Be Here Now

Hawley Roddick

Hawley Roddick
Location
Monterey, California, USA
Birthday
February 13
Title
Author
Bio
Hawley Roddick is a transplanted New Yorker who has set down roots in California where she writes promiscuously (books, blogs, Facebook, and as @HawleyRoddick on Twitter). She also co-authors memoirs for private clients as well as for publication. The insatiably curious can learn more at http://www.hawleyroddick.com

JUNE 28, 2009 5:44PM

Pedofilia - from Michael Jackson to Etan Patz

Rate: 22 Flag

  eye with tear

During Michael Jackson’s trial for pedophilia in 2003, I lived in Santa Barbara, and Neverland Ranch was in Santa Barbara County, so the trial was treated as a local event. We Santa Barbarians were privileged to varying versions of the Inside Story. Example: “My best friend’s hair stylist told her that one of his clients overheard the sister of a guy who cuts grass at Neverland say on her cell phone at Trader Joe’s that Jackson did sexually abuse that boy.”

Based on such solid evidence as well as on media stories from actual reporters actually covering the case, people I knew thought Jackson was guilty. After all, the pervert charges first surfaced in 1993 and never quite went away. And, to be frank, Neverland and Jackson, however beloved by many, were considered by more-or-less neutral observers to be just too weird for him not to be guilty of something illegally weird.

But the other day I raised the subject with the thirty-something who was cleaning my home. Let’s call her Pam. Pam said Jackson was such a beloved icon of her youth that she was convinced of his innocence. She said he just loved children, boys and girls alike, and innocently. The media indicate that she is not alone. Many, including Jackson’s friend Elizabeth Taylor, have voiced similar convictions over the years.

Pam went on to tell me that for three years her former fiancé’s father had sexually abused her daughter. When Pam found out she took the bastard to court. Attorneys and social workers believed her daughter but didn’t have enough evidence to convict the pedophile whom the girl had called Grandpa.

I have to wonder if one reason people believe Jackson was innocent (beside the fact that his guilt was not established) is that children are sexually abused by adults often enough that we want to believe our favorite stars are better than the perverts who pass as normal all around us but surface often and close enough to make us nervous.

Pedophiles (whether or not they are in their victim’s family) can, after all, be good at hiding in plain sight. A friend told me her father had raped her repeatedly when she was a child. During that same time, he was head of the ethics committee of a prominent association of professional psychotherapists. He was a pillar of his local and professional communities. My friend said people would rather think she and her mother were lying about him than believe that he was doing what he was doing to his little girl.

Unfortunately, just as people don't necessarily recognize pedophiles, pedophiles don’t necessarily recognize that they are dangerous. The mind numbs as Michael Jackson asks with wistful self-justification, on camera, “What’s wrong with sharing a bed” (with a boy)? And the North American Man/Boy Love Association (NAMBLA) actually advocates legalizing sex between men and boys. I even saw a sickening report on television about men who exchange stories about their repeated rape of their own daughters. They seem to think they are, as responsible parents, teaching their girls how to love.

Recently a client I was interviewing in connection with his memoir, which I am writing, said that as children, he and his little sister went to Saturday afternoon movies. There was a bald man who habitually attended, too, and who wanted to sit next to his sister and massage her thigh during the movie. They told their parents, who were too innocent to understand the implication. The kids coped by changing seats whenever the pervert sat next to the sister.

My client's story reminded me of the man who sat next to me at a Saturday afternoon movie in the seemingly secure Manhattan suburb where we lived. I was nine or ten. He massaged my thigh throughout the film. Later at home, I told my mother, who asked if I’d reported him to the theater manager. I said, “No. I thought that would be rude.” She said it is smart not rude to report dangerous people; and it is very important.

Still earlier, when I was six, I was walking to school when a woman stopped her car on the shady suburban street, rolled down her window, and tried to persuade me to get into the car. I said no. She persisted, offering to drive me to school. I said no. She offered me candy. Aha! Just the ploy we children had been warned about, even in that safe town. Recognizing the script, I repeated firmly the one-word line I’d been taught: “No.” Then, improvising, I added, “I’m almost there. I’ll walk.”

I still wonder what her life story was and what my life story would have been if I’d gone with her. She seemed both plaintive and dangerous. While women pedophiles are much less common than male pedophiles, they do exist. I'll never know if she was one or was instead a kidnapper with other twisted motivations or ...

Yet another time, my friend Corny (for Cornelia) and I were sitting on a bench by a river in a woods where we were never allowed to be without a grownup, because dangerous men might follow the river up from the city. We went there without an adult all the time, which is why I was perhaps more familiar with the sight of male masturbation and orgasm than many other gently raised little girls. (Me at nine to my mother: “What’s that white stuff than comes out of a man’s penis when he pulls on it?” Poor mother later said she sometimes thought I’d never live to grow up.)

Anyway, a scruffy looking man on a bike stopped, leaned his bike against the bench where Corny and I sat, and told us we should rub each other “like this:” on each of us, he rubbed the central spot just above the area where our tightly crossed legs met. I was scared but didn’t want to be rude or provoke this stranger. My mind raced. I said, “I just remembered. I have to go home right now and practice the piano.” Corny said, “Me, too,” and we fled.

One thing that probably hasn’t changed from my mother’s generation to mine to my son’s is the ghastly fear that our children might fall into the hands of a pedophile despite our best efforts to keep them safe. The defining event for my generation of parents in this regard was the May 1979 disappearance of Etan Patz in Manhattan. Last month, the media marked the thirtieth anniversary of the traumatic tragedy, and “Etan Patz” rose to the top of Google Trends. When I saw it, I was unprepared for and unguarded against the memory, and the horror and fear I’d felt at the time resurfaced with all its old intensity. The assumption was and is that six-year-old Etan was kidnapped by a pedophile while walking alone to the school bus.

Like Etan’s family, mine also lived in Manhattan in 1979. The Patzes lived downtown. We lived between Lincoln Center and Central Park. On lampposts in our neighborhood, have-you-seen-this-boy fliers with Etan’s beguiling photo appeared. We parents saw them whenever we went out; whenever we took our children to the school bus stop and waited to see them safely board; whenever we picked them up from the school bus and walked them home.

As another mother who was in Manhattan in 1979 said last month to Lisa Cohen, author of a new book on the case [Note: She has posted a  comment below], “Etan’s disappearance forever changed the way children are raised in the city.”

Her remark reminded me that in 1969 when my son was born, a friend, the photography critic and author Vicki Goldberg, said (referring to a Francis Bacon quotation), "Now you have a hostage to fortune. Your life will never be the same again."

I never forgot the quotation, and I have come to understand that every child is a hostage to fortune, and in the post-9/11 world, we all know more surely than ever what can befall a hostage. Pedophiles are terrorists in the starkest terms: they spread terror.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Excellent perspective. I agree that those who see Michaels innocence are projecting onto him their hopes, not a realistic analysis. Michael himself, like most pedophiles, did not see what he did as doing anything wrong. He poured wine in little boys drinks and called it "Jesus Juice". Really, you think someone who is not molesting children pours wine in their soda and watches pornography with them? This is fact and came out in his trials. Too many children reported the exact same scenario. And then there are those who repeatedly deflect this with "well what about the parents of those children?!" Yes, they were wrong to allow their kids around MJ. But that does not take away from the criminal acts he was performing. The first boy who brought charges and was paid off by MJ with $21 million dollars, said both he and his family had their lives ruined, broken, shattered.

Scott Peck wrote a book called "People of the Lie". He documents that evil people consistently join groups to "hide" in: churches, etc. to camouflage their actions. Like the BTK killer, who held a top position in his church, these people hide amongst the innocent and it usually works for them. Prosecutors say this is why it is often hard to convict cold-blooded killers. People on the jury who are innocent and naive just don't want to "believe" what people do and so insist they must be innocent. Prosecutors have to spend their time saying, "yes, we know YOU wouldn't do this, but this man did."

Rated.
Hawley! Good to see you back. We’ve missed you. I (Melissa) have been contemplating joining Twitter to catch up on your memoirs. That is, if I can find the time between OS’ing and working and creating and somehow managing to sleep and eat in between all of those activities!

In any case, we appreciated this honest and astute examination of a deadly serious issue. When we heard about MJ, we thought this is actually the best thing that could’ve happened to his reputation. All the suspicions, all the whispers, all the ugliness surrounding his court cases just went poof! He’s been given retroactive innocence in the popular mind. One of my (Melissa’s) first thoughts was, I wonder how his alleged victims felt about his passing. And then I thought, I wonder how the public would feel about the death of an accused pedophile sitting in jail awaiting sentence. Very differently, we suspect.

Thanks for another thought-provoking piece, Hawley.

( m&m )
what kind of "realistic analysis" can one get out of a story that comes from a kid drugged by his own father?

it really bothers me to see this kind of fantasy, masquerading as analysis.

my parents gave me wine as a child, and we watched monty python & the holy grail. there are naked ladies in it.

deborah young would think they were pedophiles.
Deborah, you make strong points and give mus more to think about.

Melissa, I've been spending most of my time trying to strengthen my marketing. I want more writing/editing/interviewing assignments. If you knew how often I've thought of you and Michael and wanted to get caught up with Metaness, you wouldn't have missed me! By the way, I gave up the Twitter memoir and now just Tweet on (thoughtful) impulse trying to figure out how to drive prospects to my website (to be candid).
During the OJ Simpson murder trial, a football fan at my office said - without ironic intent - "I've followed his career long enough to know he could never kill anyone."

We know what we want to know, and as little else as possible.
This hit home.... more than you know. These people do hide in plain site, they are often caught, never punished and released back into society. Will it take every politician's child being raped or molested before something is done?
No pressure whatsoever, Hawley! We absolutely understand, and we don’t want to contribute to the guilt of an accumulating todo list, which we know all too well :-) The metaness is patient. And we hope you gather some wonderful subjects for your next round of assignments!

( m&m )

P.S. We wholly (and sadly) concur with Hello’s wise statement: “We know what we want to know, and as little else as possible.”
Hawley, what a vivid and frank piece of writing. I get hives imagining some of this from a mom perspective. Both the car and the river bench incidents are riveting and terrifying. Highly rated, and good to hear from you.
I ran into a gay man who, one night after a dinner fueled by alcohol attempted to convince me how he was doing young boys a favor by having sex with them, how much they love it. He was deadly serious and I'll never forget it. It gave me an insight into the mentality of the type of molester that "hides in plain sight," the priest who coaches the basketball team, the Scout leaders, the friendly and well educated boarding school teachers. These molesters have bought their own lies and they see nothing wrong at all with what they do, and in fact a lot right.

Hawley this was an excellent piece and it gave me chills. It is too easy to stereotype a pedophile and run the risk of a child letting their guard down. Yes, most pedophiles are men but we know that is not always true. The recent case in your beautiful state of California is a prime example. Your own story of that frightening woman who attempted to coerce you into her car sent chills down my spine.

My own mother would chastise me for cutting through the woods to get to school, both to my elementary school and then when I would miss the bus I would cut straight through to my Jr. High School. I was a woodsy nature loving kid and there was no better way to start the day for me. I did as I pleased though in these times of graphic media representations of just what can happen to young girls in the woods there is no way I'd let my kid do that.

Jackson's interview with Martin Bashir convinced me without a doubt that he was guilty of pedophilia. His assurances to Bashir that "oh, I invite little girls to my bedroom too (as if that makes it all okay!)" sent me over the edge.

And no one, note even one as kooky as Michael Jackson, pays off someone to the tune of 20 million dollars if they aren't guilty of something pretty major.
Superb post. Etan Patz was in my oldest daughter's class. He had attended her birthday party six weeks before he was kidnapped. He was bright, friendly, charming. I will never forget the phone call from school the afternoon he disappeared. "Had we seen, Etan?" At that time schools didn't call if kids didn't show up in the morning. His mother thought he was in school; the school thought he was at home.

My brave daugthter became utterly paranoid that someone was going to crawl into our appartment and steal her, even thought we lived on the 20th floor. Etan was just at the age when we all thought it appropriate to let your child walk a block, take the elevator two floors.

To this day, Anne often remembers Etan on the anniversary of his disappearance. Two years later we moved out of Manhattan. When I tried to explain why, Etan's kidnapping is always one of the reasons.
Thanks for this Hawley. the covering over of these types of events, sadly all too common as you point out, is really distressing. I've known too many people who were molested or had attempts (as for you) and several people who treat victims and perps. What most people are in denial about is how incredibly common it is, and how often the person seems "normal" to their friends, neighbors and family. As odd as he was in many ways, Jackson was, sadly, not uncommon, and his methods and justifications ditto.
This is a great post, and I just read an article about Etan Patz, and a group of people outside the mainstream who reported the pedophile (who may have killed Etan Patz) to police for molesting their children but were not taken seriously because of their lifestyle. Kind of ironic considering all the people blending into society who really are not to be trusted.

You have a point about about MJ. I wasn't sad to see him go, not because I disliked him but he was such a symbol of sadness and decay. *Hello* was so right about people wanting to know what they do know. My father, who is a staunch conservative, was convinced of OJ's innocence and MJ's. I never really understood that inclination to want to protect these people.
The hardest thing in the world is for people to realize that their "heroes" are just as fucked up as everyone else. That pedestal simply comes crumbling down and they can't handle it.
Michael Jackson paid tens of millions to SEVERAL victims families in settlements. One doesn't pay settlements if one isn't guilty.
Rated.
How frightening, the number of close calls you had with this! I agree with you about MJ. The level of denial people can be in is pretty amazing.
Very absorbing post. Well-written.
Jackson may have been innocent in his own eyes, by way of simply being too mentally ill to understand what he was doing is wrong. Regardless, that's a threat. No amount of money can make a threat that doesn't know it's a threat go away and be rendered harmless. Srsssly, Jesus Juice.
This is an excellent post. There's a new book by Lisa Cohen about Etan Patz. It's heartbreaking.
I'm the author of the new book AFTER ETAN: The Missing Child Case That Held America Captive, as well as the reporter to whom that mother said, “Etan’s disappearance forever changed the way children are raised in the city.” It was a sad but familiar account to read in these comments about the little girl who knew Etan and grew up terrified a stranger would come through her the 20th floor window.

I talked to a number of neighbors down in SoHo who remembered the pervasive panic after Etan disappeared, about the "bucket-brigade"-like line of parents who oversaw children getting to the bus stop in the weeks following, until school ended for the year. But one of the other things I learned was that, like the overwhelming majority of child abductions, Etan's was most likely not the proverbial "stranger" abduction, but instead perpetrated by someone the boy knew, if only slightly. Unfortunately as I also learned, "stranger danger" is often a fallacy.

The most important thing you can do to protect your children is to encourage them to talk to you about their day, their thoughts, their concerns. Open lines will alert you to dangers hiding in proximity. Then, and just as difficult, you have to work to not hide your children themselves away or terrorize them so that they are victimized anyway - by their fear.
bstrangely, MJ's accusor's dad was not, as you remind us, a candidate for Father of the year.

Hello, your insight is sad but wise. Alas.

MiddleAged, you sound as if you have stories to tell, too, and I share your anger and frustration.

Annette, thanks for your support.

Ablonde, you and I both took chances and both were lucky. And yes, the "little girls" comment is nauseating.

Redstocking, I ached reading your perspective on Etan Patz. We, too, moved from the city not long afterward.

Silkstone, I agree that the pervasiveness of pedophilia is staggering, all the more so because it can be so difficult to detect.

latethink, MJ's slippery slide into decadence was as dramatic as his on-stage performances. For those of us who don't think he and OJ were innocent, it's difficult to comprehend how anyone can think they were.

tregibbs, it is so hard to see our heroes' significant flaws exposed. I'm still shocked by JFK's philandering ...

MB, my "close calls" seem much closer now that I have read comments here than they did before. I suppose I was in denial about how close to danger I came.

Travis, thanks.

Asta, it's frustrating and puzzling when people don't know they are hurting others. Denial is one of our strongest resources for self-protection, but it can be dangerous.

Freaky, your troll magic seems to have brought Lisa Cohen to us.

Lisa, congratulations on your new book. I have added a note about it to my original posting. That Etan may have known his abductor slightly is frustrating. Even if parents follow your good advice to ask young children about their day and their lives, and even if they are alert for warning signals, they still face the fact that many child abusers are known to the family and are judged to be nonthreatening. That our children's safety is not entirely in our control is a nightmare but not, as you point out, one we want to pass on to them through being overprotective.
I reemember going downtown (The Fillmore?) that summer to see Traffic. I can still picture the flyers taped to almost every lampost. My wife and I enjoyed the concert but the evening, the whole summer, was overcast with the nauseating ... I don't have words to describe it. Our children were 8 and 7.
I know that capital punishment does not deter murder but if public stoning of convicted pedofiles would save one child, I'd be the first to cast a stone, not withstanding what the Good Book teaches.
Oldgold, although I don't believe the state should murder, when I remember that terrible summer in 1979 (that you, too, lived through) and how we all ached for Etan and his family, a part of me much more ancient than the civilized passifist, feels that the parents of an abused and murdered child should be allowed publicly to do whatever they want with the guilty person. Not that I advocate this but that my inner mother would take satisfaction.
Hawley, this is a fine piece of writing. I no more know whether MJ was guilty or innocent than I do whether OJ was (unlike most people, I really genuinely don't know--and don't have an opinion), but preying on children is beyond the realm of my sad little imagination. The only scary thing is that tales of childhood abuse are so prevalent. We've all known people who were abused as children. Some of my real-life friends have stories; more of us have stories, like you, of near-misses.

I wonder where the (far more widespread than we're willing to admit, by the sounds of anecdata) drive to have sexual contact with children comes from. Surely it's got SOME foundation in biology. It can't be that so many adult men (and women) are "broken." I also wonder whether we might be able to better understand and prevent child sexual predators if we stopped pretending they're as rare as hen's teeth.

I despise the use of the euphemisms "molest" and "abuse."
Verbal, predators they are. Molest and abuse are cop-out words. If you ever learn why so many adults prey sexually on children, let me know? It's beyond my powers of empathy and understanding. Meanwhile, I agree we should stop pretending these predators are not all around us.
As a child I ran across pedophiles too. One time in particular it was the father of the children I had just spent the evening babysitting for...I was 14 and my parents insisted I be driven home when they got home late at night.

There were others...and they were not who you ordinarily think of a pedophiles as being.

They didn't even have to hide in the old days, because such things were never spoken about.

I'm glad people can talk about it more openly now. But you know what they say, it it walks like duck.....

Rated for your excellent writing.
Hawley - this is a really good piece, interesting vantage. Keeping children safe never takes a generational break. I can recall misadventures when I was a kid, and when my own kids were small some really sad events that made parents keep their children close and closer. It doesn't matter if you live in Manhattan or in bucolic Vermont, tragic stuff happens anywhere. A good reminder.
@tregibbs: People pay settlements all the time whether they are guilty or not. It's called "making it go away." I will probably have to pay such a settlement to my mother's husband's band of crooks, er family, just to avoid having to pay them a whole lot more down the road. Neither my mother or I are guilty of anything.
Lisa Cohen has solved the mystery. She got a Google Alert when Freaky mentioned her book on my blog.
Good post Hawley. Count me among those who find it hard to believe that Michael was truly innocent. But without proof, well...

Unfortunately, every generation or regions seems to have their own Etan story that changes things. In the 70s in Toronto, it was a shoeshine boy in a seedy part of the city. More recently, in the suburbs west of Toronto, it was Paul Bernardo and Karla Holmolka's kidnapping and murder of Kristen French and Leslie Mahaffey. In my own life, I was chased by two men in a car through a parking lot while going to the store for my mother. I asked Mom about it recently, because it seemed like a dream. She remembers me coming home and saying something, but since I was safe, she did nothing. I don't think I must have fully described the event being so young. To this day, I still wonder who they went after next, and if they were successful.

On the other hand, I sometimes think we've gone to far in overprotecting children. I can't imagine how restrictive the lives of youngsters are these days. No more going as far as your bike or feet could take you with the only rule being to get home before the street lights come on.
God, so much has changed since Etan Patz...so much! There's no more walking home from school unescorted by teams of adults. No more walks to the local convenience store to buy a treat for a chore well done. There's just so much that our kids and their kids have lost out on because of the creeps that hunt our children.
I will say that one of the good things that has changed in our relationships with our kids, is the tendency to believe what they tell us. When I was a kid, if I went home from school and said the teacher was acting funny or bothering me, my parents would ask what I did to deserve it, and I'd end up punished!! But I digress!
Rated