Gwool's Links

Salon.com
NOVEMBER 28, 2010 10:57PM

The Power of Antietam

Rate: 11 Flag

 woundedlion3

The Wounded Lion Monument At Antietam for the 15th Massachusetts Regiment 

Antietam grips you.  I have toured Gettysburg that was far more expansive.  A three day, somewhat methodical battle that yielded 46,000 casualties.

Antietam generated 23,000 casualties in a single day on September 17, 1862.  It was the first quasi-union victory that had the British and French rethink their support for the Confederacy and gave Lincoln cover to announce  the Emancipation Proclamation on September 22, 1862.  The proclamation freed slaves in the Confederate states as of January 1, 1863.  This much heralded historical document in actuality freed not a single slave.  A true marketing document if there ever was one.  

The armies fought here as a result of a copy of Lee’s Special Order 191 being left behind in Frederick, Maryland when he broke camp days before and was found in the grass by a resting Union Private more concerned with the 3 cigars wrapped inside it.  With knowledge of Lee’s troop movements, the Union chose to strike and to strike hard.

The skirmishing was decision making in real time.  Panic.  Troops running into one another in cornfields.  Troops fleeing cornfields for the safety of woods only to be attacked in there as well.  Troops arriving to the scene just in time to flank others.  Young kids who had yet to load muskets being thrust onto a flank, only to be over-run by serious, seasoned adversaries who stumbled onto the scene racing to Antietam on double time.  Troops marching headlong into what was called the Bloody Lane where a sunken road provided cover for surprise attack.  Other troops stuck at Burnside Bridge pinned down by sharpshooters and sent piece meal to slaughter by an indecisive Major General Ambrose Burnside who would have lost his command had he not ultimately taken the bridge.

 bloody lane

The Bloody Lane Which Yielded 5,500 Casualties 

burnside

Burnside Bridge Stormed From This Side by 12,000 Union Army Members With About 500 Confederates Holding the High Ground  

Troops were shot trying to surrender.  All hell was breaking loose and everywhere they seemed to turn, more carnage befell them.  This “decision in real time” fighting off panic becomes hard to follow on the traditional education maps showing movements.  Lots of squiggly lines and hasty retreats.  Elements of incredible valor and heroism, to boot. 

The two sides met in truce the day after at Dunker Church, a location where fighting took place several times during the day, to gather and bury their dead.  Not all the dead were recovered, being left, essentially, to rot in the fields for months thereafter.

 dunker church

Dunker Church 

From a fierce, frenzied battle that many think could have ended the War had McClellan taken up pursuit the next day to a peaceful exchange and swapping of tobacco and other personal effects as each side hauled away their dead.

Sitting mid stop on the tour in the West Woods dutifully listening to my audio CD and following along on the book, I became struck with the discussion of the 15th Massachusetts Regiment Monument.  It depicts a wounded and dying lion, paw in the air, teeth bared.  That unit went into battle with 606 people, suffering 318 killed or wounded, representing the highest casualty percentage for any unit in that day.

It struck a chord that had me thinking of it for quite some time during the remainder of the tour and the ride home.  How when cornered, trapped, or feeling threatened soft animals become hard.  We become fierce and lash out, even, perhaps, at those closest to us and perhaps merely being helpful.  It reminded me of a family Jack Russell snapping at my young son’s nose on the way to the vet’s as he leaned in to console the dog after she had been run over by a car and had an injured leg.  Feared, pained, and ferocious.

These men were all trapped, cornered and caged.  Some rose to the occasion.  Some dropped their guns and ran.  Some became brutal in their retaliatory actions toward others.  Some of the best trained military minds froze under the pressure of it all.  Others able to rise to the occasion, and others still just flat out lucky.

I could not find the monument at the tour stop in the West Woods.  Monuments abound at these sites, and it was nowhere to be found.  Still, I thought of that monument the entire rest of my time there, including my stop at the cemetery with row upon row of headstones and a huge monument of a single Union private facing North, placed on the location in 1876.

private

 

upside down 

Upright Cannons Signify Battlefield Deaths of Major Officers Throughout the Site 

On my way out of town on the highway bypassing the battle site sat the monument staring oddly out at the road from an embankment.  Not facing the field, rather, but facing those in cars perhaps whizzing by on a daily basis or merely not at all interested with the history sitting several hundred yards off the location.  Totally unaware of the majesty, meaning, and sadness encased in that simple granite statue.

Humbling.  Truly humbling.  The extent to which we as a nation tore hell out of one another almost 150 years ago, and the extent to which in our daily lives that we at times cause others to act like wounded lions or react that way ourselves.

wouinded lion 5

Wounded Lion, Pained and Cornered ... 

wounded lion2 

Fearful, Frightened, and Attacking ... Aren't We All At Times?

 

Photos my own. 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I toured Antietam on my 1976 bicentennial tour and felt the emotion and the beauty. You have captured it in your photos and words.
rated with love
our civil war was one lesson we never learned.

r
It's a pretty amazing place. Very pastoral. Rolling hills and ridges. Clearly a great place to hang out, dig in, and wail on one another. Some beautiful antique homes in the area as well.
And, it happened on Constitution Day, like Gettysburg and Vicksburg, for those of a certain belief. Very nice post.
Gwool, I can't say that I like the new you very much. Your old avatar was much more handsome, good looking, and reasonable. But you did a superb piece of writing on a bloody battle. r
Cyril: I think it was a scope of carnage we cannot properly comprehend. 623,000 died compared to 407,000 in WWII, 117,000 in WWI and 58,000 in Vietnam. The old trench warfare days are done, thankfully.

Old/New: Glad you liked the write up. As to the Avatar? Well, I need a little time buried in the self help aisle of some bookstores, methinks. This self awareness shit ain't for sissies.
Great Post Geoff. Enjoyed this. Some might say we still fight the Civikl War./
I really love your thoughts about how when we're cornered or threatened, even the best of us can go on the snarling attack. Been there for sure.
OE: Yeah, it was a huge issue. It is a very nuanced and entangled time in our history. Economic drivers. Human rights drivers. A real test of state versus federal rights, and on and on and on.

Becky: Thanks. It was sort of a double whammy out there in the fields.
I toured Antietam as a child and wish I had the maturity to appreciate it. An excellent piece. Hope I can go back on a visit east. RRRR
What a brutal scene, yet so civilized the way a truce was called to bury the dead. War seems a lot different now. Nice work.
Bernadine: I won't call touring it "fun" necessarily, but it is certainly a powerful experience to look out at this rolling land with a few slight dips and then the high bankment at the river crossing and imagine the carnage and the fear and adrenaline-base instant decision making that had to be done under incredible duress on both sides of the equation. That bloody lane was literally filled with dead. Incredible to stand in there and imagine it. Just brutal.

Reflections: Oddly enough we have greatly reduced casualties numbers through technology. Troops are more needed to occupy lands after clearing the areas out with GPS-Guided munitions. At the same time, though, our on field medical capabilities result in reducing the number killed, but greatly increasing the wounded now with far more severe limitations. We are going to have a huge debt to these people going forward from our current involvements and I worry quite a bit about how well we will treat these people. In my local community we're raising funds for a wounded soldier whose disabilities were not deemed severe enough to receive grants to modify his home for him to live in. Makes me both angry and sick to my stomach, frankly.

Kate: It's somewhat overlooked, with Gettysburg being the big show. This is a smaller battle area and was a 24 hour bout rather than three days. But it was fiercer by far.
I have never been to Antietam but plan to go. I have toured Gettysburg many times and the solemnity of it all is overwhelming. I can't wait to feel that at Antietam as well. Rated!