Notes From Northern California

and random rants

D.M. Schwartz

D.M. Schwartz
Location
Fair Oaks, California, USA
Birthday
September 10
Bio
Architect, engineer, writer, in the foothills of the Sierra Nevada. To find my stories on the Web, search the Kindle Store or Google: "D.M. Schwartz."

MY RECENT POSTS

MAY 20, 2010 12:22PM

Drawing of the Prophet Mohammed

Rate: 0 Flag
The Prophet

Muhammad ibn Abd Allah

The above is an image of the original purchased in Qum, 1999, by Ingvild Flaskerud.

The text below the image is the shahada or profession of faith: "There is no god but Allah, Muhammad is His messenger."  The medallions in the upper corners contain the words "Allah" (to the right) and "Muhammad" (to the left).

Representations of the Prophet are well known from early on, but are not very common. While some Muslims hold beliefs that it is against Islam to make images of the Prophet, others have more relaxed attitudes, and among Shia Muslims, such pictures are common, and much liked. According to Iranian informants interviewed by Ingvild Flaskerud, such portraits should not be considered "real" portraits of the prophet Muhammad. The artists make these images on the basis of conventional ideas of the character of those personages depicted, in the same way it has been done with Biblical figures in European art.

All of the above, including image, from:

http://www.hf.uib.no/i/religion/popularikonografi/exhib03.html

So, contrary to what we’ve been reading in the mainstream media, it seems many Muslims do own images of their prophet. Perhaps what some Muslims are trying to say is that disrespectful images of him should be banned, similar to the way Holocaust denial is banned in Germany or yelling ‘fire’ in a theater is banned everywhere.

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
What, no comments? Are we concerned about a fatwah?
i'll save you.

this is mildly interesting, but i already know a few moslems who drink a glass of wine with dinner, jews who have bacon for breakfast, and catholics who are not fastidious about fish on friday.

it's the fundamentalists of every faith who get their sense of importance from defending the faith vigorously. i'm inclined to give moslems a little tolerance, because western governments have mislaid their armies, many turning up blood-smeared on moslem lands.

but freedom of speech should be absolute. that may have unwelcome consequences, but allowing governments to define free speech is a nonsense.
Al;

I can't think of any human society in history that has ever had absolute free speech. As I understand it, part of the social contract is mutual restraint.

Cheers,

Dave