GirlyBoy

A Mother's Journey
Editor’s Pick
OCTOBER 26, 2009 1:45AM

A boy named Sue. Or Jessie. Or Alex...

Rate: 22 Flag

One of the fun aspects of any pregnancy is choosing what to name your child. The name you ultimately choose is most likely one that had bubbled to the top of a list of others that for one reason or another were eventually rejected. The name you finally arrive upon is one that successfully underwent a battery of tests including:

  • The last name check:  How does the name go with the surname? Does it make her sound like a hooker or him like a nerd?
  • Potential disparaging word rhymes:  Does the name rhyme with any bodily functions or secretions?
  • Creative vs. Practical:  Would you hire a lawyer named Sunbeam?

My husband and I had a really hard time deciding on a name for our first son. We had the girl name picked out – no problem. The boy name, however, took quite a bit more effort. Ultimately, we decided on a name that was deeply meaningful for both of us for different reasons and with which had very positive associations. As it worked out, it is also a popular male biblical name. Given the state of our world in 2003, we had agreed that although we do not subscribe to any religious order, it probably wasn’t a bad thing that his name would be widely accepted by one of the largest religions in the world. The name we chose was one less thing that would bring unwanted attention to him regardless of which spiritual path he may (or may not) choose for himself. It was also a decidedly masculine name.

My husband and I do our best to teach our children to respect everyone, regardless of their beliefs, as long as they bring no harm to anyone or anything. We have our own, personal sense of spirituality, and for us, it works. I have mentioned “god” to GirlyBoy before in the context of something greater than us humans and that which is all around us, but not as the creator of life or a singular diety, which is why the conversation we had with GirlyBoy on the way back from a family day trip really floored me.

It started out normal enough: BoyBoy and GirlyBoy were having some circular dialog about names. BoyBoy (who is 3 and is at that stage where he likes to make it known that he knows stuff—like names) went around the car calling out our names. When he got to his brother, GirlyBoy quickly chimed in, “Oh, that’s the name Mommy and Daddy gave me when I was born. But I have another name that god gave me.”

This piqued my interest. Although we knew of his “alter-ego” names (“Josephina” was hugely popular when he was 3 years old, and more recently “Jessie/Jessica”), I was curious to know more about the process by which he selects these other names. With interest I replied, “Go on. Tell me more about it.”

“It’s kind of a secret. I know you guys gave me my name when I was born, but god gave me another one.” I checked his face to see if he was joking. Was he trying to pull one over on us? He didn’t seem like he was living out some fantasy situation, but here was my 6 year old child telling me, very straight-faced, that he had received a divine visitation. In any case, I played along in ho-hum sort of way, attempting to ignore the chills running up my spine.

“What do you mean it’s kind of a secret? I want to know. What did god tell you your name is? Just tell me. Please?” I urged inquisitively.

Without meeting my eyes, he said, “I have my name you gave me ----, my middle name you gave me, and the name god gave me.”

“What is that name, sweetie,” I more told than asked. At this point in the conversation, I expected him to say “Jessie” at which point I would be able to call his bluff.

“Alex,” he replied.

Upon hearing a name I had never heard him use before, I exchanged glances with GirlyBoyPapa (who was driving). I knew right then that he, like me, had a million questions running through our minds, and surprisingly, GirlyBoy seemed to be receptive to answering some of them—something we rarely experience. Yet we knew that a barrage of questions slung at him would instantly close the window, so we had to proceed with caution if we didn't want him to shut down.

“Alex? Hm…” I replied. “That’s a nice name. When did god give you this name?” I asked.

“Before I was born,” he said.

“Oh I see. And when you heard this name, was it a name for a girl or a boy?” I held my breath waiting for his answer. What he said next might be a very important clue that could cast some light on how GirlyBoy sees himself and “who” his soul really is. I just HAD to know.

“Uhdunno. A boy and a girl. He didn’t really say. It wasn’t a boy or a girl.”

Alex: neither a boy nor a girl. Or both. My mind raced. Who is Alex in the context of religion and god? Was he –or she—an angel? In all my years of Catholic schooling, I didn't remember that name.

Later that evening, I entered “St. Alex” in the Google search field and discovered that there was indeed such a religious character. His life did not stand out as anything particularly noteworthy, but he is regarded as a martyr by the Catholics. The final passage of the description, however, spells out exactly the virtues of this particular saint. It brought everything full circle:

“Today when we are criticized by friends and societySt. Alexander is a prime example of how we should stand fast in the face of ridicule and ostracism.” (from http://www.catholic.org/saints/saint.php?saint_id=165)

Yep. That’s my little activist – standing tall and strong in the face of a society that tells him it’s not ok for him to dress like a girl, play with dolls, paint his nails, or wear headbands and makeup. He does all that and somehow manages to make people realize that he is NOT a freak, that he IS fun and funny, that he too craves and enjoys friendship and acceptance by others. In a beautiful way, he informs the world that he is just another kid with feelings, opinions, and preferences.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I have a niece that was named a very feminine name when she was born. She always struggled with her own personal identity and was considered a tomboy by her parents and her schoolmates. As she entered high school she began to demand that people call her Alex, and no it was not short for Alexandria, it was her new name and it was just Alex. At age eighteen she had it legally changed. I never knew there was a St. Alex, but as the patron saint of the ostracized, god/dess knows we need to hear more about him/her. Hugs and best wishes always.
Maybe you should check out the book Soul Survivor. Its about a boy with past lives. Not that this is what is happening but I thought I would recomend it anyway.
Wow. Is he going to go by Alex now, or is it still a secret name?
@Elena: I celebrate your neice's sense of self, and I quite agree with you about letting the world know about St. Alex(-ander).

@JessDFacts: I will check that book out! It sounds interesting.

@Shaggylocks: That is a good question. I wish I knew. I think he understands that his birth name is the one that everyone knows him by, and so far, he doesn't seem to want to "fight that battle" to change his name and reinvent himself as "that" person. Time will tell, I supp0se...
What a great narrative. And you sound like a great mom. Sometimes acceptance stands so close to wisdom. Rated.
Alex sounds like the perfect name for a tiny child struggling against our culture's blunt sledgehammer of binary identity.
He sounds like a very insightful little boy. Hopefully he will keep his confidence and always be true to what he likes amidst the crazy pressures of society. You are an amazing mother to nurture his personality and mind!
What is this, gender confusion week on Salon? I guess it is getting close to Halloween.
@Steve & @Karin: Thanks for your encouraging words!

@Monsieur & @marcelle: A good name for a little boy with a HUGE personality! :)

@Snoreville: Be grateful that you do not have a gender identity conflict. People that do are only trying to find a sense of peace in their lives that gender normal people like you and I take for granted. Have some compassion. C'mon. It won't hurt you.
Wow. What a fantastic story. I am so happy for your GirlyBoy. He has such a strong and unique personality. I think it's good that he also has his own name. Children are just so interesting.
@Gwen: Thank you! GB is definitely no wall flower, that much is for certain! :)
Are you familair with Alexis Arquette?

http://www.imdb.com/name/nm0000793/
Don't ever doubt that you have an amazing child.
I'm reading these comments....I'm trying to figure out a way to say this and not become the worst villian since Stalin. Um, lady. When this kid hits fifth grade he's going to have the tar beat out of him. Gender expression is great, but kids in general are little bastards that won't let him get away with it.
Better enroll the little guy in some karate classes ASAP. I mean yesterday. Let him/her know that girls have fun with karate too.
Don't make it a choice.
If you don't, have fun with the unneccisary broken appendages and sobbing.
Yes, I know, I'm a monster. I'm going back to my cave now.
I saw the "Jessie" in the title and it gave me chills, that is my son's name. I believe children have so much to teach us; they haven't been as burdened with the lessons that adults have. He is magic ~ so is the rest of his family. This story touched my soul.

You just can't argue with truth when it is being spoken by such a clear, confident, knowing voice. I love that unsullied bit of children.

Another book you may enjoy is called: Courageous Souls by Robert Schwartz.
How excellent . . . sometimes kids seem to know so much more than we do . . . and sometimes they seem to be more "in touch" with whatever the divine may be. Alex . . . excellent.
@David: Yes, I remember the story of Alexis Arquette, but had forgotten until you brought it up in this context. Amazing. Thank you for the reminder!

@sailorjerry: Thank you! Objectivity aside, I quite agree with you!

@Andy: Thanks for the suggestion. We actually tried enrolling him in karate and it failed. All he wanted to do were pirouettes, so we moved him down the street to the ballet school where he's been for the last year.

@Kate: Yes, the name coinky-dink did not get passed me. I'm so grateful you noticed. I have thought of you when I hear him refer to himself as "Jessie". :)

@owl: "..sometimes they seem to be more "in touch" with whatever the divine may be.." Truer words have never been spoken. I shared this story with my PFLAG group this evening and they pretty much said the same as you.
I relate this to relate it, I don't intend to label Alex or know what he will become. Your post just reminded me of my uncle Sandy, and so I share....

My late uncle (aunt) steve (sandy) was transgendered. My grandmother never understood even though she was always therefore him. But when he was sick and in the IU, she was embarrassed by his nails and wanted to cut them. What would the nurses think.

My mother, on the other hand, understood that you don't have to understand something to respect it. I mean, who are we to understand anything. I'm gay and don't understand what it was like for him but I could respect him and love him.

My mother, his older sister, would go into the ICU and file his nails for him, because it would kill Sandy to be an unkept mess.

I can still see her now, by the heart monitor with an emory board, making her little sister feel pretty.

I'm touched by your openness, your willingness to use an emory board out in the open. Even if "Alex" is just being a kid and not transgendered, your openness to his endless possibilities is more than touching.

And (if he is transgendered) the karate is unnecessary--and, for that matter, is a remedy you'd prescribe a boy. Alex will learn to take care of herself, although it may break your heart to realize that the world gives her no other choice.
You and your husband are giving your children--both GirlyBoy and BoyBoy--such a gift by being nothing less than completely supportive of their whole identity and not just the parts that fit into neat categories or easy to check off boxes. I imagine it may get more stares in the supermarket, but your parenting is the kind of parenting we all should aspire to. I applaud you.

Also, how appropriate that God chose a gender neutral name for your sweet little "Alex"!
I've never read anything like this before, because like most ignorant people, the subject makes me mentally itchy. I'm glad you wrote it and I read it. I'll have to think more on it. R.
Even though I'm a gay atheist, may whatever god little Alex is listening to bless him always. He's going to need as much protection as he can get.

What a wonderful narrative you've given us with this story. Thank you! It is my hope that both "BoyBoy" and "GirlyBoy" have wonderful and happy lives. Their parents are certainly trying!