I grew up listening to and enjoying country music. This was the 70's and early 80's. I am old school. I am not fond of the modern crossover tween scene. Carrie Underwood does not have the same feeling of the Dolly Parton songs of my youth. Tanya Tucker was too risque for my young heart.
But I loved the music, the emotional, fun, joyful music. My favorites were Parton, Cash, and Rogers.
And then I noticed something, as I became a politically aware teenager. There were no black singers except Charley Pride. I decided that I like rock and roll better due to some southern rock influences and I made no more of it.
But I looked at the CMA channel the other day, just to see the top 100 songs of the year on late night and I noticed something disturbing to me.
There are no black singers, some musicians, and some video dancers. So I recorded it, thinking that I just didn't notice them. And I found something truly disturbing. Of the hundred best videos of last year, I only saw 4 black performers that were not dancers or video actors. We are talking about hundreds of people in videos and 100 songs to sort from.
It has been 20 years. The country just elected a black president.
This means that country music and black people are still not on board with each other. Other music genres are still not completely integrated, but VH1 and MTV show videos with a good selection of crossover performers and pop music seems to be thoroughly represented by many races.
I thought it might be a southern thing, but it is not. Country music has a following that covers the entire country and is only referentially southern. The most popular modern stars are from all over the country. Keith Urban is Australian, so it is an international phenomena now.
So what is going on? Are country music fans motivating this culture of segregation? Is it the industry? Please explain this.




Backstage, Charley is suffering from a cold and drinking mineral water. At 68, he has an air of wary dignity. For the son of a sharecropper, he has plenty to be proud of: as well as winning 31 gold discs and four platinum albums, he played professional baseball in his youth, and has diversified into business, at one stage owning a chain of banks in Texas.
But journalists only ever want to ask what it's like to be The Only Black Man in Country. I start with a couple of softball questions about his Mississippi childhood. He cuts me off: 'You're not going to ask any questions that haven't been asked about 900,000 times - and that's OK,' he says. 'But after all the questions - like the one you just asked and the one you're gonna ask - this is gonna sum it up: American music consists of three basic ingredients: country, gospel and the blues. All are born from one another. If you want to ask about colours and cultures, we could go on and on. But that's the answer.'
Does he get fed up with questions about race? 'I understand why they get asked. But people are so hung up on skin. They're always asking "Why do you look like us and sound like them?" or "Why do you look them and sound like us?"'
Charley's first single, 'Snakes Crawl At Night', came out in January 1966, as the civil rights movement reached its height. I ask if he encountered racism then. 'No,' he replies. 'Because I was never black, never coloured, never Afro-American. I was just always American, an individual.'
His autobiography tells a different story: 'The racial element was always there,' it says. RCA concealed his background and removed his photograph from press kits for his first few singles. Charley is fond of comparing himself to Jackie Robinson, the first black baseball player in the major leagues, but while Robinson opened the way for other African- Americans, Charley remains one of a kind. 'That's not my fault,' he replies. 'I've done what I could to expand the country music audience.'
Before disappearing into his dressing room, he says: 'I don't have the answers. I get tired of being asked "Why aren't there any more of y'all in the business?" You should grab some people in the industry - see if you can get something out of them. They might just not want any more Charley Prides.'
But few record executives are willing to go on record on the subject of country and race. Tammy Genovese, head of the Country Music Association (CMA), tells me: 'The black community's lifestyle is different from what we communicate with country music.' Perhaps the problem is that the industry has failed to reach out to black fans, I suggest. 'We try to market to all types of people,' she says. 'But every culture has its own kind of music, and that is something we can't change. Black people have their own types of music that they like to listen to, be that jazz, hip hop or whatever.'
At a downtown barbeque joint, singer Carl Ray lays the blame with the record companies. 'I perform in places where I'm the only African American and I've never had a bad experience,' he says. 'The problem is not with the fans, it's with the executives - they're trying to go with what's worked before, and they're trying to keep with their job.'


Salon.com
Comments
How 'bout Latinos? Has there been a successful Hispanic country singer since Freddy Fender? (It's a serious question, because I really don't know).
I actively despise the "America, Love it or Leave it" wing of country music, and like you, I stopped listening to any new country in the mid- to late-80s.
But it stands to reason that a form of music that so closely aligns itself with the political right wouldn't be a rainbow of diversity.
You should rent "Shut Up and Sing." It made me a fan of the Dixie Chicks.
My original migration was a Doobie Bros, Molly Hatchet gateway music and a conversion to indie rock. Beck's Odelay made me very very happy. It merged the genres in a way that really pleased me. I listened to that and Moby's Play all summer a few years ago.
But it is very unclear whether the undiversified like country music because it is segregated or the segregation is a result of the lack of diversification or if it is just a natural result of a colsed genre keeping itself pure to its roots, which were definitely segregated.
I've always thought that they both drew pretty deeply from the well of southern black music.
Then again, I'm no musicologist.
If only there were a giant repository of human knowledge, right at my fingertips, that would let me do some research... [this is a running joke at my house, by the way.]
Great post. Especially as we see more and more whites turning to Blues, you still don't see any blacks in country. Does this mean that blacks dislike country music, or the business keeps them out/deters them?
Very interesting question.
(rated)
But who knows? It could have less to do with white listeners of country music not being accepting of black country singers and more to do with most black folks not being fans of country music. And maybe the black folks that do like country music can't sing.
Also, I suspect it would be easier being a gay in the black community than it would to be a country music fan. Can you imagine the look on your friends' faces the day you show up to a party armed with a Toby Keith CD instead of something by Ludacriss?
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=ASzy4YBc1Q4
I think it's pretty good and I am not a country music fan.
(But I was a Hootie fan)
(thumbified because it makes ya wanna hold your hat)
I will look at GAC and see how it holds up to the random sampling. I will record two hours of it tonight and then fast forward and get some data. I will update it tomorrow.
The Darius Rucker sounds pretty normal among the 100 or so songs I listened to on the countdown.
I really like Roseanne Cash, Linda Rondstadt, and Alison Krauss.
And they have drawn me back towards country music with the music, but the segregation phenomonon is very disturbing to me philosophically.
Notice, too, that there are practically no blacks in NASCAR, a sport that also has roots in the South, but is now a nationwide phenomenon.
When you talk of Allison Kruse, Linda Ronstadt, and Roseanne Cash you are actually talking of Americana and Bluegrass. Linda brother, Michael Ronstadt is part of an excellent Americana band, Santa Cruz River . They are quite eclectic with their music but sing in Spanish and English, songs of the South West. Based in Arizona where both Michael and Linda grew up.
Country music is more of “white man’s” music today that borrows much of its heritage from the Southern white roots mixed with more than a smattering of rock.
Americana is a much wider influence with Country, Rock, Folk, Tejano, Tex Mex and more. From Canada the influence is Cowboy from Ian Tyson, and other groups such as the Duhks, the Wailin Jenney’s and the Australian group the Waifs, realy mix it up. This is just to name a few.
In the states at Crooked Still and the Mammels, which Jay Unger (the Civil War Series) daughter and Pete Seegers grandson are part of this group that labels itself as Trad is Rad. Traditional music with a more driving younger sound.
Recently the Carolina Chocolate Drops, a black string band, has taken it all back to the “real roots” of country from the black string bands of the South which influenced American music. That music mixed with such artist as The Carter Family, Jimmy Rodgers, Heady Leadbetter, Woody Guthrie and Hank Williams.
Bill Monroe was influenced by the black musicians and jazz taking what was the traditional fiddle music and turning it on its ear with a whole new sound with his Kentucky Bluegrass Boys, thus the name Bluegrass.
There is a lot out there beyond this “New, or Young” Country sound that is whole lot more interesting. Try Clair Lynch, Laurie Lewis, Rhonda Vincent, Lyn Morris along with Allison Kruse in the Bluegrass Country sound, or as some would say, “Bluegrass, Country Soul”. And this is only the tip of the ice berg.
I have to say that I like a lot of the more current country. I could list a bunch of artists---and some amazing songs--but it is getting late, I've been writing all day, and the brain is mush.
I'm one of those people who can find something I like in any genre of music, because---well, each genre is so big---and really, there is almost always something good (maybe not new age---but even in that hated category, I've occasionally heard a pretty piece===but I digress).
I think that it is true---as someone stated in the comments---it is most likely more a result of black musicians not being into country that has kept black artists limited in the genre.
I think if you look at some of the younger, newer country performers---and you see a bit more "collaboration" occurring.
If I wasn't so lazy right now, I'd go through my IPod and give you a few examples---but one that comes to mind is Tim McGraw recording with Nelly.
The politics of country music is undeniably conservative, but I can't help but believe there is a change in the wind when Garth Brooks, Jennifer Nettles & Faith Hill all performed for Obama during the inaugural concerts and galas.
One of the biggest black country music recording acts is often overlooked by most people -- Ray Charles. Back in The Sixties, against the advice of absolutely everybody, he recorded Modern Sounds in Country and Western Music. It was such a smash, he recorded a follow-up Modern Sounds in Country and Western Music Volume II.
Those recordings forever changed country music and was very influential on Nashville recording techniques and the vocal stylings of many performers. There would be no Lee Greenwood as we know him without Ray Charles.
Brother Ray also recorded an album called friendship that featured duets with a number of country music stars including Willie Nelson and a tongue in cheek number with, George Jones called We Didn't See A Thing.
Of course, it would be foolish to call Ray a country music singer since he transcended every boundary.
There was also the CD Rhythm Country and Blues that featured duets with a number of black and white artists:
1. Ain't Nothing Like The Real Thing (Vince Gill & Gladys Knight)
2. Funny How Time Slips Away (Al Green & Lyle Lovett)
3. I Fall To Pieces (Aaron Neville & Trisha Yearwood)
4. Somethin' Else (Little Richard & Tanya Tucker)
5. When Something Is Wrong With My Baby (Patti LaBelle & Travis Tritt)
6. Rainy Night In Georgia (Sam Moore & Conway Twitty)
7. Chain Of Fools (Clint Black/Pointer Sisters)
8. Since I Fell For You (Natalie Cole & Reba McEntire)
9. Southern Nights (Chet Atkins/Allen Toussaint)
10. The Weight (Marty Stuart & The Staple Singers)
11. Patches (George Jones & B.B. King)
Unfortunately, these are exceptions that prove the rule you are alluding to which is that country music, like most churches, is a highly segregated corner of Americana.
I've always maintained that the best thing that ever happened to country music was rap. When rap took over the charts, a vast number of young white boys and girls exited to country, and it was just about the time country started going pop. That marriage of convenience was a marriage made in musical hell as far as real country fans were concerned.
One of the biggest black country music recording acts is often overlooked by most people -- Ray Charles. Back in The Sixties, against the advice of absolutely everybody, he recorded Modern Sounds in Country and Western Music. It was such a smash, he recorded a follow-up Modern Sounds in Country and Western Music Volume II.
Those recordings forever changed country music and was very influential on Nashville recording techniques and the vocal stylings of many performers. There would be no Lee Greenwood as we know him without Ray Charles.
Brother Ray also recorded an album called friendship that featured duets with a number of country music stars including Willie Nelson and a tongue in cheek number with, George Jones called We Didn't See A Thing.
Of course, it would be foolish to call Ray a country music singer since he transcended every boundary.
There was also the CD Rhythm Country and Blues that featured duets with a number of black and white artists:
1. Ain't Nothing Like The Real Thing (Vince Gill & Gladys Knight)
2. Funny How Time Slips Away (Al Green & Lyle Lovett)
3. I Fall To Pieces (Aaron Neville & Trisha Yearwood)
4. Somethin' Else (Little Richard & Tanya Tucker)
5. When Something Is Wrong With My Baby (Patti LaBelle & Travis Tritt)
6. Rainy Night In Georgia (Sam Moore & Conway Twitty)
7. Chain Of Fools (Clint Black/Pointer Sisters)
8. Since I Fell For You (Natalie Cole & Reba McEntire)
9. Southern Nights (Chet Atkins/Allen Toussaint)
10. The Weight (Marty Stuart & The Staple Singers)
11. Patches (George Jones & B.B. King)
Unfortunately, these are exceptions that prove the rule you are alluding to which is that country music, like most churches, is a highly segregated corner of Americana.
I've always maintained that the best thing that ever happened to country music was rap. When rap took over the charts, a vast number of young white boys and girls exited to country, and it was just about the time country started going pop. That marriage of convenience was a marriage made in musical hell as far as real country fans were concerned.
I think it's almost certainly the industry and not the fans. Think about it this way: if you were a musically talented black person, what would attract you to Nashville? Even if you found a supportive producer -- what sort of life would you find while ... Read Morerecording there? Friendly restaurants? Satisfying nightlife?
If the music industry can find an audience for singing Chipmunks, they can find an audience for black country artists. They just haven't looked very hard.
One of the biggest black country music recording acts is often overlooked by most people -- Ray Charles. Back in The Sixties, against the advice of absolutely everybody, he recorded Modern Sounds in Country and Western Music. It was such a smash, he recorded a follow-up Modern Sounds in Country and Western Music Volume II.
Those recordings forever changed country music and was very influential on Nashville recording techniques and the vocal stylings of many performers. There would be no Lee Greenwood as we know him without Ray Charles.
Brother Ray also recorded an album called friendship that featured duets with a number of country music stars including Willie Nelson and a tongue in cheek number with, George Jones called We Didn't See A Thing.
Of course, it would be foolish to call Ray a country music singer since he transcended every boundary.
There was also the CD Rhythm Country and Blues that featured duets with a number of black and white artists:
1. Ain't Nothing Like The Real Thing (Vince Gill & Gladys Knight)
2. Funny How Time Slips Away (Al Green & Lyle Lovett)
3. I Fall To Pieces (Aaron Neville & Trisha Yearwood)
4. Somethin' Else (Little Richard & Tanya Tucker)
5. When Something Is Wrong With My Baby (Patti LaBelle & Travis Tritt)
6. Rainy Night In Georgia (Sam Moore & Conway Twitty)
7. Chain Of Fools (Clint Black/Pointer Sisters)
8. Since I Fell For You (Natalie Cole & Reba McEntire)
9. Southern Nights (Chet Atkins/Allen Toussaint)
10. The Weight (Marty Stuart & The Staple Singers)
11. Patches (George Jones & B.B. King)
Unfortunately, these are exceptions that prove the rule you are alluding to which is that country music, like most churches, is a highly segregated corner of Americana.
I've always maintained that the best thing that ever happened to country music was rap. When rap took over the charts, a vast number of young white boys and girls exited to country, and it was just about the time country started going pop. That marriage of convenience was a marriage made in musical hell as far as real country fans were concerned.
Some of it is country music itself. My mom's friend claimed that she never liked some Grand Ole Opry founding father, because he and his friends didn't want Charley Pride playing there. "The nerve!" she fumed. "And Charley Pride can outsang all of em!" Remember, there was a big stink when Loretta Lynn kissed him? It was before my time, but I read of it. There is some racism, more among the older members, I think (hope).
Charley Pride was good. He sang country because he liked it more than Gospel or Motown. Maybe black singers of today don't feel comfortable singing country? It's not like we don't have plenty of black singers in hip-hop, gospel and blues. How many are pop singers? More than country I'm sure but maybe not representative?
One of the biggest black country music recording acts is often overlooked by most people -- Ray Charles. Back in The Sixties, against the advice of absolutely everybody, he recorded Modern Sounds in Country and Western Music. It was such a smash, he recorded a follow-up Modern Sounds in Country and Western Music Volume II.
Those recordings forever changed country music and was very influential on Nashville recording techniques and the vocal stylings of many performers. There would be no Lee Greenwood as we know him without Ray Charles.
Brother Ray also recorded an album called friendship that featured duets with a number of country music stars including Willie Nelson and a tongue in cheek number with, George Jones called We Didn't See A Thing.
Of course, it would be foolish to call Ray a country music singer since he transcended every boundary.
There was also the CD Rhythm Country and Blues that featured duets with a number of black and white artists:
1. Ain't Nothing Like The Real Thing (Vince Gill & Gladys Knight)
2. Funny How Time Slips Away (Al Green & Lyle Lovett)
3. I Fall To Pieces (Aaron Neville & Trisha Yearwood)
4. Somethin' Else (Little Richard & Tanya Tucker)
5. When Something Is Wrong With My Baby (Patti LaBelle & Travis Tritt)
6. Rainy Night In Georgia (Sam Moore & Conway Twitty)
7. Chain Of Fools (Clint Black/Pointer Sisters)
8. Since I Fell For You (Natalie Cole & Reba McEntire)
9. Southern Nights (Chet Atkins/Allen Toussaint)
10. The Weight (Marty Stuart & The Staple Singers)
11. Patches (George Jones & B.B. King)
Unfortunately, these are exceptions that prove the rule you are alluding to which is that country music, like most churches, is a highly segregated corner of Americana.
I've always maintained that the best thing that ever happened to country music was rap. When rap took over the charts, a vast number of young white boys and girls exited to country, and it was just about the time country started going pop. That marriage of convenience was a marriage made in musical hell as far as real country fans were concerned.
A couple of years ago Ron Thomason , the leader of “Dry Branch Fire Squad”, enraged a few of those elders as the California Bluegrass Fathers Day Festival’s with his humorous satirical comments on George Bush. But then the CBA is getting younger as well and moving more to the middle and left with the younger audience it is now beginning to attract.
There have been some changes in the few years since as younger musicians are taking up Traditional Music, Blue Grass, Americana, Roots and Folk. They tend to lean a little left of center. There is a real departure from the some of the old line pickers within some of these genres. But Commercial Country is still the province of the more Conservative side of America.
The Grand Old Opery is presently pretty well equal between Conservatives and Liberals. But then Ralph Stanly has always been a Democrat, and Earl Scrooge split from Lester Flat over Earl’s opposition to the Vietnam War.
By the way, a little aside here. Bluegrass music was the official music of the proletariat in the old Communist Chec regime. It was considered the music of the people and thus they have some great mandolin players who came up in this era learning to play acoustic instruments. When the wall came down there was a huge change to Rock, the music was discouraged previously.
It's a good cultural question ... any anthropologists in the house???
And so it is a sanke eating its tail. Black people won't get involved because it didn't allow for it in the segregated beginnings of it. And since no black people are involved, it stays segregated. So blacks see it as not changing and so continue to avoid it.
I looked at the CMA program and saw virtually no blacks in the audience of the show. No presenters, no winners.
A lot like the Academy Awards, although blacks in film are becoming fairly well represented these days, considering that they only make up about 20% of the general population. So at best, with perfect representation, 2 in 10 of the programs on tv or movies will have black actors, or 2 of 10 actors you will come across will be black. Or something along those lines.
But it is more like 1% in country music, and that is being wildly generous. I am about deciding that it is not ok and that I will just keep a segregated music format out of my house.
Even opera, the whitest of all originating white music, has black divas and principal performers.
So if the grand opera can do it, why can't the grand ol opry?
In the early years of String Band music Black string bands were much more prevalent than white strings bands. That began to change in early part of the 20th century to where by the 30’s and 40’s they were nearly none existent.
The Chocolate Drops have been on the Grand Old Opry, they are booked into a number of bluegrass festivals. What is often interesting is the workshops they do often someone will ask “how they came to be interested in white country music”. Little does the questioner know that what they do is Black Music that white people took up.
Here is a link to the Chocolate Drops and I suppose when things ease up around here and I have some spare time I might just do a blog on them with some You Tube videos.
http://www.carolinachocolatedrops.com/
The whole article is very well written and interesting.
And classically country including reference to a train!
I am getting my Master's degree and am writing about this very topic, and I assert that the media is prejudiced against country music. When was the last time you heard country music in an iPod ad? In a Verizon spot? Does that mean that none of those iPods play any sort of country music? Country listeners are too stupid to carry cell phones?
The country music format is the #1 music format in the country, yet the other top formats (adult contemporary and Top 40) exclude country completely from their playlists. They play all the other popular genres (hip hop, rock, pop, and R&B) but all country pop songs such as Keith Urban, Taylor Swift and Carrie Underwood are de-countrified before they air by a change in instrumentation. So unless one goes looking for country, one will not be exposed to it. AND, 'real' country, which is called alternative country these days, never ever gets air play, well, except Jamey Johnson and Zac Brown Band.
And as far as black musicians in country, Darius Rucker is doing better than fine. Perhaps the industry isn't keeping African-Americans out. Perhaps it's they who do not desire to be part of the country scene. If you were to read the author Bill Malone, you would see that whites and blacks were all together in country music back in the day - lots to read that may interest you.