greenheron

greenheron
Birthday
June 29
Bio
Since the sixties, I have drawn and painted pictures of stones, trees, birds, and other assorted relics of nature. I still do that, and have the privilege of teaching the next crop of young artists how to do the same.

MY RECENT POSTS

Greenheron's Links

Elsewhere
OCTOBER 6, 2011 12:53PM

Cancer Bitch

Rate: 43 Flag

 

pink1


It is October. Again. Pink ribbons. Heart wrenching stories of the stricken. Images of courageous smiling bald headed women in pink T shirts. Companies that donate a percentage of product proceeds to research if you buy this or that shampoo, yogurt, deodorant, or spaghetti sauce. Everyone gets on board the pink boat, unified by the desire to cure cancer.   

Cancer Bitches ride a different boat. Many of us dread October. We won’t tell you that. We would seem angry ingrates for your kindness and concern, so we quietly put our heads down until it is over. We endure the media voices speaking in hushed low tones, using the lexicon of war: battle, warrior, survivor, victim, courage. We walk down streets and supermarket aisles festooned with pink ribbons. We skip article after breast cancer awareness article that highlights anti-cancer diets, anti-cancer exercise, anti-cancer vitamins, recent anti-cancer discoveries, coffee/wine/green tea/chocolate/aspirin/tumeric.  

October 1st, it seemed fitting that I’d encounter the woman who introduced me to my personal Cancer Bitch. Suddenly, there she was, getting out of her car in our local Stop and Shop. Our eyes locked and we did not speak. Zen Bitch tries not to indulge in petty social behaviors, but Cancer Bitch does. Nearly ten years later, she is still angry, just mindfully aware of it.

In the numbest of days following my diagnosis in 2002, I told a handful of friends. One of these friends told another friend, who told the deacons at his church, thinking that members of his congregation might want to reach out with support. No one asked how I might feel about spreading the news. I had not told the people at work yet, and was figuring out how I wished to do so.

One of the deacons, the woman I saw in the parking lot, stood up at Sunday service, lit a candle, and spoke to the church congregation about her grief on learning of “another woman struck down by breast cancer–my name here.” I was not there. I did not hear her words. I did not know her. She did not know me. She did not call or write to express her concern. I was Another Woman Struck Down by Breast Cancer. She was Another Good Person Outraged by Breast Cancer.

People I hardly knew approached me at the drugstore and the bank. As I checked out a library book, the face of the librarian changed when she saw my name. Her voice lowered, “I heard about you in church.” My diagnosis was less than a week old.

With cancer comes the recognition and understanding that you have precious little control in this life. The minutiae you are permitted to control, how and when you offer information, become monumentally important. I’d always thought of my life as an open book. With cancer, I discovered it wasn’t. On a dark roiling sea, I navigated my cancer experience through the gossip, pity, and fear of strangers.

One afternoon, believing I was calm, I found a telephone number for B, the candle lighter. Cancer Bitch isn’t polite, especially not in the beginning, and years later, she can still surprise me with unskilled eruptions and confrontations around this issue. When B answered, I told her my name, then waded in.

Have you had breast cancer? Did someone close to you have breast cancer?
No.
Why did you stand up in front of a hundred people and tell them about me?
Breast cancer is a horrible disease that kills hundreds of thousands of women every year.
That is true. How are you helping them?
I speak out.
For who?
For them.
I am one of them. You did not help me.

She did not understand my anger. She was not alone.  

This month of October, instead of buying a bottle of hair conditioner with a pink ribbon graphic that contains suspected carcinogens, knit a soft cotton hat and take it to the chemo floor of your local cancer center. The nurses will know what to do with it. Write a note of concern and hope to someone you’ve heard is newly diagnosed, rather than pass on the news to another semi-acquaintance. Don’t put us on a courage pedestal, because we’re so brave and you don’t know how we do it.  We don’t have a choice.  Please don’t tell us about those women who’ve died. That is not a good topic of conversation to show your support. Try not to be afraid of our cancer. We can see it.

For further information, visit http://thinkbeforeyoupink.org/

 

Cancer Bitches thank you.

 

pink3 


Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
You are such a b*tch. Please don't ever stop.

Breast Cancer Swiffers? I'll retire to bedlam.
Thanks. Good one for all of us who are volunteered for a war we didn't want.
Also, love the pink Spongebob Squarepants. I mean, WTF? How is this fighting cancer?
I'm glad you confronted her. r
Yes, I am not a Pinker. However, I am a knitter and bitch of my own variety. Rock on sister, Survivor Bitch. :)
WOW. I didn't know this. but I want you to know I support you nomatter how you choose to deal with anything in your life, cancer included. You're a rare bird and you got me in your corner, for what that's worth. Okay...you may not want my support. but still...hey, it's support over here in the darkest reaches of CT. you might want to call me on it one day.

See, the thing is, and I suspect you know this, but the thing is we want to help. we are a collective. there are so fucking many things we, the collective need to help with. we're a society with a lot of want, a lot of issues, and cancer, while it's personal because hell, you get it, YOU got it and I don't, but still, we the collective know that. and we'd like to...well, buy conditioners because we have to anyway, but knowing that a few cents will go to something that might help someone down the line is about all we can do. and yes, knit caps. but no one tells us to knit caps. they tell us to buy conditioner. we're a consumer driven capitalist society. we don't know HOW to knit. we do know how to shop.

needless to say, but unfortunately someone needs to say a lot because we're a self righteous, bull in a china shop kind of culture, that standing up in a community and objectifying a human being is a whole other assholish ball of wax, which I'm afraid is also very human and probably not limited to being American. I suspect we have that kind of conceited asshole all across the universe.
I understand why some of my friends have told the whole world, and why some have not told anyone in hopes of avoiding "the look" from everyone else.
As she put it, "It's like I ceased to exist as an intelligent woman, now I'm just a sorrowful look recipient, the worst part of all this..."
A rare bird, indeed. RRRRRR XXOO
Ha, wonderful post.
"Try not to be afraid of our cancer. We can see it. "
A delightful bunch of gals, I have no doubt. Poor them. Yeah,
right...

Reminds me of how we "mentally ill/disabled" types are treated.
So so sad, what happened to such a soul with so much potential.
Maybe we should get em all to march.Argh. I don't wanna march.
I am bipolar, and kind of proud of it, cuz i am not
"surviving' it, but LEARNING from it.


"The minutiae you are permitted to control,
how and when you offer information, become monumentally important"...aint that the truth!

When i choose to 'speak out', y'all will know, pitypartyers.
Those about to Pink before they Think ...oughta listen to Green.

Your body ... your story to tell, if and when.
Love you even more for this bitch, Ms. Heron. XO
Yeah, I adore you, Survivor Bitch. ~r
Jeannette...thank you. I vacillated between the Breast Cancer Swiffers and the pink Breast Cancer Breath Mints. So many things to buy in the fight against cancer.

ccdarling...Spongebob Squarepants the Pink Edition wants to go home with you ;-)

hugs...thank you. I did not know how not to.

Oryoki...thank you for not pinking.

monkey...you are such a kind soul, exactly the person who Proctor and Gamble counts on to purchase pink conditioner and swiffers. There are other ways, ways that will not give you cancer and/or put more of your money into corporate pockets. If you have time, check out Breast Cancer Action or Think Before You Pink. They offer some excellent suggestions. Thanks for getting into a lovely monkey ramble. I am fond of those, and am delighted to have inspired one.

keri...thank you for reading

Just Thinking...your friend is right. The you poor thing look. Do not want.

Bea...thank you and xxoo back

James...a guy who gets it! Thank you for your sensitive comment. I’m sorry that L’Oreal does not make a nail polish remover for bipolar research. Soon perhaps.

Scarlett...that was cool! Thank you, and for calling me a bitch ;-)

Joan H.....thank you, and I adore you too, you life is precious grasshopper burier.
You touched a place in my heart with this one...
oh I don't buy that shit. but I get it. I feel for us. For us goofy Americans. I feel for our ignorant gaucheness. I believe, like most human beings, Americans have pretty good hearts. Not perfect, not all encompassing, but if they can do something nice, without breaking into too much of a sweat, they're there. ANd if it means they can buy something they like or they'd like to try, they sure as hell will because that's a good thing, shopping. And they'll light a candle too.
Nah, pink doesn't suit the green heron. You are your own color wheel, so keep on rolling. Steamrolling, when necessary :) xos
My sister's Cancer Bitch feels exactly the same way. It was hard to know what to say to her in the beginning, so I just went back to being her normal, irritating sometimes, big sister. Best thing I could have done.

This is one of those posts that really should be on the cover.

Lezlie
The whole pink thing is too commercial.
Ha! Not really that bitchy, kind of serene actually. Well said. R
I am working on a project with herceptin with BC patients, mostly young, I read this with interest because I don't like the pink, the TT's saving. the pictures of models on TV getting mammograms and I wondered if my patients felt the same. I suspect they feel as you do more likely and I am relieved I haven't been an asshole that I know of, or spilled out some god awful story or warrior bullshit.It I am glad you are saying what to do to. Thanks for this, bitch on.
There's one point I really like about this post. I don't think people remember that you didn't volunteer for this. It's not about courage, it's about having no choice. What else are you going to do?

I'm in a different kind of position that elicits some analogous reactions: I have a kid with a severe physical disability. People see me pushing a wheelchair, lifting my kid (ca. 100 lbs.), rearranging seating, feeding or giving a drink, loading or unloading the chair and the kid from the car, etc. And they say: "I couldn't do what you do." With all due respect, Bullshit. If this were your kid, you'd do exactly what I do.

Like with you, I'm not different, but my situation is.
Oh, forgot to tell you:
Keri sent me.
Green - I know exactly how you feel.

http://open.salon.com/blog/toritto/2011/10/04/reflections_on_think_pink

regards / r
When we lose track of each other's individual spirits and individual hearts and needs and hurts and the desire to find our own ways through whatever it is that finds us or comes our way, we lose track of self and integrity and soul, of what makes each of us uniquely who we are. So often you share such wisdom with us, greenheron. Thank you for reminding us of love.
Bravo, you Bitch! You make so many great observations/statements. This is a truly complex subject (I've found this out since my own BC diagnosis in 2005). I was and still am surprised, sometimes shocked, at the various responses, of every size/shape/tone and style, to my New Primary Persona as a Poor Brave Woman with Breast Cancer. I say complex, because I don't think it's easy to know how to respond, nor have I always been sure how I WANTED people to respond (though I am better at knowing how I DON'T want them to respond). It has been a learning curve that continues to curve its way along the uncharted path...
I appreciate anger around illness, particularly cancer. I still have enormous anger around my mother's cancer experience, for the same reasons you mention and for hers and mine as well. Rage on, because otherwise, people will slot you in with everything else they don't really want to deal with.
I have felt bothered oftentimes by the Pink Campaign. The commercialization is hard to take. Clerks at the stores ask if would like to leave your change:
"Would you like to make a donation for cancer? You get a ribbon."
" uh...no I'm more against it than for it."

You've laid it out well here.
Ditto on Jeanette's comment. Swell angle there. I get tired of all the pink stuff, did you read toritto's piece? It was awesome.
Thank you for this post. It reminds me of one I wrote last year--not in style, but in sentiment. I know the experience is different for everyone, but you and I seem to share many of the same feelings about this. (Hope my hyperlink works, but I bet I screw it up.)

make-hyperlink.php
Well, oddly, even though the hyperlink says "Make hyperlink," it actually DID make the correct hyperlink. Semi-competent kudos to me.
This is a wonderful piece of writing; it needs to be on the cover.
I think the pink campaign affords people the excuse to think about a symbol rather than the reality, in the same way that putting a yellow ribbon decal on your vehicle supposedly demonstrates "support" for the troops. Just as with the yellow ribbon, symbology and a nice little logo is no substitute for the real thing.
Love it. You put into words what I'd only suspected in my mind. When I phoned my mother with my diagnosis, adding, "I'll be alright." she said, "You CAN'T be alright." I beg to differ.
Love it. You put into words what I'd only suspected in my mind. When I phoned my mother with my diagnosis, adding, "I'll be alright." she said, "You CAN'T be alright." I beg to differ.
this excellent piece has so many bits and angles to it that i agree with, but i'll just pick two. first, i'll be impressed by football players wearing color-coded shoes and gloves and breathe-rite strips when they're trying to raise $$ for, say, colon cancer or maybe testicular cancer. it might be a while, since cancerous intestines and testicles aren't quite as (forgive the pun) sexy as women's breasts.

and the woman who, without invitation, spread your diagnosis? there are people who want to own your illness and latch onto your grief. it's just another form of gossip, only sicker.

you tell 'em, Righteous Bitch.
Algis...thank you, blue eyed one.

Monkey...I agree that most people’s hearts are soft. I wrote this about the angry bits. There is an equal measure of kindnesses I will not forget, from loved ones and total strangers. That is a post I do not feel like making in October however.

dirndl....funny, thank you, and ROYGBV

Lezlie...oh boy you did the exact perfect thing. My sister did this too, then I did it back at her when she got a cancer diagnosis.

Miguela...too commercial, and given its whole own month to shop for pink. Bleh.

Thoth...I like that. Serene Bitch.

Rita...it is mostly younger women on Herceptin, and I wonder how they feel too. Cancer Bitch did not like that my surgeon used to have nothing to read in her waiting room but magazines with big young cleavage on the cover...Cosmo, Glamour, Vogue, Marie Claire. It seemed insensitive to offer those to patients whose breasts you were about to carve up, younger patients especially.

koshersalaami....I love your name BTW. Exactly. There is sometimes though a certain wonder for me, that I did all that I did. If there is a benefit to any of it, it’s that I know I can get through anything that comes. You may know this too with your circumstances. What? A root canal? Piece of cake!

toritto...I will go and read your post. It sounds as if you might not want a pink Spongebob Squarepants Cancer dolly either. I’m sorry in advance.

anna1liese...thank you for your poem comment. You always take the kind and beautiful road.

Jane...yes yes yes about the ambivalence, uncertainty, murky feelings and responses. Someone must care, mustn’t they, if they are selling these nice breast cancer perfumes and dishwasher powders for us? Why then does it feel awful and kinda ugly, and why am I thinking, uh no thank you.

Ardee...there does seem to be anger around all illness. I carry Cancer Bitch and also Alzheimer’s Bitch for my mother, who became unable to carry her own bitch. We put people off in this though. It does not fit the role of the victim.

aka....hahahah! You say that?! Mind if I steal it?

SheilaTGTG55....I did not read toritto’s piece, but it is next thing on the OS to read list.

Susan...I cannot wait to read make-hyperlink.php, a refreshing title for a cancer post. Thank you for stopping, and loads of competence kudos to you ;-)

nana...I like when brave men offer their thoughts on this topic. You’re right about the colored ribbons. It is an easy thing to do. Much harder to listen to someone, or give them some of your time. Both the troops issue and the cancer issue, and well heck, just about any issue are far more nuanced and gray than a plastic car ribbon.

dianaani... sister, you are in the club? That sucks. You are alright though ;-) Here. You can tear off Spongebob Squarepants other arm.

candace...omg I want to see the burly linebackers in light baby blue shoes and jerseys, with a dainty swoosh of blue under each eye! Thanks for the read on Miss B. It felt just like that, like she hacked my story to earn some wings.
My friend, I meant my above "bitch" as a verb but you take it any old way you want, bitch! ... (as a noun) :) Anyways, just to let you know I'm also here in my mother's spirit as a complete Alzheimer's Bitch.
Thanks again for adding that. xo
You have my -totally silent- support. The cynic in me detests the commercialization of such a personal situation, and I wonder how much of the money reaches its purported destination.

It's a fact. People treat you differently when they know. And more often than not, not in a good way. Having been through this situation fairly recently, it makes me cringe to read. There are still people in both our families and friends who never knew, and never -ever- will.
Great post! Such righteous anger!

In the Pagan community we have a similar (tho less personally infuriating) fee-nom, "Doing a Ritual for the Rainforest" - people think making themselves feel good with some meaningless foofahraw equals actually DOing something about some situation. All talk, no walk.

Foolish Monkey said it well!
Well said - to both us and to Cancer Bitch.
Very well stated. I despise it when others co-opt the authentic experience of people who've actually lived through something.
Just want to chime in with my "well said" greenheron
I respect and understand your feelings.But, I also feel for that woman teller in church. My mom's a breast cancer survivor, twice, double mastectomy. Shes also a generous soul who would have thanked and loved the church lady. so, different people. Different perspectives. I learned from this.
Scarlett again....I like both noun and verb.

Kai2....even worse than B outing me at her church, would be her outing you, someone who prefers to remain quiet about their cancer. Cancer is so awful already. It’s kind of a sin to add even a speck more pain to that. I hope you’re doing well.

Myriad...I am always glad when you show up. I love the word foofahraw, and understand about the silly of saving the rainforest with that, but still wish that everything could be fixed with a good foofahraw.

Cranky...hah. The Bitch has spoken. She might not be back for awhile.

emmapeel2...people do that though. They do, and there’s not much anyone can do about it. When I ran into B last week, I could tell that our conversation/confrontation did not change her perspective, except in that she came away from it thinking I was a scary person. I did not want it to go down that way, but in my second or third week of a cancer diagnosis, its true, I was kind of scary.

trilogy...thank you for words and readng.

denese....your mom rocks. My mom might also have done that. You’re right that all cancer patients are not the same though, and their situations are not the same. I might have been more generous as you say with B if I had already told people at work and had that squared away. Figuring out how to deal with your job while you’re being treated is a biggie, a very big biggie, and it was important to me to be able to make a good decision there. B took that away. Once I knew that a hundred strangers knew in my small town, I had to inform work the very next day.
Great fucking post.

How DARE that woman "out" you and your illness before you decided to do so on your own? Concern, my ass. It is the most deeply private issue there is, and the definition of feminism -- it's MY body, in whatever condition, and none of your DAMN business.

My mother had one breast removed (she is still alive many years later) and I live in fear of cancer daily. I loathe the hand-wringing pink-shit -- where are the CURES? Every year millions of $$$$ are raised and women are still dying and dying and dying. Give it a rest, already.
I can hear you so loudly in this post; I get a feel of who you are right to the core (and I'm a little teary). I hope if ever face cancer I'll have your kind of strength and determination, especially the belief that I have a right to tackle it in my own way, that within the fight for my life, I have the right to think about my own feelings FIRST. That would be hard for me (in the South "nice" is the ultimate compliment), but I sense that it would be absolutely vital. I just hope I am never tested. (And yeah, I've never bought into the whole commercial pink campaign. It seems to me that donations should be made directly to the organizations that do research.)
Caitlin...thanks for the outrage. I lived in terror of getting a cancer diagnosis too. Multiple primary relatives had one...aunt, cousin, mother, sister. Then once I had it, the terror wasn't what I expected it to be. The media focuses on the women who die, but not on the stats: one third of those diagnosed. That means 66% do not die of breast cancer but something else, usually years later. Breast cancer is not a death sentence, but in October, that would be hard to discern.

Bell...thank you. What an incredibly nice thing to say. I hope you are never tested too. Although I can easily imagine crack me up then make me cry Bell posts about ugly mastectomy bathing suits and hot pink wig hats.
You're pretty awesome, *bitch* :-)
greenheron, i thought this brilliant. you got me laughing even as you increased my awareness of your experience, without undermining that experience.
"With cancer comes the recognition and understanding that you have precious little control in this life. The minutiae you are permitted to control, how and when you offer information, become monumentally important." - so well said.
Wow, Candace just pointed me to your blog entry, after writing a piece with a similar theme, including mentioning thinkbeforeyoupink. Thank you for this. Thanks. Teams make differences, I hope!
Thank you for writing what I feel.
That woman had no right to do what she did. What a terrible invasion of your privacy. And I hate this commercialization of breast cancer. But exposing yourself in this wonderful post is not only generous of you, it forces the reader to see that breast cancer or any cancer is not so rosy, once you get past the pink.
Rated. I work with a teacher who makes a point of telling people she owns 300 pairs of shows because "shoes are jewelry for the feet." She wears pink throughout October, every year. Imagine that! How awesome, to have 20 outfits to wear to school that are pink! There are so many people running around in this world operating on very limited intelligence.
er, 300 pairs of shoEs. Yeah. No great brain power here, either.
Welcome to the club! I am not grateful for my cancer, it has not enlightened me, I am not polite, I do not wear pink ribbons, I bite back at Komen, I wore anti-war signs on my bald scalp, I do not thank you for running or jogging or walking or biking in my name.
Sincerely,
Cancer Bitch
http://cancerbitch.blogspot.com
Cool that Beth’s post brought some new readers to this....thanks Beth.

Sandra...I like it when I get called “bitch” by someone so eloquent.

maria....thank you for your words of support

Beth...thanks for writing your terrific piece, and for not eating pink beribboned chicken noodle soup.

pinkdoorartspace...neat avatar/id! I hope you are not in the club, but if you are, well, hello :-)

Margaret...thanks for seeing that side about the candle lighter. I’m still kinda pissed off at her!

Snippy...your friend might benefit from a little pink breast cancer bubblegum stuck to some of those shoes. You're not supposed to give gum to dogs, but maybe your owner whose name begins with C but we never say, will help you.

Cancer Bitch! Hey! You’re an even bigger cancer bitch than I am...a blog! You go girl. October is almost over ;-)
Bravo! I can't believe that woman had the nerve to talk about your diagnosis in front of all those people without asking you first.

my surgeon used to have nothing to read in her waiting room but magazines with big young cleavage on the cover...Cosmo, Glamour, Vogue, Marie Claire

Unfuckingbelievable! Geez, that's just wrong in so many ways.

Keep on being a cancer bitch. I have an old friend who is a breast cancer survivor and cancer bitch. You're in good company.
It's also a book, The Adventures of Cancer Bitch. http://www.uiowapress.org/books/2009-spring/wisenberg.htm
(shameless plug)
Yes, October will be over soon, and then we can get ribbons for all the other diseases. It's unbelievable.
At least the pink lights will be gone from the Sears/Willis Tower and the Hancock Building.
--C.Bitch
Your passion and anger leap off the page. I would expect no less from you.
How timely. I just had words with someone about the need to diagnose, dissect and demean the choices Steve Jobs made with regard to his illness. I don't get where people get off thinking they know best about others. Good for you!
Bitchin' and spectacular writing. Why isn't this on the cover.

I suppose, for those who haven't been touched, (or for those who have no minds of their own) the pinkthing works: a substitute for real awareness. Anyway, your post is a powerful reminder to "try not to be afraid."
Truth is: we all are.
I never liked the color pink. Now I just downright despise it. Thanks for this. It makes me feel justified in feeling bitchy which was not my nature until 2008. I'm trying to rehabilitate my friends, one at a time, against giving into the marketing and the hype and to giving into the helping of those on a personal level. It's so much more rewarding for all parties involved.
Thank you for being a bitch. I had cancer. 9 months of chemo and 12 weeks of radiation - not breast cancer but that can't be right because according to all this pink crap the only cancer women get is breast cancer. CURE CANCER - all of it