Sarcasm Alley

In the Land of Milk and Honey when you die they think it's funny

cheshyre grin

cheshyre grin
Location
Sitting on a cornflake, waiting for the van to come
Birthday
January 01
Title
The One True
Company
An ill-favoured thing, sir, but mine own.
Bio
Quit your snooping, bitch.

MY RECENT POSTS

Cheshyre grin's Links

Fort Worth Japanese Gardens
My Opus
Lives Fallen Through The Cracks
Goupil, The Assassin
Meta Movies
Oda Nobunaga, Warlord of Japan
Photo Essays
Sei Shonagon & The Japans
Read all about it
DECEMBER 21, 2011 10:26PM

There's A Mole In The Circus!

Rate: 5 Flag

Matryoshka
I had these custom made by hand in Russia in replication of ones
used in the opening credits of the original Tinker Tailor series

First off, let's congratulate whomever came up with the Open Call question on releasing one of the all time worst movie spoilers!!!! Are you nuts? Tinker Tailor has many parts, including character and atmosphere, but the plot is as important as any of them. As I said in my first Tinker post, the revelation of the mole had me on my seat in one of the greatest movie climaxes I'd ever experienced.

Un-fricking-believable to reveal that up front.

Matryoshka1

As for the specious question, the simple answer is "No". It's sort of like asking, "If I hold the hands on the clock still, will time stop?" The two seem related on the surface but the reality is there is no connection.

John le Carré is a faithful and astute student of human psychology. He realizes psychological realities are just as real as any lead bullet - and can be just as deadly. In light of this, one cannot just "suppose anything" and deem it relevant. Assumptions must fit within the bounds of the realities of the character's behavior.

Let's start with "Bloody Bill Haydon". He's a man who has centered the best part of his life around the monuments he's built to his keen intellect. There are many smart sorts in the Service, but Bill is a star among stars. His sharp eyes and even sharper tongue don't miss a thing. But what is Bill's greatest treasure of all - his "gold dust" have you - but the fact he's pulling the wool over the entire British Secret Service!

Matryoshka2


American traitor Robert Hanssen mentioned his secret thrill in leading the hunt to find the FBI's leak to Russian intelligence when he in fact was that leak! Since le Carré always writes with fidelity to the character’s psychological reality, there's no way Bill Haydon would have jeopardized his most prized possession with careless pillow talk!

George Smiley is quite the wiley soul himself, and as the #2 man in the Circus even a whiff of something out of the ordinary would have blown Bill's cover in a heartbeat. Would Bill risk that by asking George's wife to help him? Not bloody likely! Especially since Bill could read the mercurial nature of George and Ann's marriage and know even if she swore fealty to Bill's secret she might betray that knowledge in a fit of pique.

Matryoshka3


And lastly, how could Ann help Bill anyway? Is the naturally secretive George Smiley going to casually bring his work home? Is he going to reveal things to her so secret not even one of his closest colleagues could know? Fact is, it would be almost impossible for anyone in the Circus to keep a secret from Bill - as witnessed by his knowledge of Control's sleuthing to find a mole.

Bill had no use for anyone but himself when it came to spying. Being in his own secret world, charading his way through so many perceptive and suspicious minds on a daily basis, being hailed as a hero in the Soviet Union - these were the devils and delights driving him onward in thrilling rot unnoticed. At the end of the day, Bill Haydon stood alone having even betrayed his closest ally, Jim Prideaux.

Mole

A better question might be: Just how is a cold war film relevant in a world of shattered superpowers dominated by guerilla tactics and small terrorist bands?




Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I rewatch it every year on a cloudy, rainy day, pretending I'm in dreary England ensconced by wonderful fog.
Not having read the book, I cannot agree or disagree with your point of view. However, I like your question better. R
Yeah, I gave a real insider's reply there, Trudge. And that question was the first thing to pop into my mind when I heard about the remake. A 21st century update would be fascinating and highly courageous since the truth reflects poorly on most everyone at this point. In a time of eroding civil rights, the enemy is us.
I agree that the OS open call on this is a crappy way to give up one of the central questions. I do think that the entire LeCarre "Karla Trilogy" is still relevant. Much of LeCarre's work centers on the question, "How much of ourselves, our love and our life do we give to our responsibilities?" and how institutions can crush the individual.
A favorite author of mine. Nice post.
Rated.
I'm still confused, did I make a movie during one of my many blackouts???

~wonders~ ~Wanders off~ :D
Scylla, great point! I just hope the movie takes that same tack of self-examination that Le Carre does in his books. That is certainly timeless.

Tink, I think all your movies include robots!!??