I joined OS one year ago, Dec. 11 2008. I was elated when I discovered it purely by accident, but also maddened to realize that it had existed so long by internet standards without me knowing about it. My first post was about my mother, who she used to be, and who she is now. A cri de couer that found a welcome reception. I was off to the races. I immediately became friends with several of the people who joined around the same time as me, and those friendships led to many, many more. Many of the friendships have endured, some have not. Virtual reality is much the same as "real" reality in that regard. Some people, like some situations, run their course and it's nobody's fault.
I haven't been a prolific writer at OS, I've never written more than one post in a day, and I don't blog daily or even weekly. This is the first blog post I've written in a month. When I first alighted at OS, I thought I would be writing mostly journalistic and critical work. What emerged were intensely personal explorations of my life that shocked me. In that sense, writing here has proved cathartic.
Despite the scarity of posts, I have gotten a fair share of attention, the majority of it favourable. Sometimes that surprises me. I've always had strong opinions. I am quixotic as an OS friend noted. It's a truism of my life that people either like me or loathe me; they "get" me or they don't. To quote Popeye, "I yam what I yam." Those who don't "get" or like me have made it known, but writing on a public blog means taking the brickbats along with the bouquets.
I write under the pseudonym "emma peel," one of my childhood television heroines from The Avengers. Some bloggers at OS have suggested that I am somehow "hiding" behind it, and that my opinions would be different if I blogged under my legal name. They don't know me very well. Following the crowd has never been my forte, although at times I might wish it otherwise. Using an alias online does not make me unique, or a coward.
I don't spend much time at OS any more. I was a reading and commenting fiend for a long time, and in retrospect, my writing suffered because of it. Commenting comes easily to me because it's similar to what I do for a living, and yes, it's an excuse not to write, while still writing something. I don't comment much any more, although I still read a great deal under the radar.
The zeitgeist is a major factor in why I no longer comment much. Many bloggers on a writers, artists and photographers' site as OS bills itself, have stated unequivocally that they want praise in their comment fields or nothing at all. Unless specifically (and very rarely) requested, the now-not-so-unwritten rule is that feedback and dissenting opinions are not welcome. People can post them, but they won't like the blowback. I understand what fuels that perspective, but I don't share it. It does not reflect my long-term goals as a writer, or OS member. I like giving and receiving compliments as much as anyone, but I prefer the truth, here and elsewhere. That's how I learn and improve my craft. I react to writing and ideas by how they make me feel, not by how I think I should feel, or by how someone else might want me to feel. Perhaps that is a failing on my part. Or maybe it's just OS burnout.
When I look back on my year at OS, I see it as one of the more positive experiences of my recent life. Being here got me writing again, got me thinking creatively again, and connected me to some wonderful people I would not have met otherwise. It felt like home to me for a long time. But it isn't as welcoming to me now. Although I have many friends new and old, OS feels colder, more hostile, even alien to me at times. The sheer influx of members means when I look at the feed, I don't recognize most of the names. Many members do not have avatars, which I find off putting. Several long-time members/friends have left, or rarely post or comment, and I miss them. I am aware of the irony that I am becoming one of those people.
Maybe this is normal. Maybe sites like this -- although I've never belonged to anything quite like OS before –– have a creative shelf life, and then the novelty wears off and the inevitable comings and goings and other sea changes take their toll. I have also changed in the year since I joined, and it's entirely possible that everything I've just written has no value to anyone but me. Only time will tell. I'm still going to wish myself a heartfelt happy OS anniversary that includes everyone here whose writing and lives have touched mine. What a long strange trip it's been.


Salon.com
Comments
:-)
I remember you had a few terrific pieces you specifically posted for critique and I really enjoyed some of the "writer" talk you got going on in the comments. It was like a real workshop like a writing class. I am sorry there isn't more of that here.
Anyway I've always admired your honesty and your principals. Plus you are a gifted and insightful writer.
You are one of the best here.
Time is accelerated and a year seems like ten in real life. People come and people go. I have only been here for seven months or so and I still feel like a newcomer. The thing is I think each of us have to take what we need from a site such as this and not worry too much about how long it lasts or what it will become.
I think there is something here for almost everyone, they just have to decide what it is they need. I have read your blog and more importantly, your comments to other blogs since I came here and over all I have enjoyed the experience. I hope to be able to read your comments and your blog for a lot longer, just to speak on a selfish level. One thing I can count on with you is honesty, whether you agree with me or not and I value that in a person.
Rated.
Let nobody ever say we don't know where you stand.
denese: I'm glad that you're here, too.
spotted_mind: Thanks!
Chuck: Aw, I'm blushing now. And yes, there is always a rise and fall in the tides.
MJwycha: I didn't realize/remember that I was the first to comment on your blog. The pleasure was mine. And thanks for noticing the rest of what you mentioned.
Darryl Ross: I welcome new bloggers, but I guess I am a traditionalist at heart. OS just seems so big to me now, and more impersonal.
Cat: Complex or crazy? I'm not sure either, :).
Lunchlady2: Thank you. Sometimes I forget to have fun. I need to work on that.
Torman: There is a lot of food for thought in your comment. I never thought about time being accelerated online, but it is true. I appreciate your honesty as well. It is an underrated value in my opinion!
I've spent the last 3 years on another "writer's" site that helped me discover a voice that I'd only suspected I might have. I also made some amazing friends there, and if we hadn't hooked up in a private group, I may never have had the courage to leave.
That site has truly become a joke, and when I compare what's going on there to what I'm seeing here, I feel hope. I wish I had found this place a lot sooner.
Happy anniversary. I've been here for just a couple of months. I'm still excited to see what happens over time.
Happy Anniversary!
http://joshfulton.blogspot.com/2009/12/google-expands-tracking-to-logged-out.html
Cheers to you, and may our partnership continue. xo
And damn, woman. You can wear a catsuit like no one's business.
Rated
Rated.
OK, here's a truth for you: I want to see more of your writing, and I really don't care what name you use. Hell, I don't use my own name, why would I expect someone else to?
We joined, it would appear, with a few days of each other last year, and I too, when looking down the list of my friends, see some notable absences. In most of the cases, I wish they were still here, and I'd hate you to join their number.
Second: I have never been able to understand why some people get so upset with you. But then I've adored you from the day I waltzed into this playground. You're writing is always clear and concise and your arguments are seldom ambiguous (maybe that's why they get upset). You're support and generosity have meant a lot to me. And I'm not always easy to support. Sometimes I like to think of this site as an online sanctuary, something like Rick's Cafe Americain from Casablanca, and we're a lot of refugees looking for the letters of transit. Anyway, you're something special. Here's looking at you, kid.
Happy Blogiversary. There are a few folks here that aren't afraid to leave a constructively critical comment, or send one via PM. Those people I appreciate, because those people help me figure out what I'm doing wrong. Which, of course, leads me to doing more right. :-D
Stay as you are, Emma Peel. Using a pseudonym isn't hidiing - there are thousands of professional writers who don't publish under their given names. So what?
True that, Miss Emma.
Happy Anniversary. I get the burn out thing as I've been here over a year, too. I would also like to say that I understand everything you've mentioned here and feel very similar. I would also like to say that I'm glad that you joined OS and I've always enjoyed your work.
May your next year at OS be whatever is best for you.
Looking forward to another year.
Happy Blogiversary!
Enjoy it and keep writing because you do it very well.
Kisses!
Marcela
I've always thought your writing as a milepost of what it would take to be a writer, truthful, edited and having a point. You are direct and to the point and I admire someone who stands for what they believe, whether or not I agree 100% or not. I can't remember a post where I did not find myself nodding either yes or no...that is amazing to me. Thank you for all you have given, and like others, I hope you do continue to post when the mood strikes.
I think it's normal that there's an ebb and flow here, much like there'd be if you were at school. Only at school we get holidays off.
And Happiest of Anniversaries.
Goodness, look at the number of comments you have here now. You're still an important individual to lots. OS does have its ups and downs just like any living, breathing entity.
But you are right about the numbers. I look and see middling writing especially on topical stuff: Tiger Woods for example. Ugh! I look for original writings instead.
I see the people who've left comments here and 99% of them I recognize. Those are the people I concentrate on, not on the editors who basically put the same people on the cover over and over again, or the "writers" who don't even other to put a pic. I guess they're extra shy!
With my crazy rambling aside, happy anniversary!! We want you here again, more if possible.
;)
OS is a monster these days; it's hard to stay on top of it all. I do hope that you'll stick around and keep writing here as your time permits. Your voice is an important one and one that would surely be missed. XOXO
I feel the kinship of acknowledging that OS has helped me to write more/again. I know that I am not always going to get what I want. ( Frankly, I hate that; I always want what I want!!) I like the comments because it implies readership.
Unlike you, I have not generated controversy. I do not know what that feels like and yet, I think, damn, she got to people!
Would we be friends in real life? I am not sure... But I do know I respect you and your writing. I know I am a person who welcomes honest feedback. I welcome honest back-n-forth, and I do not require same ness. Hmm, must be why I have enjoyed our back and forths...
Happy blogoversary. And cheers as we raise the drink of our choice!
Emma, I was fortunate to stumble across you shortly after you joined. I admire your ability and more so your integrity. Happy Blogiversary.
As it says in my OS bio: Everything changes.
Well I love your writing anyway! I also fully understand your frustrations, delusions, disappointments, etc. I've come to suffer some of them myself, and in less than six months. And I too have slowed down, realizing I could not give this site the time it requires to enjoy it as I like. I can't read that many posts, can't write that many comments and most of all, can't read that many comments (all of which I feel (self) compelled to do if I visit someone's work. It is an addiction of sorts, in some respects more compelling than one that is physical.
I've also struggled with what to comment. Some posts move me to comment on content ... agree, ,debate, etc. While others are just heart-moving ... revealing pain, joy, family, neighborhoods, personal history, etc. ... all motivating me to resp0nd in kind. Some just make me laugh. Yet others seem to seek editorial input ... or garner it ... as responders offer a variety of grammatical advice. And I am disappointed there is little offered that is fictional. I love good fiction.
But it is what it is ... and it has no initiation requirements ... so all are welcome ... even those I don't enjoy. I think that's why its called "Open" Salon. I have come to accept that. And I accept that there's room for everybody ... every taste, every persuasion, every temperament. Those who don't fulfill my reading needs and desires don't have to be read.
In fact I almost exclusively only read those who I've marked as favorites. They offer more than I can say grace over. And you, (fake) Emma, are among them. So I hope you stick around, and if you do, you continue to post. I appreciate your Canadian input into this crazy potpourri of ideas and thoughts.
Have a Happy Anniversary, Emma!
I've been part of a couple of writers' groups in the past, and learned very quickly that there aren't a lot of folks out there who really have the guts to do meaningful critique. It certainly isn't the easiest thing. It's harder still when you're in a public, online community, where you feel some sense of community but don't fully know all the people around you.
You're part of what has made OS a rich experience for me. I hope you'll stick around for all of us to celebrate your blogiversary again.
You being true to yourself and having a strong sense of self impressed me when I first "met" you here. Emma Peel would never "wish it otherwise."
But I'm glad you wrote this post. I says many of the things I've been thinking. This place, for me, is really what you make it. Something that's true of writing in general. It's good for some people. Not good for others. OS is an important part of my life, but I'm glad the short time when it was my life is over. And I'm very curious to see where it's headed.
I could have written that.
I should have written that.
From someone who was never a big fan of yours, I have come to find that you often speak for me. I've learned to pay attention to you. I've come to respect you.
Happy anniversary.
thoughtful post.
I'm glad your still here.
It's a great Place to learn.
I still remember your pain.
I recall -
That courageous` Father post.
Was that ever sad. But, thanks.
That open-sharing seared deep.
I believe in - Share experiences!
I realize I over do [!] an exclaim!
But, if I'm venting [!] it is to feel.
Exchanging ideas changes Lives.
A 'idea' is Light Bulbs turned on.
Or,
It's a lit-wick candle in the dark.
Ideas.
I heard "Idea" is literally a`Light.
Well, it's to try to embrace Other.
No One should agree all the time.
We humans interact. Folks banter.
`
I say this`This Open Salon opportunity is to open hearts, and choose to participate. If we withdraw into pensive moods, and cower in Fear, and never engage in constructive interaction, well, maybe we might shrivel up like a mummy. Politicos Fear sharing their individual opinion. They lift their finger in the air to feel the wind whiffs.
Worst!
They sniff!
Seek flattery!
Generally, not you?
You have strong idea.
You like a feisty fight?
That sharpens our Mind.
It's like two axes sparking.
The sparks ascend upward.
That's good. No intended pain.
If someone has stinky armpit?
We citizens ought to tell them?
Yes. Then they might be kissed?
ho ho bright shiny nose heehaw!
If we don't tell, they get scorned!
A crueler person will ridicule too.
I remember discovering you when you first joined, and I remarked you were my favorite new writer. Although you havent been prolific, I have watchedfor and read most of your stuff and still feel the way I did when I first found you here. So, thanks Emma, and hope to have the priviledge of continuing to read you.
well, I wonder where that leaves me?? I agree with you sometimes, disagree with you other times. That seems good and healthy to me. Whatever you write, I always feel you're speaking truthfully and being yourself, which is no small thing. And as others have said, I do think of you as Emma Peel, who I admired as a young girl watching that show, too!
So many fine people joined at or around the time I did and I'm relieved that many are still here, and commented. Some also commented privately. Many worthy new members have joined OS and it was great to see their comments, too. More later....
:D
"When I first alighted at OS..." You are so eloquent I can barely stand it.
thanks for the lovely words emmapeel!
And the real Emma Peel was my major crush in the formative years.
I grew up in the New York Post City Room where there was often blood on the floor by the time the paper went to press at 8 AM. And I mean that literally. I started working at the post when I was 19 years old, and if there was one thing I learned from that experience it was to appreciate good, solid, negative feedback.
I didn't know there was an unwritten rule about negative feedback. As far as I am concerned, that's about as stupid as holding an ice cream cone upside down so that it won't drip on your hand.
By internet standards, OS is pretty stable, people tend to be nice and polite, and it tends to be extremely civilized. I speak based on my experiences with financial blogging, among others.
But compared to what we might expect in the real world -- face to face, people -- things do move quickly. People join every day and also every day someone writes their last post -- usually unannounced.
Take what you need, give what you want. Like communism only it sort of works. And congrats for hanging around a full year.
You were one of the first writers I read here before joining. I mentioned my respect for you in one of my early posts. Occasionally I see your place in the two-sided coin of comments. What you've expressed is also my conclusion of your presence, you know yourself. Comments here, for me, are the Achilles' heel . I sincerely appreciate those who read and take time to comment. I especially appreciate those whose comments help me grow as a writer. The process of commenting, however, is often difficult for me. This one wasn't. Happy Anniversary.
I'm here to write, and it's good to hear that OS did that for you. The virtual world is suspect, isn't it? I mean are we really supposed to connect without our bodies? We humans exist in the imaginal realm a great deal of the time. We do make virtual connections, we're capable of doing that—but we should always question it.
BTW, were do you live? Just a hint?
Carry On!
Maybe Freaky can bake a cake?
You know, we can't be all cookies and ice cream all the time. We'd be robots if we always agreed with everyone. And for people to feel uneasy about someone who speaks her mind shows much more about them than you. (or me)
OS has changed in a lot of ways for me too. It seems to have taken on another form. I definitely think you should post more (like you have the time!). And, of course, I say that having not posted anything of substance in a very long time.
Glad you're here, Em!
Thank you for this honest - often vulnerably so - post. I hope you’ll remain at OS.
As you pointed out, comments need not always be positive or encouraging to be helpful. In the long run a sincere reproof can serve us far better than a deceitful pat on the back.
I think there’s an Emperor someone who would agree with that too.
Rated and appreciated.
Hope that you will still be in our comments as a visitor.
I also found many many new names when I came back after a short hiatus but also found many old friends still here and blogging away.
As cartouche said, I've been robbing time from elsewhere to spend here, and I am also working on a project that is taking up a lot of my energies. I can't promise to spend more time here at the moment, but I do plan on writing a Christmas post for Christmas Day.
In the meantime, I want to wish everyone at OS -- and I do mean everyone -- the best of the season.
Rated
Little do the others know how many dissenting comments you delete from your posts.
I just wrote a quite nice response to your PM and my cat accidentally deleted it. So I will answer you here.
If you ever took the time to actually read any of blog posts of the past year, you would see that many negative comments about me stand. I made a decision a while back to no longer tolerate comments on my blog that do not discuss the topic, but exist only as ad hominem attacks on me. To date, you have never made one comment about me on my blog, or on many others' blogs, that hasn't been a flat-out broadside against me. I am not the only woman to whom you display this treatment, but I am apparently the one who has angered you the most.
If you should ever choose to actually write a comment that is not a personal attack, I will be happy to let it stand. I would be even happier to read a blog post of YOURS that isn't a personal diatribe against an OS member. You have some writing talent -- it would be interesting to see what might emerge if you could knock that chip off your shoulder long enough to write a post on something that actually engages readers instead of insults them.
In the meantime, I wish you a happy holiday season, and hope that you will take this comment in the spirit in which it was written.
I will never understand the urge to delete comments from a post. What is the harm in leaving the comment there for all to see? If my comment is flawed, then that should be all the more reason to leave it posted for all to see.
You get 99% agreement on all of your posts. Without my comments here, you'd have 100% agreement.
It is such a bore to read through the comments section on most posts here at OS. There is way too much patting on the back here. None of these sycophantic comments, none of them, will help you become a better writer. My criticism of you and your writing is the best gift anyone will give you. All of these sappy sycophantic fools offer you nothing but phony praise.
If you truly had any respect for yourself, the art of writing, and your own work, you'd delete 99% of the comments posted on your blog.
" Our strength grows out of our weakness. Not until we are pricked and stung and sorely shot at, awakens the indignation which arms itself with secret forces. A great man is always willing to be little. Whilst he sits on the cushion of advantages, he goes to sleep. When he is pushed, tormented, defeated, he has a chance to learn something; he has been put on his wits, on his manhood; he has gained facts; learns his ignorance; is cured of the insanity of conceit; has got moderation and real skill. The wise man always throws himself on the side of his assailants. It is more his interest than it is theirs to find his weak point. The wound cicatrizes and falls off from him like a dead skin and when they would triumph, lo! he has passed on invulnerable. Blame is safer than praise. I hate to be defended in a newspaper. As long as all that is said is said against me, I feel a certain assurance of success. But as soon as honied words of praise are spoken for me I feel as one that lies unprotected before his enemies. In general, every evil to which we do not succumb is a benefactor. As the Sandwich Islander believes that the strength and valor of the enemy he kills passes into himself, so we gain the strength of the temptation we resist." - R.W. Emerson
I do not believe that I have to delete all positive posts, just as I do not have to delete all negative ones. This post is about me, and it's also a meta post, but it is not the kind of post that is going to generate much critiquing. I have specifically asked for, and received, critques of my writing in the past, and most people here know -- even if they've only read this post -- that I do not shy away from honest, constructive critques of my writing. I came out of journalism, and as sagemerlin noted, I'm used to blood on the floor early in the morning. It's about the work, not me, but in this case, my post is about my process at OS, and not a work of fiction, or criticism, or even memoir.
As one who has been here about the same length as you, I will say that if you ever go away completely, it would be a great loss to this website! Don't feel pressured to contribute more than you want to! (I myself have written much less than you have in this past year, but I still feel included).
I agree with you on the use of avatars and pseudonyms. I dig the Avengers too (along with most British sci-fi). I relate to you as a fellow university academic. (my favorite post of yours is the "RateMyStudents.com" one from a few months back")
My blog-identity is something of an alter-ego, but no less truly "me". A secret identity is more a safeguard against my students anonymously posting crap-comments or bringing my less-serious posts up in class discussion.
I also see the lack of an avatar as an indicator that a blogger is less-than-serious.
Anyway, thanks for being here and making this a better cyberspace.
I, too, want honesty in feedback. I'm often trying out ideas, wondering if any other people think as I do, trying to process that as a writer. Of course I don't want nastiness in return (or too many random brickbats), but it all does come with the territory.
As a newbie on OS I appreciate that you comment on my writing sometimes. Congratulations on a year an OS! I hope to see more of your writing in the future. It's great to have a place to post our opinions, and find people who will read them, and comment.
Don't know why people dislike comments from people who disagree, though. I always find those to be the most interesting. A pat on the back is nice, but it doesn't encourage me to respond. What can I say, other than "thanks"?
Happy anniversary, Ms Peel! (And sorry I'm so late, and that I didn't disagree with you on this occasion.)
What I hoped when I joined open salon that is was more about ideas and less about style. There are many very smart people in this one place. Perhaps I was naive in thinking that these smart members actually wanted to leave their comfortable existence. I think I was looking for an argument.
What I got in my very sparse postings was more like the not stated and unamed Monty Python/Wizard of Oz room of ignore the man behind the screen. I never got argument, I never got contradiction. Boredom was down the hall.
Perhaps it was too tedious or too boring. The curse of the scientist.
I would love you to stay. You are a wonderful writer and I enjoy your style.