Keep Breathing

Erica K

Erica K
Location
New Jersey, USA
Birthday
September 26
Bio
Grew up in Jackson Heights, New York, but now live in Jersey. Married and the proud owner (servant?) of 4 cats, including a little blind guy named Quincy. Jobs have included: English teacher in U.S. and abroad, cabaret performer and member of a NYC sketch comedy troupe; now a full-time legal secretary and freelance writer. Other jobs: canvasser for NYPIRG/cannery worker in Naknek, Alaska (a fisherman told me it was "the ugliest part of Alaska")/dog kennel cleaner/member of the swine and poultry crew on a California farm. This year a memoir piece will be published in Telling Our Stories Press and poems in The Awakenings Review. Currently working on a one-woman show. "Ever tried. Ever failed. No matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail better." Samuel Beckett

MY RECENT POSTS

Erica K's Links

Salon.com
FEBRUARY 21, 2012 12:52PM

Downton Abbey Redeemed!

Rate: 26 Flag

"Will someone please tell me what's going on, or have we all stepped through the looking glass?"

           Maggie Smith as Violet, Downton Abbey

I'm sure you die-hard Downton Abbey fans were eagerly anticipating the final episode of season two, the Christmas Special (aired February 19, EST at 9:00 p.m.). God knows the second to the last episode was wholly unworthy of the fine fare which had preceded it (see libbyliberalnyc's excellent post, “Downton Abbey Jumps Shark with Overplotting and Caricaturization.”) Spoiler alert: if you have not seen the final episode of season two and hope to see it, do not read any further.

I will go through the highlights and analyze as I see fit (how very British of me). Please let me know if you think I have omitted anything significant.

Mr. Bates. The beleaguered Mr. Bates is incarcerated on suspicion of poisoning his ex-wife. At a trial the likes of which Law & Order would never tolerate for its obvious lack of DNA evidence, among other things (all the evidence was circumstantial), Bates is declared guilty and sentenced to hang. Poor Mrs. Hughes, O'Brien and Lord Grantham are compelled to testify; Grantham unfortunately confesses that Bates told him he wished the former Mrs. Bates dead. Sometimes less is more!

Mary and Carlisle and Anna. Cora tells her husband about Mary's indiscretion (hmm) with the young, now deceased Turk Pamuk since he is clamoring to know why his daughter insists on marrying the abominable Mr. Carlisle, whom she clearly dislikes. After hearing the story, Grantham speaks to his daughter and tells her all is (gulp) forgiven and she needn't marry Carlisle—who could marry a man who can't load his own gun and who thinks charades is demeaning to the person playing it—but may disappear to America to live with an aunt and start a new life and perhaps marry a cowboy. Yahoo! He will bear the shame of her being exposed in the press. What a great Dad! Anna asks if she may accompany Mary to America if the worst is to happen to her beloved Bates, and Mary agrees. Rich people being kind to poor people! Oh, how it touches my soul.

Daisy. Daisy asserts herself at the recommendation of a visiting lady's maid to Violet's daughter, Rosamund, and heeds the Ouija board which instructs her to visit William's dad for a day. The kindly man confides in her that he has lost all his children and asks if she will be his daughter so he has someone to pray for. This is by far the most touching, heartfelt scene in the show.

Thomas. Oh, hapless villain that you are. I used to simply despise him, but he has grown on me. He is the only (at least that we know of) gay character in the show, and despite his dark side (plotting evil while on smoking breaks with O'Brien; oh, those evil smokers!). My heart softened to him a bit after he discovers that his storehouse of black market goods are all bad (the flour is actually cement) and he has been cheated of his life's savings. Hoping he will be next in line for the valet position if Bates does not return to the house, Thomas seeks counsel from O'Brien, who advises him to hide something Lord G values and then find it to prove his worth. Thomas takes Grantham's dog Isis into the woods and locks her in a shed, planning to come for her later after a search party has been sent out. All I could keep thinking is that the dog is going to be torn apart by wolves. Luckily, I was mistaken. Although Thomas is not the one to return Isis to her owner, Lord Grantham is touched by Thomas's endeavors, seeing him filthy and disheveled after searching in the wee hours for his pooch.

Mary and Matthew. Oh, thank God the vampiric pallor of their skin has darkened to alabaster. They are no longer among the ranks of the living dead! Isobel convinces her son that Mary is still in love with him and ultimately, he takes the bait, and proposes to her on bended knee in the snow. This is the stuff fairy tales are made of!

Carlisle. It turns out Carlisle isn't all that bad. He tells Mary that he truly loved her and she tells him of her hope that he will find someone worthy of his love. Poor sod.

Most fun scene. The fist fight between Matthew and Carlisle. Oh, how I love to see gents in tuxes roll around on the parlor room floor!

Bates. Bates' sentence is commuted to life in prison. Hallelujah! Now if only he would lose that perpetual hang-dog look. I guess it's hard when the blows keep coming, unabated (no pun intended).

I don't know about you, but I am so looking forward to the addition of Shirley MacLaine in season 3. I am certain she will stir up a good bit of mischief and fun.

 

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I mourn for Boston Legal. Until that comes back I'm boycotting all TV - except during football season.
Matt, I never watched Boston Legal, maybe because I work in a law firm. Ha ha!
Looking forward to Season 3 too. I heard Robin Williams is joining the cast as the crazy nephew who's been locked in the tower for ten years.
John, I think you're pulling my leg here! Very funny. Maybe Eddie Murphy as the long lost African-American cousin?
I must confess, although I abhor daytime soaps and have never watched them even when on work hiatus having a baby or three, I love Downton. In my dotage I have succumb to all forms of its romantic story lines. As the final episode of the season closed, I felt the way I do as I read the last few pages of a good novel: anxious to know the ending, but wishing to prolong the final scene as long as possible.
Sometimes it feels as though there are too many characters/plot lines. But I guess it takes that many to fill an estate.
I hadn't even heard of this show (not much of a TV watcher), but after reading a few paragraphs, you had me hooked. And with Shirley MacLaine to look forward to, that's just gravy. I just added Season 1 to my Netflix cue. (PBS should send you a residual of some form.)
R
Can't wait to see this show! Glad you found something good on the tube. Maggie Smith is the cat's pajamas in my book. What I have seen is Mad Men (every episode). R
jane, I think you might be right!

beauty, I'm with you, always hated soaps, could never even bring myself to watch Dallas.

Annie, thank you for that. I wouldn't mind a residual!

Margie, Mad Men is terrific. Downton is better. You can rent it on netflix.
Are there any zombies on this show? 'Cuz I'll watch it if there are.
When I saw this episode, all of the over-the-top, sort of ridiculous stuff from the season was redeemed. It was great! Thanks for writing about it - and I, too, am very much looking forward to season 3!
Very thorough, Erica. =o) I was so glad to see Carlisle sent packing. Gee, he can't figure out why Mary isn't eager to marry him when he's promised to ruin her if she doesn't and tries to bribe her maid to spy on her? Loved Lady Violet saying so quickly "Do you promise?" when Carlisle tells her "We may never meet again."

I enjoyed Lord Grantham saying "Marry a cowboy and shake us all up." Sybil's already married the chauffeur, so why not a cowboy!"

I never blamed Mary for the Pamuk incident. She had every reason to be in her own bedroom at that time of night, and never invited HIM to come visit her!

rated

Also loved the fist-fight between the men. =o) I confess during the proposal at the end, I was distracted from my joy for Mary and Matthew by thinking "Isn't Mary freezing, standing outside in a January snowstorm in Yorkshire in that skimpy evening dress?"
Erica, I will be back to read this full out when I have seen all of it. I clicked on the tube really late last night and caught the last third of it and was happy to see Hugh B. wasn't struggling with a lousily written plot betraying wife scenario and seemed in control once again. I have to see the whole finale, which I of course indignantly vowed I wouldn't watch, but reading your headline and initial paragraphs (thanks for the h/t) and getting that taste last night I will review, though the ouija board stuff was distressing me! Though I do remember during my college dorm days the boards made some of my "scare me" fellow students kinda nutty!!!! best, libby :)
Yes indeed! I LOVED the finale episode. So lovely. The only problem is the long wait for next season.
Thanks for this! I missed it Sunday and was wondering what has transpired.
This was a great recap! I thought the final episode made up for the train wreck of the one before it. So looking forward to Season 3.
Erica, We recently did a Downton marathon where we revisited the last 2 seasons. Great the second time around too. Strangely enough villian Thomas has grown on me too. Plus he's super hot in some scenes with his hair all mussed up ... dishevelled and such. Somewhere I think within Thomas are some redeeming qualities; more than I can say for Queen Bitch O'Brien. The only reason Thomas was looking for Lord Grantham's dog is he knew there would be absolute hell to pay if it was found out he was trying to score brownie points. I like L. Grantham (at times) but he needs to wake up! Fun post.
As the hopeless romantic in my family, I was getting choked up when, predictably, Matthew finally proposed to Mary ... meanwhile my wife was pantomiming putting her finger down her throat, complete with retching sounds. I guess opposites attract.

Nonetheless, I'm looking forward to Season Three.
Excellent recap, thank you.
I enjoyed this beautifully written series so much, especially Maggie Smith's clever lines. Anna's love for Bates was perfect. What she told him over the episodes--so simple, direct, logical, sentimental and heartbreakingly romantic--should be collected and published under, "This Is True Love." Also, I did not clearly understand Lady Mary's feelings or what she really wanted, or may be the point was that she did know what she wanted. Her character reminded me--although much more superior--of Pamela Ewing of Dallas. Over all I enjoyed the series so much. Thanks again for the recommendation and the fine review. R
So wait, Downtown Abbey isn't a new rock band?

Sorry, I just can't get into British series unless they are screamingly insanely funny like Absolutely Fabulous was, or the variety shows like The Two Ronnies, Monty Python's Flying Circus and that dear old guy who's name escapes me at the moment.

Soap operas literally bore me to tears. I admit I did watch General Hospital when Luke and Laura were first on and getting into all that trouble, but that was way back in 1979 or so.

Never watched an episode of Dallas. Never saw Melrose place. Didn't see any more than 15 seconds of 90210. I'm oddly consistent that way. My life is plenty engaging for me.

I wish all you Downtown Abbey fans all the best. Me? Seriously doubt I'll get into it. Of course, I suppose I could give it the time of day. Is it available through Netflix Watch Instantly?
I'm weird! I don't have television. But I do have season one and two on DVD, waiting to be opened. Get back to you later, after I finish watching the last season of Alfred Hitchcock Presents.
Your review is flawless, and I knew you liked this series from a previous post. I'm on the other hand so uninterested in TV or movies these days. Enjoyed reading this, thank you.
R♥
I love this show.. I have watched every episode including the christmas special..
I have to wait until Sept now.. Oh woe is me..:)
HUGGGGGGGGG
I have been a follower for two years, and hate that another year of waiting is on us. Still, season two was kind of snoozer for awhile. Imagine if Lady Mary and Anna had gone to NYC to live with Shirley MacLaine? During Prohibition? Oh man, those scripts would just write themselves!
Just skimmed your piece Erica as I haven't seen it yet. But I'm planning on an Easter Weekend binge of Season 1 and am relieved that it seems to have found its way again.
Jeanette, no zombies, but Mary and Matthew were becoming a pair of them until the final episode.

Alysa, wasn't it great?

Shiral, yes, she did look awfully frosty in that skimpy frock.

bluestocking, me too. It's a long time to wait.

Sheila, I'm glad I could help!

Midwest, thanks for the compliment.

Scarlett, yes, he was starting to get that wild Heathcliff look. He is quite handsome.

Gratefuldan, your wife didn't like it? Shame on her! Just kidding.

Thanks, Trudie.

Thoth, yes, isn't Anna the essence of the faithful, romantic lover, and such a kind soul.

Dunniteowl, I don't think Downton would bore you, it's not really a soap opera. Not sure about the netflix watch instantly, but don't think so.

SpiritMan, good for you! I wish I could be tv-less too sometimes. Mostly my husband and I watch BBC crime dramas on netflix, they are so much better than most American fare.

Thank you, Fusun.

Linda, we have to wait till September? Oh no! "What is a week-end?"

green heron, I like the idea of Mary and Anna and Shirley in prohibition era America. Boardwalk Empire meets Downton Abbey?

Abrawang, it is well worth watching.
[r] WHAT A MARVELOUS COMMENTARY, ERICA, AND IT IS REDEEMED!!! What a relief. I watched the finale from beginning to end and it worked me, let me tell you. No discordant notes, restrained and all the actors in the zone!!!

FAVORITE LINES IN THIS EPISODE:

Mary: IT WAS LUST MATTHEW!!! What a modern millie girl, our Mary. gotta love her!

Carlyle says to Dowager Violet: I doubt we will meet again.
Maggie Smith: Do you promise? She is always there with the snipe. love it

Carson back to Lord G. about unexpected kindness even in Thomas (the Eddie Haskell of DA): IS THERE?????? a great look of shock on his face

Favorite moments:

Thomas slip sliding in the mud.

Daisy and her father in law when he tells her he wants to be devoted to her. So sweet.

Daisy and visit with Maggie Smith at fireplace. Maggie Smith is such a great catalyst. You just want her in every scene.

Mrs. Patmore manipulating the ouija board. Love when the b*tchy woman says, "Is it usually that specific?" And OBrien shoots back, "Not usually!"

Sir Anthony coming back to Edith!!! I am glad that happened. God, Edith suffered enough and has redeemed herself.

I can't believe the Patrick character never came back for this episode. That was a bit weird but he was discordant so I was happy to see him out of it.

Lord G. was back to his strong presence. And how well they all took Mary's scandal!!! But they sold it.

Even Rex's final exit is well done with Mary sending him off. Hmmmm. I was suspecting him and his henchmen of Mrs. Bates's murder but that is maybe me overplotting!!!

I can't believe after seeing the whole arc of it I am not cynically sniping about the final ouija board scene between Anna and Daisy, "You were pushing it." "No you were pushing it." C'mon!!!!! Lavinia was pushing it. I guess we have been lusting so long for Mary and Matthew to FINALLY hook up that we were saps for that. BUT STILL, ERICA, ON SECOND THOUGHT.... PRETTY SAPPY.

Only real complaint was that Lord G at the trial didn't see himself with dangerous damning testimony that old Batesy would have ratted himself out so much and not have conferred with Lord G and Lord G so unprepared. Talk about incriminating yourself, Bates, but I guess they didn't have the fifth amendment in England, though they did have a wife not having to testify against hubby. We still have the fifth amendment, don't we? Obama et al. have been so busy I am not sure any more. (sorry, I couldn't resist!)

It really is pushing the limits to have the worlds of upstairs and downstairs so integrated as it was!!! A nice fairy tale and classily done.

Maybe the 1% will watch DA and take notes.

Nawwwwww.

Thanks, Erica K. for your wonderful run down! And coaxing me to give the finale a chance. Episode 6 was unfortunate but all was not lost!!!! :)

best, libby
Nice analysis. Though I still think Sir Richard is a rather loathsome piece of work.
Libby, yes, another great scene was Thomas rolling around in the mud. That, and Carlisle and Matthew in fisticuffs in the parlor. And of course, Violet's quip, "Promise?" after Carlisle leaves. It was a pleasure to watch. Thanks for reading!

Mary, I agree Richard is a loathsome character, but even villains need love.
I have been living for the next episode of Downton Abbey this year. Your summary of events is fine, but your conclusions are somewhat different than mine. Thomas is a snake. He has no redeeming traits and that has nothing to do with his being gay. You're too kind to Carlisle. He loved her in his way; like a new piece of property.
I do agree about the fight scene. My best new years eve party ever involved watching a cat fight involving two young women in cocktail dresses slinging each other around on the floor by their hair as their dates in tuxes tried to disentangle them.
I liked the way that Mathew and Carlisle broke up immediately on Lord Grantham's command.
I had not heard about Shirley McClain. It's good to know that she has given up her affair with crystals and is back to acting. R
I am only now starting to watch this series on Netflix. I am still on season 1. As I continue, I will appreciate more of your references, I am sure.
Rodney, to each his own. Some of my commentary was tongue in cheek: I, too, believe that Carlisle is still a monster, although I think Thomas is somewhat reformed, at least for now. Maybe I just like his smoldering dark looks.

Paul, thank you.
I didn't want to read this until I had watched the Xmas EP ... and now that I have ...

I agree, this was a wonderful conclusion to this part of the series. While I didn't dislike the end of Season 2 as much as you did, there were some things that were frustrating me. I felt that if the will-they-or-won't-they Mary/Matthew aspect went on much longer, it would be tiresome. I loved how this finally played out.

You're kinder to Carlisle than I am. My favourite line in the EP was when he told the Dowager Countess that he'd never see her again, and she came back with "Is that a Promise?"

Speaking of "Bates" -- and parlour wrestling -- Carlisle & Matthew's brawl still has nothing on Alan Bates and Oliver Reed au natural in Women In Love, har har.

It's going to be a long wait until Season 3, but I'm anticipating some delicious MacLaine/Smith Grandmama battles of wits and egos.
Various Artists, I agree that Maggie Smith's retort of "Promise?" was utterly priceless. My take on Carlisle is that he is a snake, perhaps with a tiny soft spot buried in the center. Looking forward to season 3 as well. Oh, yes the "Women in Love" tussle!