Broadsided

Modern ballads from a modern broad
Editor’s Pick
FEBRUARY 28, 2009 2:11PM

The Violence We Live With

Rate: 6 Flag

My friend’s boyfriend is flipping out about the Mardi Gras day shootings here in New Orleans. I want to scoff, really I do, but seven people were shot—including an 18-month-old baby—while they were watching parades, arms outstretched, catching beads, only a few blocks from where my family, friends, and I were standing a few hours before. The young men responsible were apprehended within moments, but no motive has been forthcoming; all of the victims appeared to be random bystanders.

And of course, the question everyone has is why. And the next question is, what is wrong with this city? I find myself waiting for the logical explanation for gunfire into a celebrating crowd. I wonder what I would have done had I heard gunshots near me, seen people fall next to me, felt a bullet graze my toddler son as I held him up to catch a bead or stuffed animal.

And then I wonder why I skip over the story, why I want to scoff at my friend’s boyfriend. I wonder, why am I not freaking out? Has it become such a normal part of living in New Orleans that I am willing to accept random acts of violence as part of the price we pay to live here? What if it had been me, my friends, my family who had been shot? Do I ignore it because it hasn’t happened to me? Is it only a matter of time?

Violence in this city has touched me personally. A year after we returned from our Hurricane Katrina-motivated exile, a friend of mine, Helen Hill, was shot and killed in her home; her husband and two-year-old son were chased down and fired at as they hid in their bathroom. Her story made national headlines, too, and her killer has never been found, her death never explained. She and I were not terribly close, but she and her husband were some of the first friends we made when we moved to this city, and their passion for this place was contagious, even as they put themselves to work to improve the many problems here. It still is difficult not to think of the horrible end to their stay here as a warning for those of us who come here to make a difference: get out, get out now before it happens to you.

But I am working hard at seeing it differently. I want to believe that the violence, the poverty, the crime, the pain can be overcome. That the overwhelming problems our city is plagued with can be addressed, that we won’t sink under the weight of it all. Am I an optimist or a fool? Will I feel differently when it happens to me? For now, since Helen’s death, I keep my doors locked even when I’m home and always use the peephole before I open my home. I tell myself that that’s just smart city living. I tell myself it’s a small price to pay to live in such an amazing place. I tell myself I want to raise my children here, I want to grow old here, I want to be part of the fabric of this city. But I don’t want to become one of its bloody statistics, a news story, a reason to leave for good.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
New Orleans is one of the most unique cities in the world. It is a shame that it continues to languish, that violence is a continued problem.
I visited the city only once: in Sept. 2005 with my Army unit. Even then, in the abandoned city, amongst the destruction and death I sensed something mystical and primal about it. In more ways than one I am haunted by New Orleans...
Best of luck to you.
MJ
The argument I make (sometimes successfully, sometimes not) is that if all the good people run away scared, only the riffraff will be left. I'm not ready to surrender my city to them...but then, I don't have a small child I'm responsible for.

I guess what makes me less scared than I probably should be is the fact that we all gonna die sooner or later, and the belief none of us truly goes before his time. I want to grow old here too, but the truth is, I don't know if I will even grow old in the first place. None of us anywhere on earth knows for sure how much time we've got.

So I guess that whether I live to be 100 or die today at 28, I'd like to make the most of what I've got, and for me that means living here.
Hang in there New Orleans. It'll never be the same after Katrina. God-willing, it'll get better. If you have to leave, there's no shame in it on your end. It's just a shame the city's deteriorating like this. Cheers from St. Louis. Great post. Sad times.
Ginny, I just read the last of the National Guard is leaving New Orleans, after 3+ years presence in the wake of Katrina. I have to be honest, living on the west coast, I wasn't aware of the problems the residents of New Orleans still face.

Our government failed miserably when Katrina demolished your city & it appears history is repeating itself. Even the guard members acknowledge the need for their presence to keep order. I am saddened our government spends billions in foreign aid, that non-profits like peace corp occupy 3rd world countries, & the needs of your cultural city after a historical disaster are ignored.

I have seen several documentaries covering the aftermath of Katrina, a slow progression, often with the humanitarian efforts of those with ties to the city. I wasn't aware of the impact that crime has had. Unfortunately, that's a problem every large city faces today. What makes New Orleans problem unique is the lack of law enforcement protection we all take for granted.
Thank you all for your supportive, warm comments. I have never felt as at home in a place as I do in New Orleans, and I try to focus on what makes this city--and its people--special. Since Katrina, especially, I have found the inhabitants to be generous, spirited, noble, resiliant--and throwers of the best parties. When I look around, I see vibrancy, not deterioration; yet when violence continues to shatter our sense of security, I worry. I came back after Katrina, I'm still here despite the violence, but where is my personal line in the sand? I hope I never find out--I wish none of us did.
My husband was born and raised in Metairie and River Ridge, and most of his family still live in Jefferson and St Tammany parishes.

I was up here during Katrina; my husband was still in Houston, finishing work on our house to get it ready to sell. He and his brother had to go evacuate his parents after the storm, because they had refused to leave. None of them had any way to keep up with what was going on, so I was up here online, reading everything, and relaying information to them. When we went down there for Xmas that year, I was horrified to see in person what had happened to the city. Hearing about this type of violence horrifies me in pretty much the same way.

It seemed there was a nice break from the violence after the hurricane, when anybody who could had evacuated; and then it picked up again, with a vengeance.

There is police presence in the city, and in fact the cops are pretty tough and one of those "don't mess with the cops" kind of police forces. The problem is the level of crime is so outrageous that a police force sufficient for any other city of similar size is insufficient for NOLA.

The abject poverty in the projects is truly unbelievable unless you see it for yourself. I've been in some rough neighborhoods before, including South Central, Watts, and the Tenderloin District, but only in NOLA's projects did I fear for my safety even just driving through. When there is that type of poverty, there will be high crime, because no one feels they have anything to lose, and no reason to care about anyone else, because who cares about them?

It seems the violence since Katrina has changed in nature, as well. Gang fights happen anywhere and everywhere, right out in a crowd where anyone could be hit by a stray bullet. The viciousness seems to have escalated, too--there are things happening in NOLA that even shock my husband's family, and they've been there for generations.

Your friend Helen who was killed--was she a school teacher? The name and circumstances sound familiar. That was a horribly shocking crime, and by all accounts happened to a nice family that was trying to make the city better. In the story I'm remembering, I think her husband left the city afterward?

My husband is especially shocked that this happened during Rex. Kind of a "how can you disrespect Rex that way?!" kind of response. So sad.

Stay safe down there, y'all.
Hm, that got kinda long. Sorry for the blog-jacking. :)
Merwoman, it sounds like your connections to this city are quite deep. I think your assessment of how it's been post-Katrina crime-wise are right-on. The extreme poverty combined with miserable public schools creates kids who grow up feeling as though they have no value, no options, and a lot of anger. And guns. There seem to be so many guns everywhere; where are 14-year-olds getting guns?!

Helen was a filmmaker, and she taught film out of her home and around town. She and her husband were activists, always fighting to improve the lot of the less fortunate, as well as great supporters (and participaters) in the arts. Paul went back to Nova Scotia, last I heard, with their preschooler son, but not before writing some beautiful essays for the local paper imploring the citizens of New Orleans to stop killing each other, to stop destroying this special place. It makes my eyes tear up just to think of it.

I hate to focus so much on the negatives here. I believe that we can overcome them, that this city is worth fighting for. But every once in a while, I can't ignore what's going on around me and have to voice my ambivalence. Thanks for understanding, y'all.
There is such anguish here, so long after Katrina had - I thought! - resulted in a glorious re-birth for your wonderful city. I wish you well - and safe. (rated)
Well, perhaps dismantling the projects will help. Public housing projects have proven to be a complete and total failure everywhere they've been tried, for the same reasons--culture of poverty, gangs, guns, drugs, violence. There's a reason that people outside of Chicago know the name Cabrini Green, you know? I really hope that helps down there. The people in the projects deserve better, and so does everybody else in NOLA.
It's a such weird place--there has been a wonderful rebirth of the city--I definitely feel like most of the folks who are here *want* to be here, and so there's an enhanced sense of community, that we're all in this together.

At the same time, there's the uptick in crime, especially violent and meaningless crime (if there is such a thing--I guess I mean more violence against people not involved in gangs or drugs, random people with no ties to their assailants).

But then there is more public outcry against the violence, more community organization to get our police and our leaders to step up and fix the problems, to be accountable, which makes me hopeful again.

Dismantling the projects is one step; replacing the homes lost with affordable housing needs to be the next--not always a given with the way things work here. I drive by one ex-project-now-weedy-lot all the time, and it's frustrating to see. (Other areas have had more success.)

But the more of us who keep up the pressure, keep talking about it, and work toward making it better, I believe *will* make it better. (Do I sound like a cheerleader yet? Rah, rah, New Orleans!)