Me Jane

Femme Fatale with a Broken Stiletto

Jane Gideon

Jane Gideon
Location
San Francisco, California, USA
Birthday
March 18
Bio
Writer, blogger, resolutionista, femme fatale has-been, and wannabe master of my domain.

MY RECENT POSTS

JANUARY 19, 2010 11:14AM

My Emancipation Proclamation

Rate: 5 Flag

Even in diversity-rich San Francisco, we have a long way to go to realize Dr. Martin Luther King, Jr.’s dream.  The following incident actually happened to me yesterday – on the day we honor the extraordinary work and transformation created by Dr. King.

I stopped for gas on my way home from a meeting.   While my gas was pumping, I went into the food mart to grab a drink and use the restroom.  The only other customer in the place was a stunning-looking young man, paying for a soda at the counter.  I gave him a friendly smile as I asked for the restroom key.

“How are you this evening?” he said.

“Very well, thank you.  And you?”

“I’m good.  Trying to get home before the rain starts again.” 

“Me too.”  The cashier interrupted to hand me the key.   I took it and said, “Well, good luck, and enjoy your evening.”

After this brief conversation, I went to the restroom.  When I came back, he was still standing by the counter. 

He gave an awkward, kind of shy wave, smiled at me and said, “You have a good night.”  Then he left.

I selected a drink and returned to the counter to pay.  The cashier said to me, “Do you know that black man?”

A conversation that begins by identifying the color of someone’s skin usually doesn’t hold much promise, and though I was taken aback by her question, I answered her.

“No.”

“Well, he was really eyeing you.”

“Really?”  I felt like a school girl who was just told that my crush likes me.

“Yes.  He waited for you to come out of the bathroom.”

“He did?”  I was quite pleased.

“You better be careful going to your car.  Do you want me to have someone escort you for extra security?”

“Uh…what?”

“You need to be more careful about who you flirt with, you know.  He might be waiting for you out there.  My husband’s in the back.  Do you want me to get him to walk out with you? ”

Now, why would I trust her husband, also a stranger to me, any more than I would trust the young man who was ‘eyeing’ me?  I couldn’t believe this was actually happening in San Francisco, California, arguably the most liberal and open-minded city in the nation. 

“Uh, no ma’am.  Thank you anyway.”

I paid for my drink and walked to the door, still dumb-founded.  Just before leaving, I turned around to the cashier and said, “Actually, you might want to send your husband out to protect the young gentleman from me because if this cougar decides to pounce on his fine bod, he may never be heard from again.”

When I got outside, the man was still in the parking lot standing with his car door open.  Instead of getting in the car, he closed the car door and walked over to me.  The cashier peered out the window with an “I told you so, but not even God can save you now,” look.

He stopped just a couple of feet away from me and said, “I just wanted to tell you that I think you’re beautiful.”

“Thank you so much.  I think you are too.”

Then, I’m sad to say, he said good night, got in his car and left.  He simply wanted to offer a kind word, and what if I’d been too paranoid to receive it?  Misjudging his intentions would have been my loss, because he obviously wanted nothing in return.

There are so many problems with this series of events that I don’t know how to separate them all.  It’s not just that the cashier instinctively feared this man because of the color of his skin.  There was also implied audacity in me finding him attractive…or him finding me attractive for that matter, which is why I said what I did to the cashier before exiting the store.  In addition, there were gender issues at play.  My friend Dr. Hugo Schwyzer writes extensively about the ‘myth of male weakness.’  The myth is that men can only be expected to exercise so much restraint or control in the face of sexual temptation before they have to give in to their biological desires, and therefore, men cannot be trusted and are treated as a threat.  Black men are the extreme representation of this myth.  The cashier’s fear wasn’t just about the color of this man’s skin, it was his skin color combined with his gender that posed such a danger.  And I was chastised for ‘asking for it,’ because if men cannot be trusted to regulate themselves, that responsibility obviously falls on women.   There also seems to be a myth that people of color cannot be trusted to regulate themselves.  I believe this myth is the seed lurking behind current immigration policies, withholding monies owed to Native American tribes, slow diplomatic engagement with Africa, inaction after Hurricane Katrina and shocking statements questioning the value of rebuilding Haiti in the wake of the recent earthquake.  This myth of male and color weakness is what prompted the cashier to offer her husband, a white man, as a viable protector for me from a black man.

Forgive me for not quoting Dr. King directly, but I’ll paraphrase one of his speeches:  Nobody can do this for us.  No document, no emancipation proclamation, no civil rights deal can do this for us.  If we are to be free, we must reach down into the inner resources of our own soul and sign our own emancipation proclamation.

We must not become complacent just because there are signs of progress.  Yes, we have our first black President and that was a day many thought they would never see (though undoubtedly Dr. King saw it from the Mountaintop).  At the same time, we are passing laws that explicitly separate groups of citizens and deny them the equal rights and protections afforded by legal marriage.  There is still so much to be done to reach the Promised Land, and we all have to look into the depths of our souls and sign our own emancipation proclamations because the truth is none of us are free until all of us are free. 

This is my emancipation proclamation:  I free myself from letting someone else design or impede my present or my future.  I free myself from fear of others.  I free myself from telling anyone else who or how to love.  I free myself from idling in the presence of fear, bigotry and hate.  Because (now paraphrasing Dante and Dr. King) the hottest places in hell are reserved for those who in a period of moral crisis maintain their neutrality.  There comes a time when silence is betrayal. 

Dr. King’s dream does not work without each of us finding that place where we are not free or cannot allow others to be free and ripping that dark place out for good.  Emancipate yourself.

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Wow!

This had EVERYTHING. You nailed this Jane. Pitch perfect. You lead us from the story to the point PERFECTLY.

Just beautiful.
great advice, and a great story. How sad is it when people are afraid of eachother because of existing prejudices...I like Dr. Hugo Schwyzer's theory.
Thanks, guys. Appreciate it. It was a surreal experience, for sure. And Dolores, definitely check out Hugo's stuff. He blogs on his own site, www.hugoschwyzer.net. Really thought-provoking stuff.
Well done and well said, Jane.

My friend Dr. Hugo Schwyzer writes extensively about the ‘myth of male weakness.’ The myth is that men can only be expected to exercise so much restraint or control in the face of sexual temptation before they have to give in to their biological desires, and therefore, men cannot be trusted and are treated as a threat.

Your encounter was friendly, unthreatening, and both you and the young man reached beyond stereotypes and fear to give one another a moment of pleasure and mutual admiration.

I wish I could say I would do as you did in the circumstances. I've always been taught to guard against racism and to fight it and that it's stupid to discriminate against anyone for anything so basic as the pigment in their skin. I believe that it's definitely wrong, yet I'm repeatedly ashamed to find the seeds of racially motivated fear in myself, even though I want to deny they're there. I can only explain them by saying they are at least partially caused by experience; I was raped by a black man at age eighteen. I'd like to think I'd have repaid friendliness with friendliness with the young man too; I'm afraid instead, I might well have accepted the escort. Not because of anything that specific black man did, but because of awful memories I can't quite erase.
Shiral, thanks for sharing your point of view. I have not been through anything remotely similar to the violent violation of your person that you spoke about, so I cannot possibly say what I would do in your shoes. I commend you for trying to move beyond it, as I can only imagine that those memories are irrevocable.

Unfortunately, men have certainly lived up to the weak attributes we have come to expect of them, and we see them as a threat for very valid reasons. Hugo talks about this in his writings, so I'll just point you to him and not try to put words in his mouth, but basically I believe he says people often behave as we expect them to and men are not only capable of self-restraint, but we should expect it of them, not excuse them. However, rape is not an act of uncontrolled biological desire, but an act of rage and violence and it's a whole other level.

Did I put myself in harm's way by my actions? Possibly. I have definitely been taught not to behave as I did with men of any racial make-up. And I admit that I went with my gut. My gut said this guy did not have a violent intent. His behavior just wasn't pointing to that.

Unfortunately, women have good reason to be cautious of strange men at gas stations at night. I don't mean to discount the very real dangers that are present in such situations. But I hope to demonstrate that we must allow that not all people have ill-intent, and sometimes, it's the right time to open up and let someone have the chance to perform a random act of kindness. That's what happened for me, and my goal is to move towards expecting the best from others rather than the worst. It controversial, I know, but what can I say...I'm an idealist. :-)

Thanks very much for your comment. I truly appreciate your candor, as I think many of us will admit to having the exact same fears, even if we feel ashamed for having them. Letting go of fear isn't easy.
In the OS days of yore this post would have been a bigger buzz. I understand prejudice, but know that fear and mistrust cuts both ways. You are beautiful. And perhaps offer the next "stunning" brother you meet a cup of coffee. ;-)
You are too right, Eric. I only have myself to blame on this one. I said to a friend the other day, "Now, what possess a guy to walk up, call you beautiful and then just walk away and leave you standing there?" He said, "And what possessed you to let him walk away?" Touche. :-) Thanks for the comment.