fingerlakeswanderer

fingerlakeswanderer
Birthday
May 09
Title
cassandra
Bio
Lorraine Berry lives in the Fingerlakes region of New York, although it's her transplanted home. On weekends, she can be heard throughout the area, cheering on her beloved Manchester City F.C. When not writing at Does This Make Sense? or Talking Writing, she can be found hiking with her two dogs, hanging out with her two daughters, eating what her beloved Rob has cooked for her, or teaching creative writing at a small college in the area.

MY RECENT POSTS

NOVEMBER 18, 2009 10:32AM

Mumbai: No Hostages (part iii , VQR)

Rate: 1 Flag

Part III is now posted.

Imagine what we would learn if one of the 19 suicide bombers who took out the World Trade Center and the Pentagon had lived. In Mumbai, one of the terrorists did live, and his interview in the hospital bed brought up a plethora of feelings for me:

“Where were you supposed to go after today’s incident?”

“Nowhere. We were meant to die.”


How many accomplices were sent with you?

Kasab tried to dodge the question. He was ordered to wage jihad, he said, was blindfolded and put on a boat. Asked if he’d ever done something like this before, he momentarily broke down. “Nowhere, nowhere,” he said. He only did this because Uncle Zaki promised to give his struggling family a large amount of money.

 I think about this. Somehow, you are trained to think that your own life is expendable, but that in making your sacrifice, you are leaving your family in a much better financial position. For those who have grown up in the slums, have endured the degradation of not only poverty, but political repression the likes of which we, as Americans have never known, these pie-in-the-sky promises must be tempting. 

I'm not excusing the behaviour. But I am trying to understand it. I keep thinking that if we understand it, maybe we can prevent it. If we change the structures that create terrorism, perhaps terrorism will disappear. Years ago, Frantz Fanon warned us that terrorism is the weapon of the poor, but we have failed to heed the warning. 

 As Motlagh reports, the Mumbai terrorists were expert at combining chaos and panic to create terror:

Handler: The ATS Chief has been killed. Your work is very important. Allah is helping you. The minister should not escape. Try to set the place on fire.

Gunman: We have set fire in four rooms.

Handler: People shall run helter skelter when they see the flames. Keep throwing a grenade every fifteen minutes or so. It will terrorize.

I try to imagine how the people under attack felt. Like hunted animals. Like prey that was being flushed from every safe place they had found to hide. These are images from my worst nightmares, the ones where some madman is after me, and I hide, trying to quiet my terror pantings so that my very breaths do not give me away.

I finish the article. I feel hatred toward those who organized the attacks. Those who stayed on the telephones with the suicide attackers, giving them orders over the phone. Why were these men, so willing to send others in to do their dirty work, why were they not willing to die for Allah? 

Is this the way of the world? That everywhere, at all times, old men will tell young men that to die in service to your country/religion/family is the highest honor? It is always a myth. Meaningless. Oh so costly. 

The images in my head are blood-stained. The numbers of the people who survived the first attacks only to be taken hostage and then killed methodically. Subject to the terror, for long periods of time, of knowing they were going to die. Cruelty. Sheer cruelty.

I want to understand....

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
It's fascinating to read the comments over at VQR. Witnesses to the original event are writing in to tell their stories, so their narratives are being added to the meta-narrative constructed by the writer.
I'm glad you are trying to understand! We should all strive to understand. It's our only hope, for with understanding there is hope for change. I say this despite, as you pointed out we've all ready been told "that terrorism is the weapon of the poor, but we have failed to heed the warning. " Which says we should all ready understand, now why aren't we heeding?! This is why i so love the book Three Cups Of Tea by Greg Mortenson. Mr. Mortenson has found a way to break that hold of poverty and ignorance and has made a difference to countless lives but he needs all of us to join in with him.

Okay, that's my soap box for today. I'll quit hijacking your post now. Excellent post!
Zashin,
You weren't hijacking my post. I'm glad for the dialogue. I haven't read Three Cups of Tea.
I lost two very close friends and this incident brings up a lot of emotions in me. I say these attacks live. Like the one 9/11 where they attacked an iconic structure of the US (I lost colleagues there too), this particular Hotel built by King George and the Gateway of India is an iconic structure.
Such a waste of human life. So long human kinf exists, this will keep repeating it self.
As Einstien said, I dont know how Warld War 3 will be fought but I know that World War 4 will be fought with sticks and stones.
Sigh.. these attacks leave a void in me.
kalyan,
Thank you for stopping by. I can't imagine the pain you suffered. I'm sorry for it.
why? because there are many humans who like to intimidate through violence in all walks of life.men who intimidate women through violence in marriage, human trafficking and exploitation, forced labour,politics through war and terror to achieve their goals.at the end of the day humans are evolving as social animals most of them like to work in teams and co operate, sad but true quite a majority dont like to evolve still want to live in hitler and hiroshima's world of violence.one thing we can all do look at ourselves first and eliminate violence in our day to day life before preaching and cursing others.Be the change as my father of the nation passed on ,i intend to pass it on to others.After world war 2, from the 70s each generation has been passing on terror(intimidation by violence) from one generation to another it is 2009, no end seems from left terror to islam.by the i was born in 1981 , i couldnt coprehend 9/11, 26/11.But i can comprehend violence in all walks of life