advocate against US occupation?  Maybe join in with other organizations who might be sending the same message?  
 
Maybe even consider a trip to Haiti to speak out against what's happening.  

Author tags:

elaine brower, haiti

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Thanks for this. Very much.
Everyone wants a piece of this pie. And the expense of this little feast? The souls and intellects of Haitians. The natural world victimized this country, so do let's victimize them further by continually portraying them as weak and stupid.

We need to realize what a narcissistic grandiose lot we are and stop playing hero when we still haven't solved the Katrina issue. There are these things called: other countries. Doesn't seem like the UK is having a problem getting supplies into Haiti. Neither is Denmark. We make everything about us. xox
The armed forces are trained to fight wars against enemies. I can easily believe that soldiers who've seen combat in Iraq are extremely leery of mobs of locals.

Our military needs to work a lot harder on nation building protocols. We do enough of it and we screw it up often enough.
And my POV is not one of: take care of our own first. If we were able to do that at all, New Orleans wouldn't still be a mess. If doctors and nurse and all of these many very concerned parties cannot get to Haiti, then there are people still living in trailers down South. xox
Well said. Thank you. I also agree with Robin on many points.
As Elizi Danto put it in a recent post of hers on my blog: Obama sends 12,000 troops and what Haiti needs is 12,000 doctors. Yes, soldiers are principally trained to kill. That isn't what Haiti needs or wants right now. They need a modicum of security and a maximum of rescue and relief.
Elaine, Thanks for this article, Dennis, Thanks for posting this article.This is indeed outrageous, and to add insult to injury, an article appeared in the Miami Herald on January 27,2010 which stated that "The U.S. military is evacuating Haitian earthquake victims to northern portions of Florida to make sure Miami emergency rooms are ready for the Super Bowl." This was after a five day suspension of the flights of critically ill Haitian patients who were suffering from spinal cord injuries, brain injuries at which they were at a very high risk of dying as that the hospitals in Haiti were NOT equipped to take care of them and that the U.S. had already taken over control of Haiti's airport and other key areas and had turned back multiple flights by Doctors Without Borders who were bringing in critically needed medical supplies, equipment and personnel(including fully equipped field hospitals with operating rooms).This military CANNOT build nations(look at how Iraq was DESTROYED by the U.S. occupation on top of 12 years of killing santions)- it's duty is to maintain and expand the American empire. We cannot sit back and let these crimes happen under our noses just a few hundred miles from the U,S. and think it's OK because Obama is doing it instead of Bush. He is just as much a mass murderer and war criminal as Bush, except that he is WORSE because of all of his nice, kind sounding rhetoric.
Dennis, glad to see you in fine form. I think your essay today complements my post on the Haiti telethon. Take a looksie...
Thank you for starting dialogue about Haiti. God bless Haiti!!!!!
Thank you for posting this.

What is the idea behind sending soldiers to Haiti?

Is it so that this the thing Americans can do the best?
Or do they want to occupy Haiti?

I understand that you need a working structure to keep the things in order, but I doubt, if the military has got the right way of working to get the rescue work done effectively.

As there must be big problems of getting clean water in Haiti, I asked if my friends in the solar cooker factory of China could send there a shipload of solar cookers to get boiled safe water using free energy. But they cannot without somebody to pay it.
The Haitians have a role in creating their histroical tragedy to be fair too, although it is not pretty on our side, although I think we have done a lot better lately.
For example, when the Marines occupied Hati from 1917 until 1933, they did lots of good public works, but also ticked off the Haitian mulatto elite, which on balance was a push.
At least we gave Aristide a chance, at least compared to tolerating the Duvaliers, which was ugly, if no more ugly than China supporting the Khmer Rouge or the Russians supporting the MPLA.
Nonetheless, you are right about an opportunity being potentially missed, if we don't do this right.
Thanks for posting this!
We posted an article called "More Pain for Devastated Haiti: Under the Pretense of Disaster Relief, U.S. Running a Military Occupation" by Arun Gupta, which you might find interesting.
Here's the link: http://open.salon.com/blog/washingtonpeacecenter/2010/02/24/more_pain_for_devastated_haiti_under_the_pretense_of_disast