Dr. Ayala's Blog

The latest science of healthy food and healthy living

Dr. Ayala

Dr. Ayala
Location
Philadelphia, Pennsylvania, USA
Title
V.P. Product Development
Company
Herbal Water
Bio
I’m a physician (Pediatrics and Medical Genetics), artist, and mother of 3 school age active kids. I recently co-founded Herbal Water Inc. (www.herbalwater.com) with my husband, Albert. I am a serious home cook, and love to entertain. My expertise is vegetarian food (I have been a vegetarian all my life). I strongly believe that eating healthy and enjoying good food go hand in hand. My main interests are science, nutrition and art, and I am overall a very curious person that tries to learn something new every day. Dr. Ayala (Ayala Laufer-Cahana M.D.)

MY RECENT POSTS

Dr. Ayala's Links

MY LINKS
NOVEMBER 28, 2012 7:45AM

Caffeine, coffee and type 2 diabetes

Rate: 3 Flag
Slide2

A new study of caffeinated drinks and type 2 diabetes caught my eye. I’m always on the lookout for studies on coffee, because – let’s admit it – I love coffee, and like many other coffee aficionados, I fear that someday this adored pleasure will be found a guilty one. And then what shall we do? Decide it’s worth the risk? Or convince ourselves we never really cared for this delicious, thought brightening, history-defining drink?

For coffee lovers most research news has been reassuring. Years of investigation have shown that coffee in moderation poses no threat to healthy adults – those worries about heart disease and cancer risks end up being unwarranted. What’s more, the coffee habit has even been shown to confer health benefits, and is associated with protection from Alzheimer’s and Parkinson’s disease, stoke, gallstones and liver disease.

Caffeine and diabetes

The new study, published in the American Journal of Clinical Nutrition (online ahead of press), observed a very large population of about 75,000 women and 40,000 men for more than two decades, trying to see if there’s an association between the caffeinated and caffeine-free drinks they consume and the development of type 2 diabetes.

The study looked at all types of typically caffeinated drinks: coffee, tea, sugary drinks and artificially sweetened drinks.

Over the years more than 10,000 of the people developed type 2 diabetes. There are many factors known to increase the risk of developing type 2 diabetes, such as obesity, family history of diabetes, hypertension and smoking. After controlling for those, the researchers set about to see whether caffeinated drinks made a difference.

Here’s what they found:

  • Coffee, caffeinated or decaf, was associated with a lower risk of type 2 diabetes.
  • Caffeinated tea was associated with a lower risk of type 2 diabetes.
  • Sugary drinks, both caffeinated and caffeine free, were associated with a significantly higher risk of type 2 diabetes.

Are coffee and tea protective?

It’s impossible to conclude cause and effect from these kinds of studies. The authors describe a few plausible protective mechanisms in which coffee and tea can affect diabetes: both are rich in flavonoid antioxidants, which may help in reducing inflammation. It’s likely that it’s one of the multitude of compounds in coffee and tea – or several of them acting together -- that have positive health effects, and caffeine, which we treasure for its stimulating properties, has nothing to do with the other benefits.

On the other hand, the association between sugary drinks and diabetes is very suggestive of a direct biologic effect:  sugar and high fructose corn syrup are quickly absorbed and cause spikes in blood sugar and insulin. Several studies have shown that sugary drinks are linked with diabetes independently of the weight gain associated with these drinks.

What this study shows quite well is that it’s the sugars that are associated with the development of type 2 diabetes, not the caffeine. The caffeine content of soda seems irrelevant to the risk of diabetes.

So hurray for coffee – and tea – but before you go on a coffee binge, a few words of caution: most studies showing coffee’s benefits and lack of harm looked at people drinking coffee in moderation. Coffee in moderation is fine, but that doesn’t mean that coffee in large amounts is even better – quite the opposite!

That also doesn’t mean that caffeinated drinks are healthy – it seems that energy drinks can be quite unsafe.

And it doesn't attest to caffeine’s safety for kids. These coffee and caffeine safety studies were done with adults only, and kids’ physiology is quite different.

Dr. Ayala

Image: The shrub on the right, Coffea Arabica, carries coffee berries. On the left: the familiar roasted coffee beans, which are the seeds of the plant.

Full disclosure: I’m vice president of product development for Herbal Water, where we make organic herb-infused waters that have zero calories and no sugar or artificial ingredients. I’m also a pediatrician and have been promoting good nutrition and healthy lifestyle for many years.

 

Read more from Dr. Ayala at http://herbalwater.typepad.com

Follow Dr. Ayala on Twitter

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
The way this is presented is detestable. Why are so many blogs, articles, and essays on matters medical so filled with mealy-mouthed weasel-words?

Do none of you who write these things own a freakin' measuring cup? Or a kitchen scale? Do you have any notion how much harm you do with articles that make statements like.......

""So hurray for coffee – and tea – but before you go on a coffee binge, a few words of caution: most studies showing coffee’s benefits and lack of harm looked at people drinking coffee in moderation. Coffee in moderation is fine, but that doesn’t mean that coffee in large amounts is even better – quite the opposite!""

......which use such un-scientific measures as "binge," "moderation," and "large amounts." Thanks a lot; that's a real big help......NOT! Or are you leaving it up to your readers to follow links to determine exact measures? How likely is that? Heck, even I won't do that!

Even the term "cup" when used with tea or coffee is very flexible. A proper cup is 8 oz. A restaurant cup is usually about 7 oz. A home drip coffee-maker cup is never more than 6 oz. It's no wonder that the public is even more confused by such terms and weasel-word descriptions as 'moderation' in these articles.

.
I think we need to be dubious of any medical studies involving statistics. Statistics is not science nor is it a branch of science. Those who use them often unknowingly or knowingly skew data interpretation. Especially since the funding for coffee studies is most certainly skewed by who is paying for the study and what the intent is. ie, I can take the data results from most medical studies and convince you that you aren't even who you think you are. Which is why mainstream medicine has failed us on so many levels of preventative healthcare.

Additionally, a clinician with decades of real world experience treating mood disorders, Julia Ross, has identified caffeine as a major contributor to serotonin depletion.... and mood disorders. There are other documented issues with coffee and caffeine as well. That we are a very depressed nation who is addicted to coffee might have more than a passing cause and effect.

Don't feed your confirmation bias. :p