Ilya Shambat

Ilya Shambat
Location
Melbourne, VIC, Australia
Birthday
November 21
Title
Partner
Company
Adda Enterprises
Bio
Born in Russia, family moved to America when I was 12. Got a degree from University of Virginia at 18. Worked for Oracle, translated four books of classical Russian poety, was part of San Francisco and Washington, DC poetry and music scene. Good friends with San Francisco's own Persephone's Bees and acquainted with Patch Adams. Currently married with children, residing in Australia and working on a clean energy technology implementation.

MY RECENT POSTS

Ilya Shambat's Links

Salon.com
SEPTEMBER 27, 2012 9:45AM

Paul McCartney's Error

Rate: 0 Flag

In 1974 Paul McCartney came up with a song called "Live and Let Die." This song stated, "What does it matter to you? If you've got a job you gotta do it well. You gotta give the other fellow hell." This mentality has had a lot of influence, and it was not the better kind of influence.

There is everything to be said for doing one's job well; there is nothing to be said for giving the other fellow hell. All this does is make life ugly for everyone, including the people who have such attitudes. And the result is a worse world for everyone.

Paul McCartney had a legitimate grievance. John Lennon got more credit for the work of Beatles than did he, even though apparently McCartney wrote a number of the songs that were attributed to Lennon. But to generalize this on all of humanity and teach people to give each other hell is completely wrong. And unfortunately these wrongful conclusions had a lot more influence than they ever deserved to have.

What we see with McCartney and his wrongful conclusions is an influence on a generation that started from the position of caring, to being completely un-caring. The result was a worse world for everyone. Many among baby boomers see the change they underwent as themselves going from youth to adulthood, with the appropriate changes in attitudes to adapt to realities of the world. But the greatest reality of the world is that people make the bulk of it; and when people develop wrongful conclusions then that is reflected in the reality of the world that they create.

Having a life-and-let-live attitude is not a function of youth; it is a function of conviction. I, for one, did not start with a live-and-let-live attitude; I started out as a Virginia-educated yuppie and became convinced of the rightfulness of live-and-let-live mentality from realizations and interactions that I've had in life. It may very well be said that McCartney and I moved through life in opposite paths, with him starting with "live and let live" and going on to "live and let die" and with me going in the opposite direction.

Paul McCartney can be credited with producing a number of brilliant songs; but one thing he can't be credited with is giving his followers rightful direction. He made a wrong choice, and the world suffered for it. A generation that started from the position of caring went to a position of aggressive non-caring. And that was just as bad for his generation as it was for the rest of the world.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Are you on crack? McCartney wrote "you got to give the other fella hell" because it's ryhmed, my man. Take every song, break it down, read it carefully and they are filled with lines and words just like that. Paul McCartney has done for for peace and love than anyone I can think of. Remember, he also wrote that " The love you take is equal to the love you make"~
The song was written for a James Bond movie ferchissakes! It seems quite normal to relate such songs to things like, oh, I dunno - the plot of the movie?