I've been walking through cemeteries a lot this past week or so. The puppy, who has tripled her size in the seven weeks we've had her (so much for that "little dog" we thought we were getting), knows that the prize for getting through the cemetery is the open fields beyond it. There, she can go off-leash, run her fool Tennessee Treeing Brindle Coon Hound (don't ask--she's a rescue from Kentucky) off, chasing the skittering brown leaves, shoving her nose into tufts of grass looking for voles and mice, barking at the crows that gather in the trees to watch us. She runs closer to me when the nesting pair of red-tailed hawks scream and take to the sky. For the first couple weeks, when she was five pounds or so, I'd get nervous, too, but now she's too big for them to carry her off.
Although there have been days of late when I've kind of wished that the flying monkeys would come for me.
Novembers are rough months around here. The state of denial that one maintains all throughout vibrant, glowing October is drenched in the cold downpour and gusting winds that simultaneously strip the last leaves from the trees and turn everything else brown. Skies range in color from pewter to gunmetal, and the buffetting wind announces that seven months of winter lie before one.
Novembers have been tough in the past for their own reasons. In a few days, I'll mark the occasion of a lover's death, who collapsed of a brain aneurysm while I was with him. For some reason, all the peace I have made with that day gets all fucked up about this time, and I have flashbacks that make me shake, take me to some dark place inside myself I don't want to be.
And yet. None of this is what I started out to write about. I suppose if this was an essay, I'd delete those first few paragraphs, begin again. But as this is a blog, well, if you're still reading, you might as well come along for this ride.
I've been thinking -- a lot-- about whether the work I do means anything. I teach college. Specifically, I teach creative writing. I can say that good things consistently come out of my classes: I see improvement in student writing; I have students who find in themselves a talent they often didn't know they had; most important, for me, is the fact that I create, in my classroom, a zone of trust in which students can write about things they've never told anyone.
For a long time, I assumed my students just didn't know much about the world. For a long time, I thought they only seemed to be concerned with whatever the latest reality show was, or the movie they went to see. (And no, they never discussed books.) For a long time, I was a real grouch about students who wanted to write who didn't read. I still am. Now though, I dispense with the grouchy lecture on the first day of class, when I declare that you can't be a writer unless you read, and then mention that I've been using my budget every year to build up a library, which they are free to use.
What I have found out about my students has enlightened me, enchanted me, but enraged me, too. Certain people on this earth should not be allowed to have children: when I read the stories of what some of my students have gone through, I weep for them. And then I correct their grammar, show them how to make their words more effective, offer to publish them in the school magazine. I have sat with students whose family members have come home from Iraq and Afghanistan as strangers. I have sat with students who have lost best friends in car crashes. I have sat with students who have lost mothers to cancer, who have found out friends their age have terminal diseases, who are watching someone they love self-destruct from drugs or alcohol or mental illness.
They come to me to talk. And I, in turn, counsel them as best I can. Sometimes, I encourage them to write about what's going on. And sometimes, I get them the professional help on campus that is better able to evaluate when a student is on the edge of the cliff.
Is this enough? Is what I do enough?
For months now, I've been haunted by the idea that I'm not doing enough. I feel the need to be somewhere else--the Congo, for example--working with women and children who have experienced war trauma. Or I feel the need to be working with an organization that is bringing direct aid to the starving or victims of war or some other catastrophe.
When I was a kid, I wanted to be Gandhi. That was childhood narcissism, to think that I could do that. But I wonder sometimes whether what I am doing now is simply meaningless.
How many people do we have to lend a hand to before we feel it is enough? At what point will I feel that what I do matters?
I can already hear a voice telling me that there are millions of me, teaching, every day, and dealing with the same things I'm dealing with. And, if I were to quit tomorrow, somebody else would take my place.
So, if it would be that easy to replace me, does that mean that I'm meant to be doing something else? It's the question that eats at me, a lot. Sometimes, it's a mean fucking voice that tells me to just shut up and go to work and do my job. But sometimes, it's a gentle voice that tells me that somewhere, out there, is a job that is meant for me.


Salon.com
Comments
DY--I hear this. That inner voice of mine just won't seem to be quiet of late.
on the other hand, and I do not say this lightly, you can always come back and teach. there are not many people who have a strong need to change the world. you know, we all know the truth is most of the time you don't change the world, if you're lucky and the world is lucky, you can make a small impression on it, and make certain lives much better for however long. if you feel a need to do more, you might do the research to see the viability of your calling. why not?
what is the point of being alive if not to live and follow destiny?
Of course, only you know what is right for you. But don't discount what you already do.
And lib: I hear you. I really do. I know, most days, that I do important work. But there are some days, well, you know....
I should also mention that I have been trying to do work in my community to aid those who are not in college. So far, my attempts have not gotten much beyond the doors of the bureaucrats that I have gone to see-- I assume because they are too busy to help me get the project started. So, I just need to find a way to start it up myself.
The fact that you're still contemplating this change should be all you need to know this is really what you should do.
(thumbified for the crux of the biscuit.)
Are those enough? For you to decide, of course. But I think it's important not to diminish what you do achieve.
you add something rare and important to life on os and you add I'm sure a lot to the lives of your students and your friends and family...maybe have conversations with the voice that asks you to do more and see what it asks of you and what you could do that would be meaningful to you in a bigger way. but also I think you should be careful of listening too hard when the voice keeps saying you aren't doing "enough." Is there an enough for the voice? Is the voice being too hard on you? As much as it's important to follow your dreams it's also important not to overlook what good you have done and are doing in the community where you live.
I'm not a life coach. I have a voice that tells me the same thing. that I should do more. sometimes this voice has led me to more meaningful work, and sometimes this voice has just led me into depression because my voice at least has a hard time ever believing in "enough."
Being there with your students through their hard time--this isn't nothing though. And as far as quitting and someone else taking your place--I hope you don't really believe this. A teacher like you is rare and a writer like you is rare. And not replaceable at all. Too often women just don't hear the appreciation that they should for what they do. If someone took a look at your life and everything you've done and are doing and said this is wonderful. This is amazing. This is extraordinary--you are extraordinary. would this make a difference to your restlessness?
I just say this as someone who admires you. And also admires and respects your heart for changing the world. I hope you continue to follow your heart. But I hope that the voice you hear can also be reasonable and kind not only to changing the world but to you. "Enough" is an impossible word...even for saints. Doing what we can do without harming ourselves or the ones we love in the process...this is important. This matters too. Being happy and joyful some of the time is okay too.
(I read the autobiography of Ghandi once and although he did so much good his children didn't really have a father and they didn't attend decent schools and his wife also remained uneducated...his ideals served his country but not always those in his immediate circle...)
okay I hope this doesn't sound silly or ridiculous.
Skel--I know. I don't know if the Peace Corps has any use for creative writers, either, but if I find out, I'll let you know. :)
Jodi--thanks for reminding me of butterflies.
AHP-Thanks for turning the question around. Sometimes, one needs to change one's perspective to get a more accurate picture.
Dolores--Oh. I know of what you speak. So much so that you just took my breath away. I have to go think about that now.
“I've been thinking -- a lot-- about whether the work I do means anything.”
Let’s settle that immediately. Resounding yes! Consider the impact teachers made upon you, realize that your motive for teaching and counseling is of the most noble order, ponder how few we can ever make that statement about in the course of living our lives, and then recall these words,
“Few will have the greatness to bend history; but each of us can work to change a small portion of events, and in the total of all those acts will be written the history of this generation ... It is from numberless diverse acts of courage and belief that human history is thus shaped. Each time a man stands up for an ideal, or acts to improve the lot of others, or strikes out against injustice, he sends forth a tiny ripple of hope, and crossing each other from a million different centers of energy and daring, those ripples build a current which can sweep down the mightiest walls of oppression and resistance.” - RFK.
Your noble hearted work means more than you’re going to know in this lifetime dear lady.
Rated and appreciated.
I have listened to people's problems my whole life. Literally, since I was a child, other kids would talk to me. Throughout my school years, people would tell me I should be a psychiatrist. Even now, people still come to me for life advice. (It even seems I have a sign on my forehead at the grocery store that says,"What's wrong with you today?") I am no professional but I am compassionate. And I feel that even in my small world, I am making a difference. I work with young children now (K-8), as a volunteer music teacher and sports coach. I KNOW I am making a difference. I don't need to travel to some foreign land; there are kids right in my own town who need me. And it is fulfilling to know that I provide life lessons and advice and encouragement and love to these kids. Maybe it is unrealistic, but I picture some of these children later in life saying to themselves, "Ms. B. never let me get away with 'I don't have a pencil' as an excuse for not doing my homework before practice" or some similar small but important lesson.
So, PLEASE, know that YOU ARE MAKING A DIFFERENCE. And you may never know it, but I promise you that your words or kindness will stay with these kids throughout their LIFETIME and they will pass along your compassion. I believe that with all my heart. You should, too.
OM--I hear what you're saying. I don't pay enough attention, sometimes, to small actions.
And Dennis. Thanks for the words of inspiration. They remind me...
Sometimes "keeping on" seems to hold no relevance, but you have touched many with your generosity, kindness and wisdom. The falling leaves replenish the earth.
I had a teacher like you once upon a time, her name was Mrs. Willis. I grew up in rural Missouri where most people's lives mirrored the television show the Waltons than anything else going on in the early 70's.
Mrs. Willis was was tough on the students, not necessarily "warm & fuzzy" and she was different from the locals. I don't now how she wound up in our little town. She was rather hip and groovy, which immediately made her suspect in our insulated community. I was one of those students with a secret home life that others didn't see, and that my family took great efforts to disguise in public.
She was the first teacher to treat me like a Person, with a capital P. This is amazing because I was only 8 when she came into my life, 3rd grade. We were still corresponding through my college years. Not only did she validate me as a young person who had value and could contribute, she helped give me my voice and develop my confidence.
I lost touch with her after college. The school secretary told me she left and was teaching on a military base in Guam. If I could talk to her today (she would be somewhere in her late 60's possibly) I have so many things I would tell her...above all would be "Thank you".
Now 45, that 12-year-old is a writer, and that teacher is still encouraging her, helping her, reminding her of the past and looking forward to the future.
That teacher is also guiding that student's teenage sons.
That teacher had more to do with me finding, honing and maintaining my voice, and my sense of self, than anyone else.
What you are doing is more than meaningful; is it essential.
I had the chance to go to teachers' college when I was 20, but I realized I was temperamentally unsuited (and probably too stupid) to be any good at it. I commend your continuing efforts.
The other point of inquiry that comes to mind is whether or not your inner critic would ever be satisfied, even if you crucified yourself to do its bidding. The flaming cross you hang yourself upon would be underfueled and you would still not have bled enough in the eyes of a tough inner judge.
I don't know the answer for you. For me it has been that it is possible for me to help and it is not mine to know how much difference I make in the world. For some reason, I can't and I accept that I can't know.
Susanne-Yeah. That voice can be particularly brutal, and it has been of late. Not sure what set it off, but it's been vicious. Sometimes, I think that voice is good for getting me to move, and other times, I think it's just there to torment me.
Boan--thank you for your assurance.
the other Lorraine-; I had teachers like that in my life. I don't know why I never think that I could be one of "them" in someone else's.
Emma--Must be the phases of the universe, because this nagging sense that I need to be moving--but where--is affecting me, too. Glad I'm not the only one
Ben sen--of course you're right, but sometimes it's about wondering about the "one that got away"
Suzabel--I feel honored that you got to honor your teacher here. Beautiful.
Chuck. Yeah. Keeping on. Pushing through. sometimes it's all we've got.
Stim--it's nice to know that it comes across as passion. If I was being mean to myself right now, I could think of other words, but I'm trying to take in the good things right now and quiet the little shit in my head.
if helping young people find their way isnt meaningful, then i dont know what is. true, these are kids that AT LEAST have the wherewithal to go to college. but they are still kids.
and i dont know too much more meaningful than that.
But, on to the question---which we both spoke to today--here's a question that I found useful "Do you do what you do best every day?" Rate yourself on a scale of 1-5. For me right now---between consulting gigs and scrambling for anything---I'm at a "1". But there have been times I've been at a 5.
When you are at 5--that's a huge piece of the puzzle.
but as far as being "replaceable". its true the darwinian economic system makes everyone *feel* replaceable, exchangeable, dispensible, etcetera. but its part of the Big Lie....
stilltryingtofindmyselfamidstalltheconfusionolder/exasperated
Yeah. Me, too.
That's enormous in a person's life. It can lead to so much later on. It's a common thread in the life story of every person I've ever read that overcame a horrible childhood or other tragedy to have a life of giving to others that they had an adult who believed in them, nurtured them -- often a teacher, not a family member. You are modeling so much for them, as well as giving them a sense of self-worth. You have no idea how that will pay off, not only in their own lives, but in the lives of others they choose to help later on.
If you keep talking about injustice in the world with your students, as I know you do, and helping them become competent and even inspired, who knows how many Gandhi's you might make? That's the power of teaching -- to help people become what you yourself might have wanted to be. It's taking what you want to do and multiplying it. There's enormous power in what you do!
I admire your skill as a writer and the ease with which you can move between the recollection of a passionate interlude to a political cause you feel deeply about, and then a series of photos that are often Thoreau-like in your delight with the natural world.
It is only natural to have self doubts about anything we do, or don't do. There is so much suffering and injustice in the world it can seem like nearly all of us lead lives of futile triviality, that we should be doing something tangible to make the world a better place, just a little better.
You are making a difference FLW.
I think it's important for me to note that this time of year always brings out restlessness in me. Today, for example, the sun is shining, and I'm suddenly seeing my way clear to being able to do things at school that would continue to allow me to teach and to do other things (like the Congo teach-in I organized and taught last year). And, on Friday, my students, as if sensing that I needed something from them, wound up having a meaningful discussion about a new book we had started reading (INTO THE WILD) in which they had insights that had never occurred to me. I love when that happens, because then everything feels reciprocal.
Still, that yearning is there. As I figure out how to channel it, perhaps I will continue to write about it. I know I'm not in this boat alone. And I must say, the community that has rallied around me has heartened me in ways that have left me simultaneously humbled and deeply, deeply grateful.
But individual replies are coming, I promise, after I take the puppy out for a walk on a 65-degree, sunny day--how often do you get those in November?
Recently, I was subbing, and it was the last class of the day, and study hall, to boot. Naturally, the kids had no intention of working. Instead, they were break dancing, yes, I said it, break dancing, and mainly just hanging out together, black and white kids, unselfconsciously, developing bonds, relaxing...and I let it happen, but should not have. However, looking back, I can see that something special happened during that hour.
I sat back, and watched, and let it unfold. The possible spin off--we have no way of knowing. But think of it like a stone thrown into a pond, and imagine those ripples.
I teach writing in Rochester, but only as an adjunct, and I'm constantly struggling with the same things you write about. But have you ever had a student come up to you at the end of the semester, or in the halls, and say, "I remember something you said on the first day..."? I think that the joy lies there. Plus, who knows if a student will be walking down a busy street 10 years from now and will suddenly freeze, stricken by something you said or had her read, that appears, mewing and crying, in her arms? It may be that her education begins at that moment, alone at an intersection, and that the cosmos begins -- just begins -- to realign. Anyway, I keep telling myself that...
Once more condolences :/.