Faith Paulsen's Blog

Faith Paulsen

Faith Paulsen
Location
Norristown, Pennsylvania, USA
Birthday
December 27
Bio
Writer. No relation to Henry Paulson or Gary Paulsen or Pat Paulsen.

Faith Paulsen's Links

Salon.com
MAY 29, 2009 10:43AM

Blaming the Otherwise Unidentified Black Man

Rate: 8 Flag

  

  

  

  

  

  

(A Somewhat-Related Digression From the Open Dialogue on Race)

The Open Dialogue on Race continues with a new post on Joy-Ann Reid's blog at:

http://open.salon.com/blog/joy-ann_reid/2009/06/07/open_dialogue_on_race_part_vii_discrimination_envy         

    “BZZZZZZZZZ! "

              "THIS IS AN AMBER ALERT! 

              "REPEAT: THIS IS AN AMBER ALERT!” 

I had dozed off in front of the TV the other morning when the buzz jolted me awake.  I blinked, looked at the screen, saw the counties affected – Bucks and Montgomery Counties Pennsylvania, the mostly suburban where I live.

 

A child was missing.  I listened to the details – You never know, I frequent those roads, while I was driving the carpool, running errands, or out on my bike, I could have seen the car in question.  So I noted the winess's description.

 

“Suspects are two black men, otherwise unidentified.”

 

That’s when I knew. 

 

Maybe it was the echo of Susan Smith.  Even back in 1994 when Susan Smith’s story was first in the news, I remember thinking that her story did not ring true to me.  Smith blamed “a black man” for abducting her children.  And then it turned out she herself had drowned her boys in a lake.

 

Or maybe it was the memory of Charles Stuart, who claimed “a black man” had killed his pregnant wife.  Or the clearly unstable Ashley Todd, a McCain supporter who reported that “a black man” had carved a letter “B” (for Barack) into her forehead but who turned out to have cut her own face.

 

Or maybe the tip-off was that phrase, “otherwise unidentified.”

 

A day later, my hunch is confirmed.  I hear it on my car radio. 

 

A day after claiming via a dramatic cell phone call to 911, that two black men had rammed her car, abducted her and her daughter and thrown them in the trunk of a Cadillac, Bonnie Sweeten and her daughter Julia were found together, safe, in Disney World.

 

Hearing the news, I told myself the police had no choice.  Even if they too had doubts about her story, they had to put out the Amber Alert, they must pursue any possibility, they have to act.  They must investigate the witness’s account -- even as they question it -- as long as a child’s safety hangs in the balance.

 

But Amber Alerts and police procedure aside – and acknowledging how sick, how seriously disturbed these false-reporters are --

 

I have to ask this question – When will this particular lie stop repeating itself?

 

When will false-reporters stop believing they can get away with bald-faced lies as long as they blame it on “a black man”? 

 

"Otherwise unidentified."

 

*  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *  *   *  *

For information on this case: 

Please Check Out:

Open Dialogue on Race Part V

on RonP01's blog

http://open.salon.com/blog/ronp01/2009/05/25/racism_and_classism_open_dialogue_on_race_part_v#

The hypothesis is "Classism has/will replace Racism as the dominant social issue in America."

Catch up on the OPEN DIALOGUE ON RACE:

PART I:  Video: Buchanan, Cheney, and Limbaugh Attack Colin Powell

 Part II: Faith Paulsen  "Racism isn't just political -- It's personal"

Part III: Open Dialogue On Race Part III  "Code Words, Symbols, Stereotypes, & Myths"

Part IV: David A. Love  "(1) Race is a social construct.........
(2) ....... racial disparities that are statistically quantifiable."  
                                                                                                                                                      Ground rules for participating comments in the open dialogue on race:

1. ABSOLUTELY NO PERSONAL ATTACKS
2. NAME-CALLING OR FINGER-POINTING ARE PROHIBITED
3. READ COMMENT(S) THOROUGHLY BEFORE RESPONDING
4. STANDARD OPEN SALON RULES APPLY
5. VIOLATORS WILL BE TOWED

Catch on:  Join the conversation, comments always welcome.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Racism is alive in imperial colonialist america and thriving
(as is misogyny and war-mongering).

(rated)
Out here, the equivalent is "unidentified Hispanic male" or "unidentified Native American male." All are shorthand for "dark skin, dark hair, dark eyes, Other."
Because black defendants are paraded across the 6 o'clock news every day, they probably think it's a safe bet that people will believe that particular brand of lie. These sociopaths have a one size fits all mentality when it comes to branding minorities as CRIMINAL in order to hide their own criminal activity.
There will always be pathetic individuals who will try nonsense like this.

This really isn't a horror...just substantiation of the fact that pathetic individuals live among us.

What does bother me are the people who would use incidents like this to indict an entire population. I'd say 99.999999% of the people in this country as are disgusted with this kind of thing as you and I are, Faith.

We gotta understand it on some level...and stay away from branding ourselves because of it.
Frank, I sure hope you're right.
frank: "I'd say 99.999999% "

Do you gave to major in math to be a bartender?

The more iIread your comments, the more I see you are significantly challenged in ALL of the essentials of moral life.

Mental. moral and, in fact, a physical midget (even got no nads).
It will continue as long as the response is the same... Which is why dialogues and discussions on race are of vital importance...

The chain of events that are triggered when a finger is pointed at an otherwise unidentified black man is almost incomprehensible to the average white person who has never been stopped by the police in middle of the night within sight of their own home simply because of the coloe of their skin........
the ethereal "black men" of these false-reporters minds are more than a product of solitary troubled souls. White folk like Bonnie Sweeten invent black attackers because it helps them in the public light. The racism and fear of the white-dominated media/police/community brings at least short term empathy to people like Bonnie.

Frank, I think you're off a little bit. You're giving white folks too much credit.
About 18 years ago, the husband of a woman I worked with was charged with rape. My co-worker testified that he was home at the time of the alleged rape. The description of the rapist, given by the victim, did not match my co-worker's husband. But the victim ID'd him in court. The victim and my co-worker's husband were casual acquaintances. His fingerprints were found on a glass in her refrigerator. But NO WHERE ELSE in the apartment. And the story of the rape was that the rapist had opened the patio door, entered the bedroom, ransacked the dresser, and then proceeded with the rape. So, why were the only fingerprints on a glass in the refrigerator. Not even on the refrigerator door handle. Nothing in the story charged the rapist with drinking water from a glass in any room of the apartment. Nevertheless my co-worker's husband was convicted. She was white. He was black. The victim (white) had a black boyfriend. I have no idea what really happened. But my sense is that my co-worker's husband went to jail for a crime he did not commit. Not just because he was black, but because the victim was under pressure to identify somebody and he was handy. I hate thinking that justice in our country is that casual.
I think this casual nature of justice is partly to blame for the false charges.
Edgar wrote:

"Frank, I think you're off a little bit. You're giving white folks too much credit."

Yeah, I guess I could be. But I hope its not by more than one or two of those 9's after the decimal point! I truly hope!
Important example of the issue. Racism is far from dead in this country.

Frank, I hate to say it but your % is way, way off. Wish it were not but I live in hillbilly heaven and I can assure you that "unidentified" black men take a lot of the raps here, and when you realize that less than 2% of the county is black you have to believe that black men must commit 99% of the crimes in order to justify the accusations. The accusations are purely racist.

Monte
Faith, thank you for speaking out on behalf of the countless unidentified individuals out there, the potential scapegoats in yet another irresponsible, narcissistic lie. Reading this post, I immediately thought of “Murder on a Sunday Morning,” a profound documentary about just one such otherwise unidentified black man. That film, coupled with “After Innocence,” should make every viewer reconsider their position on capital punishment—and question the precarious vulnerability of the justice system in this country.
—Melissa
I had exactly the same response when I first heard the news report. Even assuming this was a car-jacking, the last thing car-jackers want is kidnapping or murder charges, and they surely don't want to worry about a mother and child. It just didn't make sense.

As for what's going on with Pat Buchanan, et al, let's call it what it is -- neo-racism, which is the same as the old racism only with less obvious language. The High-Priest of neo-racism was Lee Atwater, who used this new-old racism to get Reagan and Bush the Elder elected. Their campaigns as well as Juniors were the most thinly-disguised racism I've seen since "states-rights". And lest anyone forget, states-rights original objective was the states rights to keep slavery legal.

Racism is also part of the war against Islam, and Bush said as much (before his handlers straightened him out about language) when he called it a Crusade. Can't have those darkies controlling Jerusalem -- or all that oil. As Jesse Ventura rightly asked, how many non-Muslims have we water-boarded?
This is disturbing. The amber alert was put into affect to help save children that have been abducted in order to help find them faster and safe. If these false reports continue to go on than soon no one will pay any attention to the amber alert and then the children who really are abducted will be lost because the news wasn't taken seriously.
Unfortunately racism is a big part of these false reports and a part of your country.
Faith, when "hillbilly" prejudice happens in the suburbs, its called suburban prejudice. Blaming the bigotry on the backwoods is a convenient liberal tactic that people use to feel better about their own potentially bigoted/mostly-one-race communities.
You're absolutely right, Edgar. I regretted that term after I posted the comment.
You know what, Edgar, you're so right I've pulled the comment. Thank you for helping me be more careful with my words. I apologize to anyone who was offended.
RonP01, your point reminds me of Neilpaul's piece currently posted on your blog.

Edgar, that's an interesting thought -- that false-reporters get more attention when they play into racial stereotypes.

geezerchick, what a tragedy - and travesty - that you friend's husband went to jail when it sounds like there was at least a reasonable doubt about his guilt. By casual nature of justice, do you mean that once a suspect is found, often the goal becomes to confirm what is already suspected rather than to get to the truth?

Monte, thanks for your rseponse.

Metaness -- I have to check out this documentary you mention, Murder on a Sunday Morning." I have not seen it.

Tom, you make a good point. Her accusation didn't even make sense as a crime. I hadn't heard that great quote from Jesse Ventura before. I think ol' Jesse's been on a roll.

Thanks to everyone for reading my post!

Keep the ball rolling on our Open Dialogue on Race
I'm just glad you're putting real effort and thought into all of this. Thanks for promoting this conversation, Faith.