OPTIMISM, TEMPERED BUT STRONG

Don'tBlameGrima

Don'tBlameGrima
Location
Wisconsin, USA
Birthday
February 06
Bio
Waxes nostalgic for the days when he didn't know better

MY RECENT POSTS

Don'tBlameGrima's Links

Salon.com
AUGUST 16, 2009 11:18PM

Down and Out in Open Salon

Rate: 11 Flag

 

Author Cory Doctorow 

 

I have recently been thinking about Cory Doctorow's wonderful futuristic book, Down and Out in the Magic Kingdom.  It really reminds me of Open Salon.

In the Bitchun Society to which the main characters belong, people don't use cash but instead gain Whuffie points, basically points given you by people you've encountered.  The more people approve of you and your behavior, the more Whuffie you accrue.  In other words people who do kindnesses for others are rewarded with Whuffie for gratitude.  People who are funny are given Whuffie for making people laugh.  If you are smart...  Committing a mean-spirited act will cost you Whuffie, if you're caught.  Of course, there are those with plenty of Whuffie and not a drop of actual kindness or decency in them.  High Whuffie count can give you leadership positions and other advantages associated with wealth today.  The instantaneously updated count itself can become a form of behavior modification. 

I don't want to go in a negative direction with this comparison to Open Salon.  I am not accusing people of campaigning for Whuffie.  It just shows what I have learned in recent weeks.  We are moving toward a time when we all have an online self, capable of garnering friends and even enemies.   We gain friends in favoriting others, rating their articles, commenting on their articles.  In exchange, we are more likely to be read, rated and favorited.  A cynical person could see it as game-playing and politicking, but it really is just our cyber-self moving into a new community and meeting people.

Our online self is an interesting entity, in turns a total fabrication or the maybe the truest picture of ourselves we have.  In this forum, my cyber-self is very free to speak my mind and relate mistakes from my past.  My flesh and blood self cannot always do that as a public school teacher in a very small town.  So cyber-me is a little more open in many ways than real me is allowed to be.  In both incarnations I'm genuinely friendly and have a tempered optimism about the world.  If that gets me Whuffie points, okay.  But in the cyber-world I am also a little more likely to express controversial viewpoints.  I think that cuts both ways in the Whuffie count.

Anyway, having fun here, meeting good people here, expressing myself here.  These are all good.

DOWN AND OUT IN THE MAGIC KINGDOM--by Cory Doctorow.  You can read it in one evening.

Author tags:

technology, books

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
i haven't read the book and since i blog in my real name and face, perhaps i filter what i share a bit. that said, i'm glad for the freedom of expression here that can take place because of the anonymity of handles and avatars. i always learn so much.
Here are 10 Whuffies for you. Hope it is enough.
I thank you for the Whuffies, judie.

Cindy, I just read your article on using your real name as a safeguard against identity theft. Very good.

So now, I have a real self, a cyber self, and might have a false cyber self who is someone pretending to be my real self. I think all myselfs need some time alone!
One whuffie is all anyone can give, according to the rating button.
Well, you know I agree with you. Great post. Speaking of the interconnected nature of OS, I'm pretty sure our two posts are friends. I just saw them getting a beer at a bar together :-)
Yeah, that was our two posts hanging out together. They have a lot in common.
I also thought you might like this one since you blog on books so often.
Sorry, but I can't take anything "Whuffie" seriously.
Monkey picked for the use of the word "Whuffies" without using the term "Googly Googly Goo!"
You may need therapy with all those "selfs" running amok!

Well written... you've expressed what so many of us have experienced, and done so quite eloquently.
I always think of this site as a 'virtual bar' where I go meet with folks I know and plenty I don't, and the bar is full of story tellers.
I do laugh at the analogy of whuffies but it works.
I think in our naked capatalistic society we just call them bucks, or if yer canadian Loonies (if you will). What I wouldn't give for a double whuffie with cheese...
Question - is he related to E.L. Doctorow?
As far as I can tell, they are not related.

By the way, since Cory Doctorow is a huge promoter of re-defining copyright and intellectual property laws, you can down load this book from his homepage without buying it. His homepage is called craphpound.com and the link to the actual download page is http://craphound.com/down/download.php
He has basically allowed any not-for-profit re-posting of the book as well, but someone in the publishing industry likes to send bogus takedown notices to people who do.
I'm giving you Whuffie for this Grima; it's as great a metaphor for the way rates etc work in OS as I've seen anywhere. And I'm checking my library right now to see if they have "Down And Out In The Magic Kingdom." I'd just go to the bookstore and buy it, except for, well, you know, the poverty:)
Yeah, Nate, that poverty thing is a real kick to the canastas...
A bar with books? Careful Grima you don't want me to get too keyed up and whuffie you to death.
This is an interesting comparision. Whuffied.
Nanatehey,
If you don't have it, check my comment right above yours. You can download it for free.