I've been thinking about memory a lot lately. Many here at OS write about their experiences as very young children of two or three years old. I can only marvel at their ability to remember their childhoods from such an early age. I have only one memory of being very young. I am four, and I am standing on the small porch of our house in the country. It is stormy outside with hissing wind and dark clouds high above in the prairie sky. I am wearing a robin's egg blue wool sweater and it is scratchy. That's it. There's nothing more until I go to school, and even that is hazy. My entire childhood is a blur.
I don't know why I can't remember more. Sometimes I think it is post traumatic stress disorder, the result of a chaotic and violent upbringing. Other times I wonder if it's the result of too many recreational drugs when I was a teenager and young adult. When I visited relatives I hadn't seen for a long time last summer, they told me things about my childhood of which I had absolutely no recollection. I was fascinated.
Occasionally on that visit, one of my aunts would mention an event or situation, and a phrase or a scent would awaken something in my consciousness, but nothing ever came fully to the surface. I have mostly accepted that memories from my early past will continue to sleep undisturbed. But what about the memories and emotions I associate with material objects?
As I contemplate moving house, I have been thinking a lot about stuff lately. Why I have it, why I keep it, and would I still have the memories associated with my belongings if they were no longer mine? This morning I held a pair of slightly too-small burgundy suede shoes in my hand that I haven't worn in at least 15 years. I know I should get rid of them, but when I look at them I remember a more adventurous time in my life when I travelled for work and stayed in five-star hotels. I was sitting with friends one night in the bar at the Four Seasons in Los Angeles when a sophisticated man came up to me and complimented me on those very shoes. He said something like, "I can tell that you aren't from here because your shoes are very elegant, not like the trashy high heels they wear here." I was flattered, but one of my male friends told me it was just a pickup line. I don't think so. Still, it occurs to me that I can have the memory without hanging onto the shoes.
I envy my friends who can toss posessions from clothes to family heirlooms aside and not bat an eye. A woman I know has a pact with her husband that if they haven't worn something in six months, it has to be given away. They wear some pretty odd combinations of clothes at times, but their closets and drawers are a marvel of organization and style. She has what she calls "memory totes" in the attic of her house, carefully tended bags with small objects representing important occasions. I did not know her at this time, but these friends are legendary for selling their house and everything in it and moving into a new house with all new things. They frequently visit the house where they used to live since they sold it to friends, and drink out of the wineglasses they left behind and sit on "their" sofa. It helps to be wealthy as they are, but it is the intent, and the willingness to let go, that fascinates me.
Sometimes I think I hang onto things because I haven't felt rooted anywhere since I was 10 when my father died and we moved to a strange city away from relatives. I've never owned a home, and even now, live at the mercy of capricious and unpleasant landlords. I've been robbed of many people in my life, and also robbed of most of my possessions, including an entire household of furniture, personal mementoes and what scant family heirlooms I possessed. But that is a topic for another post.
NOTE: I have "borrowed" the title of this post from Gerald Nicosia's wonderful biography of Jack Kerouac, Memory Babe.


Salon.com
Comments
R because I like your writing...
I'm all for purging of household objects and clothes. I'm merciless when it comes to my closet, but if a particular object has special meaning for you, if you'd write a story about that object and then pass that story down to someone you love, then keep it. Items like that are no longer mere "clothes."
Take a picture of those burgundy shoes and write a post about them. (Wow, that makes me think of Patty Griffin's song about the burgundy shoes.)
Interesting post, and well done. Thanks for this. I don't think it was a pick-up line; I believe it was a genuine compliment. I'd hang onto those shoes.
Lezlie
You probably know this better than I do. Memories are so tricky to decipher. This was very interesting, especially since I can remember being in my crib, maybe 18 months old, vividly. Crazy, huh?
R
thanks for stirring up the pot
As for memories, I don't think you're that odd. I have one distinct memory of being 3 years old and sneaking into my mother's closet to get one of my birthday cards (it had a paper doll inside). That's probably close to my earliest memory.
Thank you all for your comments.
I hang onto some clothes ripe with memory too. I have a few suede and velvet vests from the seventies I haven't been able to part with. Funny, huh?
@Bellwether Vance: I don't know that song, but will look for it on YouTube. Maybe I should take a pic of the shoes but they actually look better on my foot than off. I need someone like you to help me purge because I am not very ruthless.
@Lunchlady 2: I think like you, which is the way my mother thought, which is why I have so damn much stuff!
@Kathy: I have a feeling those shoes aren't going anywhere.
@L in the Southeast: It's strange, but most of what I do remember is not good.
@diary of a food addict: I liked your story. The problem is, I do have lots of new shoes. :)
@consonantsandvowels: I believe my friend hired a professional organizer who had the idea of memory totes. It's a good one.
@junk1: I agree. I won't push.
@dianaaani: I guess I need to get better at packing!
@kissing lessons: Yes, I am the oldest. I never thought of that being a reason, but it makes sense.
@Chuck: You are a wise man.
@catnmus: Good for you. I used to get a lot of free T-shirts at one point in my life and I am down to 3 now that I just can't bring myself to throw out.
@Scarlett: Funny you should say that. I have a long velvet, gold braid, and silk vest that I can't bear to part with either.
@Robin: That is what I am working on -- being present now. It's hard but necessary.
I have moved a number of times. Some after more than a decade, and commensurate accumulation of books, clothes, furniture and memories. Shedding stuff can be very freeing. It is just stuff mostly. Some of it is important stuff, but most of cart around a lot of extraneous junk that we don't need.
Getting rid our baggage, tangible and intangible can be traumatic but after the feeling can be as if one has suddenly shed many pounds, lighter and unburdened.
Let go.
@Ablonde: I remember reading that piece about your childhood. It was very moving. I have let go of quite a bit -- not all of it voluntarily -- but there is much more that needs to go.
I have the same problem I can't remember anything before I turned 13 years old. Sometimes something, is said, or done, and or see something, maybe a certain smell, then a memory comes to my mind.
I only know my childhood, before 13yrs old, because of what family has told me , the stories about my childhood.
From 13yrs old, to teenage year,s young adult and adult, I can memory everything like it just happened yesterday, and they play back in my mind like a movie, very vivid and very detailed.
Wonderful post and very thought provoking.
Thank you!
stress/memories.problem.
"I am wearing a robin's egg blue wool sweater and it is scratchy. That's it. "
your.writing.is.like.my.favorite.white.button.down
after.it.has.been.dry.cleaned.
a.crisp,cool.classic.feel
Here is something tangential but perhaps illustrative of "extra-memory" type images we accept as our own:
For me, my earliest memory is what I would call pre-verbal in that its pictures but no words. I remember seeing my parents talking in the kitchen while I stood in a crib and tried to get their attention. When they didnt respond, I broke a glass bottle over the crib bars. They came running. I've often wondered if it is a real memory or a cobbled together set of images from other things.
When younger I couldn't toss anything away and I lived in literal chaos. Now I toss everything and find myself missing needed things.
I only had a few childhood memories until my abuse memories broke. Now, I remember so much (and more is still coming). It's interesting when processing them, as they usually come in parts. Not once have they been fluid. With all of the 2nd and 3rd parts I've integrated, there is only more truth, nothing contradicting the previous parts.
So, I believe memories have truth, as long as they have the proper context given to them. Alluring piece Emma.
PTSD is definitely something you should consider identifying (with). That need for self protection is fierce.
(I, too, was surprised to get to the end of this - expecting two more beautifully crafted paragraphs at least! I guess I have a sense for your writing.)
AND
I dreamed last night
Of my wife, and we were young.
And the fury of love filled me.
And she felt distress I should look at her
With such immense passion and delight.
And she turned her face down and away.
And I took her shoulder and turned her to me.
And I drank her in as we walked the evening street
On cobblestones up a steep hill
In Paris or Grenoble or Helsinki.
And the world was wonderful.
Post traumatic stress disorder is not repressed memories. In PTSD the memories are at the surface and certain things trigger the memory. A person who was shot at jumps at loud noises. A person who was raped by someone wearing a certain cologne may get nauseous smelling that cologne.
Repressed memories are extremely rare, now you are delving into the world of multiple personality disorder also known as disociative identity disorder.
There were a lot of crackpots in the 90's who claimed to be repressed memory therapists.The talkshows ate it up! Basically they would hypnotize people who had depression or other issues and under hypnosis tell them all kinds of false horrible things that their parents did. This still goes on. ABC had a special about one guy named Meinke, a real wacko. So many families were torn apart by these quacks. A friend got sucked in by one of these weirdos.
As far as people who can remember back to 18 months, yes it is possible. Something made an impression on them, or their brain is wired differently. Some people have photographic memories.
I can recall back to four months old, that was the turning point for my leg braces, the treatment got more aggressive and more painful.
I clearly remember my parents fighting and my dad saying "Damn it if we don't start these new ones she'll never walk" Lots of epinephrine and norepinephrine produced in those days. My sister's earliest memory is falling off the back of the truck and cutting her leg at five years old. Disneyland is wasted on anyone under 5!
As far as stuff goes, if it makes you happy and you don't have 14 pianos and paths of newspapers and tv dinner trays threatening to tumbledown on you, what the heck. Enjoy it!
I am often said to be a walking history book, the things I remember. But for me, as a memory my childhood doesn't begin until somewhere around 4 or 5. I remember where I lived. I remember pets. And I remember a variety of specific events, but the have no chronology; they simply occurred ... and they are limited. My chronological memories begin around age 6 when I entered first grade. Maybe it is that structure, the structure of school and friends that gives them order.
But whatever memories lie in your possessions, think of them as photos ... a graphic reflection of a prior time. Then dump the ones that are lousy; keep the ones that are good. I am sure that is what our brains do. {{{R}}}
Rated because I remembered to (and because I remember, too).
I really liked this view of you.
Good luck, it's a little like brain surgery on yourself.
R
Memories are strange, they will sometimes mix into my dreams like, "Hi!! I'm here for a bit, but I'll be gone when you awake!!"
**nodding and rating** **wandering off**