Heather Michon

Heather Michon
Location
Virginia,
Birthday
June 25
Bio
Follow me on Twitter @heathermichon

MY RECENT POSTS

Editor’s Pick
DECEMBER 3, 2008 9:51AM

Hillary the Un-Drama Queen

Rate: 23 Flag
barack_and_hillary

 

With Senator Hillary Clinton now Secretary of State Designate Hillary Clinton, the never-ending narrative of "No Drama Obama and the American Evita" is seemingly poised to enter a new season.

Can Barack "control" Hillary? Will she "go rogue"? Is she, in the words of one HuffPo commenter "Mommy Dearest on the Pepsi board" all over again? Or, by giving her this position, has the President-Elect cannily "neutralized" this mortal political enemy AND her troublesome still-husband Bill? Is this the "end of Hillary?" one writer asks. "Will she no longer be the bright star, blazing her own path across the political skies?" And so on.

For most of the past two decades, Hillary Clinton has been portrayed by Republicans and assorted others, along with a large swath of media, as an unstoppable force of nature -- like a thunderstorm, or a busted sewer line. The hysteria with which she had viewed over the years is hard to capture in words. The saga of Hillary the Harridan, the Human Nutcracker, has long since developed a life of its own.

As we saw during the primaries, she has somehow become the living embodiment of those things we fear about women and power, and we reflect those fears back on to her in much the same way we reflect our hopes and dreams back on Barack Obama. It has less to do with who they are as actual living, breathing human beings than what they represent to us as a culture.  

There were dozens of articles and blog posts over the last few weeks warning the President-Elect not to let himself become caught up in the soap opera that is the Clintons. These two are so egotistical, the refrain generally goes, that when they walk into a room, all the attention turns on them. (The nerve.. You would expect a gregarious, popular ex-president-turned-philanthropist and a former First- Lady-turned-senator-who-came-within-a-few-million-votes-of-becoming-the-first-woman-president-in-history would just blend right into the woodwork.)

The "soap opera" narrative was played out in all its three-act glory over the last month, as the President-Elect began to fill his Cabinet.

First, there were those undisciplined Clinton people, leaking the story that Obama had asked her to be Secretary of State before he really had. It's a little hazy as to how that is Senator Clinton's fault, but like a lot of soap opera plots, you just have to overlook the holes. This was widely interpreted as power-play, an attempt to shoulder her way into a Cabinet position by making Obama look petty for NOT asking her. (Interestingly, John Kerry and Bill Richardson were openly lobbying for a nomination to State, and nobody said boo about it. But, then, we attach roughly the same excitement to Kerry and Richardson that we usually reserve for a flu shot.)

Now, it had been clear for some time that Clinton was going to be offered some big post; her name had already been floated as possible head of Health and Human Services, or Supreme Court Justice. The Democratic leadership was getting ready to dangle some juicy positions within the Senate. Everyone knew something was coming, and since gossip is the life's-blood of politics, it's no wonder someone blabbed.

Then there was the protracted "will she or won't she?" dance after the offer was truly made. The subtext was that she was just playing hard-to-get. Because the decision to give up a seat in one of the world's most august deliberative bodies -- a seat that she probably could keep, without much effort, until she slumped over dead in the middle of a subcommittee hearing at the age of 99 -- for a chance to spend the next four to eight years diplomatically stomping out fires and trying to solve the world's unsolvable problems....that requires no thought or reflection. You just jump at it -- but not TOO fast, lest you look "entitled."      

This was paired by the obligatory "will he or won't he?" over Bill's role in the process. That too was pretty drama-free when you get right down to it. He signaled early on that he was ready to do what he had to do if she decided to take the offer. But people who has been through as many legal struggles as Bill and Hillary Clinton are going to spend a good long time talking to lawyers and advisers about their exposure before throwing open records. Is that dramatic, or is that just prudent?      

In the final act before the official roll-out on Monday, there were the similarly obligatory stories that Senator Clinton had "demanded" the right to select her own senior staff. Again: is that really an over-the-top "demand"? She's looking at heading up a department filled with career staffers who have their own turf wars and their own agendas. (There's already a battle between the Secret Service and the Diplomatic Security Service over whose jurisdiction the new Madame Secretary would fall under.) Walking into that environment, wouldn't you want your closest staff to be people you knew you could trust?        

The undramatic truth is that Hillary Clinton didn't kill Vince Foster. She and Obama kind of like each other. While her marriage to Bill Clinton may not be the stuff of epic poetry, they have managed to keep an imperfect union together for going on 35 years and are unlikely to give up on it now. She's an "American Idol" fan. When she's stressed out, she likes to re-organize closets. She's exactly as human as the rest of us, and just as contradictory.   

And, like her or hate her, Barack Obama has assigned her the task of rebuilding our global diplomatic bridges after nearly a decade of abuse and neglect, and of striking the right tone of toughness and pragmatism in an era when we no longer look like the biggest, baddest kids of the block.

It's an enormous job, and there IS something we can do to help: we can turn off the soap opera. Not by casting Hillary Clinton out of government -- that serves no one -- but by not treating her like a bomb that's about to go off, or a train that's lost its breaks. By treating her, finally, with the respect that we want the world to reflect back on us.
          

hit counter

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
loved the tag harridan :)
and I couldn't agree with you more.
Excellent! I wish I could rate it twice.
Nice post.

Personally, I'd give up a lot to be a fly on the wall and watch her in action as SOS. She's gonna be kicking butt and taking names---and she is going to be terrific. Kudos to her, Obama and Bill for all doing the right thing.
My guess is that she will be a terrific secretary of state...and will assist the Obama administration to be as great as it can be.

Let the Hillary detractors detract all they want. I feel their pain. In fact, I revel in it.


Heather, you did one hell of a job with this post...just the right amount of info, satire, humor, and stick-it-in-your-eye.

I loved it.

And this one deserves a rating...so I'm rating it.
Right on. What a lot of these people who pull this foolish hue and cry is that THEY are the ones on the soap opera wagon. Everyone else would like to move forward. Alas, self reflection is not popular.
Loved this! I agree with everything you wrote. Hillary is damned no matter what she does or doesn't do, at least in the eyes of many people who are ready to tear her down.

I personally have mixed feelings about her, but I only get more on her side when I see what gets thrown at her. (And as much by women as men, IMO.)

And I think she's an insanely smart, talented pol who will work her ass off for this administration. I also think people miss how dutiful she is (perhaps only one dutiful type can recognize another). Deep down, she's still the good girl, the A+ student and the hardest worker in the room. I think people will be surprised at how well she serves Obama.
Good post, and Kudos to you. I loved this:(The nerve.. You would expect a gregarious, popular ex-president-turned-philanthropist and a former First- Lady-turned-senator-who-came-within-a-few-million-votes-of-becoming-the-first-woman-president-in-history would just blend right into the woodwork.)

I didn't love everything Bill Clinton did during his presidency or after it, but overall, I think he was a good, effective president, and I have no regrets for having voted for him. (Even if I dearly wish he'd taken a cold shower and kept his pants zipped rather than ever even talk to Monica Lewinsky.) I've never bought into the hype that Hillary only married Bill to gain power. I mean an unknown guy from Arkansas after she helped impeach Nixon? If she had been half as power hungry as her detractors like to portray her, wouldn't it have made more sense for her to stay in Washington D.C. back in 1974? For all their troubles, they've stayed married, and I don't think it's just for the sake of their now adult daughter.

I like it that Obama has given her a prominent role in his administration. I wish them BOTH good luck, and God speed at repairing our relationships around the world. At least we know Hillary probably won't be tickling the ivories for Queen Elizabeth II.
We need to write the cable shows and let them know this. They always need to make drama about the Clintons when there already is enough in the world.

Just came back from a trip to New Zealand and everybody --everybody-- I spoke to from dozens of countries LOVED the idea of her as SOS. (And of course, were moved by Obama.)

Sometimes I wonder what's happened here. We let the darker, non-rational side emerge to much.
What we have come to know as "Clinton Derangement Syndrome" is a far-flung cancer afflicting many on the far right and, over the past few years, some very vocal members of the left as well.

Hillary is aware of it, and tries as hard as she can to rise above it, but no matter what she does there are those who will view her with contempt.

It is nice to read piece like this every once in awhile, however, that helps to put things into proper perspective.
I agree with your assessment. I think Hillary has the potential to be a great SOS during a critical time for the USA. Let's hope it works out.
If you've been around a little, say had a long marriage, or say ran a business where you have to be "professional," or if you simply understand the need for the media to appeal to a nation with 5th grade reading skills, you know the drama is manufactured.

The focus needs to be NOW on what she may possibly be able to do as SOS particularly in the Middle East, and yes I mean Israel, that could possibly further the cause of peace before the right wing of that country turns the first half of the 21st century into the last half of the 20th.

Hello, hello, is anybody home?
As I have made clear at OS, I think Obama has done precious little right during this transition. But picking Hillary for SoS was dead solid perfect--which is why the detractors have to go off-policy/off-experience/off qualification to make their case.
The simple fact is that the Clintons are hugely popular overseas. She was an excellent choice for the post and I’m glad she got it.

I must admit, I was kinda routing for her to get a Supreme Court nomination so I could watch her kick Scalia’s ass.
Right on. Hillary is an important political mind in the 21st century. You cannot ask her a question on Foreign Policy, and not get an educated, thought out, answer. I have not heard on person--except for Hitchens but he does not count--challenging her credentials.

"Now, it had been clear for some time that Clinton was going to be offered some big post; her name had already been floated as possible head of Health and Human Services, or Supreme Court Justice. The Democratic leadership was getting ready to dangle some juicy positions within the Senate. Everyone knew something was coming, and since gossip is the life's-blood of politics, it's no wonder someone blabbed."

Obama could show up for a speech, and 20,000 people would show up on less than a week's notice.

If Hillary came up to the North Country, where I am, I guarantee that 10,000 people would show up.

She is world known. Are you telling me that popularity and ability do not count for something?

You have this right on. Thank you.
Ah yes. My Hillary as Secretary of State. I have a house
cleaning client who goes bat shit crazy whenever her name is
mentioned. He had a difficult relationship with his own mother
and projects it (I think) on to HRC.He is a total Obama person,
and I'm not. I'm just loving this, he must be eating nails.