Perils of Divorced Pauline

The Names Have Been Changed, But the Story Is True

divorcedpauline

divorcedpauline
Location
USA
Birthday
April 05
Bio
World-class gnarly divorce survivor. Custody Battle blogger with a sense of humor. Mom. Wife. Cat-Lover. Visit me at www.perilsofdivorcedpauline.com or on Twitter @divorcedpauline.

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
JUNE 21, 2011 7:58PM

D: The Scarlet Letter

Rate: 32 Flag

On Sunday, another one of those you're-divorced-so-go-ahead-and-throw-yourself-off-a-bridge articles designed to make divorcees feel like post-modern Hester Prynnes appeared on the front page of the NY Times Styles section. The piece tracked the changing perceptions of divorce from the "Ice Storm" 70s--an era when personal fulfillment trumped all else--to the 21st Century--when a long-term marriage is now a coveted status symbol, especially for the bourgeois bohemians among us.

The article offered a few positive tidbits, namely the current belief that the damage divorce wreaks on children can be greatly mitigated by those who can pull off peaceful divorces, such as Molly Monet.

But basically, the divorced women (no men mentioned, oddly) interviewed for the piece described feeling viewed by their married peers as social pariahs, bad moms, and abject failures who might infect the Marrieds with their divorce cooties.

Many of the article subjects stated that growing up as unhappy children of divorce made them determined to keep their own marriages together, no matter what--which is contrary to the statistics that adults who came from divorced homes are more likely to divorce.

Whether it's because I spend an inordinate amount of time perusing the Huffington Post divorce section, or reading other divorce articles such as the one cited above, or the fact that my recent custody battle has sent me spinning in an endless hamster-wheel-like examination of the eight years of post-divorce hell (if I'd done x, y, or z, would my ex have been less angry and my children less damaged?) that has tainted the lives of my children, me, and now my second husband, I can tell you this:

My one-time conviction that leaving a high-conflict marriage would eventually morph into a low-conflict divorce and thus ultimately be better for the children, was misguided. Post-divorce life has been more hellish than I ever could have imagined. And the undertow of shame and sorrow for being unable to shield my kids from this level of craziness has gotten so powerful that I've decided to go back to therapy.

As the women referenced in the NY Times article, I was a child who came of age during the key-swapping, Me-Generation, Ice Storm era in which women in particular fled marriages, borne by the social current that promised personal fulfillment and a sense of self-agency to those brave enough to break loose from the shackles of traditional marriage. Many of these unions, I imagine, could have and should have been saved.

I, however, was not a child of divorce. I grew up in a home with two parents who loved and respected each other. There was very little overt conflict. I cannot, in fact, remember a single argument. Perhaps because I was an introverted, bookish kid who longed to be accepted by the cool crowd whose divorced parents were boozing, pill-popping, and key-swapping, I often wished my parents were divorced. I felt dull and out-of-sync next to my peers, who got to run glamorously wild due to their preoccupied parents' permissiveness.

Statistically, given my upbringing in an in tact marriage, I should still be married myself. I should have acquired early on the fundamental building blocks to develop self-esteem, a sure sense of values, the ability to recognize Mr. Right, and a committment to see my marriage through till death do us part.

But that was not the case. I derived my self-worth mainly from externals (as long as my outsides looked great, my insides didn't matter). I lacked the courage of my convictions. I mistook my ex for Prince Charming when he was really Prince Machiavelli. And I was riddled with ambivalence about my marriage from the moment I stepped my white-satin-clad foot on the aisle, until the ambivalence outweighed the committment and I filed for divorce.

How did this happen? When I perform a psychic autopsy on my parents' marriage, and my childhood in it, the distance between my parents is laid bare. While my sister (who has been long-time married) remembers my parents as a vibrant, social couple embarking on a grand adventure, I, ten years younger, recall two genteel, polite people who went out of their way to avoid each other.

My parents hid out in a myriad of ways. They ate TV dinners on trays in front of the Mary Tyler Moore Show. My mother, worn down by mysterious somatic afflictions, took long afternoon naps. Weekends that could have been spent playing tennis or visiting friends were divvied up separately. My mother compulsively cleaned the house and my father escaped either to his study or to a buddy's to play pool.

My mother lived for her job as a highly-acclaimed elementary school music teacher and producer of children's theater. She loved being a big fish in a small pond and thrived on the urgency and drama of mounting theatrical productions, then basking in the kudos she received. Next to her creative endeavors, home life paled. For whatever reason, she turned to me to meet her emotional needs--quite often sobbing about her internal despair--which eventually kept my father out of the house for entire weekends, and kept me percolating in a stew of resentment and swallowed feelings.

Given the lives of quiet desperation my parents and I lived, juxtaposed next to the anything-goes, seize-the-day existence of my peers and their parents, it's understandable why I grew up to think staying in an unhappy marriage was worse than exiting one.

Yet as frustrated as I think my parents were, they--and I--would probably have fared far worse had they divorced. Neither of them had the financial or emotional resources to be on their own, and, I, a nervous-nelly of a child, did not have the constitution to navigate domestic upheaval.

That said, I know quite a few adult children of divorce who were relieved when their parents split up because the conflict stopped. These adults now tell me that the only fantasy they harbored about their parents was that they would stop fighting. One friend confided that her parents, long-divorced, are friends now and have grown into the people they never could have been had they stayed together. When I asked her if she ever wished they'd reconciled, she literally shuddered, looked at me as if I were insane, and said nononono!

But what of the adult children who never get over their parents' divorce, and blame every problem they have on it? I used to believe that every misfortune I had was due to my being adopted. Conventional adoption literature can really mess with an adoptee's head: according to adoption statistics, adoptees are more likely to have learning disabilities, failed marriages, addiction, and a lifelong sense of not fitting in. In my own life, I can lay claim to all of these issues. Would I not have had them had I not been adopted? Who knows? But I do know one thing: my birthmother was in no position to raise me and my life would have been far more chaotic had she tried.

Until I accepted this simple truth, I spent much of my childhood and adulthood being angry that I was adopted, that I had been denied the breezy entitlement that comes with knowing where you belong. But while adoption may have been the cause of some of my problems--such as picking the wrong person to marry--it's not an excuse for mistakes either. My birthparents and adoptive parents did the best they could with the resources they had at the time. It's up to me to decide whether or not I'm going to let adoption, or divorce, define me.

I wonder if the current divorce literature isn't saddling children of divorce with the same you're-screwed message doled out by adoption researchers before this current era of trendy adoption. Are we guilting parents who left marriages that should NOT have been saved--those where addiction, abuse, personality disorders, and mental illness ran rampant--by insinuating that they didn't have "the right stuff" like their still-married counterparts?

Are people legitimately trying to work on marriages for the sake of the children, or simply because Marriage is the New Black?

The twice-divorced Nora Ephron, who co-created the HuffPo divorce section hoping to lessen the stigma of divorce, has this to say on the subject:

"Divorce seems as if it will last forever, and then suddenly, one day, your children grow up, move out, and make lives for themselves, and except for an occa­sional flare, you have no contact at all with your ex-husband. The divorce has lasted way longer than the marriage, but finally it's over. The point is, that for a long time, the fact that I was divorced was the most important thing about me. And now, it's not."

I hope that my kids will one day make a truce with divorce as I have with adoption. That divorce, like adoption, is something that happens to you. From time to time, especially in the face of another loss, it can creep into you like a virus and leave you feeling ragged. But most of the time, it's just there, one experience among many that make who you are. Maybe it even brings you some gifts: the ability to appreciate what you do have; a belief in your own resilience; the wisdom to look at things from others' point-of-view; perhaps a talent for mediation.

Until then, I look forward to the day when divorce is no longer the most important thing about me--or my children.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I waited 25 years.. way too long . But it took that long to build up the courage to leave.
rated with hugs
That day will come, believe me. It is difficult to see when you are still embroiled in questions and seeking answers, but it happens one day. Very thoughtful and a well written piece.
♥R
Great post. I really liked what you said at the end that divorce is just " one experience among many that make who you are. "
So well-put. As a child of divorced parents, what I think is that it also depends on HOW the parents deal with the divorce and its aftermath. I love my mom and dad, but they are AWFUL at being divorced, and have been for years - still bickering, picking on each other, and bitter. On the other hand, maybe it would be different with people whose parents handled it better. Not sure. I do think that the statistics out there are daunting but when people fall in love and meet who they think is Mr. or Ms. Right, they try to think they'll beat the odds. I personally don't know if I will, and neither does the boyfriend - one of the reasons we won't ever get married. But I don't feel my life is any the worse for this, in the long run. Thank you for this fascinating, thought-provoking read. And I'm glad you found closure and answers to many of the questions you've had about your own life and relationships.
People who are unable to maintain successful relationships tend to get divorced. They also tend to not have successful relationships with their kids, their exes, their neighbors, etc. Is the problem of children of divorced parents that their parents divorced? Or that had one parent who couldn't maintain successful relationships?

It sounds like your problem is that you married a man who hasn't figured out how to have successful relationships. Perhaps the biggest problem your kids have is trying to have a parent-child relationship with him. Or learning about relationships from him.

I hope your therapy is focused on how to deal with manipulative people, which is what your ex sounds like.

I don't know anyone who stigmatizes the divorced, but it is true that many couples find it easier to socialize in couples.
Wonderful piece. I have a friend trying hard to avoid divorce, despite the fact that her marriage is toxic to the point of no return. Understandably, she fears the Scarlet "D"
If there's a pill for self-pity you could certainly use it. The scarlet D exists only in your mind. You're a free person to marry or not marry and lead a fulfilling life as is your choice. Your friends or neighbors or whomever don't determine that at all! All this self-torture doesn't make you a good person.

Most marriages are simply a contract of depravity. Move on, move out, grow up. No one gets a free ride.
Even in the friendliest of divorces there is a sense of loss and failure.
rated, sweetie - but i won't read for now... after almost 40 years, still too painful. (though i sure don't regret the result.)
Well done! Excellent writing and great insights. You've raised an important question about the "popular" wisdom that is being purported as absolute truth concerning all parties affected by divorce. Just as each couple, each divorce and each person is different, the effects are different as well. There is no blanket result with divorce.

This statement speaks volumes: My birthparents and adoptive parents did the best they could with the resources they had at the time. It's up to me to decide whether or not I'm going to let adoption, or divorce, define me.

We love to blame life's problems on some "thing" or "someone", when in reality, it's up to us as individuals to choose how we let the things that happen in our lives shape us. For a couple of generations now, we've not been big on personal responsibility. Terrible, sad and/or unfortunate things happen every day. We used to say those things "built character," now we use them as an excuse for why our lives haven't gone the way we think they should.

Dear Pauline, I kow it's easier said than done, but let yourself off the hook. At least cut yourself as much slack as you were willing to cut your birth and adoptive parents. We ALL do the best we can with the tools we have available.

My best to you as you continue to sort through the post-divorce trauma.

And again, excellent article.
They say time heals all things. I'm not sure if that is exactly true but I wish it for you. Wonderful story full of a poignancy that had to be hard to let out.
I stayed in a bad marriage 13 years because it's the devil you DON'T know, and because by the time I realized he was my enemy, I was afraid to let him know I knew he was my enemy, and I was right. The divorce was hellish, but it was 10 years ago.

It's something I am very glad I did even though my kids have not gotten through it unscathed (nobody gets out of anything unscathed though, I'm convinced). Now it's behind me, and the kids' problems are the kids' problems. We were all in therapy (except my ex) during the marriage anyway. Life is still difficult, but there's no longer anyone standing on my neck. My parents were married for 20 years and miserable and we knew it. They're divorced and still miserable 20 years later. Life is what you make it. Take your time choosing a mate and especially a father to your children. Marry in haste, repent at leisure.

I think the article you mentioned is nonsense. I read an old, old, 193o's Ladies Home Journal that said there is no shame in realizing a mistake in choosing a mate and rectifying that mistake legally by divorcing. So there.
There is no shame in divorce. I am a woman of many-mom-married-and-divorced, female, kid.

I am nearly 48.

When it came down "to the hammer" of filing for divorce from my gay ex hubby, I had to do it. He is the father of my only two children - to have two by him is a miracle. He like man ass. I was married to him for nearly 20 years of hell, hell, because he never wanted me, never loved me, and I poured my heart into that guy. It didn't matter..he liked man ass.

Children survive. As I did, I figured it out between my parents when I was 25. I cut it before I knew he was gay and using me. I knew it. Call it woman's intuition, but I knew something was wrong and I could not fix it.

I refused to destroy my children with a false sense of security by "towing the line because I am female". I gotta love my mom, she may have been a bi-polar not taking her medication, but she was good hearted and could make a decision about bad men.

I moved on. I matured. One thing I read today on a poster board was "Don't let the past starve your future".

We, as adults, have many decisions to make, and how we make our lives and live it is a better testimony than living in the past. It's what we do with our pasts, or not do, that matters. No one comes from a perfect background.

I read this article and I feel you are still stuck in the past. The past is over. I am sure, as many of your readers realize, that the past cannot be changed. It is what it is. You cannot change it.

Just move forward, as an adult, with much experience, in your own life. This is the best thing you can do for your children. Set an example.

My mom, as nutso as she was, tought me this. The past is over. The only thing you have to do is carve your future.

Stop it. Now.

Spedie
You are eloquent here and I read every word with relish. I do believe time will heal your wounds and those of your children. We don't all heal perfectly, but heal we do.

This will sound impertinent, but I will say it anyway. Perhaps you ought to think about changing your handle at some point...to something other than divorcedpauline. I only say so because it seems like as long as you have it, you will identify as that "divorced person". Not trying to be rude or judgy...just sayin'.
Toxic divorces aren't separate from toxic marriages. There are marriages between two well-meaning, open-hearted people that, for whatever reasons, don't work out. The parties move on, make things work.

Then there are marriages/divorces where one or both parties are stuck in the past, bitter and angry, perhaps mentally ill, and those relationships are carried on and on and on in ways that are damaging to everyone involved.

Either way...staying together wouldn't have made a difference. The marriages where mental illness was brewing, it would have continued to brew. In those marriages where the parents might have, with effort, maintained some civility, if not happiness, within the same household...the kids wouldn't have enjoyed that either. In that sense, if you make a "bad match" there are no optimal solutions, so why not choose the one that at least has the potential to make you happier?
Interesting look at the subject pauline. I was relieved when my folks finally split. I'm separated and soon, I hope, to be divorced but I haven't felt any stigma. Maybe it's because there are no kids or maybe I'm a tad oblivious. Good luck to you in any case.
After reading your post, I'm kind of glad that I waited til the kids were grown up, although that left me in my 60s navigating the rugged road of divorce. I hate the feeling of failure, but looking at the alternative of an unhappy ever-after, I think I made the right decision.
When I was a kid, I wished my parents would divorce, because of the conflicts between them and the anguish it caused us all. Then, when they finally move apart, I wished they'd get on with it and stop dragging it out and putting us into the middle of it. Both of them were jerks. I got stuck with way too many duties cleaning up their messes too early on. Now, neither myself or my sister is married, although I do tend to find relationships and she does not. Even though I believe in the institution of marriage, I haven't found someone I believed in being married to who believed in respecting me. My relationship now is good, but not what I wanted for myself. No marriage, no children, no property, mostly self reliant.
i was adopted as well and can pretty much agree with the statistics you mentioned. i am also going through a divorce as well (chalk one up for the surverys lol) but as i'm coming to terms with everything i know i can't keep viewing the life i had with my ex husband as a ruined thing, but more a learning of what my son and i deserve from the next person who will share our lives should there ever be anther. the things that tag us through life don't have to to define us if we don't want them to. choices choices choices...
DP--

Divorce, like any other trauma, takes the time that it takes to heal. It's like trying to ripen a banana by putting it in the oven--never happen.

Not that my own divorce was sweetness-and-light (far from it, the best thing that happened in that marriage was its death), but every wound has to be allowed its time to heal before moving on. It took lots of therapy and alone-time, and yeah it got lonely--still does occasionally.

But in retrospect, so many good things happened that never would've occurred had I remained Mrs Shit. I now have a tiny recycling sideline that's taken off like a rocket, and I've gotten involved in volunteering w/domestic violence victims--something I know a little about.

There are days now when I think about the Bad Old Days, then look around my little cave and think, "I'm so damn HAPPY."

Divorce is as divorce does. How you see the show depends on where you sit.
it's gotten funny to me. most of my wife and our friends divorced, and when i'd ask their reasons they seemed to me mere illusionary whimsey. "incompatability" never seemed the match for rejection, betrayal and abandonment. unbeknowst to them, i had far more reason, but only saw divorce as stepping from the frying pan into the fire.

now that my wife is dead, however, i regret the loss of the years when i could have started over more than anything. the real task begins with knowing ourselves, and that is what most are most afraid to do.

also, i think the fact that i stayed, realizing fully the necessity of establishing an independant relationship with my daughter paid off with the most significant relationship in my life--as per my latest blog.

Nice work, incidently, a much deeper cut than most. rated and befriended.
I do agree with Spedie quite a bit. Dwelling on the past does rob of the future. I've done this so many times. -R-
I have absolutely no idea where the media's "take" on divorce and divorced people comes from these days. Like almost everything in big corporatized media, it bears no resemblance to anything in everyday life. It's bizarre. I've been divorced for a while now and know a lot of divorced people over 45. I knew a lot of them before I was divorced, too. Just folks. There really is nothing to report.
Rated.
Wow, great post. I'm in a long-term marriage and I kind of hate to see my friends break up or divorce. Our marriage is in many ways non-traditional, including non-monogamous, and that has kept the pressure relatively light in spite of the serious challenges we've faced. We've worked at our relationship, too, but really, a lot of it is luck. We were older, more mature when we met, and we just happened to find someone compatible in more ways than not. If we didn't like each other and get along more than we fight, we probably would not have lasted. No one should live in constant conflict. It's not healthy. You were right to get out.

My friend's divorce really highlighted for me how conflict-driven divorce still is, even with no-fault divorce. As you mentioned, you can revisit custody, child support, even spousal support. My friend's uncontested divorce, done with a mediator, costs thousands of dollars which they didn't have. They were probably better at negotiating than most divorcing couples. Even though it's costly and painful, a lot of people can't let go of their issues long enough to make divorce any easier than marriage.
I'm sorry your divorce has been so harrowing, Pauline. As a child of divorced parents, I have to say it was the best option. I was thrilled, glad the fighting would end and that my fears about them killing each other were over.
Divorce also gives you the gift of meeting someone else, and having a wonderful marriage.
Thank you for sharing! You are inspirational!