Donna Carbone

Donna Carbone
Location
South Florida, USA
Birthday
April 21
Title
Owner
Company
Writers Bloc
Bio
Married for thirty six years and the mother of the two grown children, I began writing at the age of ten. My first success was winning a poetry contest in grammar school. From that moment forward, I realized that the written word was as vital to my survival as food and air. I am presently working on two books, one of which I hope to finish before I die. A number of my poems have graced A Long Story Short, and I have been published in the Lucidity Journal. Each day inspires me...what I see, hear and experience.... if it stays in my mind, I write about it. __________________________________________ "To believe in something not yet proved and to underwrite it with our lives: It is the only way we can leave the future open." (Lillian Smith)

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
JANUARY 5, 2011 11:06AM

Three Flags

Rate: 18 Flag

 

tumblr analyticsA Palm Beach County country club of some renown has celebrated its founding anniversary over Veterans Day weekend for the last six years. The members have generously used the occasion to fundraise for a charity focused on the needs of veterans and deployed soldiers in our Armed Forces.

Each year the opening ceremonies are quite impressive and have included paratroopers jumping from a plane while holding a large, fully extended American flag. The tear filled eyes of the membership gaze skyward as the National Anthem plays. Pride is evident on every face.

This year over $36,000 was raised and donated – a praise worthy accomplishment especially in these tough economic times.

While reading the article and looking at the accompanying picture in the local paper, I asked my husband whether he thought any of the people depicted, dressed in golf plaids and tennis whites, realized how different their attire was from the uniforms worn by our military men and women in the field. Do they, I wondered, ever stop to consider that the flag on the pole in front of their clubhouse, waving over luscious greens and pastel flower gardens, represents something much different than other flags across this nation and around the world?

A few miles from my home is our local VA Hospital. Here, another flag flutters above a parking lot so packed with cars that there aren’t enough spaces to accommodate the many veterans in need of care. Each person who enters through the front doors has served this country with honor, integrity and dedication.  They suffer illnesses too many to mention – physical, mental and emotional. For those with Post Traumatic Stress Disorder and Traumatic Brain Injury, the need for relief and answers is an especially urgent one.

As I stand quietly against a wall, watching but not wanting to intrude, I see recognition register on each new face. They all know each other. They’ve all been here before – many times. Outstretched arms and clasped hands are extended in gestures of friendship and commonality. Then they laugh a bittersweet laugh and complain loudly about the lack of parking and the tickets that will most likely be stuck to their windshields when their appointments are over. Complaining gives them a few minutes respite from the pain that is their constant companion. So do the laughs.

There is a third flag that comes to mind as I write this article. I see it in my mind’s eye draped over the casket of Staff Sgt. David Senft, who was buried at Arlington National Cemetery on December 16, 2010. Sgt. Senft is a statistic to everyone but his family. He is one of the many and growing number of soldiers who has committed suicide as a result of a trauma suffered in battle. 

A 2008 study by the Rand Corporation estimated that more than 620,000 veterans who had served in the Middle East would need long term care for traumatic brain injuries. According to that study, one in five soldiers returning from the Middle East display symptoms of PTSD, putting them at a higher risk for suicide. That number rises daily. Now consider that it is estimated that 18 veterans a day actually do commit suicide.

As the snow fell softly on Sgt. Senft’s coffin, the American flag was lifted and folded with all due ceremony. The flakes that clung to the fabric fluttered to the ground, a symbol of another life lost to a “disorder” only recently recognized and yet to be treated let alone cured. 

I wonder how long it will be before Sgt. Senft’s five-year-old son, into whose hands the flag was placed, starts asking, “Why?”

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
We need to do more for our military veterans, as your moving essay suggests. Their service to our country must be respected.
Donna, this is an outstanding post. It is a privilege to read it and rate it. Perhaps if the sons and daughters of those at the country club volunteered to serve or were conscripted, the duration and outcome of our troops would be different. they literally have no skin in the game.
OE,

Many of the people at that country club have children far too young to volunteer for military service. Others do have sons and daughters who serve or have served. Still, life within the gates of communities such as these are often more fantasy than reality. With that in mind, these people do a wonderful service each year by raising money and donating it for the betterment of all of men and women in uniform.
This is a brilliantly-conceived post and extremely well-written. r.
Thank you, Jonathan. It is a subject near and dear to my heart.
Bonnie,

We both know it is easier to read and do nothing. As I've told you, I've been communicating with a veteran of the Vietnam War, and the stories he has told me are frightening. That war ended 35 years ago, and our military men and women are still waiting for treatment.

To be fair, some service received at the VA is exemplary -- or so I've been told by other veterans. However, it appears there is a web of connections -- a hierarchy so to speak -- that must be climbed before some soldiers are recognized. It's sad to think that one person's life is considered more valuable than another's.
The most important thing we can do besides treating our servicemen and women with the respect and treatment they deserve is to keep them out of unnecessary conflict in the first place. This is very well written Donna and is deserving of the front page.
I think about this a lot. The modern technology of warfare means that fewer people are killed. Modern technology of healthcare means that more are saved. So many more coming home with PSTD and missing limbs than in Vietnam. I hope those who were so anxious to fund the wars will be as eager to fund the care for these brave individuals. Good post, Donna. R
Thank you, Michael, for both recognizing our Armed Forces and your kind comments about my post.
Amy,

Funding for military healthcare is a bi-partisan ping pong game. Harry Reid recently tied money to a bill with outrageous earmarks. Of course, the GOP knocked it down. If they really cared, on both side of the aisle, our veterans/deployed soldiers would stand apart when bills are constructed.
For twenty years I asked: "Why?" Then, I just quit asking and put the question away in a deep hole inside me. Nowadays I'm just too numb to ask why.

Great article and a well deserved EP.
An excellent title and an interesting examination of our use of icons--often without realizing what they might mean
Popular opinion and vocal support of the military can change things. I am just barely old enough to remember Jane Fonda going to Vietnam to support the communists torturing our soldiers. I doubt her career would survive today if she rushed to Bin Laden's side to help wage war against our soldiers. I am just old enough to have seen our country recognize PTSD, and other horrible problems suffered by our vets that were not previously recognized. While many, if not most, of the homeless are still vets, at least there are more organizations trying to help vets, and we are more sympathetic to those with problems.

I am not trying to look through rose-colored glasses and say all is well. We have a long history of breaking promises, and we are still failing. But I do see that we can change things if we keep at it.

Thank you for remembering our soldiers!

kurt -r-
Back to congratulate you on the well-deserved Editor's Pick.
I regularly see those cutesy little fucking magnetic ribbons stuck to the backs of vehicles.
I seem to always wonder what these people have actually DONE for a/any veteran(s) other than sticking that cutesy little fucking ribbon on the back of their vehicles.

I see a lot of them on my way to the VA clinic or hospital in Tomah or Madison.
Don't bother to excuse me for what I said because, you see, I'm a Vietnam vet, you know, not one of those that are in vogue as are the American military veterans of bush's invented wars.

There, I said it.
XJS

You won't get any lip from me. Recently I made friends with a Vietnam vet who has been filling me in on his own "conflicts" with the VA. It's been an eye opener, i.e. the role different veterans organizations play in getting help for their members, minority treatment, the pill game, etc. etc. etc.

With my new friend's help - and others who are willing to contribute -- I'm hoping to write an expose on VA policies and treatment over the 35 plus years.

Interested in telling me your story?
Donna, thank you for posting this. I agree with you that much more attention should be paid to health care for veterans. They give so much of themselves in service to our country, and they get so little in return. Last year, my 84-year-old uncle, a decorated Navy Commander and veteran of 3 wars, passed away from a circulatory system disorder in our local (civilian) hospital. During his declining months, he refused point-blank to go to any of the nearby veterans' hospitals for treatment, because according to him "they won't take care of me in those places-- they'll just put me in a room and forget about me". A telling comment indeed. If veterans who are seniors can't expect decent treatment, younger vets don't have much more of a chance.
Donna,
I'll get around to another blog or two/three, etc.
When my fellings reach my fingers and my fingers are ready to type, I'll blog about it.
ZaZa

I've heart that same story many times. Sad! Sad! Sad! Sorry to hear about your uncle. I'll bet he had some good stories to tell. We need to listen to our "old soldiers" and " old sailors" a lot more often.
In addition to suicide, nearly 20% of all the homeless on any given night are veterans, and a good number of them are suffering from PTSD or TBI. If the healthcare issue isn't enough to get us off our collective butts, the idea of these warriors surviving the perils of war only to come home to live in the gutter; well, that should do it.

Lezlie
See?! I have a knack for recognizing great content and secreting them to the front page. you can thank be later.

I kid, of course. Congrates on the well deserved EP!
Michael,

Your seem to have "power." Could you whisper in Congress' ear and get them to approve a few million (billion) bucks for our soldiers?

Thanks for the congrats!
L :

The Department of Veterans Affairs estimates that approximately 107,000 soldiers are homeless. Last year, 92,000 veterans applied for help through the VA’s specialized programs. Another 100,000 reached out to churches and charities for food, shelter and clothing.

According to the National Coalition for Homeless Veterans, the majority of “old soldiers” without a roof over their heads are men (5% female). They are single and suffer from mental illness (ptsd) and substance abuse. A staggering 50% served during the Vietnam War, which ended in 1975.

1975? That's 35 years ago. Shame on us!
An outstanding post Donna. Really well written and shines the light again on one of the most perplexing issues of the military today, how we treat out returning soldiers. Congrats on the EP and best wishes on writing and developing your expose'.
Posts like this make me proud to be a member of Open Salon.
We use them like pawns that can be sacrificed as if in some game. Support Our Troops we always hear until they really need us. Disgusting it is and always has been.
Thank you, Sarah. That means a lot to me.
Donna, This is a great article that breaks one's heart because of the disparity between the ones who serve and the ones who do not. It will take powerful people, inspired by the chorus, to make the services get serious about PTSD.

I saw lives shattered in my hometown in the 60's, as disillusioned young folks returned, utterly frustrated at how people placed importance in small things, ignoring the efforts of those young veterans in their need to exorcise the horrors of their experience.
This is a wonderfully thought provoking post. Thank you -R-
Gary,

The veterans I have been talking to are still trying to escape the Viet Nam war - awake and asleep.
Donna, I am just catching up on old posts and this is the first time this one has come to my attention. I'm so glad to see this was an Editor's Pick.

The issue of suicide is actually far worse than the statistics would have all of us believe. Many of the deaths are reported as "noncombat related death under investigation". It is my belief that most of these deaths are suicides or "accidental overdoses" because the troops are prescribed so many medications that should not be taken simultaneously.

Don't even get me started on the VA and their pill-pushing ways! It is easy to see why each day 18 veterans take their lives. I predict that number will rise.