Greg Correll

W R I T E R

Greg Correll

Greg Correll
Location
New Paltz, New York, US
Birthday
September 21
Title
Founder, Chief of Deselopy (small packages); Editor (doesthismakesense.com)
Company
small packages, inc.
Bio
I write.

MY RECENT POSTS

Greg Correll's Links

New list
more more more
my daughter Molly on OS
more more works
more works
my works
what i do
DECEMBER 26, 2009 11:11AM

I am still, among the living

Rate: 27 Flag

~ | ~

 

Read this aloud:

"Paint a vermillion bamboo
with bright pigment"

You inhabit now the last real part of Jin Nong, a painter.

Read this aloud:

"Paint another one: an ink bamboo
using the other one as a model,
but don't do anything surprising."

His written instructions, as mentor, to Luo Ping.

A translation, and 251 years old, but you have expressed - imperfectly - Jin Nong. Resurrected him. Piffle to your reservations about the original language. He didn't say "orange pancake the candled carp". We are close enough to his intent.

Ideas, our words, are the only lasting part of us. No wonder the Christians make so much of logos - the word - and think us such recent beings. We achieved immortality of a sort when we learned to write.

But I say more. All of our biology becomes crudescence, but my Idea Part will last as long as the medium it rests within.  I say: it is no less me than my toe.

Put my toe in a jar. Pinched, it feels nothing, but is it any less my toe? Are my words, my expressions less than a toe? Did I not grow both?

When I wrote Jin Nong's instructions up there, I extended his human presence. Ditto copy and paste, and especially longhand. Another medium receives Jin Nong, and he lives.

It works for "bring home eggs" and it works for this, from the first recorded book:

(read this aloud)

"A sparing tongue is the finest treasure
among men; the well ordered tongue
has infinite charm."

(Hesiod's Work and Days, V. Maxims of conduct)

Something vital happens when we say words. If we are young, and not  yet a Reader, perhaps we simply confirm grammar, learn a fact, catch some sense. Perhaps we hear music and pulse.

Because I am a Reader my eyes move over the source and when I speak them I literally breathe meaning into the only life that lasts. Because I grasp syntax and have a vocabulary, and have read in approximate order our human struggle, I say aloud and gain a perspective, or disagree, feel blessed or repulsed. I speak aloud and I join the thought -- the writer -- and I extend the thought, the writer, myself.

Perhaps in a meagre or mundane way. Perhaps I add to myself alone, and I will never go further. Or I see that older time, I smell an orange or taste wine or feel barley under my hand. But when I say aloud I also hear an old voice in my own, one whose only living part lives again.

Say this out aloud:

"[when one] acts knowingly but
without premeditation it is an injury;
such are all acts due to temper
or any other of the unavoidable
and natural feelings to which
human beings are liable."

Feel this? (If not, read it again, slowly.)

You and Aristotle are one. The real Aristotle and the real You. A rock on the moon did not grade the severity of human misconduct. Aristotle did. He survives.

I am a Reader and so the Early Me has given the Now Me priceless gifts. When I read Aristotle aloud my mind is quick, I connect with lightning. And something important stands up, a light grows.

My poor fingers are tasked with a slo-mo reveal. Bear with me.

At the first words I wonder for milliseconds at Hammurrabi and Solon, I feel the necessity of law, and I flash on some grimy night court in the Bronx, a weary judge, a tired bailiff. As I absorb "unavoidable and natural" a Lego-work forms, of the Buddha plus a memory of my own time in jail, at 14, one terrible night, my attackers; hate and compassion war in me for hundreds of milliseconds. I lose my way.

I must read it again, aloud, and I end up in a swamp, amid the cracked branches and broken stumps of injuries long past, my own cringeworthy errors, my own dishonesty and anger. My crimes.

But Aristotle hums in me. I calm. I find the shore; I am in the litoral wash of something larger; I am hungry, and I find and read aloud:

"Have compassion for all beings,
rich and poor alike;
each has their suffering.
Some suffer too much,
others too little. "

The Buddha lives within me.

I find and read this aloud:

"Knowledge and ritual
without compassion
is empty."

Jesus breathes in me.

I sit under the empty sky and before the full ocean of life and feel all of this. I speak with many voices, my breath is many breaths. Something of them, something greater, is in me now.

I am a Writer, so how do I say this?

Whose voice do I use to invoke this evanescence of my shame, my compassion, my intellectual achievement, all I understand and invoke from the long-dead? The fluorescence, the pollen that suffuses the light, the new sound on this ancient shore?

It must be the bailiff's. He casually shrugs, perhaps to a newly minted public defender, as she stands bruised and reeling from her first all-nighter with the hopeless, the venal, the dregs. On the steps of the courthouse, their shift over, he gives her a pat on the arm, and says:

(I say this out loud)

"Some of us always get the cart
with the broken wheel. Some of us?
'I turn the same way you do, every time' 
-- abbadee, abbadah -- and we can't
get past each other.
Some of us? We watch out."

He smiles at her. She will recall this later, in her heart, and many years later she will breathe his words to someone else. The bailiff dies; the bailiff lives; human justice and compassion endures.

Death stands at every corner, waiting for us to rush our last yellow moment of caution, but our words are beyond his reach, our ideas above his senseless head. He hears our hoots and notes only the sound of us, our love, or fear. Our struggle for meaning is incoherent to him. Death does not understand us.

We only understand each other.

When we say each other out loud, we say what is still Now. What is insensate -- the writer, long gone -- feels no commensurate part, and for this we grieve, for the dead writer, for ourselves. But we the living breath into each lasting Part our own new breath, bellowed, whispered, re-marked. New in us, and they still live.

I read this out loud:

"Reserve your right to think,
for even to think wrongly
is better than not to think at all."

-- and I remember Hypatia, pagan, the last director of the library at Alexander; she was skinned alive with sea shells by Christian zealots, as her scrolls burned. She burns in me, when I say her words.

Remember Jin Nong. As calling card, recommendation, and a reminder that he was not gone, Luo Ping carried a scrolled self-portrait by his old friend and teacher, who had written in its ample margin:

(say this out loud)

"[If you see] extraordinary men who,
hearing my name, want to know of me,
[you] ought to take this out -- and
show it to them, so they will know
I am still among the living."

 

  Linen2

~ | ~

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Don't ask me why, but I looked up Heraclitus this morning before reading this. He posited a pre-Christian Logos.

Weird harmonic convergence.
Con: Heraclitus is one of my favorite Greek writers. His fragments also contain an early form of humanism, and I find a thread from him to Descartes to Spinoza to Jefferson.
this is as good as anything Kurt Vonnegut ever wrote Greg...I can't think of higher praise coming from me...this is that good. I love the imperative to read out loud, and I love this:

"A sparing tongue is the finest treasure among men; the well ordered tongue has infinite charm."

such a lovely post...I'm sure it will make my 2010 list of favorites, even though I have to stretch the days a bit to make it work.

Thank you.
I will take all into the new year with me, but this one especially: "Knowledge and ritual without compassion is empty."
man oh man that's good. man oh man.
I learn so much from you, I should be paying you. When I have to go and look something up, it stays with me. Thank you!
R~
Lovely and I have crushed on a Heraclitus for a long time. Thanks for this.
Greg, thank you for another fine read.

You write, “…when I say aloud I also hear an old voice in my own, one whose only living part lives again.”

And the first thought I had was the idea that perhaps this is the power of the priest, preacher, and antagonist, those who use words to drive inhumanity. Religion is best left to an individual rather than the pulpit.

Of course, there are those who use the spoken word for other purpose. Unfortunately, and perhaps I’m wrong about this, it seems the negative usage is more powerful among societies.

Also, I found a particular significance in your use of a comma in your title: I am still, among the living. Stillness among the motion.

RATED
The entire thing, quotes, concept, words, ideas, fairly dances in your writing. Loved this.
Wow! I don't know what else to say, except this is amazing. And I'm glad you're here.
bbd: I am honored and overwhelmed by such a kind comment. I love vonnegut. thank you.

mypsyche: compassion is such a simple thing, most of us begrudge it, or infelicitously, "take it as a given". thank you.

the squirrel: from one of the best and most original writers on OS or anywhere, your oh mans mean much to me. thanks.

marcelleqb: thanks

WalkAwayHappy: oh that's cool. my name, aloud. thank you

scanner: yes by all means pay me. in fine comments is good, but I could use a nice pastrami sandwich, about this high, on seeded rye, not too much kraut, mustard, and a pickle from the barrel. Thank you.

Dorinda: Me too, crush on Heraclitus. As I see it, for three reason: 1. he was erudite when so many humans wore animal skulls for hats; 2. he was thinking when so many had animal brains for brains; and 3. he was pithy and accessible and rational
Thanks.

Rick: you honor me with this close read. And you take me to new places; funny how we get into a drive with our work and sometimes don't see where it takes us. I agree: The co-habitation with the dead, with their ideas and passions and arguments, becomes a pulpit'd mausoleum for scoundrels and ignoramuses, who leverage old words for new gain.

And we social hooters, we ape others for advantage. Susan Wise Bauer offers an explanation and antidote for thus: Don't just collect facts. Learn to read for meaning. I add: theology yields meaning only when it is fearless, and it hardly ever is.

Hyaptia also is attributed with this:

"All formal dogmatic religions are fallacious and must never be accepted by self-respecting persons as final."

Thank you, Rick.

Scupper: thanks

Owl_Says_Who: Thank you. I am little miffed that you didn't single out my use of semicolons and extended hyphens for special praise, too, but no matter. sniff. :)

mginmn: Thank you. I am glad I am here, still.
Beautifully written, Greg. You never cease to amaze me.
Rated
I read about Luo Ping and think, this is interesting. I didn't know this. Then I read about the bailliff and the public defender and I understand because I do know them. Stories from dead people have been told to me and I understand how they live in me. A writer can dazzle with infinite knowledge of things. A teacher must understand his pupils don't know these things. He may dazzle some, but will lose the rest. He knows he must reach into the classroom and pull them along. As a result of his generosity, there is now someone else walking around out there who understands a little better the power of words. I hope this makes the teacher very very happy.
Such a pleasure to read this. What are you up to with that comma in "I am still, among the living," I wonder? The phrase w/o the comma fits your theme better, but maybe you are after the ambiguity? I must be missing something . . .
junk1: thank you for this kind comment and the even kinder PM.

jimmy: Though I have taught as an adjunct at two colleges, I am not a teacher. I do, however, struggle often with the pontificato Voice in my writing.

What the hell do I do with all this reading? all these connections? I figure on OS I might hone this: make it accessible, pare off the pomposity, reveal the ache and the intimate parts, try to explain to myself why my self-learning matters so much to me, why I feel learning saves me, body and soul. Thanks.
hells bells: ambiguity makes the heart go ponder, true. But I realized it works in these ways:

1. It is still the phrase that ends the piece.

2. I am still and thus can listen to long-dead lives

3. My favorite meaning: The voice of the long dead themselves, who say to us: "I am still, but I also live"

4. I am not the whole or healthy man I used to be, even compared to just two years go. It is an existential truth: I am ( ever more) still, less vital, among the living -- but I am HERE, still alive.

5. Finally: the thread in this, seemingly in all my writing, is compassion, and justice; I am more compassionate now because I have learned to be "still", to quiet my monkey mind, among the living, who live in all ways, still or not, angry or not, compassionate or not.
Ahoy! Whoa! Giddy! No kidding.
I was on respirator last summer.
When I eventually ask this:` '*'?
`
I asked an Ethiopian nurse this:`
"Did I die?"
She smiled:`
`
"No."
You are still in The Land of living.
Memory.
Thanks.
You may know of Robert Torrance?
His great book`Encompassing Nature.
Art James: thanks, and 'Encompassing Nature' looks dreamy. i just read two short reviews, and put it on my Amazon wish list (already fatally long).

You have made a kinetic synthesis (kinesynthesius?) of the theme, with alacrity; you extend my part, if I may be so bold.
What a cool post, and I don't even know who Heraclitus is.

Do you sometimes think the written word is more real than spoken conversation? I'm wondering about that. There are times when I feel freer to put up a Facebook status that is the real me when I'm too shy or embarrassed or inexplicably reticent to say it directly to someone. I don't know what that's about. But then there are times I think the written me, Lainey, is not the real me. The real me is messier, less civil, uglier. I guess they're both the real me, and there are more me's than that, even. Which brings me back around to the gist of your post; do dead writers live? Or does just that part of them that they want us to see live? I'm thinking about the author Vladimir Nabokov, who explicitly asked that his unfinished work be burned but whose son has published it. Will we gain insight into who Nabokov is by reading this work? (I'm setting aside for a moment the ethics of ignoring his wishes). Or would the real Nabokov better have been seen had he himself been able to see it through to the end?

I love your work, as you must know.
Lainey: This profoundly extends my idea. My written part is more real is some respects, but only when I reveal my trembling, troubled, fallible self. And no matter how I do it i "protect" myself in ways that are impossible in real life, making it what? less "real"?

The truth is we control our persona here, in words. And Nabakov's control ended when he died.

Silence, in real life, is one way to change our impact on the world, but what does it express? The temptation to impress upon others our ideas, our passion, our opinion is with us always. The Buddha and others make a strong case for silence -- but we know this because of their eloquence about it. The more we read and know, the more we want to be heard.

The impression we leave. What a thing it is to us. Herodotus, the first historian, in his first words in the proem to his "Histories", established how his work was made to ensure that the noble deeds of Greeks and barbarians alike would not be forgotten.

Nabakov probably would appreciate not being forgotten. As I appreciate not being overlooked by you Lainey. Thanks for this fine comment.
Greg you raise the bar. And make accepting the challenge of living a life of learning and compassion seem imperative. Thank you, sir.
Lonnie: what a compact, meaningful, and beautiful comment to me. Thank you
I love the idea of reading pieces aloud or out loud. There really is a really cool kinetic energy that happens when those words move around in the mouth.
I love the idea of reading pieces aloud or out loud. There really is a really cool kinetic energy that happens when those words move around in the mouth.
greg, these are great but they remind me that I think I lose serious IQ points around every holiday...it took me a long time to grasp the aristotle one about acting without premeditation, and am still not sure I have it.

also I wonder about those humans who suffer "too little." there seem to be too few of these in my life & environs...

but thanks for the reminder to say words out loud sometimes to breathe them to life...
Eloquent and moving, but in these days of family gatherings, I have another thought: it is not only artists and thinkers who remain among the living (though they, perhaps, last longer), but our ancestors, who live on in the stories we tell of them and their traditions that we maintain.
Miss Adams: I love reading aloud and being read to. too.

doloresfloes_d: The Aristotle quote is part of a rather dry, longer piece (http://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Nicomachean_Ethics). It makes more sense if taken as a matter-of-fact statement.

But that's sort of the point: it only seems dry when we don't understand the larger context: before Aristotle only a handful of writers "bothered" to sort out the fundamentals: what is injury? what is malice? how does a just society respond if they are different?

It means more to us, to our inheritors, if we bother to say it out loud, say it until we hear it. Passion is fine, but misapplied if mustered for anger, vengeance, punishment for its own sake.

Sometimes, dry is our friend. Sometimes, the glory is in the dry accounting, not the wet and bloody reaction.

Thank you for the careful read.

AtHomePilgrim: My "bring home eggs" was not a slight. You make a compelling addition: we live in the wash of herbs cut by grandmothers, we survive from sharp restraints cried by cautious mothers, we improve from the admonitions of our elders, and the sharp-shinned comforts muttered by age to youth are lo! great solace when they are all we find at our own end times.

But few of us are blessed with Writers among our forebears. We improve the specie when we use words for currency, even after we are long separated from our skin.

Thank you.
Greg, this is quite moving. I want to share this with all the writers I know, and all the readers. Thanks you.
Greg, since I am (ahem) voicegal, I am a true believer in saying things aloud. The vibrations make it live forever, just as the written word makes it live forever, too.

lovely.