One Friday a few weeks ago, Alex dressed himself in a pink striped sundress over his jeans and t-shirt. As he was slipping his feet into his shoes, I broached the topic carefully.
“Are you sure you want to wear that?”
“Yeah,” he replied dismissively.
“Ok. Well, you know some kids may not understand what to think, and they may tease you. I know you know this but if you wear that, you should be prepared for it.”
My words were only thinly masking my nervousness about the situation. After all, it was the first time he had ever worn a dress on the outside of his clothes.
“I know, I know!” he said sounding exasperated.
“Well, do you have an idea about what you can do if kids tease you?” I wanted to be sure he knew that he had an out. He had to be prepared.
“Yeah, I’ll just tell them to stop and if they don’t I’ll tell a teacher.” His answer, although sounding rehearsed, satisfied me, so I backed down and let him lead this one.
I silently watched him finish getting his jacket and backpack on while my mind reeled at the possibilities of how the day could play out. Wearing a dress was a blatant display of gender non-conformity—a show that even he had dared not present to his peers up until now. All his other clothes—the headbands, the skinny jeans, the sparkly peace sign shirts—those could be loosely accepted. They made people wonder, but there was still an element of doubt. The dress, however, removed all doubt. The bold statement he was making by wearing it, at the time, meant to me that he was ready to really tell the world who he is and what he was about.
Hey Mom, I’m ready to do this really risky thing and you can’t stop me. I’m gonna be me for once. These clothes make me feel proud. I imagined him thinking.
As I watched him skip across the playground (and swim into shark-infested waters), my heart ached. Why is it so painful to be different? My eyes welled up, but before they could spill over, the pride I had for this child whose courage to express himself in the way that makes him feel good reigned me back in. I reminded myself that he was no one to feel sorry for, rather someone to rejoice in! Look at how wonderfully unique he is!
Still, I worried throughout the day. I wondered if he was having to beat back any teasing, whether his ego and esteem would be intact at the end of the day.
When I arrived to pick him up at 4:30, the first thing I noticed was that he was still wearing his dress. That was a good sign. He got through his day. If he was still wearing it, that surely meant that his day was free of incident, right?
“How’d it go,” I said initializing the interrogation.
“Fine.” That’s it? That’s all I get?! I wanted more! I wanted to know what Tania—his BFF—said. I wanted to know what he heard kids saying. Where they whispering? Did they say anything complimentary? Anything hurtful? Please, tell me!
Of course I didn’t take the conversation much further. The friendly “hellos” from passing parents of other kids suggested to me that no one seemed to take any overt issue with his statement. In fact, people actually seemed friendlier to him than I had noticed before.
In retrospect, I recognize that it never crossed my mind then that perhaps there was more to his wearing the dress than I originally thought. Maybe his dress-wearing wasn’t for them, or even himself, at all, but for me—that supporting his choice of expression unconditionally was more important than the decision to wear the dress itself. In a sense, it may have been a test for him to take the pulse of how much I really trusted him.
This evening we had an episode that was a stark reminder that just beneath the surface lurks some demons of self-doubt, hurt, anguish, and frustration. Pissed off because he was not allowed to go on my computer as he had apparently thought I had promised, Alex reacted by promptly running into his room, turning around red-faced, screaming on the top of his lungs “FUCKIN’ DAMMIT!” and slamming the door as hard as he could.
In a former life, I would have reacted with anger. But I caught myself after realizing that this was no longer considered a “normal” reaction Alex was having to something. In fact, I had not seen this behavior for many, many months. The time away has provided me insight into what the behavior actually means. For instance, I now know that this reaction means anxiety. Something was going on, but I had to be patient and wait for him to share what it was with me if I ever wanted to find out what was eating at him. Reacting or pressing him would only render him entirely inaccessible.
Somehow he managed to calm down within two or so minutes (which is a HUGE accomplishment, by the way!). As he had been administered his medication an hour before, he was deliriously tired and crawled quite willingly into bed. I turned out the lights and snuggled next to him, as is our nightly routine. Once he was quiet and a few minutes had passed, I started to hear sniffling. And then, sobbing. And then, wailing.
“What’s the matter? Why are you crying?”
“I can’t tell you. You wouldn’t understand. I don’t even understand.”
Ok, now I had to understand.
“Please, try me. I want to know what’s going on,” I said.
“Well…” he started, “you know that day I wore the dress to school?”
“Uh-huh.”
“Well, some kids teased me about it.” He went on to tell me all about how two third grade boys teased him and said some words that he “couldn’t remember” but they were hurtful. He shared that it made him feel angry and sad, and he did, in fact, tell the teachers, and while they were sympathetic, it was clear that the boys were not reprimanded for the behavior.
Part of me sympathized with the daycare staff. In truth, I don’t know what I would have or should have done in that same situation. Another part of me felt compassion for the boys, who clearly didn’t understand Alex and felt threatened in some way so felt the need to tease.
Confused about what is truly acceptable in a situation like this, I turned to chapter 7 in my “bible”—The Transgender Child (by Stephanie Brill and Rachel Pepper) for guidance. Every passage, every line in this book speaks to me, but with this one particular passage, I find renewed motivation to follow up on a teachable moment and force the school to provide my child a safe place, both emotionally and physically, while he is in their charge:
“Personal beliefs or philosophies should not factor into public education. All children have the right to learn in a safe environment, free of bullying [and teasing]. To ensure this security for a gender variant child, the teacher has to be proactive and set the tone for the entire class, and both for the students and their parents.” --page 156.
Another passage in the book suggests that children of color are not expected to paint their skin white, so why should gender non-conforming kids be made to wear something that doesn’t express their inner selves?
What I realized this evening is that NO, my child is NOT emotionally safe from bullying and teasing because of the way he expresses himself. And while the teachers may have been sympathetic and recognized “rude” behavior, they were NOT willing to enforce a no-teasing (i.e. SAFE) environment, which is just simply unacceptable.


Salon.com
Comments
Wish I'd been half as clear when my children were growing up! Your son is very fortunate.
"Personal beliefs or philosophies should not factor into public education. All children have the right to learn in a safe environment, free of bullying [and teasing]."
Well, that's great. Now try to enforce that right. In addition to teasing, don't forget other children laughing behind his back or simply ostracizing him. Unless the school is expected to police every word spoken on the playground or in the lunchroom, these things will happen. It is a simple fact of the world that his wearing a dress to school is tantamount to wearing a "kick me" sign on his back. Perhaps it should not be that way, but there it is.
"Another passage in the book suggests that children of color are not expected to paint their skin white, so why should gender non-conforming kids be made to wear something that doesn’t express their inner selves?"
The difference is that black children are not "expressing themselves" per se. They are going to school in regular clothes. They are not dressing up as Shaka Zulu or Mandinka warriors. Religious children are not dressing up as priests or as Jesus Christ.
Another fact of the world is that most children and probably most of their parents will see a boy wearing a dress to school as abnormal, if not pathological. Again, perhaps the world should not be this way, but that's the way it is.
And what happens if the boy insists on using the girls' bathroom? What happens if in middle school he wants to use the girls' shower room?
I don't see how wearing a dress to school has any kind of good ending. In the long term it might be less damaging for him to come to terms with dressing in standard male attire in an unfair world than to be the object of ridicule for the next decade.
Expressing one's "inner self" is often a luxury in this life, many times not accomplished until adulthood, if even then. The prudent person will keep a low profile until that time so as to experience the least amount of damage. The boy has gone swimming in shark-infested waters and has discovered that yes, there are sharks. Time for a new plan -- regular clothes, home schooling, or whatever, in my humble opinion.
Change moves more slowly than many of us would like. In 2007, the city manager in Largo, Fla. was fired when he announced he was planning to undergo a sex change operation. Even where I live (Canada) the rights of the transgendered are only slowly being written into law; cultural acceptance, of course, can't be legislated.
Every post, every autobiography, every article that raises the visibility of the transgendered and every other group who suffers from the effects of lack of understanding, prejudice or just plain ignorance, is a step towards greater visibility and understanding.
Thanks for sharing this.
I have a friend who is a Parent Advocate for parents with autistic parents, and who is, herself, the mother of an autistic boy; I know that she has spent endless hours working with building staff on resolving conflicts, educating students, and even how to answer questions from other parents about her son's behavior. Can you do that? (And forgive me if you already wrote about it; I'm sort of starting at the end, here). This is, sadly, much more "loaded" for people than being a person of color, or of a certain ethnicity or religion, because he could choose to conceal the differences if he wanted to. I don't think it's right to make him conform, but I hope you can help him understand that people are not necessarily "bad bullies," they are themselves uncomfortable, unsure of what to do, and without any frame of reference. That makes them not evil, but educable and flawed humans.
R - to the stars and beyond.
she has made no decisions about what's next. She is just enjoying a life where acceptance by her peers and colleagues. Take heart. She has always had loads of great friends, male and female and is embarking on a successful life as a a young adult. It is absolutely in Alex's future. Keep writing with the insight and love you have. It will make a difference!
Rated
When my husband and I were just becoming aware of the nature of our child, we hit the Internet fast and hard, and let me tell ya, there wasn't a whole lot out there. But what WAS out there was so powerful. It was a life-line. My hope is that these posts will provide the "familiarity" needed so that the next time a reader sees a boy in a dress or a girl with short hair and baggy jeans, they will have a little background. These kids are who they are. Forcing them to be someone they're not is just not fair. In fact, it drastically increases the risk of mental unhealth and even suicide. I'm sorry, but if I need to let my boy wear a dress in order to build his self-esteem and not kill himself, then so be it. I can live with that. I cannot live with the alternative.
@mishima666, I truly appreciate the energy and thought that went into your response. Clearly you have invested a good amount of time trying to educate yourself on this subject. I appreciate it from the bottom of my heart. The questions you raise are valid, especially for those who are not familiar with our situation. The feedback you provided to me suggests that I can do a better job at really conveying my situation. For, I firmly believe that any truly loving and accepting parent dealing with this situation would do exactly the same as I have done. Perhaps I have not convinced you (and others who feel the same) well enough that this whole journey is really not about me at all. I am a merely bystander (admittedly one of 2 of the most important bystanders in his life). Every story I have heard of the journey of a gender non-conforming person implies that "reparative therapy" only deepens convictions and creates an environment that suggests to the child that they are in some way damaged. MY CHILD IS NOT DAMAGED. In my mind, he is perfect in whatever way he chooses to show the world. In doing so, he is happy. He knows he is loved because we show him that his opinion matters. He's wearing a dress, not wielding a gun.
And yes, we do plan on enrolling him in martial arts at some point. We hear that all the time from family members and friends. I agree: he needs to be able to kick some gender-conforming ass when necessary.
Thanks again to everyone posting comments here. It means so much to me!
But I am still a son. From my perspective the most important thing you can do is encourage your kid to trust you and to talk to you. It looks like you are doing that.
You fight to make sure he always confides in you. If you can keep open lines of communication things will be fine.
I guess one final thing is make sure he knows the world is tough, and sometimes you're gonna get bullied, no matter how safe an environment is. I'll be having some kids soon and I am already freaking out about how much pain they'll experience before they become adults. They don't even exist yet! Imagine when they do, I'll be a mess. Realistically, we can try to protect our kids from everything, big or small, but we also need to let them grow up. Sounds like your kid will be one tough son of a gun when all is said and done, and if you and his father are with him the whole way he will also grow up to be a healthy and loving adult.
I and others were terrorized on the school playground in one school I was at by kids who used to “pants” (as in, remove the pants of) kids on the playground to humiliate them. That's well beyond speech, and it should have been stopped. Neither the kids it happened to nor the others who feared they were next should have had to endure that. But just teasing someone for how they look is a more complicated thing. I think teachers should try to help with this, but I find it hard to say kids have a right to be free of it. In 8th grade, white socks were out of vogue (maybe they still are, but I like them now) and I cried to my mother about how I was a “Willy White Socks” ... I have no idea who contrived that concern, but in retrospect it seems the ultimate in manufactured concern. Even so, Mom bought me some colored socks so I could escape ridicule. Should she have phoned the school and insisted these people like me, white socks and all? I can't really say that I think so. People have to make their choices about whether they want to go with the pack or not, I guess. If you decide not to, you get that kind of thing. I have to believe some good things come from learning to stand up to that kind of thing, learning to speak one's mind independently of what others think, etc.
Being told that you're entitled to have others like you for being different doesn't really match reality, so I hope you don't lean into that direction. (It didn't sound like you were. I'm just thinking aloud.) I think the school should provide a safe space, but I don't think the world “safe” should be watered down to merely mean “pleasant.” Pleasant should certainly be a goal, but I think it's a bit much for it to be a requirement.
So I'd hope you resist the urge to intervene if it doesn't seem like it's essential. Instead I'd hope you train your son clearly about the difference between teasing and threats and about the difference between words and actions, so he can complain if things do seem to be trending the wrong way. And then beyond that, I hope you just tell him that eventually he'll find other independent-minded folks ... that often the good ones are hard to find. Tell him to look for an internal sense of right and wrong, and that with all the bad things that come of peer pressure, it's good to find his own compass anyway.
Oh, and fine writing too.
R
Your son said he wanted to be a girl. So what? I once met a little girl his age who said she wanted to be an alligator when she grew up. Little kids say all kinds of weird things. That doesn’t mean one should take the weirdest idea one can think of and center one’s life around it. Has it ever occurred to you that if you had just laughed it off he would have forgotten about the whole matter by the next day?
Anyone who has any experience with life as it is lived knows that young children have a tremendous desire to please their parents, even at the expense of their own needs. Clearly you take great pride in your son’s courageous stance against gender role stereotypes, these horrible confining straightjackets which as we all know are the cause of all human misery. But your son is going to be the one who pays the price, not you.
In spite of the fact that your child may very well be gay, I find it disturbing that you insist on labeling him as “girly-boy”.
It is always wrong to label children, even if the label is accurate. Let the child tell you who he is himself. Have you asked him what he thinks of the girly-boy label? Is he aware that you have publically referred to him in those terms and have presented his private life to strangers?
I’m sure that in your circles, being the mother of a gay child gives you a certain amount of social currency. However, I feel that there is an element of exploitation in these posts. Be aware that some of his behavior may be the result of trying you win your approval.
I’m sure you are a loving and supportive parent, but it is important that you allow your child to be himself without you projecting your needs and wants on to his psyche.
Here's what I can contribute: NPR has some good links at this site, and the one I can speak to is the one titled Two Families Grapple with Sons' Gender Preferences.
http://www.npr.org/search/index.php?&sort=match&searchinput=transgender+children
Best wishes, and good luck.
You're an incredible mother. I feel for your son. It's gonna be tough until he gets a group of goth girls to surround him and keep away the bullies. Those of us who felt weird while we were growing up, only made it through because of the close friendships we made. Those friends kept us going.
Even if you accept that an individual's freedom of sexual self-expression should be the central organizing principle of society, your son is far too young to give informed consent to be enlisted as cannon fodder in this paticular war. He's being robbed of his childhood. In his future I forsee ostracism, loneliness, misery, and worse. That's a pretty high price to pay for your ego gratification.
I'm appalled by some of the comments I've read. I think these types of comments are based on fear. I just don't get it. It makes me sad. It makes me angry. My child, and your child, deserve to be treated with respect and compassion and kindness - just like any other child. Forcing a transgenderd or gender variant child to wake up every day and conform to gender stereotypes, to hide their true selves, and live a lie is highly damaging. It teaches them that it is more important to 'conform' than to be who they truly are. It teaches them that appearances matter more then their own happiness. It teaches them to be ashamed. I refuse to teach my child those things
If I forced my gender variant son to dress and act in gender-typical males ways - forced him to wear boy clothes despite the fact that it would make him wretchedly unhappy - then *I* would be the bully. I refuse to do that.
Will my child be teased at school because he wears a dress? Maybe. He hasn't been teased yet. However, as his parent, is it my job to force him to dress a certain way to avoid teasing? No. It's my job to give him the self esteem he needs to withstand teasing and to have the strength of character to be himself. If your child had red hair and was called carrot-top at school, would you make him dye his hair? Of course not. It's really no different for a gender variant child. Gender variance is a core part of their being. They can't change it. It's who they are. I will never force my child to hide his true self.
The whole agrument about teasing is assinine anyway. Years ago (and not that many years ago) many people argued tooth and nail against inter-racial marriage. They argued that children of those unions would be teased mercilessly, they'd never fit in because they would be different. Now that argument seems completely absurd. The peolpe who made that argument were on the wrong side of history and are now viewed as bigots or racists. The same held true for those who were against the rights of women to vote, the rights of black children to attend the same schools as white children, etc. The same WILL hold true for the rights of transgender and gender variant people. One day we will look back with shame on the treatment of people who are 'genderly' different.
Your son didn't choose this. You did. A brightly colored dress caught your three-year-old son's eye. You could have laughed and told him, "That's for girls, silly," or even just said "Yes, it is a pretty color, isn't it?" Instead you used this occasion as an excuse to launch a full-scale, all-out campaign to convince your son he is "trans-gendered." Now at the age is six, he believes this is what he really wants. Of course he believe that. All small children believe whatever their parents tell them.
By the way, this has nothing to do with "shattering gender steroetypes." Rather, you are foisting upon your son a ridiculously exaggerated stereotype of femininity which is going to be horribly maladaptive for him, as a boy and as a man. And while you wrap yourself in a cocoon of sanctimony, he is going to pay the price -- ostracism, loneliness, misery and worse. This is a really weak and cowardly way of getting back at men for whatever you fancy they have done to you. Go pick on somebody your own size.
“Finally he shrilled at the top of his lungs, "I HATE BOYS WHO LIKE GIRL THINGS!!! BOYS WHO LIKE GIRL THINGS ARE STUPID!!!" (pause) "I'M A BOY WHO LIKES GIRL THINGS! I'M A LOSER!"”
You then unironically ask, “Could he really mean it?”
This would all be comical if it weren’t so sad. You come across as a raging narcissist, like the most odious and manipulative stage mother times one thousand.
He doesn’t want to be your “girly-boy.” What he wants – desperately – is the love and approval of the only mother he’s ever known. And apparently this is the only way he can get it.
Why do you always refer to him as “Girly-boy?” Does this kid have a name? Does he mean anything to you – anything at all – other than as a symbol of your courageous commitment to overturning oppressive gender-role stereotypes, blah blah blah blah blah.
And, as I said before, you start out claming to be rebelling against gender stereotypes, and you end up by foisting upon this child a ridiculously exaggerated stereotype of femininity which is going to be horribly maladaptive for him, both as a child and as an adult.
It’s obvious from reading your posts that – gender issues aside – this is a child who has serious emotional problems. Have you ever for a moment stopped to consider that you may be the cause ? Isn’t there anybody in this kid’s life – an uncle, a grandmother -- who cares enough to speak up on his behalf?
You WILL regret this, twenty years or so down the road, when he confronts you with all the rage of a full-grown man and demands to know, “WHY DID YOU FUCK ME UP SO BADLY?” What I wouldn’t give to be a fly on the wall when that happens.
Setting aside the irony of the date you decided to post your comment (Happy Valentine's Day to you, too), I have been mulling over the best way to respond to it.
I've concluded that to subvert to the level of your anti-progressive, hurtful, narrow-minded views would only prove to be non-productive. My best advice for you would be to actually *RE-READ* my posts (vs. scanning them) and reach deep within your heart to try to understand what this journey means. To reduce it a "problem" as simple as telling my son he is "being silly" is to absolutely, completely miss the point.
And if my posts really disgust you to the extent you say, I recommend skipping them altogether. My intention is not to bring an audience to the point of revulsion, but rather to help shed light on the colorful spectrum that has existed for as long as history has been documented and in all cultures across the globe.
Also, I meant to add that I could have easily deleted your comment, but I elected to leave it here as a perfect example of the sort of views and behavior that we are up against in our journey.
So for that, I want to thank you for your contribution.
You're correct in that he does not want to be a boy who likes 'girl things'. Nobody wants to be different, we want to be like everyone else and when we are not we can hate who we are, we can hate being different. But he is different, he is a boy who likes girl things.
He is so lucky to have such supportive and understanding parents that are helping him to not only accept his differences but celebrate them. We should all be so lucky especially when there people like you in this world that he will have to deal with.
Now, why don't you go back to washing trucks!
Parents who believe otherwise and pressure the kids to be something they are not (i.e. gender conforming) simply drive their children into depression and suicide, and leave the child to face the challenges adolescence and early adulthood without parental support. It's not pretty.
If you experienced this stuff first-hand (especially if YOU were the gender-nonconforming one), you would understand. I don't think any parent would knowingly drive their child to depression, to suicide, to run away from home, to prostitution... but that is what happens in so many cases of well-intentioned parents who just don't understand.
GirlyBoyMom is not perfect --- no one is. And she's shared so much, anyone could surely find fault with her. But boy do I wish I'd had a relationship like that with my parents when I was growing up.