The video above was posted on Youtube December 17th, 2010, and received over 4 million hits and over 108,000 comments. There were over 107,000 anonymous remarks on this 12 year-old girl's video; one of many similar videos by children as young as 10 that are asking the same question.
"Am I pretty or ugly?"
"Deep down inside, all girls know that other people's opinions don't matter," the young teen said. "But we still go to other people for help because we don't believe what people say."
Am I just brain dead or does that statement seem to contradict itself? It's not the Internet posting that's the issue, it's the low self-esteem and insecurity - this just has parental failure written all over it. The video has over 4 million views - why haven't the parents pulled it, and started monitoring her internet use?
"I crawled out of my mother’s womb into darkness so deep it could not be measured and some days it feels like it is still suffocating me. Days of trying to fend for myself and do the right thing have not always resulted in a positive experience or outcome. I say balderdash to those that think keeping a positive outlook will eventually give the results you are looking for. Sometimes the mire is so deep anything positive cannot find its way into your life no matter how hard it tries."
All 300-1000 of these Youtube videos by kids ask the world to decide if they are acceptable and of course the viewers do quickly and often with many hateful comments. Some commentators call the young video creators "fugly", "attention whores" and some even have the audacity to ask for sex. It just amazes me how obnoxious and mean-spirited people are on the internet and many can be just plain cruel. What makes people think it's okay to talk maliciously to someone; especially a child? Is it because they are protected by the ever-dividing internet with a screen and not dealing with a real-live human being?
If I have read correctly; Youtube's posting policy prohibits videos and comments "containing harassment, threats or hate speech" and encourages users to flag such material for review." What a joke, a policy in which the users do the work, and they deny any fault.
"Self help books crowd the bookshelves with titles that profess to make you a stronger better person. I have always been a firm believer that only you can help yourself until you wake up one morning and find yourself sinking into the quicksand. Immediately you must quickly find some sort of invisible shovel to start digging your exit as you will not find any extended helping hands around you most times."
These particular videos remind me of these communities they had on "Livejournal" a long time ago where people would post their pictures for others to vote on them being ugly or pretty. Once they had enough "uglies" or "prettys", you were inducted into the club and could go on to judge other people the same way.
Of course it has come full circle in a sense. Facebook was originally created by Mark Zuckerberg, after he spent a night using "Hot or Not" as an inspiration for drunken shenanigans, which ultimately became a precursor to his social networking endeavors.
"Maybe some of us are just asking for too much and are doomed to walk this fascinating journey full of non delicious surprises in a original theatrical cut for the rest of our lives."
Kids today have their own computers, smartphones, and they can easily access school or library computers or those of friends. Sadly the day of "parental" controls are gone as no parent can be an "overseer" 100% of the time.
We have created a world where being beautiful or handsome is the ultimate acceptance goal. Kim Kardashian is an example of a person who would be nowhere were it not for her looks, as being on television has become the measure of how you rank in the world. You can be famous now for being pregnant or acting like a drunken idiot as on MTV Shows such "Teen Mom" and "Jersey Shore". If you are not pretty, rich or famous; you are judged and bullied by your peers and kids today feel that they might never stand a chance of being loved.
The internet isn't the problem, we ourselves are the problem and social media should not be for kids. "Phineas and Ferb" on the Disney Channel have cartoon characters singing songs about surfing safely on the internet and one might think that an 8 year old might be too young to be reminded of this. After watching a lot of these videos today I now think that is the right age to be driving home that anything you post on the internet might not go away.
So many young girls with makeup asking us if they are pretty makes me sad as we live in a world where we are judged by our looks and possessions. In the end it really doesn't matter as you need to love yourself the way you are and if people don't like it-well you know.
" The love you seek is seeking you at this moment.” (Deepak Chopra)
Linda Seccaspina 2012
Quotations from my blog: Why Won't "Eat Pray Love" Help me too?
Linda Seccaspina 2012-Menopausal Woman from the Corn
Linda Blogs about this and that daily on:
Linda blogs hot celebrity gossip daily on
Ask Kirstie Whittaker how she feels in the video below as she just wants someone to love her for who she is.
Octofinder RSS Aggregator



Salon.com
Comments
JMac
Belinda: One of my sons friends as a kid was a child of a huge Christian family. He towed the line until he left home and then he made up for it in a huge way. His father had him in hockey, socceer you name it but he was not allowed to watch The Simpsons and other things. He became an alcoholic and a huge bully in his prime. I agree we should monitor our kids lives but just hope when they leave the nest that it all goes well. Kardashians are huge. All ya have to do is mention their name in a blog and the hits go out of control.
As for Kirstie, I can only imagine the courage it takes for her to go out into the world every day. If our insides and outsides could be reversed, she would outshine Kim Kardashian and all of her clones put together.
Jeanette: I was not going to post it. I had it on my other site but hummed and hawed. I have watched that Kirstie video at least a dozen times and wondered if I could even walk out the door.
r.
Children NEED attention, they check in with adults to see what they need to survive. They observe closely to see what others do to get it. Adults giving so much attention to useless motorized knick-knacks like the Kardashian girls is what young girls observe.
What use is it in being around attractive or wealthy people who make everyone around them feel terrible? Who wants to endure such people for long? The poor children, growing up in a world where many keep score with looks and money and not behavior.
R♥
Steve: you are lucky to have a smart daughter
Bleu: what is more tragic is Kirstie at the bottom.. the rest are a great concern.. but how brave she is.
Fusun; she has never done anything of importance yet the kids love this family.
PS: What jmac1949 said.
Kim needs to live like Kirsty for a few days
Kim needs to live like Kirsty for a few days
http://www.swc-cfc.gc.ca/med/news-nouvelles/2012/0308-eng.html
Linda, you have an amazing depth of feeling. The irony is that probably only came from your hardscrabble experiences. That is the gift of a difficult life. Thank you for this.
provocative post linda, as always. :)
if you wait until your child is in the midst of the horror that is puberty to work on their self-esteem, you have waited too long!
with my youngest, who had the (mis) fortune to be born (yes born!) a strikingly beautiful child, the work started almost instantly.
strangers & family members were too quick to comment on her beauty, even as a toddler and compliment her as though it was something she controlled.
I got in the habit of reminding them of her OTHER wonderful qualities. every time they would say "gawd shes so beautiful" i would say "and smart & funny & generous etc etc " in response. it was always important to me that she NOT get the message that what was wonderful & important about her was the way she looked.
we must consciously raise our children ... VERY consciously. otherwise, nothing ever changes.
A friend of mine and her daughter have both 'friended' me on facebook, which I accepted with reservations only for the fact that I don't see an 11 yr old as ready for her own fb page.
I've been horrified over the last few weeks to see the stuff that crosses that young girl's account!
What really got to me were the contests, some initiated by her and some by others, that are literally side by side slightly provocative pictures of her and another girl, labeled with their names; ________ vs. ________. Their friends then 'vote' in the comments section ("You can only vote for one, no bothsies!"), complete with inappropriate sexual comments and mean-spirited denigrations of the perceived "loser" girl (usually my friend's daughter.).
I asked her mother if she was aware of her daughter's fb activity/contests, and she really just shrugged it off.
It breaks my heart to read the frequent confused fallout postings, ("why doesn't anybody love me", or "why doesn't anyone think I'm beautiful?"), and as I live a state away I've chosen to support the girl best as I can with private message reminders that every girl is beautiful in her own right, with her own strengths and talents - there is no competition. And I resist the urge to slap some parental sense into her mom.
I'm sharing that last video with both of them as well.
Walter: I put posts up there when the sun sets at night as it is too hard in the morning with all the writing 'work' I have. Open Salon is and will always be my first love and the writers on here are my closest friends. I may write on other sites now but this is my home and need to post at least once a week. You are my beloved friends.
Sheila; Thank you for being my friend..HUGGGGGGG
Lorianne: Just looking at you I know your daughter has to be a Goddess. Wise words and we need to keep repeating them for what's next? Good Mum you are, thank you.
BUT I cannot believe her mother cannot see this. Thank goodness she has you.
If they do not get Kirstie.. I just don't know
With both my kids I've tried to loosen the reins slowly. For them to be equipped to be on their own by the time they leave, its got to be a process. From managing money to laundry and peer pressure. Its a tough transition at best.
I boycott the Kardashians. And again, excellent piece.
Asia: I liked Crabby's comment of no webcams.. but how do you monitor them if they are not at home? Hard times to raise kids..
Jeanette: I had boys.. still s tough job. I cannot even imagine what it is like today with the the internet changing all the time
Gerald: Yup they are kind enough to ask for sex.. just awful
Razzle: I used to speak about eating disorders starting at Grade 6.. Younger and younger every year
for these kids today as I had it way back when in the 80's.
Lookism.
Except: now i go on facebook once and awhile
and see what happened to all the beautiful people from back then.
I was roundly criticized by my aesthetic minded peers in
my teens...
for my appearance...
it made me ashamed and disgusted at my own flesh.
Thankfully there were books...to escape......
To any young person who looks in the mirror,
i give this suggestion:
first, focus on your own eyes.
look yrself straight in the eyes.
that is where your soul is.
blur out your face.
gradually, include your face with yr eyes.
So, you tell them and tell them and tell them and they still go do dumbass stuff. And you help them put back the pieces and say "I wish you didn't have to learn every lesson the hard way and that you'd just listen to me." And maybe once they do. And then they don't and you are soothing a broken heart or spirit again. Because they push, they fall and we help them get back up. Teach the lessons again.
I always knew I was better equipped to have sons, and sons was what I fervently wished I'd have...and do have.
I didn't consider much how it would be for them with their girlfriends...one son yelled at me once, " You didn't prepare me for girls! You don't have bucketloads of makeup, you don't stare in the mirror for ages, you didn't help me prepare for girls at all!"
Of course, when I WAS a bit like that, I didn't have kids...hopefully these girls will grow up and out of it too. Too bad this seems rare -- so many women just keep staring as they get older and then choose surgery, whether a good idea for them or not. Eeek. Some surgery whatever, your choice, but over and over??
Such a sad state of affairs...
Thoth: what happened to playing outside?
Thanks Kevin..
Keri: so right, I never had anyone to do that but wish I did.
Zuma: bad lighting??:)
Just thinking: I wrote a blog on another network where this plastic surgeon did boob jobs on his 21 yr old daughter and her friends. Who is encouraging who?
Thanks Scanner
Terrific post, Linda.
If more people just accepted the fact that they're ugly, and maybe get on with their lives and do something useful, this might be a better world.
Fernsy: I am so glad I am who I am and am old
Neutron: NO one is beautiful and I doubt you are ugly. But you are right let us just get on with living..
DH: when mothers do not take down the videos what can we do?
Thankfully. :)
You've shined a light on some painful, sick stuff here. I thought we started changing all this in the 60s...
Scarlett: eating disorders and competing with each other has grown like a wild seed. If one parent sees this and thinks about it then I have done my job.
Maureen: who knows; maybe it just wasn't an important enough topic.
Muse; it get worse every darn day one only has to look at Facebook. If you don't think your daughter is doing this if you have a young teen check
Various: those shows are at least three volumes in itself
I love Life: parents are so busy right now that kids are a secondary factor..
Algis: from the beginning of time
Erica: That girl should be famous for how she is.
Jack: You are right.. and the republicans are tearing down women even more. God help us all if the get in
Just frightening
Your article is well done as always, but it is disturbing to me that we spend so much time engrossed in artificial things. I just turned on the television about 6 months ago (hadn't watched in 20 years). I cannot believe the things that people enjoy. The state of the world comes as no shock when I consider what is influencing people.
Parents need to teach their kids not to ask the question, "Am I pretty or ugly?" cause trust me, the answer is going to be UGLY no matter what.
The Internet is filled with trolls and stalkers, and not the nice stalkers either who leave presents on your front porch but more like kidnap your dog and eats it!! :(
Self esteem has never been my strong point, and from what I've seen on my run of life here on Planet Earth, a lot of people have the same issues!!!
Kids, be kids, don't worry if you're pretty or not, till you hit high school and even then, don't worry, very few people there are pretty....
RATED!
Such craziness!
Thanks again for bringing the important stuff to us with your most accessable way...
HUGGGGGGGGGGG
Thanks too, for all that took time to read my long first response to this post.
The 11 yr old child I referenced in that comment has this as her fb status today, regarding having broken up with no less than the third "boyfriend" in as many weeks:
"It sucks NOT HAVING A BOYFRIEND I'm single ANYONE can have ME!!!!!!!!!!!!!! :D Just inbox Me if yu wanna go out with ME!!!!!!!!!!! :D"
What do I say to this young girl...or her mother...that can make a difference in the face of such low self-value? I'm at a complete loss.
Donegal: you are so right..
Barb: Glad to hear you are okay.. I am getting better.. writing 14 hours a day does not help:)
I see the same thing from some kids back home and just worry that these kids are going to get into trouble. Some feel so much power on there and others do not like your neighbour.
Anyone can have me??? Now Id make sure her mother saw that.
That is scary.