A Hard Day's Blog

Oh, by all means, I'd be quite prepared for that eventuality.

Jeanette DeMain

Jeanette DeMain
Location
Nashville, Tennessee,
Birthday
January 01
Bio
My bio, like my life, needs a lot of work.

MY RECENT POSTS

Jeanette DeMain's Links

Photo Essays
Posts About Films
Posts About Music
AUGUST 31, 2011 4:40PM

The Price of the Weekend is Eternal Vigilance

Rate: 20 Flag

Labor Day is one of the few holidays where I feel I have a tangible connection to the source.

Columbus Day?  Not Italian.  St. Patrick's Day?  Not Irish.  Easter?  Not religious.  Memorial Day?  No family members, save for a first cousin once removed, have been killed in action.  Mother's Day?  No kids.  Christmas and Thanksgiving are nice, but they usually mean traveling during the worst weather of the year and dealing with assorted relatives.

But Labor Day is something that means a little more to me than just a Monday off and a cook-out.

Although it had been celebrated earlier in certain parts of the country, Labor Day became an official U.S. holiday in the aftermath of the Pullman Strike of 1894, in which at least 13 workers were killed, and over 50 wounded.

The history of U.S. labor movement has been chronicled in countless books and movies, so that's not something I'll repeat here.  But I will say that whenever I see Norma Rae (a character based on the real union activist Crystal Lee Sutton) holding up that sign, in silent defiance, challenging her co-workers to turn off their machines and stand up for their rights, I get a genuine thrill.

When I look at this picture, or when I read about the early struggles of the garment workers in New York City (especially the Triangle Shirtwaist fire), and then when I sign off on a contract that I helped to negotiate, I realize that I am standing on the shoulders of giants.

You see, I am a paid staffer for a public-sector union (Tennessee Education Association), and I am also a union member (Tennessee Staff Organization).  My workplace organized quite peacefully and uneventfully in 1999.  I'm sure that this is only because of the violence and bloodshed that came before.  I had the right to cast my vote to unionize in safety, and I have the right to sit down at the bargaining table with management without fear of retaliation, because people died to secure those rights.  I often wonder if I would have had the courage of those early activists and leaders, but it's because of their sacrifices that I most likely won't ever have to find out.

So, I watch a film like Matewan or Harlan County U.S.A., or Schmatta:  Rags to Riches to Rags, and I marvel at these people, these heroes, mostly poor and uneducated, who made things so much easier for me.  And they made things easier for you too, whether you're in a union or not, and whether you support unions or not.

Because we need to get one thing straight right now:  employers rarely ever do anything out of the goodness of their hearts.  That's not to say that employers are inherently evil (although there are some who would certainly fit the bill).  It's just that the interests of the employer are almost always diametrically opposed to the interests of the worker.  And that, in itself, isn't evil either.  It's just the way it is.  But there seems to be a persistent mindset that somehow regards the interests of the employer as sacred and good, while characterizing the interests of the worker as greedy and unreasonable.  Why can't we just view those interests as competing, and admit that unionization is a way for both parties to sit down and talk about those interests?

The fact is that a compromise between those competing interests can be reached.  That compromise is hammered out at the bargaining table, line by line, where both groups meet as equals and talk about their issues.  And the gains that the labor movement makes are then often extended to non-union industries and workplaces as well.  The 40-hour work week, the weekend and the paid vacation didn't just appear out of thin air, you know!

Although I was reluctant to get involved at first, I have been on the bargaining team for my union for a number of years.  Sometimes the responsibility of it all is overwhelming, but I realize what an important job it is.  It takes a lot of preparation and perspiration, and we never get everything we want (neither side does), but the written guarantees contained in that contract have made my life and the lives of my co-workers more secure and prosperous.  As a result, I believe we are more productive employees.

Are unions perfect?  Of course not.  We all know that organizations run by human beings are vulnerable to corruption.  It pains me when union officials do the wrong thing because I believe that unions should represent a higher standard.  But for every Jimmy Hoffa, there are at least a dozen Ken Lays, whose criminal activities often have far more detrimental effects on workers.  And the fact is that national union leaders have very little effect on the rest of us at the grass-roots level.  The bulk of the work of unions is done by people who are uncompensated, and who give up many of their evenings and weekends to plan, organize and motivate.  All of the officers and committee members of my union serve on a volunteer basis.

There also seems to be a belief that it's only weak people who need unions, people who can't do for themselves.  The peculiarly persistent American myth is that everyone makes their own destiny, and that "collectivism" is the refuge of the irrresponsible.  I reject that characterization.  The American worker is not weak.  However, the American worker is, in many cases, powerless.  Weakness is an internal quality, while powerlessness is something that is imposed externally, by social, political and economic forces, and the way to overcome that powerlessness is to speak with a collective voice.

I can't tell you how many times I've heard people say that we don't need unions anymore.  That workers have everything they need and there's no more room for improvement.  Wow, I'd like to know where these people work!  Also, are there any openings?

Which brings me around to the title of this blog.  Of course, everyone will recognize that I am paraphrasing Thomas Jefferson's famous words, "The price of liberty is eternal vigilance."  (The quote has also been attributed to others, but I'm going with Jefferson.)  He realized that, once you win something that important, you don't just sit back and coast.  And so it is with things like the weekend, or workplace safety, or workers' compensation, or pensions, or overtime, or paid vacation and sick leave, or employer-provided health insurance, and the list goes on.  

Believe me, there are well-funded groups out there lobbying state legislatures and the United States Congress to weaken worker protections.  The spending of these groups far outpaces the amount that unions give to legislators.  According to OpenSecrets.org, an incredibly useful website, the National Education Association spent $3,646,077 on lobbying in 2010.  I'll admit that that's a lot of money.  But Wal-Mart, a corporation that is notoriously anti-union, spent nearly twice as much, $6,160,000, that same year!  Who do you think has more influence in Washington and in statehouses across the country?

In 2005, Senator Edward Kennedy introduced the Healthy Families Act, legislation which would require companies with 15 or more employees to provide up to seven paid sick leave days per year to employees who work a certain number of hours.  The bill has never been voted on.  Do you think corporate lobbying had anything to do with that?  (By the way, my union guarantees me 12 paid sick days per year, and the ability to accumulate any and all unused days for use at a later time.  If you don't get any paid sick leave, don't you think you could use some?)

We cannot sit idly by and watch the gains that people fought and died for dwindle away.  This is why the union movement is still relevant.  If the labor movement disappeared today, I have no doubt that we would see a wholesale return to the worst violations of the past in terms of worker safety, pay and benefits.

Honestly, I see it happening already.   It's no coincidence that peak union membership in this country occurred at the same time that a prosperous and productive middle class was born, a middle class that could buy houses and cars, put children through college, and retire comfortably.  Now with union membership on the decline, employers are using the precarious state of the economy to treat workers in ever more draconian ways.

So I dedicate this post to all of those past heroes, the ones who felt the billy-club to the head, who worked 16 hours a day six or seven days a week, who went hungry while out on the picket lines, or who risked everything for the sake of a greater good.  And to all of those who are trying to keep that dream alive today, spending unpaid nights and weekends in cramped motel rooms or offices, living on take-out pizza, stale donuts and coffee, talking one-on-one with workers, organizing, filing grievances, writing contract language, or just listening and understanding.


Happy Labor Day! 

And while you're enjoying those three days off, thank a union member.


Photo 185 

Oh, you're very welcome!

Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
Excellent post as always. I live here in Rick Perry's "miracle" economy of Texas. Perry and most of the moneyed interests he represents are strongly anti-union though some do exist. One such union is the AFT(teachers union) which Perry and the Republicans have relentlessly attacked.
Texas leads the nation in minimum wage jobs per capita and workers earning less than minimum wage in agriculture, food service and some other businesses.
Some miracle...
We've commiserated before on this Jeanette. Op-ed pieces in the local rag favoring a union position usually have some counter-puncher going at it. You know they couldn't wait to get to their keyboard right after getting off work at 5 p.m.
Thanks, Dicky. Yup, the teachers are the reason the country is going to hell in a handbasket, doncha' know? And what's going to happen when they go after the minimum wage? Bad times ahead.

aka, yes we have. (In fact, this is a repost from last year. I've been around here so long that I can now recycle!) I know that it's can be difficult to really understand how bad things were in the bad old days, but really, some people just lack any imagination whatsoever.
Wonderful essay, Jeanette, and I wish this could be posted as an op-ed in the Wall Street Journal as a counterbalance there.

I was a member of IBEW in the 1970s and helped negotiate a new labor contract at my then-plant. I could tell a few stories about issues with the labor union, but also plenty to emphasize your point: "employers rarely ever do anything out of the goodness of their hearts." What I see today, with the weakening of labor unions - one word: Wisconsin - is a growing imbalance in the workplace between management and employees, and a nagging, frightening sense that we are pushing back toward a two-tiered society.
You are terrific. Everything you wrote here is an important truth, and you do it every year that I've known you. Thank you, and have a lovely Labor Day yourself.
Great piece. I worked in state and local politics and the unions were powerful. I always liked working on labor issues and particularly respected a local SEIU leader in L.A. named Maria Elena Durazo. She would bring down the house with her speeches about how to organize and bring about change. Rated!
Everyone who is against unions should read a little history...
have a good holiday, too, jeanette, and remember that there are a lot of people (here and elsewhere) who agree with what you say and are cheering. excellent post.
When I first saw this title in the feed I thought the post would be sort of a Beastie Boys "Fight for your right to party" thing. As cool as that would have been, this is even better. As you point out here, the years when unions were strongest coincide with the years when our middle and working classes were at their most prosperous. That there are so many working people out there who don't understand the correlation tells us that corporatist reactionaries such as the Koch brothers (greatly aided by their lackeys in government) are winning the battle of ideas in this country.
I recall this from last year with maybe some additional copy here. For those interested in union films I will also recall the film called "Made in Dagenham", an independent movie about a 1968 strike for equal pay for women. Now I also think I'll revisit Matewan this Labour Day weekend. Thanks Jeanette!
This deserves an EP!

I made $57K a year teaching in Minnesota Community College System (union) then moved to Phoenix, Arizona (non-union) salary $34K and they could hire 75% of their teaching staff could be part-time, no benefits, and p/t didn't even get the same pay.

Go Unions! (Hear that Wisconsin?)
Good on you Jeanette. Most of the substantial improvements in working conditions are due to union activists of this and several generations back. I fully agree that for every episode of union misjudgment or malfeasance, there are dozens more on the corporate bosses side. And I say this as one who took the following business school lesson to heart - companies get the unions they deserve.
I missed this the first time around and am so glad you recycled.

The 40-hour work week is already gone, you know. People just stay on til 6, or work from home, or go in on weekends. We're probably working 50-60 hours per week, which makes the drop in our incomes and the drop in our buying power even more galling.
This is a beautiful post. I'm glad you recycled it, since I missed it the first time. I especially like the distinction you make between weakness and powerlessness. It's becoming frustratingly common in public debate to conflate economic/political powerlessness with personal weakness - as if those without power were somehow deserving of their lesser status. Thank you for stating it so clearly and succinctly. Have a great weekend!
Thanks, Jeanette! A wonderful post that deserves the widest possible readership. No one is the MSM is reminding the public of these realities, both historical and present-day. The goal of the politcal elites seems to be to remove any protections, any barriers, any limits on maximizing exploitation and degradation of anyone who works for a living. If you have any benefits or rights on the job, thank a union member! I also like your pointing out how much of a grassroots, bottom-up movement this has been, not a matter of benevolent despots condescendingly handing down gifts to t he poor. Rated.
Wonderfully informative, without any heavy hammering. The only union I ever belonged to was when I was 20 and worked for a store called Hoffritz. I have no idea how it helped me, because it as 1973, and I was young and more aware of the union dues taken out of my $95/week paycheck. However, I have freelanced every year of my life since 1979, no benefits, no raises, spiraling downward financially even as I think I am staying afloat spiritually, and here I sit feeling vulnerable in these economic winds. There is a Freelance Union, finally (as of 1995!), as I stick my finger in the air to try and determine which way the wind is blowing in my life of 58 years. I do appreciate what you do and what you share here.
I apologize for taking so long to come back and respond to all of your wonderful comments!

Cranky, thanks so much. I think it might signal the actual end of the world if the WSJ gave column space to someone as "radical" as me! And of course, any organization run by human beings is going to have problems, including unions. None of them are perfect, buty they sure beat the alternative. Wisconsin, yup, horrible. They're emboldened now. Things are going to get worse before they get better. If they get better.

greenheron, I know you commented last year as well, and I thank you for your loyalty. You know what I'm talking about here! I hope you have a terrific holiday as well.

Christina, SEIU is really helping to keep the union movement alive, and I have great respect for them. I so admire people who are able to inspire others. Although I have many positive qualities, I am not really an organizer, and I am in awe of people who can do it well.

Toritto, thanks! (But, you know, you wrote a Labor Day blog and I wrote a Labor Day blog, and I'll bet some other people did too. But here it is, nearly the start of the Labor Day weekend, and nary a Labor Day blog has been graced by an EP. Hey Editors, it doesn't have to be mine - just please put something about Labor Day on the cover this weekend!)
This could be the most remiss I've ever been in responding to comments! Between a couple of horrible days at work and OS's technical problems, I haven't had a lot of time here. So, let's get on with it, shall we?

Myriad, I agree. It always amazes me that people can be so myopic about things, and only see what's right in front of them. There is so much that has come before to get us where we are. We can't lose it!

Candace, thanks so much. I hope that there are enough people out there who are getting angry enough that things will start to turn around. And I also think it's just a matter of time before the people in those countries that American companies have forsaken us for will start the move to organize themselves.

nanatehey, perhaps we could get the Beastie Boys to do a remake: You've gotta' fight! For your right! To baaaaaaar-gain! And, yes, the likes of Koch brothers are winning the hearts and minds of too many people. But perhaps this just points out a weakness in the union movement. We need to do more in terms of strategizing and messaging.

Scarlett, thanks for commenting last year and this year. I'll have to put that movie on my Netflix list. Happy Labor Day!

Kate, thanks so much, but it looks like it wasn't to be. And your story is a perfect example of the tangible results of unionization, to the tune of $23K!

Abrawang, I'd never heard that saying, but I like it! As I said, I am in awe of those giants who came before. There are so many things we wouldn't have without them. Thanks for reading and for your comment.

Snippy, thanks for stopping by. It is true that, for "salaried" employees, the 40-hour work week is an illusion. For those of who are hourly, we still have some protections under the law, but even those are in a precarious state. WalMart is notorious for not paying overtime, for example. And of course, that makes one's hourly wage even smaller.

Lillesild, that's it exactly. There is a very dangerous mindset now that blames people for things that are really out of their control. We are heading in the complete opposite direction of "enlightenment" and back to the dark ages. Thanks for reading!

Donegal Descendant, you've said it better than I did. I don't think we've met before, so hello, and thanks for your comment. Workers have had to fight for everything, and it's a shame people seem to forget that.

Now I'm off to Cranky's cook-out!
Oops, I overlooked dirndl skirt - apologies! I know that younger workers would question why they have to pay those darn union dues month after month. After all, when you're first starting out, you feel like you don't need any protections, as if your very youth and energy will keep you safe. But as you've found out, things can be really difficult when you're out there on your own. I didn't know that there was a Freelancers' Union, and that's encouraging news. Thanks for sharing that here, and Happy Labor Day!
although i am in my heart anti-union, we need to recognize that without unions workers have little power. folks like myself do have some power, with our relatively rare and so high priced skills (i am an insurance underwriter).. so what do we do?

if not unions, than guaranteed benefits including a minimum 401 k with a match and a higher minimum wage.

again, my reaction is normally to hate unions, but my memories of unions go back to the 60s when i was a teen and unions powerful.