Hayley's Comments

Introspection on Healing, Vegetarianism, and Life

Hayley Rose

Hayley Rose
Location
HayleysComments.com, Connecticut, TheVeggieStand.com
Birthday
December 31
Title
HayleysComments.com
Bio
I was born when Halley’s Comet last appeared overhead and named accordingly. Since then, I've become a writer, artist, and columnist. In addition to Open Salon, my work appears frequently in The Huffington Post, All Things Healing, Gender Across Borders: A Global Feminist Blog, and several other publications. I blog daily at my site HayleysComments.com I recently published my first book, "I Know Why They Call a Shell a Shell." The book is about domestic violence, a topic that I am very vocal about. It chronicles my journey away from tumultuous love affairs by weaving stories of her past with stories from literature, music, and visual art of both modern and classical significance. Find me on Twitter @HRoseStudios

MY RECENT POSTS

JUNE 30, 2012 11:44AM

Tom Cruise and Katie Holmes Split: Is Scientology to Blame?

Rate: 14 Flag

After five years of marriage, Katie Holmes plans to divorce Tom Cruise and she's seeking sole custody of their daughter Suri, 5. Columnists speculate that Holmes', 33, motivation for leaving Cruise, 49, revolves around Cruise's involvement in The Church of Scientology and the Church's influence on their five-year old daughter. But one has to wonder the reason for this concern.

Scientology was established by L. Ron Hubbard in 1952. Though it is referred to as a "church," many prefer to think of Scientology as a cult. L. Ron Hubbard, a famous writer of science fiction novels, did not set out to found a church. Its development began with his authoring of Dianetics, a metaphysical literature based on the theory that negative human experiences and emotional scars, or engrams as he called them, were responsible for physical symptoms and illness.

With Dianetics Hubbard proposed a type of emotional cleansing, or audit, through which the emotional wounds of the subject were revisited and erased thus restoring the subject to a state of Clear. Once achieving a state of Clear, the individual faces challenges with a newly acquired demeanor of calm in which he or she reacts reasonably to situations that would've formerly provoked an emotional response. Thus theorizing, through achievement of this state, a Clear individual is in control of their thoughts and is able to think rationally.

Hubbard initially made a lot of money off of this type of "auditing" and his auditing courses. However, after a failed public demonstration of the promises of Dianetics, Hubbard lost public interest and received criticism. Now experiencing financial difficulties, Hubbard had to think of a new plan quickly.

As Dianetics faltered, Hubbard came out with a new theory called the Science of Survival in which he theorized that within a human body was a thetan, an immortal God-like soul trapped inside of a physical body. Becoming trapped in a body, the thetan lost memory of its origins which he theorizes, lie in the creation of the universe as the thetan is considered a God-like being. The concept itself closely parallels the idea of an immortal soul though not entirely. Through Scientology, Hubbard promised to "rehabilitate each person's thetan to restore its original capacities and become once again an 'Operating Thetan.'" Once achieving a state of Clear, an individual could pursue the state of becoming Operating Thetan, however, it would cost them.

New Scientology centers opened up throughout the country. In these centers, auditors provided basic services to customers. More expensive auditing was only permissible at Hubbard's central location. With finances in mind, one of his chief operating managers suggested turning Scientology into a religion. As a church, they would enjoy huge financial benefits. Hubbard's treatments were already costly, reportedly at least $500, and as a religion, Hubbard's organization would become tax exempt.

From there on Scientology grew exponentially. Practicing Scientologists aimed to reach the final state of Cleared Theta Clear, the highest state of being, but to achieve this the person had to first pass through eight different levels of Operating Theta. "It is alleged that people are encouraged to complete very expensive courses and expect wonderful results; when the improvements fail to happen they are told the next course will bring the changes they anticipate." This often turns out to be a costly endeavor.

Is Scientology truly to blame for Tom and Katie's divorce? Is it really some sort of theological irreconcilable differences? Regardless, Scientology sounds on par with many New Age religious movements and to me, the only crazy thing about it is the amount of money people are willing to give to the church. However, the act of donating large sums of money to a church is not unlike many Christian sects in which it is customary for denominations to enjoy large tax-free donations from their followers. I leave you with one final quote:

"Writing for a penny a word is ridiculous. If a man really wants to make a million dollars, the best way would be to start his own religion." L. Ron Hubbard, 1948 at a writer's convention.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
I never liked Hubbard. He sure figured out a way to make money writing tho. I think a short fellow like Cruise would eat up that "Be A God" stuff. Time to move on and save your daughter from becoming a zombie, Katie.
Yes and if you read about the conditioning process, they spend HOURS talking to you and I'm sure they devote a lot of time to their celebrity clients and some actors live for attention
"Writing for a penny a word is ridiculous. If a man really wants to make a million dollars, the best way would be to start his own religion." L. Ron Hubbard, 1948 at a writer's convention.

~nodding~ So true!!!

Rated!
My thoughts exactly! Glad she is waking up and smelling the scientology.
I don't know or care why they are breaking up -- so many rumors swirl around the Scientology cult, also around Tom Cruise himself -- but I do hope Ms. Holmes comes into her own in acting and in life as well as Nicole Kidman did after she moved on from her first marriage, I really like Katie Holmes and wish her and Suri well.
It is possible that ages 33 and 49 is enough of a difference of world view without all the rest, but rumor and drama will swirl around this breakup for ages, likely.
Maybe Tom will find lasting love with another Scientology die hard, John Travolta.
They looked so happy and in love on their wedding day! ... Maybe it was Tom's role in "Rock of Ages? ... I never got the whole Scientology thing.
False idols and all that, boils down to the religion of money and a very intelligent man scheming to part people with their cash for his own purposes. Criminal.

There will be much speculation no doubt, I do hope Katie Holmes and her precious daughter come through intact.
Grab your daughter and run for both your lives, Katie. I can't understand why you put up with Scientology for even 5 years.

Tom Cruise--good looking but serious, serious religious weirdo.

rated
Things must really be bad if Katie is asking for sole custody. That's practically unheard of these days.

Lezlie
Has to be Scientology. It's not as though the marriage of a twice-divorced Hollywood star to a third wife 16 years his junior has any other risk factors.
Hayley- my ex has rented to the church of scientology for at least 18 years. Any one or group that keeps a special office empty with a bust of Ron L Hubbard in it... well I would not my kid join it.
My opinion.. but it is all scary.
I'm jumping up and down on the couch!

The Scientologists have basically bought up Clearwater, Florida. Apparently cold isn't part of their program.
Lots of rumors swirl around Tom Cruise. At a minimum he seems manic. Glad she's able to leave.
How about because Cruise is a dick?

Occam's razor and all.
You have to wonder how much this strange religion played into the decision for them to break up. I used to live in Clearwater Florida and the whole downtown area has been taken over. It was just the Fort Benjamin Harrison Hotel but now it is everywhere. Creepy.
@Nick: If you're going to employ Occam's Razor, your question should have been, "How about because Cruise LIKES dick?"



Not that there's anything wrong with that.
I have to wonder how big a factor Scientology is in the divorce. After all, Cruise was gung-ho about it when he was "wooing" her so nothing that happened since then should have been a surprise to her. Perhaps the age gap between them became more glaring; perhaps she thought being married to one of Hollywood's biggest stars would do wonders for her career and she's finally realized it's hindered it. Considering the rumors that have always swirled around Cruise, I have always suspected that there is a lot of hidden reasons behind both Nicole Kidman's, and now Holmes', divorce from him.
And I put "wooing" in quotes for exactly the reason Margaret Feike referred to.
Tink- I think it's time for Tink to start his own religion!

Just thinking- I'm starting to think that a lot of organized religions seem cult-like

Deborah- I know look at her smile- definitely authentic

Abrawang- good points as always

Cranky- not sure about the age gap, out of the five people I am related to/ friends with that married people 15 yrs + their senior they are either still together or were together until one of them died- Maybe it's just Hollywood and the lifestyle of traveling keeping them apart that got in the way?