Keep Breathing

Erica K

Erica K
Location
New Jersey, USA
Birthday
September 26
Bio
Grew up in Jackson Heights, New York, but now live in Jersey. Married and the proud owner (servant?) of 4 cats, including a little blind guy named Quincy. Jobs have included: English teacher in U.S. and abroad, cabaret performer and member of a NYC sketch comedy troupe; now a full-time legal secretary and freelance writer. Other jobs: canvasser for NYPIRG/cannery worker in Naknek, Alaska (a fisherman told me it was "the ugliest part of Alaska")/dog kennel cleaner/member of the swine and poultry crew on a California farm. Currently performing my solo show, "The Year of Dead Cats," at Stage Left Studio in NYC. http://stageleftstudio.net/ "Ever tried. Ever failed. No matter. Try again. Fail again. Fail better." Samuel Beckett

MY RECENT POSTS

Erica K's Links

Salon.com
APRIL 16, 2012 3:40PM

Robin Gibb in a Coma

Rate: 26 Flag

Let me admit right up front that I’m a sucker for the Bee Gees.  They grew in popularity during my preteen and high school years and the first album of theirs I bought was Children of the World, released in September 1976.  Who can blame a 15-year-old for going ga-ga at the sight of Barry in tight white (or any color, for that matter) pants?  And they sang good too.  From the Saturday Night Fever hits and beyond, I was smitten.

 

Children of the World
Children of the World album cover (Robin, Barry, Maurice)

The brothers were born in the Isle of Man to British parents, and the family re-located to Queensland, Australia in the 1950s.  The band's first U.S. hit was "A New York Mining Disaster 1941," written by Barry and Robin Gibb and released in the U.S. in 1967.  I was too young to appreciate the song at the time, but now I do.

 "New York Mining Disaster 1941"

In the event of something happening to me,
there is something I would like you all to see.
It's just a photograph of someone that I new.

Have you seen my wife, Mr. Jones?
Do you know what it's like on the outside?
Don't go talking too loud, you'll cause a landslide, Mr. Jones.

I keep straining my ears to hear a sound.
Maybe someone is digging underground,
or have they given up and all gone home to bed,
thinking those who once existed must be dead.

Have you seen my wife, Mr. Jones?
Do you know what it's like on the outside?
Don't go talking too loud, you'll cause a landslide, Mr. Jones.

In the event of something happening to me,
there is something I would like you all to see.
It's just a photograph of someone that I knew.

Have you seen my wife, Mr. Jones?
Do you know what it's like on the outside?
Don't go talking too loud, you'll cause a landslide, Mr. Jones.

 

Aside from their musical success, Fate has dealt the Brothers Gibb a cruel hand.  The youngest brother, Andy, died at age 30 from an inflammation of the heart caused by a virus, not drug abuse, as had been initially suspected.  Then Robin’s twin brother Maurice died at age 53 from complications resulting from a twisted intestine.  In October 2010, Robin revealed that he was suffering from colon cancer, which eventually spread to his liver.  That same year he underwent surgery to treat a twisted bowel, a congenital condition that killed his twin brother in 2003.

 

Despite his poor health, Robin completed his first classical symphony, “The Titanic Requiem,” with his son Robin-John, to commemorate the 100th anniversary of the disaster.  The concert premiered on April 10, but Gibb was too ill to attend.

 

Gibb is said to keep an antique journal at his bedside in which he writes lyrics and other ideas.  He expressed a desire to set up a children’s charity involving music and was working on a “bucket list” before he slipped into a coma after contracting pneumonia.

 

"I sometimes wonder if all the tragedies my family has suffered, like Andy and Maurice dying so young and everything that’s happened to me recently, is kind of a karmic price we are paying for all the fame and fortune we've had,” Robin told The Sun in March of this year.

 

He added, “But we’ve worked hard for everything we’ve achieved. I am not and never have been at death’s door. But the illness, and the untimely death of my brothers, has made me conscious of the fact that - rather than just think about it – it’s crucial that you do today what you want to do.”

 

A celebrity with a heart--my kind of guy.

 

Here’s wishing him and his family well during this difficult time.

 

 

 

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I had no idea. Thanks for this, Erica. They gave the world some memorable music.
Chicken Maaan, I think so too.

Heidi, yes, it is. It must be horrible for their mother.
Really love to listen to them. Had several of their albums. (in the day)... There is one song in particular about coal miners.....ties in with Deborah Mendez Wilsons story about Ludlow....a sad day for BeeGee Fans.
Ande, I know that song, "Mining Disaster."
Poor Barry. Tough be the eldest and last one left. I remember being around 10 years old at the pool listening to "Ji-ji-ji-jive talking..." A good memory.
Rated, by a fellow sucker.
Midwest Muse, I loved that song!
Harry's Ghost, here's to us suckers!
I remember dancing around the house as a kid to their music. Very sad for their family.
Asia, me too. I feel so sorry for their Mom.
It's so sad that another Gibb is about to be lost. I grew up with their music too. Good post!
PTS, I'm sad to be reporting on yet another tragedy in the Gibb Family.
Very sad. My neighbors and I would play disco in my basement listening to the BeeGees. This getting older thing is not fun sometimes. I don't like seeing others get older. I feel like I'm still 8 yrs old.
Patience, I feel the same way. Raises our sense of mortality, doesn't it?
I have always loved the Bee Gees. Indid not know all that you shared today. The medley is wonderful.
Rated with love
I had no idea, Erica. Thanks for posting. They are the sound of the radio in my childhood--skating around the roller rink on a Friday night in a small town. How sad for their family.
Romantic, I love the medley too--they looked so young and innocent.

Froggy, I know.
So sad. Thank you for bringing this to our attention. I had no idea, either. Rated.
Deborah, I know.
i have the album in my garage! it's quite wonderful. thanks for the post and remembering robin gibb!
They were terrific, and full of heart, unscripted.
"Mining Disaster" was my favorite Bee Gees tune... "it’s crucial that you do today what you want to do."

Man...
AMEN. And I did not know this, either. I always thought there was something "a cut above" in their music. It doesn't seem "fair" (even if you invoke karma), but by saying such a thing I know I'm naive whether I keep faith or despair. It does make you think about the value of this moment and the sound of that bell tolling.
R+
I had no idea...I swung both ways Disco/rock. I grew up in NYC too! The disco boys never took to me though.
I loved them when it was uncool to love them. Adore them still. They were just great. So sad that life has been so rough for them. Who can know why but I don't think it's karma.
When they did their last concert together, a HBO special, I think, they blew the roof off the joint. I'm an ole Rock & Roller but have always liked the Bee Gee's and they played hit, after hit, after hit. Amazing!
Very sad. We never know when our time will come, do we? Best wishes to all.
jmac, that is a terrific song, which I didn't know as a kid, but now when I hear it, it blows me away.

Ash, I agree. They were talented, full of heart, classy and good looking! And they always looked like they were having a good time.

snarky, that's funny. I swung both ways too. Never found a disco boyfriend either, LOL.

fernsy, I don't believe they "deserved" what has transpired in their family either (karma), but what Robin said just goes to show how humble and grateful he is. Not like most of today's celebrity musicians.

Sheila, I know.

Scanner, I wish I had seen that. Never saw them perform live.

C Berg, exactly. We never know. Have to live every day like it's our last.
I apologize in advance, but I can't tell you how much I hate the BeeGees. I cringe when I hear them. The world without the
Brothers Gibb is not necessarily a bad thing.
I've been a Bee Gees fan since I was a young boy and I first heard "I Started a Joke" one morning on the radio as I was getting up to go to school. The melody of that song, the lyrics, and the ethereal voice conveying the message of the song in a way that made the lyrics almost superfluous, struck me in a way that was unknown to me before that. I was not a big fan of their "disco era" and my purist tendencies kept me from fandom even after the disco era faded, partly because it seemed they never completely abandoned the disco era approach. I always hoped they would trend back musically to their earlier styles, and there were hints from time to time that they would, but I missed the raw edge that their earlier recording had like on Mr. Natural, Life In A Tin Can and earlier. But even during their disco phase, they created some beautiful melodies and music. I'll hope that Robin recovers.
His family has had an overdose of sadness. I used to enjoy singing their songs more than dancing to them....not a disco fan. I recall a duet album they—mainly Barry--did with Barbara Streisand. It certainly put words to the feelings I was at a loss to express at the time.
Sad news indeed! I always loved their music, especially that romantic era is forever on my mind. Thank you, Erica. R
This is so sad, but soon he will see no trouble from the world.

My friends and I were sitting around one night and the Bee Gees came on. It didn't hurt that we were high. But I said that the Bee Gees wrote some jammin' music. Their musicality was unassailable.

To my surprise, everyone agreed and we gigged to the Bee Gees, a great part of our music culture.
Rick, I guess I had the opposite experience. I became acquainted with their music during their "disco"/dance music period and later discovered their earlier work, but appreciate both.

Beauty, yes the duet with Streisand, "Emotion," was gorgeous.

Thoth, yes, they certainly wrote some beautiful love songs like "Love So Right," "Fanny Be Tender," and "Emotion."

Zuma, they could jam with the best of them.
Didn't know at all; I've never really been into their music but they're on my 'respect' list as an influential band. Not to mention an embarrassing ''How deep is your love" karaoke episode in Singapore!
icyhighs, I can only imagine what that would sound like.
What a lovely tribute, so elegantly written and kind. Thank you for sharing this!
Sally, thanks. It's not looking good for Robin, sad to say.
I too was smitten, and still am. That sweet Bee Gee sound always gives me a lift when I'm in one of my retro moods. I hope Robin pulls through....or goes peacefully if it's his time. Thanks for the music.
Bluestocking, doesn't look like he's going to pull through from what I have read. I am hoping he goes peacefully too.
Never was a Bee Gees fan but you wrote and illustrated a lovely piece and it is sad news indeed about Robin Gibb.
Yes: "it’s crucial that you do today what you want to do." Their music carries that message. Thank you for reminding me of their songs and lyrics. Uplifting Persistence.
I love the insights you have shared here. Such a gifted family. Thank you for writing this. R
Mary, it is sad.

Geezer, yes, their music is full of life, love and hope.

Rita, thanks for stopping by.
So sad for the Gibb family, and that they never had a chance to make more music together.

On a related note, I read this morning that Levon Helm is also in his last days or hours. I'm reminded of a line from one of my favorite novels, "Love In A Cold Climate" by Nancy Mitford, spoken by a middle-aged woman attending the funeral of a friend:

"It's the dropping off the perches . . . I've always dreaded when that begins. Soon we shall all have gone . . . "
Montanarose, I am not familiar with Levon Helm. Will have to educate myself. Thanks for stopping by.
Erica, Levon Helm was the drummer and a lead singer for The Band. They were Bob Dylan's backup band at one time, but enjoyed huge success on their own in the mid-1970s and '80s. You might recognize his voice on songs such as "The Night They Drove Old Dixie Down" and "The Weight."

In recent years, after recovering from his initial bout with throat cancer, he rejuvenated his career with two great solo albums in the Americana genre, "Electric Dirt" and "Dirt Farmer." His daughter, Amy Helm, performed with him; she is a member of the folk/Americana band Ollabelle and a wonderful musician in her own right.

He also had something of a career as an actor: he played Loretta Lynn/Sissy Spacek's father in "Coal Miner's Daughter" and Chuck Yeager/Sam Shepard's aircraft mechanic, Ridley, in "The Right Stuff." I think he has several other films to his credit, but those are the two I'm most familiar with.

Sorry; I probably told you more about Levon Helm than you wanted to know! But I loved The Band, and him, and I do so hate this dropping-off-the-perches thing, especially being of that generation myself.
Montanarose, yes, I know those songs and I loved "Coal Miner's Daughter," and I remember his performance in it: excellent. You should write a post about him!
Shit! And I am still getting over Andy Gibb's early demise.
Brass, so much tragedy in the Gibb family. Their mother was quoted saying she thinks their family is "cursed" like the Kennedy family.
I was so happy to see you include that clarification about the drug abuse thing regarding Andy. The kid was born with a heart vulnerable to the very thing that took him.
I love your article, I too am oblvious to the Bee Gees. One just can't help one's self. Can I please correct a mistake you said an Austrialian Band. They are not. even though moved from Manchester, England to Austrialia. Infact, their first hit was Spicks and Specks when they left Austrialia to come back to England.
I don't mean to upset you on this. Please forgive me.

perhaps you like to read this http://mrslagibbthebeegees.blogspot.co.uk/
LA, not upset in the least. I know the brothers were Manchester-born, but the family moved to Australia when they were young, so perhaps I should have clarified that. However, their first U.S. hit was "New York Mining Disaster."