fingerlakeswanderer

fingerlakeswanderer
Birthday
May 09
Title
cassandra
Bio
Lorraine Berry lives in the Fingerlakes region of New York, although it's her transplanted home. On weekends, she can be heard throughout the area, cheering on her beloved Manchester City F.C. When not writing at Does This Make Sense? or Talking Writing, she can be found hiking with her two dogs, hanging out with her two daughters, eating what her beloved Rob has cooked for her, or teaching creative writing at a small college in the area.

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
SEPTEMBER 2, 2010 1:42PM

Is the Newest Oil Rig Explosion My Fault?

Rate: 32 Flag

01

(Photo from Salon.com. Deep Water Horizon burning.)

I have the air conditioning on. Outside, it's 91 degrees at 1:10 p.m. By late afternoon, especially down on the Commons, it could once again top 100 degrees. 

September 2nd is usually the beginning of autumn here. At night, it should be nippy enough that I would have added a blanket to the bed, and, if going out, have layered myself in a cardigan. Right now, Rob and I sleep, on top of the sheets, nude, and debate the efficacy of opening a window when the temperature has only dropped 20 degrees. 

I am sitting here in my second-floor apartment, grading a batch of papers by my new students. 

Or I was.

I went on the Internet to retrieve a late paper that was being sent via e-mail when I saw the headlines about the newest oil rig explosion, and I felt sick.

The hum of the air conditioner amplified my unease. 

We have had the hottest summer on record. Consecutive weeks of 90-degree plus weather, little rain, one brief respite of a few days of 60-degree days, and then the hot weather returned. Trees are shedding leaves like a Husky in spring, and already, I'm concerned that the beauty that keeps  me sane--namely, the iridescence of fall--as winter bears down upon us, will be lost to the drought and the heat. 

Reports say that the 13 members of the crew of the rig owned by Mariner Energy have been accounted for. That is fantastic news, given that we quickly forgot the men who perished on the Deep Water Horizon. (I take marine accidents personally, given that my brother fishes in the Bering Sea, the most dangerous profession in the country)

Of course, working on an oil rig is dangerous. As is coal mining, and this Labor Day, how many of us are going to remember the risks that we put others through to make sure we can drive our cars to our vacation destinations?

Which brings me back to my air conditioning.

My air conditioning is brought to me courtesy of coal miners. Just up the lake, you can see the enormous coal plant that burns, night and day, each and every day of the year, to keep us hot when we're cold and cool when we're hot, to power this computer upon which I type, to power the refrigerator that keeps my food fresh, and my rooms lit against the blackness of night.

Each evening, this entire town comes to a stop as the enormous coal train lumbers through, crossing major intersections at rush hour. Dozens of coal cars, packed to the rim, bringing up black gold from just over the Pennsylvania border. And we sit, our engines running, as we await the raising of the railroad-crossing barriers. 

At this moment, this region is involved in an enormous, neighbor-vs-neighbor fight over the natural gas companies who want to frack us. Sure, some of us will get rich from leasing our properties to the natural gas companies, but most of us will get screwed when our drinking water becomes contaminated. 

 

 

I've turned the air conditioning off. Already, the temperature in the room has risen a few degrees, and the air thickens and presses against my face, inviting the migraine to begin. 

I struggle. I ask myself if my air conditioning is contributing to the problem. Yes. Of course. Of that, there's no doubt. But does turning off the air conditioning, sitting in misery while I work, is that going to make a difference? 

If each and every one of us agreed to turn off our air conditioning for one day, to really feel how hot it's getting, how we're boiling in that big pot on the stove, would it be enough to make us stop and pay attention to what the hell we're doing to our earth? 

Would it make us think about what our thirst for energy costs others? The miners in Chile? The dead from the Deep Sea Horizon? The 13 crew members on board the oil rig that's currently burning? The millions of fish, fowl, and mammals that died in the gloopy mess of the Gulf? Of Prince William Sound in Alaska? Of the troops who died in Iraq? Of the troops who are dying in Afghanistan? 

My head spins. Maybe it's the heat. 

I have papers to grade. 

In five more minutes, I'm going to turn that air conditioner back on, and, if I'm lucky, obliviousness will return. 

It's too hot to think right now. 

 

 

 

 

 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Yes, Lorraine. Suffer or perish. It's sad news indeed. Thanks for a nicely written piece in response to what ultimately is always a human tragedy.
I'm sure we are all guilty. It's a vicious cycle, like your air conditioner. Even if I drove a Prius, which I don't, I would still be guilty. My plastic cups, my polypro clothes, my vast migrations on the roads of America, my plane trips, all the goods that arrive in Alaska from the rest of the world on ships and planes... Holy cow!!! It's my fault!!!!
this is a perfect response posting--making each reader taking this event personally. thank you
I wonder how people lived in Arizona before electricity. It seems impossible on some days with it. We do get humidity in the summer, during monsoon, it's not all dry heat. The oil rig is causing your hot summer night as surely as your need for electricity causes an oil rig and coal plant. It's not a matter of fault. Sorry for your discomfort. If we learned to adjust the way the Spaniards did, with siesta, perhaps life would be a little more tolerable all around.
Oryoki,
If we learned to build our houses out of mud, keep our window shades closed during the day, keep our windows open at night, take advantage of siesta, change our waking hours--yes. I agree. I lived in Italy for a while, where the heat is also quite intense, but there was much less suffering. For one thing, nothing is cooler on a hot Italian afternoon than the inside of a magnificent cathedral...
we're embedded in an economy and political system that make it very difficult to be functioning, contributing members of society without participating in eco-destruction, nor can many of us simply get off the grid, when it's the grid that keeps most of us alive

can we hope that thinking, learning, teaching, spreading the word, bearing witness to truth, holding our representatives accountable, mitigate in part our complicity? I think we have to
I wish we had a better way . . . right now it's just one more fucked up cycle of life, and short of finding a way to step off the grid almost entirely, there aren't many choices which really change the cycle.
FLW- eschewing the grid is not the solution, either, as the intensity of labor and the dirtiness of wood burning is a step backwards. So, simplicity may be found by refining and reducing, using prudence. Money can not be made off of passive energy, and so there will be many laws preventing its integration into "society". Same with alternative housing. It would be nice if we lived like Hobbits, but what would we be willing to give up to get there? Our laptops? Our refrigerators? What would we be willing to use in place? Hard answers for any of us, because we must survive and be productive in any environment.
This was a very thought-provoking post, Lorraine, and I think things are going to get much worse as global warming continues to worsen.

But I endorse Jane's comment. Your/my personal culpability in this is very tiny. People are always going to choose comfort. Lack of industry oversight and governmental indifference are the biggest culprits.
I knew when I started writing this that I had no answer. Just this feeling in the pit of my stomach that it's going to get worse.

As if we I didn't need anything else to remind me that I'm powerless, well, here came this. And so, as Roy says, I just find myself bearing witness, paying attention, and hoping that the small things I can do will somehow make a difference.
Very well put, L.
I just walked to the garden store to get some collard plants for the winter garden. Feeling smug for not driving? Very briefly as I still drive the car to Trader Joe's two blocks away...
Air conditioning, the power strips for all of the ghost electricity stealers like computers and TVs...there is a lot we can do...every little bit helps.
Air conditioning, the power strips for all of the ghost electricity stealers like computers and TVs...there is a lot we can do...every little bit helps.
I feel you on this. I am at a Community Action Conference with my husband (his work conference-my "writing vacation") We had lunch and he grimly described what the last session was about. There is no need to dwell on it here. But the researcher who presented gives us maybe another five years before a total collapse of our economic and social system. If we all believed it and put united effort, there still isn't enough time to avert it now. And one of the major problems is our dependency on oil which will effect everything. Shall we dance, knowing the house is on fire? Maybe.
lorraine, it's not just the heat. our planet is crying. are we going to ignore the tears?
This piece is so important. A well deserved EP and I hope everyone reads it.
Lorraine, great post, and these are questions everyone should answer for themselves. I moved to the mountains so I didn't need ac, and this year it was so hot, I needed one anyway. But even if we all cut down, the wealthy and the oblivious will force the demand to stay high. The value in your question is, if the power systems fail - a real possibility - could we live without our power-ed up existence. It's worth shutting down the ac periodically to find out.
Sure. We could solve the energy crisis if everyone below the Mason Dixon moved to Canada and stopped using AC. Of course, then they would use a lot of heating oil, so maybe that's not the best strategy. Or ocean liners and battleships could get all their oil from the gulf. They just have to hang around waiting for spills. Not expedient, but cheap. And they would need someone with a hose that can siphon gas without swallowing it.
I'm so glad you made the explicit connection between Iraq, Afghanistan, and America's energy needs. They are inextricably linked. But don't blame yourself for the lack of a national energy policy. There's only so much one person can do.
If I had air-conditioning, I wouldn't turn it off, but since I don't, I'm perfectly willing to blame the rest of you that do. On the other hand, as you said, it's too hot to think right now, so my reasoning may be flawed.
Lorraine, you've got me thinking: about what, if any, personal responsibility I bear, about what, if anything, I can do, and about the power of writing, about which I have no doubt. Thank you for that.
you can make decisions for yourself, but you cannot participate in community decision making. so relax and turn the air conditioning back on, because the usa won't be saving the planet any time soon.

the only genuine 'gw' legislation is population control. seen any evidence of that happening?
There are so many ways we could change the way we consume and quantitatively make an impact and send a message loud and clear. We would have to sacrifice and ration though - I don't use air conditioning at home - been 100 degrees for the last week - believe it or not in Maine. Until I was 44, I never bought gas because I rode a bike in Philly and did not get a driver's license until 44 and my first car at 45 - in beautiful Maine, I have a car and every day that I buy gas I am conscious of the impact. I am looking into alternate ways of heating my house since my oil furnace died. We may not be able to go cold turkey on all our energy consumptions but we certainly could make a big difference if we really do care. Action speaks louder than words and big corporations will only understand and get the message when we refuse to line their pockets in the manner that they are accustomed to...
I'm torn - I recently wrote a post complaining about how not having air conditioning in Paris makes the summer miserable. All the same, I do see your point. But then again, when there was a long heatwave here a few years back, 15,000 people died because they weren't equipped to deal with the high temperatures. There has to be a compromise. I wish we could just find a way to effectively convert to solar energy. But I know there are a lot of issues with that. Nuclear is supposed to be clean and good...but it scares the heck out of me. Thinking about all this is torture. I'd say, for now, leave on your air conditioning and contribute to a fund to help the victims of this oil disaster. When the first one happened, I donated money to The International Bird Research Rescue Center. It wasn't much, but I like to think it helped. I hope you'll have some piece of mind about air conditioning, and I hope we can all find a solution one of these days...
My opinion is that:

1. I like the essentially symbolic act of turning off the AC and a moment of penance for the aggregate costs of energy use in the developed world. Overall, we live well compared to our ancestors and most of the rest of the world and it is too easy to forget.

2. Alternative energy needs to go from a "nice idea" to a compelling national priority.

3. As Stalin said, one death is a tragedy, a million a statistic. People die every day in job related accidents. But way, way less than in the not so distant past. Among the most dangerous jobs are any that require driving and jobs like convenience store clerks. Here is a list of annual fatalities by industry group and cause.

4. Overall, people are good. I like the fact that people on OS are concerned with this.

5. Turn your air conditioner back on tomorrow. Take care of yourself. Take care of your students.

The above may sound arrogant and presumptuous, but I think that perspective is in order and we are doing much better now than 80 years ago when we (as Americans) totally raped the earth in the ecological disaster referred to as the dustbowl.

Excellent post and rated, of course.
I wish, we Americans, could have a "walk day". A whole day where we all lay aside our convenience of the car and either carpool via public transportation, cycle, walk or take the day off. I would love to see what a collective day like that would do to the oil barons as well to our own sense of entitlement. I know I'm guilty of taking things for granted. There is something to be said for a moment in time of disallowing ourselves of a thing, a penance if you will.

I wish we had more opportunities as a collective to feel what this might be like - to work together towards a solution.
Yes, well. Well, just yes. True shit.
Amid all the ranting and raving about the perfidy of Big Oil and its executives--only scape goats in my opinion--I have kept looking for something like this. You are the first whom I have encountered to make a start at least at placing the ultimate responsibility for this mess where it belongs--with each and every one of us.
Truly felt, and well done. But after 6 hrs. on the road today, attendant traffic, and several meetings, I am, truly, well done. I'm turning the AC on, dear.

(Oh. And fracking sucks wind.)
It's the same with everything electrical. Computers, TV's, ovens, refridgerators, etc, etc, etc. It's always a battle of conscience if you have one. It's been hotter where you live this week than it's been down here in the Sunshine State. Go figure. Oh, and BTW, have you heard that Global warming is a myth?
It was YOU. It was all YOU! It wasn't an impossibly over-extended fossil fuels market that is bursting at the seams from massive build ups in infrastructure in India and China and elswhere to try and stay ahead of impending social catastrophe. . .NO. It was YOU, all along, it was all YOU!!!!

And stop using spray cans, too. You're breaking up the ozone.

rated.
I appreciate your awareness but sadly have no answers. Is there a way out? How can we live a different way and have it make a difference? I have only questions and concerns. I would sacrifice some comfort if asked and knew it was part of a broader solution. In the meantime, will it ever rain again?
Oblivous. That is the truth of it, but the truth is some of us are more oblivious than others -- for some reason, they are called Conservatives.
It's actually my fault. I gave in this summer and allowed air conditioners in two rooms. And now I can't sleep without 'em.

I like taking pictures of wind turbines, but I'm not sure if that is even an answer. I don't connect (ha ha) electricity to coal in my consumption. Maybe we need an energy pyramid, like the food pyramid, to give a basic lesson.

I literally lived in tents or rudimentary structures for a few years - during the summer. I moved indoors when I became feral. Bathed in lagoons, brushed my teeth with precious gallons of water. It's not hard unless you have children or a career.
Now I am a huge consumer. And yet I still feel like I live more simply than others - but obviously much less "simply" than those who don't get to choose.
I wonder if the concsious consumer is going to get us out of the hole - or if a communal poverty, which is the norm in many other countries, is our destiny.
I feel like I'm good at being poor, but not sure I want to give up the thought of rising in socio-economic ways.
Thanks, Lorraine. I lived happily without the A/C - just used fans and exhaustion - and that is one thing I will give up today.
Yeah, you are right, commenting on something is very easy. We can express our sadness but cannot do anything for the tragedy, we can take the help of the government or the government should itself grant some relief to suffering people through funds.
very well said, Lorraine r.
I appreciate the thoughtful responses to this post. I just felt so enraged and helpless when I heard about the second rig explosion--just felt as if I was seeing the future--more and more of these types of industrial accidents connected to our endless hunger for more energy.

I should mention that we have one window-unit in the house that we use to cool the living room, where both of us have our computers. I suppose that in the scheme of things, it's really nothing, but a lot of nothings add up.

Still, I also agree with many commenters that the major culprits are behind the comfy bed that the political parties and the energy companies have made for themselves. I wonder if oil executives think about their grandchildren, and what they're leaving behind to their progeny? Or do they think that, somehow, the rich will always find a way to survive?
Ever try to convince a bunch of old folks that using electricity/ac/water is over-consuming? To a person, they (in my building at least) come back with, "Well, we don't pay for it so it doesn't cost us anything." Gotta love that logic. And they all to a person think I'm a little crazy for worrying about it and asking them not to run water by the gallon just to rinse one plate or cup, not to let every light in the place burn all day and most of the night, not to run their furnace or ac all the time while the windows are wide open. I've never seen such waste as I encounter here. And don't even get me started on the amount of paper products used--we don't pay for trash pick-up either, so why worry? Arg.

Thanks for this, Lorraine. I know it makes you crazy, as it does many of us. I wish I had an answer. But I don't. All I can do is try to use these things sparingly--and maybe, just maybe, encourage others to do the same. Rated. D
The homeotherm's dillemma
Questions about individual responsibility...yes. I'm sure we can all change things which might make a difference.
It's too hot to think right now. We've inherited a world that uses a template for progress that's unsustainable. Your list of lives lost, of dollars wasted--those are a part the true cost of that template we use, but those costs have externalized for decades--spread thinly across the globe in minute layers and increments. Only now are we starting to gasp as we bury ourselves alive under those layers. Sure, it's a little hot, maybe the Indus river is flooding (Where's that?), another hurricane drowns Bangladesh. What? St. Mark's is flooded again? Too bad--Venice was such a pretty place. The lower ninth ward? Well, it never was really that pretty, was it? We have 6 billion individual rationalizations for doing nothing. But we have to lose that inertia. Vast trains of coal exit the Montana prairie headed for power plants in the midwest. Those same plants fuzz out your views, sterilize your lakes. Electricity is easy to make. Vision is hard to find (Remember who said "This energy crises is the moral equivalent of war"? Wasn't he electorally crucified, or something?) We have be doing all we can, when we can, advocating as much as we can.
We are all guilty by degree. In short, I live a life considerably different than I did 10 years ago. I DO turn off the AC, I pick up trash on the beach, I don't buy aerosol cans, I support organic farming, I buy second hand clothes, I ride a bike whenever I can, I reuse tons of items, repair things I'd normally throw out, I'm cautious with cleaners and detergents (barely use laundry detergent for instance), I TRY to walk lightly on this earth. So I hear your point, but there are SO many small things that make a difference. CHoices we'll make in the next hour.

BUT WITH THAT SAID, the level of big, corporate corruption is so great, so powerful, so pervasive, that my adaptations don't amount to squat in comparison. THAT'S what makes me mad. We may all be guilty - but there are some that are PROFOUNDLY guilty. Nothing touches them.
We have embarked on an economic and a political system that makes it very difficult to be functioning, contributing members of society without participating in the eco-destruction, not many of us just out of the grid when the grid is most of us live