The Shepherd

Jason Hill at Open Salon

Jason D. Hill

Jason D. Hill
Location
Chicago, Illinois, United States
Birthday
June 10
Title
Associate Professor of Philosophy
Company
De Paul University
Bio
Jason D. Hill, Ph.D is an academic philosopher and fiction writer. He is the author of 3 books: "Becoming A Cosmopolitan: What it means to be a Human Being in the New Millennium." (Rowman&Littlefield, 2000); "Beyond Blood Identities: Post Humanity in the 21st Century," (Lexington Books, 2009) and "When We Should Not Get Along: Cosmopolitanism and Cultural Differences," (Anthem Press, January 2011). He has written for salon magazine, and penned several newspaper editorials in Europe and the United States. He was born and raised in Jamaica and in 1985, at the age of 20, came to America to become an artist. He has just completed his novel called, "Jamaica Preacher Man."

Jason D. Hill's Links

Post Humanity
New list
JANUARY 18, 2010 8:51PM

What Should Obama Presidency Mean to African Americans?

Rate: 9 Flag

As the nation marks the one-year anniversary of Barack Obama’s ascendance to the presidency, we will once again be subjected to endless discussion about the significance of the nation’s first non-white president.  For many African-Americans, this may be a time to again celebrate the achievement of one of their own.  As a person of color, I would like to offer a word of advice on why it might be best to table such inclinations.

 

Clinging to an overly strong racial, ethnic or national identity is akin to addiction.  It is a psychological crutch that allegedly bolsters “self-esteem” and promises to confer some a sort of “biological prestige.” But in reality, it creates barriers to our ability to relate to those outside our group in profound and insidious ways.  In this increasingly globalized and interconnected world, clannishness will likely produce only more conflict.

 

We all must be careful not to lean on the laurels of our kinfolk.  Pride can come only from individual achievement and accomplishment, not from being born into any particular tribe. As a native Jamaican, I am well-aware of the success many of my fellow countrymen have enjoyed–especially those who have immigrated to the United States.  The traits they attribute to this success – resilience, strong work ethic, dignity and a “don’t-take-crap-from-nobody” attitude – are indeed pronounced for many of my countrymen.  But then again, aren’t they also cited as positive personal traits of virtually every other ethnic group?

 

Many of my fellow Jamaicans bask in the achievement of Usain Bolt’s achievements of setting the record as the world’s fastest runner. Perhaps they feel this provides some measure of national prestige.  In reality, it has nothing to do any individual Jamaican and to the extent a person thinks it does is likely to diminish their capacity for personal growth. We should be proud of human achievements, period—wherever we find them in the human community.

 

As a huge fan of Barack Obama, I was filled with pride at his election. But that pride flowed not from the similarity of our skin tones.  Rather it was in the capacity of the people of the United States to move beyond its traditional limitations, to show the world that the U.S. has the ability continually renew itself and fully abide by the fundamental principles of its constitution.

 

It was, first and foremost, rational pride I felt in America and in the collective ability of a majority of voters to transcend its own clannish ways in choosing a new leader to take us forward. It is America and the American people that deserve praise for executing this extraordinary historic phenomenon.  Perhaps the crowning irony came when Obama himself observed that it was easier for him to be elected president in the U.S. than it would have been in his father’s native Kenya, as his father did not come from the right tribe.

 

It was a collective achievement that proved itself eminently worthy of emulation. Perhaps this realization on the part of the American people has made other noteworthy political firsts possible with minimal fanfare. For example, the recent election of Annise Parker as the first openly gay mayor of Houston seems to have occurred without too much fuss among any group.

  

It is understandable that people flock to their own in a society as historically race- obsessed as America.  You are implicated in the achievements and failures of members of your group when you are a minority. Yet tribalism goes awry when we imbue morally neutral features of a person like race, ethnicity and nationality with moral significance.

 

As we move further into the 21st century, we are seeing globalization spark a resurgence of ethnic, religious and nationalistic pride across the globe. Globalization is perceived as having a leveling effect, and I fear that in order to hold on to their particularity, people are going to bolster their tribal identities. To avoid letting these tendencies bring us to a constant state of conflict, we must move beyond the conventions, the binding norms and the oppressive mores of our cultures.

  Jason Hill is an associate professor of philosophy at DePaul University and the author of the recent “Beyond Blood Identities.” 

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
It seems human nature to cling to the familiar for the comfort it offers, and as you so aptly point out, that very source of comfort can result in tribalism.
Great piece. Make sure you tag this appropriately so the editors will recognize it as a response to an open call. It deserves to be widely read. Excellent, Jason.
"To avoid letting these tendencies bring us to a constant state of conflict, we must move beyond the conventions, the binding norms and the oppressive mores of our cultures." Amen to this statement with which you ended your essay.

I have never viewed Barack as a black man. I know his history. He is perceived as a black man by many but I know of his "white side". He was and is an inspiring man that captured me with his writing and his speaking skill. I see him as a writer more than anything. I am glad a writer is our leader; his skin tone means nothing to me. Glad to see you back here gracing us with your skills and always thought-provoking posts. A big wave Jason....
Jason, I married a Jamaican and lived there, in the bush where Sav-La-Mar seemed huge as Manhattan, for over 5 years.

You are incredibly accomplished but though I am rarely contrarian but have been so all night on OS, I do not buy your argument though it is extremely well-argued.

I did not feel at home in Jamaica not because of any racism but because it wasn't home for me, ontologically speaking. It was home for my husband who is still there. Israel felt like home for me. Then Palestine did.

I talk too much here about being born Jewish but since I was and right during World War II, I know that in my age group there are group affiliations. Few people were more pro-Obama than I was, constantly registering younger kids, moving from NYC to FL for my vote, breaking the bank to help him etc etc. And yet, on the night of his win, at a party that was right in my home, half-black half-nonblack, I can tell you that the black women especially but the men if less obviously were sobbing in a way that I did not feel. I felt ecstatic. They felt redeemed. There is that difference. And may I add: This was an international, educated group, some were filmmakers who directly knew Obama. Many inter-racial couples. But I learned in that night, that we do have primal connections to others who seem like us... Seem So, because this is such a fractured culture. It helps to have some bearings.

That said, you write extremely well. Rated
I'm with Steve. This post deserves a far broader audience and reading because it is so well done. Add the open call tags. Rated, of course.
Yup. Getting elected is just a start, not an end game. I'm less interested in the novelty of it that what actually gets accomplished.