GaryBaumgarten

GaryBaumgarten
Location
New York, New York, USA
Title
Director of News and Programming
Company
Paltalk.com
Bio
Award winning journalist Gary Baumgarten hosts the News Talk Online show on Paltalk.com. He asks critical questions, and invites people from all around the world to talk directly to his newsmaker guests using Paltalk's voice over IP technology. Gary came to Paltalk as director of news and programming from CNN where he was the radio bureau chief and correspondent in New York for a decade, where he covered, among other things, the 9/11 attacks in New York and Hurricane Katrina. He was previously reporter and assistant news director at CBS all news radio station WWJ in Detroit. Prior to that he was managing editor at Detroit Radio News Service and a reporter for the Jackson (MI) Citizen-Patriot, the Detroit News and a number of weekly newspapers. Paltalk is the largest multimedia interactive program on the Internet with more than 4 million unique users. News Talk Online is also syndicated by CRN Digital Talk Radio to cable systems serving an additional 12 million households.

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
DECEMBER 3, 2010 11:33AM

Posting school fight online results in suspensions

Rate: 3 Flag

By GARY BAUMGARTEN

We all remember the days when the rumors would run through the school.

“They’re gonna be a fight after class – by the bike racks” was how we always got the word at Coffey Junior High School in Detroit.

Sure enough, after class, seemingly the entire student body would be gathered to watch the fight. I’d always wonder, “are the teachers and the principal this blind that they don’t see this going on?” But never, not once, did a teacher or other school official – not even the janitor – show up to break things up.

We’d all watch the fight and then go home – excitedly talking among ourselves about who the newest, baddest kid in the school was. The next day, we’d always watch from afar to see how the loser was treated. Once popular – he was always shunned – at least until the embarrassment over his defeat waned.

Never were there any real consequences. But I always figured that if there were, certainly it would be the boxers, not the ones “promoting” the fight  by spreading the word nor those in attendance, who would get suspended.

Today, things are much different. Today, your biggest infraction as a student would be to use your camera phone, video the fight and post it on YouTube.

Once again – this time on Long Island – five Half Hollow Hills High School East students have been suspended for posting a video of a fight on YouTube. The school says they were disciplined for one day for “sensationalizing violence,”the New York Post reports.

Right.

The reason they were suspended is because the video – which YouTube has since removed – embarrassed the school.

The same thing happened to my daughter when she was in high school. She happened to witness an altercation in the school cafeteria and posted it on the Internet. There were teachers and lunch aides in the vicinity of the spat when it happened. None of them took action.

After it was posted, my daughter got in trouble. But not the girls who were involved in the altercation. Despite the evidence collected by my daughter.

It made sense in a way. The school’s reputation was far more important to the school than the safety of the students. Just like in this case on Long Island.

Gary Baumgarten is news and programming director at the Paltalk News Network.

Author tags:

education, school, youtube

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
dude, theres this thing called "posting anonymously" or pseudonymously. you can do it with videos. give it a shot. theres a good reason for it. yes, ALL AUTHORITY IS BASED ON HYPOCRISY. surprise!!!
@tomreedtoon
Seriously? Have we become that jaded about our children's health and education??? I don't know which I find sadder, the contents of the article or your comment on it...
OK -- as a long-ago graduate of HHHHSWest -- seeing a photo of the "rival" school from my home district pop up on your blog threw me for a bit of a loop. (My fondest memory of HS East -- the annual visit of my elementary school class to the school's planetarium (yup, the high school had its own planetarium)).

So the gist of your post, Gary, is that the budding social media journalists were punished in lieu of the actual brawlers. I'm not siding with the school administration here, but I do want to note that the NYPost article you link to doesn't really tell us what happened to the brawlers themselves either way. I don't think the administration was justified in punishing the YouTube posters at all, but I also don't see evidence to suggest that theirs was treated as "the biggest infraction" (your words), either.