Erika's Haven

Eclectic musings, musical leanings, readings & writings.
AUGUST 25, 2009 11:15AM

a shameful state of affairs

Rate: 1 Flag

I really never intended for this blog to be so political. Honest.

Some issues really do need more exposure, though, & since I have this place to vent, might as well use it.

Racism continues to rear its ugly head in Canadian life. I'm ashamed of our current federal regime, led by Harper & his band of neoCons, and of everyone (including some of my own family) who voted for them. They're doing their utmost to ruin our country's international reputation, and sadly, they're succeeding all too well. I'm also ashamed that the opposition in Parliament has been so ineffectual in protesting against their actions. What we need most is for the opposition to coalesce so that their minority government is ousted & can be defeated at the next election. I'm not holding my breath, though. 

Two major cases ongoing now:

1) The federal government is appealing a ruling of a lower court that would bring home Omar Khadr from Guantanamo.

Khadr was all of 15 when he was captured in Afghanistan, after allegedly throwing a grenade that killed a USAmerican soldier, and has been interned in Guantanamo Bay for the past 7 years, awaiting trial for murder, conspiracy & support of terrorism.

This man deserves a fair trial, and as a Canadian citizen (born in Toronto), it should be in a Canadian court. After so long a denial of due process, our Federal Court of Appeal ruled that his Charter rights had been denied and he should be brought home. Our mean spirited neoCon government is appealing this ruling to the Supreme Court, who have yet to decide if they will review the case. It's to be hoped they won't.

How can this one man, who was 15 at the time of his alleged actions, be considered such a threat to our national security that it warrants an appeal to the Supreme Court to keep him incarcerated in a foreign internment camp? How can our elected officials continue to bully this individual in such an ugly way?

 

We have jailed mass murderers & other violent offenders for a shorter time than he has already served, in what is known to be dire conditions, where torture has been a factor in treatment of detainees.

 

A key quote from the above article: "In his decision, O'Reilly pointed out that Khadr is the last citizen of any Western country held at Guantanamo. Other countries have repatriated their citizens."  I'm ashamed that Canada has not seen fit to do so, & continues to emulate the now (thankfully) defunct Bush/Cheney administration in their illegal & immoral acts.

2) At least 2 Canadians have been stranded for lengthy periods in African countries on spurious passport issues.

Suaad Hagi Mohamud, a Canadian citizen, was stranded in Kenya for 3 months because embassy officials thought she didn't look enough like her passport photo & she was accused of being an imposter. It took her insistence on a DNA test to prove her identity and get them to back down. She is now suing our federal government (i.e. the taxpaying citizens) for their negligence & failure to support her. I hope she wins, even if I'm paying for part of the settlement.

There is at least one other Canadian citizen,  Abdihakim Mohamed, who has been stranded, also in Kenya, for 3 years. Clearly, the staff of the embassy in Kenya need some serious retraining, at the very least. (The "diplomat" in charge has been recalled -- it's a start.)

It's no coincidence that all 3 of the cases here involve Canadians who are also Muslims.

And this from a regime that claims it is innocent of ethnic profiling. Appalling.

Author tags:

racism, news, politics

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I'm not trying to defend the government in general from these types of charges, but in the specific cases of people stranded in Kenya, I don't think that the fact that the stranded people are Muslims and/or black is proof (or even good evidence) of profiling by the Canadian government. Yes, the Canadian High Commission in Kenya is handling this wrong, and the Canadian government probably is, too.

But some officials in Kenya apparently have a habit of extorting money from travellers by accusing them of not looking like their passport photo and then expecting a bribe; Canadians visiting Kenya are likely to predominately be Canadians with some connection there, and thus are more likely to be Muslim and/or black. I think these facts adequately explain why the 3 cases of Canadians stranded overseas are black or Muslims, without any need to speculate about ethnic profiling on the part of the Canadian government.
Well, Don, I guess we'll have to agree to disagree on this one. I cited these 3 examples as merely the most recent & blatant instances of profiling. I wouldn't be quite as incensed about the Kenyan incidents if I hadn't plenty of personal experience, including accompanying colleagues & friends of various ethnic or racial "types" through a variety of government offices including Customs and Passport Offices and observing the differences in treatment obtained. I'm not just talking about the rent-a-cop security & baggage screeners, either. There appears to be a concerted policy, much more noticeable since our border policy changes to align more with the USA's Homeland Security & glaringly more noticeable since the current regime took office. But perhaps your experience differs.

I'm not sure how your comments about the Kenyan situation inform the issue -- this isn't about how Kenyan officials treat Canadian citizens on passport issues, but how Canadian ones do. And what does the fact that travelling Canadians are likely to have connections in the country they're travelling to have to do with anything?

I notice you don't address the Khadr issue, which is clearly in the hands of the current regime, and clearly related to his ethnicity.
Gagsome, Erika. I cringe in embarrassment for you and your nation. Not that me and mine (the US) have anything to be proud of either, when it comes to racial profiling.

Way to put this out there.
Hi again.

I didn't address Khadr or a lot of the other things you mentioned because, as I said at the top of my earlier comment, "I'm not trying to defend the government in general from these types of charges".

It does sound like we'll "have to agree to disagree" on some things, but I don't think that we necessarily disagree on as much as you think.
Thanks for clarifying, Don. It sounds like we do agree on some & not on others. Always good to hear other points of view.