Pointing out that "body bags aren't taking a vaction," anti-war activist Cindy Sheehan announced that she would be traveling to Martha's Vineyard to protest during the President's week-long getaway there next week.
The response from most of the media? Cue the crickets.
Well, with a couple of exceptions.
ABC's Charlie Gibson told Chicago's WLS radio the other day that "you have to be sympathetic to her. Anybody who has given a son to this country has made an enormous sacrifice, and you have to be sympathetic. But enough already."
And this morning on CNN, contributor John Avlon named her his left-wing "Wingnut of the Week." (Tom Delay got the right-wing honors.)
A former speechwriter for Rudy Giuliani who now holds himself up as a centerist, Avalon said: "Maybe she should spend a little more time protesting the Taliban. I mean, especially after this election, get a clue and sense of perspective."
Nothing better proves the inherent shallowness of modern commercial media than "enough already."
ABC and CNN couldn't wait to put her on the air when she opened "Camp Casey" on the road leading to George W. Bush's Texas ranch in the summer of 2005. For three years, she was the grief-stricken face of the anti-war movement. Her quixotic attempts to hold Bush accountable for his actions in manipulating the country into war in Iraq and Afghanistan were held up as the noble work of a mother on behalf of her dead son.
Of course, that was back when the dominant narrative was "Bush Lied, People Died." With the election of Barack Obama, people have moved on to hope and change and the inherent misery of being an American in 2009.
From an anti-war movement perspective, not much has changed. We're by no means out of the woods in Iraq. We're escalating in Afghanistan. One of his first acts as President was to order a increase of 17,000 troops into Afghanistan, even though many security experts doubt an increase in troops will lead to anything other than an increase in casualties.
On a good day, Iraqis and Afghans die by the dozen. On a bad day, they die by multiples of dozens. We literally can't count how many civilians have been killed in those countries over the last 8 years.
We can count our own dead and wounded. According to Defense Department returns, as of yesterday at 10 am, 5,118 soliders have died in Operations Iraqi Freedom and Enduring Freedom. Another 18,968 have been "WIA not RTD" -- Wounded in Action, Not Returned to Duty.
Even those raw numbers don't capture the toll of war. They don't show the suicides, attemped and successful. They don't show the marriages and families torn apart. They don't show those WIA who will spend the remainder of their lives coping with the affects of lost limbs and traumatic brain injuries.
"No good social or economic change will come about with the continuation or escalation of wars in Iraq, Afganistan or Pakistan," Sheehan said in announcing her summer travel plans.
And this is supposed to be "wingnut" talk?
According to a poll released last week, 51% of Americans now oppose our continued presence in Afganistan. Only 32% of those questioned supported the Obama policy.
I haven't always agreed with Sheehan's rhetoric or her tactics, but always worth our while to consider how we use our military power. The more we tune out, the more we become passive actors in our own national story.
At the VFW convention in Phoenix last week, Obama told the audience that Afghanistan is "not a war of choice. This is a war of necessity." Both those points are arguable. We should be willing to have the argument.
And Cindy, if you haven't already, get yourself some fleece socks. Nights up on the islands get mighty chilly this time of year.
------------------
Like it? Leave a comment, link it, tweet it, rate it, Reddit!
Follow me on Twitter @heathermichon
Friend me on Facebook @ Heather Michon


Salon.com
Comments
Good post. Well done.
I apologize for sullying your blog with this, but allow me a sincere, heartfelt note to Charlie Gibson:
"Enough already"?!? F*CK YOU!!!
Tragic.
@Noah -- Yup. I'm firmly in the "honor the troops by bringing them home" camp. The amount of $ that goes to our military adventures is just throwing it down the hole at a time when we could really use it here. My feeling is we need to get beyond the Cold War mentality of buying ourselves into supremacy.
@Deborah -- from your keyboard to the Editor's eyes! I can't decide if the mainstream media is bias or just lazy...probably a bit of both.
They pretty much dropped her like a hot rock.
@Deborah........same goes for the homeless stories. How many stories are we hearing about the urban outdoorsmen now?
Both the Left and the Right are attempting to marginalize her because she brings truth to the table.
She has dangerous enemies. I really hope she doesn't suffer an unfortunate boating accident.
This woman is a true patriot. I am grateful to her ever diligence.
Do we now have proof that most, not all, liberals are FOS?
Between Lou Dobbs and this a-hole, CNN is sliding down toward that Faux News region of media. Calling an American citizen who lost a son in service is just disgusting. It's something slimy Fox Snooze would do.
Shame on them and shame on people for not letting her be heard without such vitriol.
Rated
© David Rovics 2005
All Rights ReservedAuthor: david rovics
Casey was a good boy
He treated people well
And his momma loved him
Anyone could tell
She'd send him off to school
Pack his lunch with care
When he came back home she hugged him
With her fingers in his hair
Cindy, she loved Casey
And when all is said and done
She is every mother
And he was every mother's son
When Casey was a little older
He spent his time each week
In that church in Vacaville
In the service of the meek
In the service of his city
In the service of the lord
With his momma in the pews
All the time they could afford
And if their love alone could save us
Then the world would be one
She is every mother
And he was every mother's son
People thought the priesthood
Was where he'd someday be
So some folks were surprised
When he joined the army
The recruiter told him
He wouldn't have to fight
Cindy hoped this was the case
And prayed for him every night
That was before they sent him
To the desert with a gun
She is every mother
And he was every mother's son
His truck had no armor
And when it came under fire
It and half the soldiers in it
Became a funeral pyre
Cindy, she was sleeping
The moment Casey died
And she knew she'd never see him
Standing by her side
There was no consolation
No safe place she could run
She is every mother
And he was every mother's son
The president, he told her
He died for a noble cause
But Cindy's wondering
Exactly what that was
Since they never found the weapons
And now that Casey's gone
It seems that oil is the game
And Casey was the pawn
Cindy's got some questions
And so does everyone
Because she is every mother
And he was every mother's son
free download here:
http://www.soundclick.com/bands/default.cfm?bandID=111310&content=music&songcount=201&offset=0¤tPage=2
Journalism's "muddled middle" mentality deserves criticism for the way they have treated her. Their misguided sense of "fairness" and "balance" and "objectivity" means they must castigate someone on the left every time they report of the very real misdeeds of someone on the right and Cindy is one of their favorite go-to "villains."
Of course mainstream media and "centrist" hacks of either corporate funded political party consider Cindy a wingnut. She calls accurately recognizes them as either war criminals or accomplices. Our "leaders" in Washington and on the TeeVee dutifully do the bidding of their corporate masters, resulting in "wars on terror" and American militarism all over the world and a shredded Constitution at home, all glossed over in pretty sound bite friendly packaging and celebrated as patriotism by fearful and ignorant Americans. The hatefulness and hypocrisy of this country are on full display right now as so many "Christians" treat peacemakers like Cindy with scorn and angrily deny that we are our brothers' keepers in the healthcare "debate".
Calling Cindy a wingnut is of course meaningless and would be unworthy of comment except that it attests to the incredibly sad and deep sickness that now cripples my beloved America that - thanks to companies like CNN - considers war to be normal. How many thousands of people around the world like Cindy have buried children and other loved ones thanks to the crimes committed by the thieves, racists and liars who really run this country and the cowards in the media who let them get away with it?
Cindy loves this country enough to truly honor our soldiers and fight for peace, and CNN laughs at her. See you in church, you damn hypocrites.
As for "giving" her son, I would respectfully disagree. Yes, she lost her son, but she did not give him. She did not support his beliefs or his convictions to join the army. Her son gave his life as a free thinking adult who chose to join the army. He gave his own life, Cindy had nothing to do with it.
She has every right to grieve and to protest and to voice her opinion, but in the end she had nothing to say.
1) We didn't know Casey Sheehan personally, so we can't know if he would have been proud, appalled, or completely indifferent to his mother's anti-war stance. To use our personal interpretation of how a soldier might be feeling about his mother's moral and ethical opinions from the Great Beyond is useful only to praise or condemn her, and we don't have the right to do that. It propagandizes -- and thus dehumanizes -- a man who is no longer here to issue his own statements.
2) Anti-war does not mean anti-solider. The War and The Solider are two different things. Wars can be good or bad, moral or immoral. Individual soliders can be good or bad, moral or immoral. The fact that one might think War is wrong does not, in any way, diminish the work of the Soldier, doing his or her duty as they have sworn to do.
And what better way to honor the troops then to work to get them out of harm's way?
When I got a chance to speak I said "Senator this is Cindy Sheehan who lost her son in Iraq and has been kind enough to join our meeting."
Cindy in a very quiet voice said "I didn't lose him." and then paused. Usually I am not at a loss for words, but I didn't know if I should say something or what.
After a long pause Cindy continued "George Bush murdered him." She then briefly explained to our senator that lying to start an illegal, immoral war constituted murder for all those that died as a result. She then told our senator that we were doing a great job telling him exactly what he needed to hear and let us continue our meeting with him.
I have had the opportunity to meet and hear Cindy speak several times and believe her to be the consience of America. She tells us what we always don't want to, but need to hear.
When she first went to Crawford Texas, the Democratic Party sent aides there to mold her and script her comments to the Party Platform. For a few days, confused her message was somewhat tempered. Her mother took ill and Cindy returned to California to be at her bedside. She then wrote a letter about how she had allowed these Democratic Party operatives to "take words out of my mouth", but she would no longer allow it. She has been 100% her own woman ever since.
ya can't be against war.
WHAT? It is not war; rather it is
what Ike warned us about - the MILITARY
Industrial Complex. The simplest part
of the complex is that you cannot
know if the factory up the road
is living off of defense contracts.
If yer local factories ARE livin' that way,
then you stop the wars, and you stop
your local economy or someone
else's local economy.
I like the president and think he would tilt
at the windmill that IS the MILITARY Industrial
Complex, but maybe they got to him, and he made
a deal wtih the DEVIL. "You can get you domestic
agenda done; just let us keep things going
in Afghanistan." IRAQ?
Violence is urban there like in the U.S.
Per capita killings are statistically greater
in U.S. cities than in Iraq. Last year this
time the Iraqi government had rejected
a status of forces agreement. It was
not reported in U.S. media.
the Bush regime negotiated a status of forces
agreement at the last minute less than 40 days
before leaving office. U.S. media reported most
casually not saying that the U.S presence in
IRAQ would have been illigal had the last minute
deal not been accomplished. The pull back from
cities under Obama was prescibed in the status
of forces agreement. I mean if Iraq turns
ugly all over again that's just what
the generals are saying
because that's what they are hoping for.
Afghanistan? Status of Forces Agreement
is not necessary. U.S. military is running
the show, and that is exactly what it is.
It is all so complex and complicated; only
the generals know all the ins and outs.
if war is profitable, I as an American do not
need that kind of profit. There's the really
simple part. I need 60% of all Americans
to agree with me, and this should be
Cindy's angle too
Enough already, indeed. Enough war for profit.
Afghanistan OR Iraq; doesn't matter, all the money
and man power poured in has not made anyone
anywhere safer. PERIOD
missiles that is
Ever since disheartened conscripts of the State
were mythically spat upon by those who would end the God of War
and lost the battle,
We have vowed never again
To question
the nobility of the mercenaries and their profession
who kill in foreign countries
to defend our way of death
and to protect Our right to speak anything
except to speak against them