Hallucina

I Just Realized Earth Is An Anagram For Heart

jeanv999

jeanv999
Location
Miami, Florida, U.S.
Birthday
February 12
Bio
Writer on the make. My REAL blog- the one you should stop by- is at http://hallucina.blogspot.com This is just sort of the red-headed step-version that ocassionally deletes videos and the such.

MY RECENT POSTS

Jeanv999's Links

Salon.com
OCTOBER 4, 2011 3:33AM

"Restrepo" - Sebastian Junger and Tim Hetherington

Rate: 1 Flag
In "Restrepo," you never see where the shooting is coming from. It falls down from the Afghan mountains that surround the Korengal Valley, where American soldiers have built the titular military outpost. The men, (kids, really, some with pimples in their haunted, startlingly young faces) might as well be fighting ghosts.



Sebastian Junger (perhaps best known for his best-sellers "War" and "The Perfect Storm") and director Tim Hetherington (who was recently killed while covering Lybian conflict) spent most of a year embedded with a platoon in Afghanistan, reporting for Vanity Fair. What emerged is a document that puts you as close as you'll ever want to be to the sheer confusion of fighting against foes you can't even find, for a cause you can't quite articulate. Junger and Hetherington make an apolitical film, (thank God): the futility of the soldiers' efforts need no commentary. You'll never figure out WHAT they're trying to accomplish from their missions. The best answer is they're trying to stay alive while being constantly shot at. No, you don't get the side of the valley villagers, that's beyond the scope of the camera for reasons that should be obvious: if you can't supply your own context, that's a failure of your education and/or imagination. And yes, you may want to sneer at the soldiers and their naive talk of "bad guys" and "revenge" and "making them pay," but again, these are kids, not political philosophers; they say exactly what you would say in their situation- if you were daring or foolish enough to ever wind up where they are. "Restrepo" collected plenty of awards and adulation during its initial release, and although it's hardly DRAMATIC or COOL-LOOKING- why isn't war like in the movies?- it's a GO WATCH NOW film, if only because you need to know what it's like to be caught in an ambush. After you see these tough men, the toughest you'll meet, break down in hysterics at the sight of their fallen comrade, you'll appreciate their sacrifice anew and hate war all the more. Whatever you feel about the absurdity of our war machinery, never forget that soldiers are not machines, but human beings. And, frankly, much braver than you or me.


Your tags:

TIP:

Enter the amount, and click "Tip" to submit!
Recipient's email address:
Personal message (optional):

Your email address:

Comments

Type your comment below:
[r] jean, excellent review of an awesome documentary that every citizen should sit through to appreciate the insanity of war -- young people with any "romantic" ideas about it and those older who numb out their consciences on what physical and psychological nightmares our soldier youth are having to endure. real "hamburger hill" stuff in which young people die to take a faux-strategic location which is eventually lost any way and on to the next hamburger hill for more deaths. You are right, staying alive and protecting your buddies is what the surreal nightmare is distilled down to. Hetherington's death shows how violent real REALITY reporting is for the few left who are or were willing to reject cronyism with those in power and willing to speak and show the horrifying truth. best, libby
Re: libby
Yeah. At the end they simply abandon the position they had worked so hard to attain- as you pointed out, its strategic worth was entirely imaginary. There was a great interview with Junger and the late Hetherington in the A.V. Club. http://www.avclub.com/articles/restrepo-codirectors-sebastian-junger-and-tim-heth,42526/
jean, i look forward to checking this link out. thank you. we have few role models in courage and integrity and they are to be cherished and learned from! it was such an experiential documentary ... as you sat watching you could not intellectualize ... you could only coexist with -- though safely in the dark theater -- the terror that totally permeated the psyches and bodies of those soldiers. glad i discovered you, Jean. love the hat. libby