Donna Carbone

Donna Carbone
Location
South Florida, USA
Birthday
April 21
Title
Owner
Company
Writers Bloc
Bio
Married for thirty six years and the mother of the two grown children, I began writing at the age of ten. My first success was winning a poetry contest in grammar school. From that moment forward, I realized that the written word was as vital to my survival as food and air. I am presently working on two books, one of which I hope to finish before I die. A number of my poems have graced A Long Story Short, and I have been published in the Lucidity Journal. Each day inspires me...what I see, hear and experience.... if it stays in my mind, I write about it. __________________________________________ "To believe in something not yet proved and to underwrite it with our lives: It is the only way we can leave the future open." (Lillian Smith)

MY RECENT POSTS

JULY 8, 2011 10:08AM

When women lie about rape

Rate: 5 Flag

From the moment the Dominique Strauss-Kahn accusations hit the newswire, I had my doubts. Call me jaded but with the number of false rape claims against the rich and famous in recent years, it stands to reason that someone with a yearning for increased wealth but not a willingness to work for it might see the man as a target. Understand, I am not saying he isn’t a sleaze. DSK might very well be the human incarnation of Jabba the Hutt, but unless and until that is proven, he is a man falsely accused of a heinous crime – one that can destroy his personal and professional life. If the charges against him are, indeed, proven false, they can also destroy every inroad women have made to bring legitimacy to charges of rape and hamper the prosecution and conviction of actual rapists.

Lest you think that this article is written in defense of Mr. Strauss-Kahn, let me reassure you that this is not my intent. He is merely the foundation for a post on a far worse crime – treason. Women can and often are their own worst enemy. To unjustly accuse a man, any man, of rape out of greed, revenge or narcissism (those 15 minutes of fame can be very tempting) is detrimental to society as a whole and women in particular.

As an advocate for real victims of sexual assault, I find such tactics almost as heinous as the crime of rape itself. Why? By lying, women are further victimizing those who have already been victimized.  Lying corrodes the still shaky foundation that has been set in place to make society aware that rape is not about sex and that the victim is not – never, ever – at fault. Unfortunately, if just one woman is found to be lying, suddenly, all women lie! Chalk it up to the guilt by association mindset and the need to pretend that mankind does not prey on weak and vulnerable among them.

I often attend professional luncheons where I mention my work on behalf of victims of sexual assault. I also tell people that I am a member of a local Human Trafficking Coalition. Let me tell you that, if you want to clear a room quickly, all you have to do is mention these two dark clouds. Where, just two seconds before my announcement, all eyes were riveted on me, heads suddenly lower and an imagined loose thread or food stain becomes the focus of attention. Recently, I asked to be the designated speaker at a women’s luncheon. The moderator’s response, “Oh, I like to keep these events lighthearted. Can you put a happy ending on that topic?” My answer, “Sure, every time a woman doesn’t die, that’s a happy ending. I’ll only talk about the rape victims who live. How’s that?” Denial is a weapon that will bury us – sometimes literally -- time and again!

I would like to disassociate myself from the less honorable of the female gender, but I doubt that those who thrive on sensationalism will let me off that easily. So, instead, I acknowledge that not everyone’s motives are pure – humans are a mixed bag of honorable and dishonorable character traits, after all -- and I stand proudly in support of women who have known the horror of rape, giving them the encouragement they need and deserve.

You might be wondering why I feel so strongly about this issue. Forty years ago, I was one of those women. Four years ago, my daughter joined the sisterhood. If ever there was a club no one should aspire to join, this is it. Since women do not voluntarily apply for membership, those who are forced onto its roster need to hold strong against anyone who would undermine their progress. That includes other women who use the accusation of rape for their own gains.

Let’s adopt the battle cry, “From victimized to victorious – nothing less will do.” Only the truth will allow us to achieve that goal.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Without all the facts -- and when do we ever get all the facts? -- we will never know what actually went on in that hotel room. However, any woman who lies, not just this woman -- any woman, who lies about being raped does immeasurable harm and a vast disservice to true victims, who have fought valiantly to bring aware of this crime to a society that often buries its collective head in the sand about distasteful subjects.
Your piece makes a very valid point, Donna. Truth often gets lost in the murkiness of uneducated or politically correct, even biased voices who can shout the loudest. Unfortunately they do more harm and disservice to the issue at hand in favor of their own agenda.

I particularly like the paragraph which ends with this sentence:

"Denial is a weapon that will bury us – sometimes literally -- time and again!"

Well done - I hope your piece gets a lot of readership.
♥R
Thanks, Funsun. As you know, this is a topic near and dear to my heart.

BTW: The attack on my daughter is being considered for an episode on "I Survived." We are keeping our fingers crossed as that show never stoops to sensationalism but strives to bring the "fact" to light.
Fusun,

My apologies for spelling your name wrong. I get so frustrated with this site that I type and post without checking for mistakes. Forgive me!
This is the best piece I've read on the subject, and I've read them all over cybertown and beyond...even wrote one myself. There are some out there, mostly women, who want to cling to the idea that she was raped and the wealthy scoundrel got away with it... no matter how much evidence to the contrary comes to light. I don't claim to know for sure what happened in that room, but this woman has some splainin' to do.
I agree that false accusations of rape harm the credibility of women, something they can ill afford to lose. An important post.
Donna, beautifully told as a survivor, not a victim (tears). Thank you for your love and strength and wisdom that we all need on days like today!!